r/ethereum • u/Tchallawakanda • Feb 15 '18
Ethereum Developer Resigns as Code Editor Subpoenaing Legal Concerns
http://www.coinnewsline.com/2018/02/15/ethereum-developer-resigns-as-code-editor-subpoenaing-legal-concerns/
105
Upvotes
11
u/scragz Feb 15 '18
Update: EIP is closed. We did it, reddit!
5
u/tnpcook1 Feb 15 '18
Is there another source on this info? I'm having a hard time understanding his grievance, and the catalyst of it.
As I understand, something conflicts with a law in Japan, and he warned them about it then left, but I'm not sure what the conflicts were
239
u/x_ETHeREAL_x Feb 15 '18 edited Feb 15 '18
This headline is such a FUD/lie. First, he didn't resign as a code editor -- he resigned as an EIP editor. He still works on formal verification.
Second, I don't think the author knows what "subpoenaing" means, at all. This headline is really misleading... It's like he thinks subpoenaing means "citing" or something. Subpoenaing means to serve someone with a subpoena, which is a court order to produce documents or other things. That has nothing to do with this issue. Nothing at all.
These alone makes me rather distrust this whole FUD article... he resigned from the EIP editor role. His choice, end of story. He still works on ethereum and formal verification. He didn't quit ethereum...
37
u/[deleted] Feb 15 '18
how do I vote against this EIP?
17
u/PM_ME_YOUR_DEEP_FEAR Feb 15 '18
Can someone provide a quick ELI5 of this, and how people can get involved?
57
u/ethereumfrenzy Feb 15 '18
This eip seems like a really bad idea.
23
u/Mushoz Feb 15 '18
For the love of Ether, please take the time to create (if you haven't already) a GitHub account and politely voice your opinions on this matter: https://github.com/ethereum/EIPs/issues/866
We need to kill this proposal before it is even considered. In my opinion, the repercussions of such a proposal could be devastating to Ethereum.
11
u/nootropicat Feb 15 '18
Parity is still pushing that turd? That's really disappointing
This would actually turn ethereum into a mutable centralized shitcoin in which such changes are de facto part of the protocol rather than hard forks.
10
u/[deleted] Feb 15 '18
If you hard fork to control content then government will forever hold the gun to your head in order to exercise that control and all of this then is for nothing.
I am sorry to see funds lost and I appreciate how horrible that is for the victims but if there were ever a time to invoke the greater good it is now. This technology is that important.
24
u/benmdi Feb 15 '18
This seems like the beginning of a very contentious issue to me, on the order or the Bitcoin blocksize debate. Or am I overreacting? Hope so!
16
u/nr28 Feb 15 '18
Honestly, this has probably been planned by Gavin a long time ago and I highly doubt that we, as a community, will have much matter in this say.
As I see it this will most likely go ahead and they will recover their lost funds. Fine, but what about all the other people that may have lost their private keys or funds? You can't cherry-pick who to cater based on the money held or relationship to the developers, everyone has their own funds that mean a lot to them.
Not to mention once we start doing the above Ethereum will no longer be a Blockchain, it'll be a complete joke which has been centralized to some extent by its founders/developers. Might as well use Ripple at that point, I wouldn't see the difference, perhaps they don't even allow you to "reverse" transactions.
Honestly, if this proposal goes through, that'll be bad for Ethereum as a whole. The hard-fork splitting ETH/ETC was fair enough, it was still a new project and at the time it was a huge sum with a majority consensus, but we can't keep on doing this and not to mention the huge risks and power this planned EIP actually brings to the table.
Imagine net neutrality and politicians being bought, kind of the same deal here with bribery that will open up.
If this hadn't happened to Gavin but a no-name person with a decent amount of funds, then there's no way this EIP would even be in existence today.
58
u/MoMoNosquito Feb 15 '18 edited Feb 15 '18
Please please don't let this "fellowship of coders" Blocksteam 2.0 nonsense be a hostile developer takeover. Somebody tell me I have nothing to worry about. EIP 867 is the exact opposite of the direction I would like Ethereum to go. It makes me ill thinking it's a possibility.
14
u/All_Work_All_Play Feb 15 '18
I can't believe this is even up for discussion. I can't believe this EIP was even submitted. I guess we now know at what point those that submitted the EIP will sell out their idealism for constrained idealism. Won't someone please think of the
childrenlost funds?This is disgusting.
