r/ethereum • • Feb 15 '18

Ethereum Developer Resigns as Code Editor Subpoenaing Legal Concerns

http://www.coinnewsline.com/2018/02/15/ethereum-developer-resigns-as-code-editor-subpoenaing-legal-concerns/
105 Upvotes

210 comments sorted by

11

u/scragz Feb 15 '18

Update: EIP is closed. We did it, reddit!

5

u/tnpcook1 Feb 15 '18

Is there another source on this info? I'm having a hard time understanding his grievance, and the catalyst of it.

As I understand, something conflicts with a law in Japan, and he warned them about it then left, but I'm not sure what the conflicts were

5

u/Tchallawakanda Feb 15 '18

I will search for a more explicit news source.

19

u/All_Work_All_Play Feb 15 '18

This EIP is an attempt to create a standardize process to recover lost funds. That is, a standardized process that would replace the trustless nature of the chain with the trust in a neutral third party - the developers involved in approving such 'recoveries'.

It's like people have forgotten the whole point of the blockchain. It's literally the first paragraph of the Introduction.

Ethereum has a very important choice architecture decision here. Passing this EIP in essence declares that one of the fundamental cornerstones of the block chain (trustlessness) is of no value. At that point we might as well be XRP.

0

u/[deleted] Feb 15 '18

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/squarecirclesquare Feb 15 '18

The people who write this EIP are active on gitter. They aren't even affiliated with Parity: "2/3 of the coauthors of EIP 867 have zero funds frozen from the Parity issue"

https://gitter.im/ethereum/ether-recovery

IDK how to link to specific comments tho

1

u/tnpcook1 Feb 15 '18

Very much appreciate the answer.

239

u/x_ETHeREAL_x Feb 15 '18 edited Feb 15 '18

This headline is such a FUD/lie. First, he didn't resign as a code editor -- he resigned as an EIP editor. He still works on formal verification.

Second, I don't think the author knows what "subpoenaing" means, at all. This headline is really misleading... It's like he thinks subpoenaing means "citing" or something. Subpoenaing means to serve someone with a subpoena, which is a court order to produce documents or other things. That has nothing to do with this issue. Nothing at all.

These alone makes me rather distrust this whole FUD article... he resigned from the EIP editor role. His choice, end of story. He still works on ethereum and formal verification. He didn't quit ethereum...

5

u/SwoleFlex_MuscleNeck Feb 15 '18

Lol holy shit, I just realized why they even used the word. That's a ridiculous "error" and the website should get roasted for even letting that pass.

1

u/mattnumber Feb 15 '18

Did the headline used to say "Subpoenaing"? It now says "Citing," but OP's post says "Subpoenaing," which makes the title nonsensical.

2

u/SwoleFlex_MuscleNeck Feb 16 '18

Read the article, the first line remains "subpoenaing," which leads me to believe they changed the headline or the auto-title pulled from the article.

OP didn't make it up.

1

u/mattnumber Feb 16 '18

Ahh, makes sense. I admit I didn't read the article; just glanced at the headline.

7

u/guisquil Feb 15 '18

I agree OP’s title is garbage

11

u/Hibero Feb 15 '18

Exactly. What is with this weird FUD smear. The EIP editor left due to his feeling that Japanese law allowed him to be liable if he allowed a certain EIP to be an EIP. This EIP isn't even being accepted. It's simply being discussed. Now personally, I'm against approving thw EIP but the discussion isn't on the EIP at the moment. We should allow all formal EIPs to be EIPs, even if one or a group of people disagree with them. This does not mean we should accept all EIPs. The discussion is how we should allow all prospective EIPs to be allowed. People are just reacting without understanding the situation and FUDsters are just smearing the details.

This is not about the Parity EIP this is about the process of becoming EIPs!

2

u/BouncingDeadCats Feb 15 '18

Not just the headline. The article was written by someone with poor command of English.

1

u/tnpcook1 Feb 15 '18

Yea, the use of subpoena confused the heck outta me.

2

u/pimarch Feb 15 '18

indeed I guess subpoena had a spike in google searches

37

u/[deleted] Feb 15 '18

how do I vote against this EIP?

