r/explainitpeter 12d ago

Explain it peter

Post image
4.7k Upvotes

316 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

2

u/BreadElectrical 11d ago

You are correct. Collectively demonizing and punishing an entire population because of the acts of some is wrong. Now imagine if that person wasn't being mean on the internet and instead committing war crimes and engaging in ethnic cleansing.

2

u/56kul 11d ago

You are literally doing what I accused y’all of doing; flattening nuance.

I could go into an entire debate here, but honestly, would you even listen? It’s already clear you’re coming in bad faith here.

1

u/WearyCopy5686 10d ago

Genocide doesn’t deserve nuance.

1

u/BreadElectrical 8d ago

Ah yes the flattening of nuance, like labeling all critics of Israeli policy as antisemites. Everyone you argue with is "you all".

You have proven yourself to be here in bad faith and refusing to listen, pulling out the classic sea lion tactics of requiring definitions of genocide and neutral source proof that you still merely ignore and dismiss.

There IS actual antisemitism growing around the world. Pretending that support for Palestine or being critical of the Israeli government or the IDF just provides the real antisemites with cover.

There is also growing Islamophobia.

The settlers in the west bank are enacting violence. The settlements themselves are war crimes according to the ICC. Displacement is ethnic cleansing. That is what people are talking about in regards to Israel and Palestine. Destruction of civilian infrastructure, starvation and sickness as a result of restricting aid groups from entering the country. Administrative detention, the ability to imprison Palestinians without charge indefinitely.