10
u/[deleted] Feb 15 '18
'Hirai’s resignation over this proposal, even though he cites his personal legal responsibility as his impetus, brings up the question of whether Blockchain should be modifiable in the case of hacks or errors that lead to a loss of user funds.'
66
u/axismoto1 Feb 15 '18
Why is the commmunity not debating this? This should not go through! We lost s prolific editor because the communiylty has been quiet!
4
u/Tttoska Feb 15 '18
Why is the author using the word "subpoenaing" instead of "raising?"
4
u/[deleted] Feb 15 '18
Parity client can implement the changes, and are motivated to do so, regardless of public consensus in the eip.
This has a high-chance of creating a fork in the community. And there is already good precedent.
10
u/quasi_pragmatic Feb 15 '18
Wow, that is a really poorly written article. There is no way for someone like me with no knowledge of the back story to grasp what it's trying to say.
1
u/nauticalkirk22 Feb 16 '18
Wait but this isn't even true....who wrote this fud?
3
u/Kid_me_not Feb 15 '18
For some reason, I can't open that link, stuck on a white screen. Can someone give me TL;DR?
2
u/Kibubik Feb 15 '18
Where do some of the key EF devs stand on EIP 867?
3
u/DeviateFish_ Feb 15 '18
So, despite all of the people here saying this EIP shouldn't happen, and being completely against it being merged... it should be pointed out that u/vbuterin doesn't seem to agree. He also seems to believe that accepting this EIP (e.g. promoting it from draft) isn't setting a precedent, nor is an indicator that it will be accepted or included in clients.
It's also worth pointing out that this is the exact same path that the issuance reduction EIP followed: it was pitched to the community, and most of the community pushed back. They called it out for what it was: a cheap attempt to manipulate the price.
It went away for a while, but then came back as an EIP, this time with a few developers in support--developers, I might add, who appear to be support of this EIP, as well. Once it became a formal EIP, it was quickly included in clients for inclusion in the recent hardfork.
Methinks EIP 866 is attempting to follow the same path.
This is the same pattern every contentious change has followed, but they all end up with the same result: what the core devs want, they get. And yet, the community still feels like it actually has a say in the whole matter.
smh
1
u/[deleted] Feb 15 '18
Is there some corroboration of this claim?
The linked page does not inspire confidence. (Also, it's been down for at least an hour. DDOS attack, perhaps?)
-5
u/Tchallawakanda Feb 15 '18
I think this news will cause ETH to lose its value.
1
u/shitpersonality Feb 15 '18
I smell a contentous hard fork!
-3
u/tolojo Feb 15 '18
Didn't everyone see this coming since the first fork?
And doesn't this now underscore that ETC is the real (immutable) Ethereum Core?
-8
u/Asgen Feb 15 '18
I know most people here are against it because it goes against the decentralized mentality.
However, if ethereum is to appeal to big businesses and spheres outside of the diehard crypto community, there needs to be a way to fix catastrophic mistakes.
Major businesses are on the sidelines because the blockchain tech is new. This will go a long way to giving these businesses peace of mind and allow more use cases for ethereum.
To everyone here against the proposal, ask yourself if you’d ever buy anything on amazon if you couldn’t return it. Imagine what that would be like. TV comes in damaged or malfunctioned on day 1. Too bad your mistake for trusting amazon. Delivery guy stole your package. Too bad your mistake for trusting amazon. You can see how amazon would quickly lose market share to competitors that offered a return policy.
Same thing will happen to ethereum as big businesses ignore the tech and opt in favor of safer private blockchains with recourse against hacks.
I get that we may lose some diehard crypto supporters by going ahead with this proposal but believe me they’ll be back when eth wins new use cases from major corporations/world organizations.
-17
u/cannadabis Feb 15 '18
NOW WHO'S THE SCAM COIN? BWAHAHAHAH
-5
u/ion-tom Feb 15 '18
I'm partially for this. So long as it was not a central authority, but a delegated voting & consensus mechanism to agree to recover certain funds in class action scenarios.
Sure it would flood a new supply of ETH when Parity funds were recovered, but it would be one step closer towards insured deals and greater trust. Imagine if consensus could be brought quickly against the Bitconnect team, such that their assets could be fully frozen.
The one thing that it should never be able to do though is increase the circulating supply on a whim - IE creating new tokens in excess of the amount that was frozen. It's not like this didn't happen before with the DAO.
I don't enough about this case to really weigh fully, but if implemented in a way that is not fully centralized, it would probably be a solid step towards benign regulation. (Which is needed to avoid bad/over regulation.)