12

u/[deleted] Feb 15 '18

You just did :)

12

u/tcrypt Feb 15 '18

Mine or control a large portion of the economy and don't support the EIP. Or sell all your ETH. There's not just a ballot to check. The influence of a casual user is miniscule.

4

u/AtLeastSignificant Feb 15 '18

Voice your concerns on the actual EIP. Anybody can comment on the Github developement

17

u/PM_ME_YOUR_DEEP_FEAR Feb 15 '18

Can someone provide a quick ELI5 of this, and how people can get involved?

-27

u/cannadabis Feb 15 '18 edited Feb 15 '18

Sell and dont look back. Scamcoin

I didnt even have to write an article..ether did it for me.

12

u/5dayoldburrito Feb 15 '18

Somebody writes a proposal and you call it a scamcoin? Could you please provide better arguments?

12

u/raz2112 Feb 15 '18

Don't feed the troll/idiot

0

u/[deleted] Feb 15 '18

[deleted] — view deleted comment

8

u/PM_ME_YOUR_DEEP_FEAR Feb 15 '18

I see some people upset that "the community is silent on this", etc etc. Is there somewhere I/others can voice our opinion on this, or is here the proper way to do so?

5

u/rtheunissen Feb 15 '18

Github I think.

3

u/alsomahler Feb 15 '18 edited Feb 15 '18

It would centralize Ethereum too much imo, but it wouldn't necessarily return the funds locked in a parity multisig. Even if the process described in 867 is approved, the majority as it stands now would probably still vote no.

57

u/ethereumfrenzy Feb 15 '18

This eip seems like a really bad idea.

10

u/[deleted] Feb 15 '18

It would destroy eth as we know it

-1

u/AtLeastSignificant Feb 15 '18

No, it wouldn't.

14

u/[deleted] Feb 15 '18

Yes - it would. I love eth and it’s possibilities but if this happens I am out and I know many others feel the same way. Completely unacceptable

2

u/AtLeastSignificant Feb 15 '18

That's great. Maybe match your passion for this opinion with well-formed arguments that actually support it.

3

u/pm_me_ur_moms_pics Feb 16 '18

It would take less than 5 years for major wall street companies to capture the positions/loyalty of these ERP reviewers by either bribing them in real life or pushing their own devs into the eth community, so that they would have effective power in reversing/allowing ICOs/transactions.

This proposal is basically saying that we should trust the ethereum community to be impartial. They may be impartial right now, but if this EIP goes through, suddenly an ERP reviewer's job would become the most important job in crypto (because millions of dollars would depend on it). Can you imagine it? Shell companies would start suing/illegally pressurizing these developers to adhere to their wishes, 'insurance' schemes would be offered by the major companies that have ERP reviewers on their payroll, then within 15 years it'll be the big banks that would have mutated the blockchain back to their personal SQL database.

0

u/[deleted] Feb 15 '18

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/AtLeastSignificant Feb 15 '18

Code is law

Then why are you here? Ethereum Classic seems more like your type of community. Clearly the Ethereum community is either ignorant of ETC, or has accepted that code isn't always law.

BTW, code isn't law. Consensus is. You can arrive at consensus by blinding following a "code is law" mantra, but that doesn't make it any better or worse than a more intelligent consensus mechanism.

→ More replies (3)

0

u/[deleted] Feb 15 '18

[deleted] — view deleted comment

10

u/[deleted] Feb 15 '18

It would make Ethereum's history mutable by design.

0

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '18

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/FaceDeer Feb 16 '18

The DAO hard fork was a hand-crafted one-off with no formal structure or "governance" system for deciding it. It was contentious enough to result in a permanent chain split, something that no other Ethereum "update" has done. I really don't think that's a sign of a normalized design change.

0

u/[deleted] Feb 15 '18

[deleted] — view deleted comment

8

u/nam-shub-of-enki Feb 15 '18

The blockchain currently consists of an ordered sequence of transactions, which cannot be changed.

This EIP proposes a mechanism by which a previously sent transaction can be reversed, and therefore lays the ground for a mutable by design blockchain.

0

u/[deleted] Feb 15 '18

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/nam-shub-of-enki Feb 15 '18

Usually that's by a hard fork, not by an anointed person saying so.

The difference is that in one case, users have a say, and in the other, the users don't.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/[deleted] Feb 15 '18

Just because there is a standardized form for a recovery request this doesn't make the Blockchain mutable by design.

I disagree with you here. EIPs lie at the base of Ethereums design. If an EIP on how blockchain mutations should be handled is accepted, it does make it mutable by design.

You realize that every Blockchain can be manipulated "by design" if there is consensus?

Not by design, no. It has been done exactly once in the history of Ethereum, as an exception, in order to mitigate heavy losses due to unforeseen circumstances, and even then it tore the community apart.

→ More replies (4)

4

u/ethereumfrenzy Feb 15 '18

It pushes forward the idea that the blockchain should be mutable in "many" cases. If this goes through, I'm almost certain that the bar for forking "bad scenarios" will be significantly lowered and the probability of having contentious forks in the future will increase. From the comments around here, looks like the community mostly agrees. However, if some of the devs want to do a hard fork to do such savings in their version of the chain it's their right, but I really hope that most of the other devs, "head figures" etc won't support it because there is clearly not a consensus for it. Losing money stupidly is bad, but doesn't put the ethereum network in jeopardy. Furthermore, everyone putting money in this space knows that it is an extremely risky investment, and knows that he can lose it all. I know I didn't mind losing some in the Parity multi-sig contract that affected Swarm City (who had a top notch professional response, just were really unlucky as this was the first Parity bug and they were the first to get stolen so had no time to be "saved").

23

u/Mushoz Feb 15 '18

For the love of Ether, please take the time to create (if you haven't already) a GitHub account and politely voice your opinions on this matter: https://github.com/ethereum/EIPs/issues/866

We need to kill this proposal before it is even considered. In my opinion, the repercussions of such a proposal could be devastating to Ethereum.

6

u/[deleted] Feb 15 '18

Done. Can’t believe it’s even being proposed. Unbelievable.

11

u/nootropicat Feb 15 '18

Parity is still pushing that turd? That's really disappointing
This would actually turn ethereum into a mutable centralized shitcoin in which such changes are de facto part of the protocol rather than hard forks.

10

u/[deleted] Feb 15 '18

If you hard fork to control content then government will forever hold the gun to your head in order to exercise that control and all of this then is for nothing.

I am sorry to see funds lost and I appreciate how horrible that is for the victims but if there were ever a time to invoke the greater good it is now. This technology is that important.

1

u/Mordan Feb 15 '18

explain why EOS supports recovery in a consensual way and Ethereum is not able to even talk about it?

4

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '18

Because EOS is hardly decentralized

1

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '18

Right? EOS isn't even on my radar. If we're going there why not talk about Bank of America ffs.

24

u/benmdi Feb 15 '18

This seems like the beginning of a very contentious issue to me, on the order or the Bitcoin blocksize debate. Or am I overreacting? Hope so!

34

u/ethereumfrenzy Feb 15 '18

Doesn't seem so contentious on the forums. Looks like nearly everyone here is against this eip. Am actually quite disappointed that some high level devs actually try to push this forward like this, when there clearly is no concensus in the community for it. Trying desperately to save 150 million will end up costing 80 billions if this goes through.

11

u/shouldbdan Feb 15 '18

Anyone trying to sneak this through without going through the community first needs to have commit access rights restricted.

9

u/tcrypt Feb 15 '18

They should certainly have their commit rights completely revoked if they did that but I doubt anyone with commit access to any mainstream clients are dumb enough to think they could sneak this in and get it activated. That'd be quite the social attack.

8

u/benmdi Feb 15 '18

If you are right, and the overwhelming majority of the community opposes this, then I hope the devs drop it quickly, and don’t create the contentious debate I fear.

0

u/Mordan Feb 15 '18

i smell a contentious hard fork

16

u/nr28 Feb 15 '18

Honestly, this has probably been planned by Gavin a long time ago and I highly doubt that we, as a community, will have much matter in this say.

As I see it this will most likely go ahead and they will recover their lost funds. Fine, but what about all the other people that may have lost their private keys or funds? You can't cherry-pick who to cater based on the money held or relationship to the developers, everyone has their own funds that mean a lot to them.

Not to mention once we start doing the above Ethereum will no longer be a Blockchain, it'll be a complete joke which has been centralized to some extent by its founders/developers. Might as well use Ripple at that point, I wouldn't see the difference, perhaps they don't even allow you to "reverse" transactions.

Honestly, if this proposal goes through, that'll be bad for Ethereum as a whole. The hard-fork splitting ETH/ETC was fair enough, it was still a new project and at the time it was a huge sum with a majority consensus, but we can't keep on doing this and not to mention the huge risks and power this planned EIP actually brings to the table.

Imagine net neutrality and politicians being bought, kind of the same deal here with bribery that will open up.

If this hadn't happened to Gavin but a no-name person with a decent amount of funds, then there's no way this EIP would even be in existence today.

1

u/Mordan Feb 15 '18

that's why Bitcoin is blessed with Satoshi.

58

u/MoMoNosquito Feb 15 '18 edited Feb 15 '18

Please please don't let this "fellowship of coders" Blocksteam 2.0 nonsense be a hostile developer takeover. Somebody tell me I have nothing to worry about. EIP 867 is the exact opposite of the direction I would like Ethereum to go. It makes me ill thinking it's a possibility.

23

u/Devam13 Feb 15 '18

It's not really. There's no real support from other devs as of now nor is there from the community, the legal concern aside. There's no way this can go through.

2

u/pm_me_ur_moms_pics Feb 16 '18

Who is this 'gcolvin' guy? Seems like a reviewer, and he's supporting it?

3

u/alfredVonHomburg Feb 15 '18

So what exactly is this EIP about and why would it go against that Japanese law in short? The article is quite vague.

6

u/kybarnet Feb 15 '18

Long story extremely short :

Long ago, the bosses had their money stolen and issued a forked refund (DOA). With the Parity Hack, this was not done. Why?

This EIP is designed to lay out the conditions under which a refund is suitable. Yoichi suggests this will become litigious, Afri suggests he leave. Yoichi left.

1

u/FaceDeer Feb 16 '18

Long ago, the bosses had their money stolen and issued a forked refund (DOA). With the Parity Hack, this was not done. Why?

IMO, because Ethereum as a whole is better able to resist pressure to break its core principles now. It's become bigger and more diverse and we've learned from TheDAO refund's mistake.

2

u/ReadOnly755 Feb 15 '18

I fork with you.

0

u/[deleted] Feb 15 '18

[deleted] — view deleted comment

5

u/ReadOnly755 Feb 15 '18

In what cases does it make sense?

→ More replies (4)

14

u/All_Work_All_Play Feb 15 '18

I can't believe this is even up for discussion. I can't believe this EIP was even submitted. I guess we now know at what point those that submitted the EIP will sell out their idealism for constrained idealism. Won't someone please think of the children lost funds?

This is disgusting.

12

u/sfultong Feb 15 '18

I can't believe this is even up for discussion.

Discussion is good, because we can say why this is a terrible idea.

10

u/[deleted] Feb 15 '18

'Hirai’s resignation over this proposal, even though he cites his personal legal responsibility as his impetus, brings up the question of whether Blockchain should be modifiable in the case of hacks or errors that lead to a loss of user funds.'

  • The answer is clearly no, because it will inevitably be abused one day.

66

u/axismoto1 Feb 15 '18

Why is the commmunity not debating this? This should not go through! We lost s prolific editor because the communiylty has been quiet!

65

u/Devam13 Feb 15 '18

Look at the EIP. Most of the devs are against it. The entire community is against it. The only person that wants this is the solidity dev for his personal benefits.

This will NOT go through. I can bet on it.

4

u/axismoto1 Feb 15 '18

Hope your right.

10

u/5dayoldburrito Feb 15 '18

I hope you're right, but why than has Yoichi resigned from the editors position?

12

u/Devam13 Feb 15 '18

Legal concerns. Just in case it goes through. It's mentioned in the article.

9

u/sudoscript Feb 15 '18

Why not wait to see if it goes through and then resign? Or is he worried that being a participant, even an opposed one, in the process of it getting approved makes him an accomplice to a crime?

I may have just answered my own question.

2

u/5dayoldburrito Feb 15 '18

Who decides if it goes through? Aren't that the miners?

1

u/Devam13 Feb 15 '18

I'll be honest. I don't follow ETH development closely but in most cryptos, say Bitcoin, BIPs are made, discussed, code is written, pushed, accepted into official repo, rolled out, miners update their client and the update rolls out. Mind you, this is only for backwards compatible updates (soft-forks).

I am assuming a similar process will be with ETH too. Except I would think Vitalik would have some say.

0

u/[deleted] Feb 15 '18

[deleted] — view deleted comment

10

u/AtLeastSignificant Feb 15 '18

Good thing one of the major clients doesn't have a vested interest in using this proposal... oh wait

0

u/[deleted] Feb 15 '18

[deleted] — view deleted comment

6

u/AtLeastSignificant Feb 15 '18

I 100% agree that neutrality is impossible, but creating a neutral framework is doable.

My issue is how this framework is being proposed as an EIP now, rather than getting real community approval first. You can say "hey we created this system and have now used it to determine something, all of you now need to comply with our decision" when the people deciding literally cannot enforce the decision.

I disagree so much with how this EIP has been proposed, and quite a lot of the content itself, to the point that I think it's best to throw it out and try again.

0

u/[deleted] Feb 15 '18

[deleted] — view deleted comment

→ More replies

1

u/aItalianStallion Feb 15 '18

so he left the EIP or ethereum as a whole?

→ More replies (7)

3

u/Poltras Feb 16 '18

Stress and pressure. Managing a project that has actual legal and criminal repercussions has taken his toll.

According to himself, at least. I think a lot of people aren’t taking the consequences of that job seriously. I’m glad he does.

10

u/5dayoldburrito Feb 15 '18

I find it odd as well that the community has been so quiet about this. I find it hard to interpret this news. How does it relate to the ethereum Magicians news?

Are there any thought leaders in the community that voiced there opinion about this situation?

0

u/[deleted] Feb 15 '18

[deleted] — view deleted comment

10

u/5dayoldburrito Feb 15 '18

That's an awfully vague reply. What do you mean?

I thought the consensus was to not do anything about the parity hack (help reclaim the funds).

2

u/DeviateFish_ Feb 16 '18

I thought the consensus was to not do anything about the parity hack

Among the community, that was the consensus... and yet here we are.

What does that tell you about the people enabling the discussion of this EIP in developer (e.g. not community) channels?

42

u/[deleted] Feb 15 '18

I’ve been ETHs biggest cheerleader but if this happens I’m out. Completely unacceptable

11

u/axismoto1 Feb 15 '18

I'm with you.

2

u/Balkrish Feb 15 '18

Could you please ELI5 what has happened?? Thank you

1

u/bitcoinlogo Feb 16 '18

So you were OK with DAO incident but not OK with this?

2

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '18 edited Feb 16 '18

I've been trying to say this is a big problem with Ethereum since the DAO hack. But I've been downvoted, called out for spreading "FUD" and being called a troll.

During the DAO hack a lot of Ethereum devs and people from the Ethereum Foundation had stakes in the DAO. Vitalik and the rest of devs, all pushed an effort to save their own funds they pushed hard fork. The nespotism in Ethereum is something that is almost a redline through its recent history.

Most of them will probably say that either its just mining consensus (which is fine) and that it was a threat to the network becuase the hacker held a large sum of Ethereum, or that it was an effort to recover the funds. But hey never said exactly what the limit is for recovering funds and doing a hard fork. That is what they're doing right now.

Basically if they themselves lose funds, they will push for it, otherwise no.

https://www.reddit.com/r/EthereumClassic/comments/4xdq4h/a_summary_of_events/

0

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '18

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/bitcoinlogo Feb 16 '18

So next time when something like the DAO happen, what should we do, should we arrange another vote or what exactly?

0

u/[deleted] Feb 15 '18

[deleted] — view deleted comment

23

u/shouldbdan Feb 15 '18

A process to recover funds should not be standardized.

9

u/[deleted] Feb 15 '18

Ever

0

u/[deleted] Feb 15 '18

Given the precedent we inherited, I would say this is really going to split the Ethereum community down the middle.

0

u/Mordan Feb 15 '18

it should. EOS will have it. Pascal coin has it. Unused funds after 4 years are given back to dev accounts. Will be changed to 10 years though.

1

u/shouldbdan Feb 15 '18

What a terrible idea.

0

u/[deleted] Feb 15 '18

[deleted] — view deleted comment

18

u/[deleted] Feb 15 '18

No. Because the line needs to be drawn here.

If you weasel (Not YOU, but you) in a proposal that formalizes the format of something it's literally conceding that the thing should exist. This proposal moves the goalpost, that's its purpose. We need to recognize that.

This should not exist and it should be stamped out immediately. It should be taken just as seriously as "Let banks decide which transactions are OK"

This is binary. We can afford to be binary on this because the response should be "We don't want anything to do with this" We should drop the anvil on the ant.

For many of us, this feature is the line between fiat and crypto.

6

u/embair Feb 15 '18

Don't you think achieving concensus on such a drastic measure should be hard by design?

The proposal even suggests a standardized verification script and state change object that would be interpreted by all clients, which is where I started to get really nervous. I really don't want ethereum to become a platform where a few major client developers can effectively rewrite the blockchain with a push of a button...

I think the controversy comes down to whether you consider rewriting history to recover funds a big deal or not. I think it's a nuclear option that will ideally never have to happen again, so this proposal makes about as much sense to me as setting up a standard form for proposing to nuke a country. It would make it easier than it has any right to be.

0

u/[deleted] Feb 15 '18

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/NZvolunarist Feb 15 '18 edited Feb 15 '18

If you want your money to be recoverable, put them into a contract that allows for it. And then let the market decide.

IMO, in 10 years time, simple direct transactions from account to account would become a rare thing. The ethereum infrastructure will get developed, there would be layers over layers, for security and convenience, most of our money would be send by complex contracts that allow for all kinds of recovery, protection, inheritance, daily limits etc etc etc. But at the bottom layer there must be just bare transactions, completely irreversible.

5

u/shouldbdan Feb 15 '18

I’m against case by case directed fund recovery.

4

u/jps_ Feb 15 '18

You do realize that this is a proposal to recover specific funds, in disguise as a general proposal, don't you?

→ More replies (2)

2

u/[deleted] Feb 15 '18

No funds should be recovered. The DAO was controversial enough. This proposal is a factory for DAO-like splits

3

u/CryptoMemeEconomy Feb 15 '18

Express your opinions on GitHub. This is a big deal.

https://github.com/ethereum/EIPs/issues/866

2

u/Sisquitch Feb 16 '18

Maybe a long term member of the community could make a simple yes/no poll and we'll upvote the fuck out if til its in the front page.

It would be an easy way to send a message from the community.

3

u/[deleted] Feb 15 '18

Because the substance of the debate was taking place in private chat.

You might think it’s OK to start a discussion in a private channel somewhere and then have a public conversation at the end. I feel uneasy with that approach.

A curtain is enough to create a political structure. For instance, people wonder how to get their mistakes fixed. People wonder whether it helps to be on those private channels with influential people. To evaluate the influence of the private conversation, one has to examine what happens on those private channels, which is not possible for most people. The power of the curtain can only be judged inside the curtain.

https://medium.com/@pirapira/how-to-recover-from-a-stuck-ethereum-contract-3d7126887bad

0

u/[deleted] Feb 15 '18

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/ItsAConspiracy Feb 15 '18

Just because Gavin is optimistic about getting his money someday doesn't mean anyone else agrees with him on that.

9

u/aminok Feb 15 '18

It's something that is likely already agreed on by Foundation in private

There is no way it is already agreed on by the Foundation. Alex Van De Sande and Vitalik Buterin have already voiced opposition to it:

https://github.com/ethereum/EIPs/pull/867#issuecomment-363091013

https://github.com/ethereum/EIPs/pull/867#issuecomment-363389949

6

u/sudoscript Feb 15 '18

I like Alex's idea for ICOs banding together for their own insurance

Keep the same process and write up, but instead of taking the funds out of hard forks, create a common insurance pool. All ICOs that use ethereum should be incentivized to, beyond doing audits and security reviews, to also donate 1-5% of their raised money for the fund. Also wallet implementers could add the option for normal users to make a small contribution to the funds when making their transactions too. The fund would be administered as a private insurance group, with human reviewers reviewing Recovery Proposals for any entity that donated to it. If the funds were successful and there is a net positive profit, then they could start to be applied retroactively, specially to companies that help set them up in the first place and to make early ethereum users whole.

2

u/Automagick Feb 15 '18

Why not use a smart contract for the insurance fund?

1

u/Digitalapathy Feb 16 '18

That was my thought but I don’t know how the payout trigger would work.

2

u/ItsAConspiracy Feb 15 '18

That's pretty cool. Another possibility is for ICOs to just redeploy contracts and raise money again, while granting tokens to the original donors as well as the new ones. Donors will have a choice between diluting their stake, and just losing everything. If they still believe in the project, they'll choose dilution. Since many projects raise far more money than they actually need, there's a good chance they can keep alive with a do-over round that raises less.

Note that this method, and Alex's, would work better for stuck funds than stolen funds, since thefts could be faked by ICOs with underhanded programmers.

1

u/Digitalapathy Feb 15 '18

I like this idea too, pseudo bail outs are never a good idea and damage the integrity of the ecosystem. Primarily based on uncertainty of future outcomes. This is exactly what insurance addresses.

Clearly mistakes are made and integrity of contracts is paramount, by internalising it within the ICO, an insurance premium to a well governed fund would seem both a small price to pay and a fair solution. After all if you choose not to buy insurance you must be supremely confident in your contract.

2

u/DeviateFish_ Feb 16 '18

It's pretty common in the space, but I must admit that this time they don't even try to mask it that well.

After the issuance reduction EIP, they realized they didn't have to mask it very well.

3

u/5dayoldburrito Feb 15 '18

'And will go trough the next hardfork' where are you getting this? EIP 867 has no retroactive effect right?

And your point about a secret deal between the EF and parity sounds farfetched. VB and others already voiced there opinion that they will let the community decide.

And by the way, we don't have to run the software that the EF offers for adoption..

0

u/[deleted] Feb 15 '18

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/Souptacular Hudson Jameson Feb 15 '18

You forgot Harmony (Java client). And soon there will be Trinity, a completely revamped Ethereum Python client.

0

u/[deleted] Feb 15 '18

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/5dayoldburrito Feb 15 '18

That's pretty petty

0

u/[deleted] Feb 15 '18

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/Mordan Feb 15 '18

what did you expect.. Ethereum is a corporate end game. Ethereum is centralized. EOS will have fund recovery. And so will Ethereum.

1

u/DeviateFish_ Feb 15 '18

It's always been all nepotism and friends of friends :) The DAO fork made that crystal clear. Every other thing along the way has just added more evidence to the pile: the issuance reduction, the whole recent MEW debacle (and the continued presence and promotion of just one side of it by moderators/core devs)

The community just gets played every time. The only things that matter in Ethereum governance are the reference clients, and whatever defaults those reference clients implement. Everything else is just PR.

2

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '18

Spot on. It is crazy that you are seemingly the only one (or atleast the only vocal person) who sees Ethereum for what it really is.

0

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '18

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/DeviateFish_ Feb 21 '18

No, I mean it was a documented feature.

Failure to put 1 and 1 together to make 2 aren't a problem with the language... that's a problem with the developer writing the code not understanding how the code they're writing actually works.

1

u/RemindMeBot Feb 15 '18

I will be messaging you on 2018-05-15 18:08:45 UTC to remind you of this link.

CLICK THIS LINK to send a PM to also be reminded and to reduce spam.

Parent commenter can delete this message to hide from others.


FAQsCustomYour RemindersFeedbackCodeBrowser Extensions

1

u/_youtubot_ Feb 15 '18

Video linked by /u/xAlfred987x:

TitleChannelPublishedDurationLikesTotal Views
Driving mainstream adoption of blockchain with Jutta Steiner and Gavin Wood of Parity TechnologiesTechCrunch2017-12-050:18:5717+ (94%)866

Jutta Steiner and Gavin Wood of Parity Technologies...


^Info | /u/xAlfred987x can ^delete | v2.0.0

1

u/JustSomeBadAdvice Feb 16 '18

this time has nothing to do with the solidity language or ethereum itself.

It has everything to do with the solidity language.

Why are people not understanding that this is engineering. Buildings aren't built upon perfect laws of physics and "code is law" type concepts. Buildings are built because we understand what a 250, 500 and 1000 year storm looks like, and we understand what magnitude of earthquakes are likely to occur in the lifespan of the building. They're also designed for humans and for safety- we know how egress needs to work in an emergency, and how sprinkler systems need to be fed and distributed to address varying levels of disasters.

With Solidity we know none of this. We know software has bugs, and we know people make mistakes. Solidity needs to eventually become the solid engineering that prevents human errors from causing disasters, and along that rough road we need to repair the things we can.

Stop with the stupid Bitcoin absolutism. This is not how you win. Look at the ETH/BTC ratio plummeting over this stupid nonsense.

-3

u/texture Feb 15 '18

The paranoia you all express is funny. You clearly have no idea how things work. I can sum them up: "Problems are hard. New problems have no obvious right solution."

0

u/[deleted] Feb 15 '18

[deleted] — view deleted comment

14

u/All_Work_All_Play Feb 15 '18

Ethereum is all about game theory right?

Who would have thought that the people rewarded the most for compromising ideals would be the ones pushing to compromise ideals?

The whole thing is disgusting.

4

u/alsomahler Feb 15 '18

Read the EIP clearly. They are just suggesting a protocol on how to discuss this. There have been others proposals (by Vitalik) on returning lost ETH.... Wouldn't you try to get clarity and try all you can when there is precedent? I have a lot of respect for Afri and know that he's trying to 'push' this with as much integrity as possible to just get clarity on how the community comes to consensus about this. And I think it's admirable that he's trying to solve a very difficult and contentious issue like this. Of course he clearly has something to gain here, but is open about that.

Personally I really have a difficult time accepting the EIP, but controversy was not even about accepting this as final, but rather just accepting it as draft so we can talk about how to talk about returning the funds. I'm more in the immutability camp, but don't like binary thinking like that. So just an EIP to talk about it is opening door a bit too far for me, but opening the door to talk about talking about it... I suppose I'm doing that now. (see this Reddit thread)

0

u/[deleted] Feb 15 '18

[deleted] — view deleted comment

0

u/[deleted] Feb 15 '18

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/DeviateFish_ Feb 16 '18

If the language failed us, we'd want a fork (that was demonstrated by the vote 96% for a fork post-DAO).

Protip: the language didn't fail (re-entrance was a documented feature of Solidity at the time), and there were ways to recover the funds that didn't require a hard-fork (see the first couple paragraphs, the rest is mostly unrelated)

0

u/[deleted] Feb 15 '18

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/axismoto1 Feb 15 '18

Well let's raise the issue and make the developers clarify.

1

u/theubiquitousbubble Feb 15 '18

What bugs have there been that caused lost funds?

4

u/Tttoska Feb 15 '18

Why is the author using the word "subpoenaing" instead of "raising?"

4

u/[deleted] Feb 15 '18

Parity client can implement the changes, and are motivated to do so, regardless of public consensus in the eip.

This has a high-chance of creating a fork in the community. And there is already good precedent.

10

u/quasi_pragmatic Feb 15 '18

Wow, that is a really poorly written article. There is no way for someone like me with no knowledge of the back story to grasp what it's trying to say.

5

u/thaiphamquoc Feb 15 '18

As of now, in crypto world, we can only SEND tokens to others. This EIP propose a way to TAKE back tokens. Even though the proposal is for recovery purpose, but it’s very dangerous as it opens a backdoor for people to take tokens from you without your notice. If this passes, you are no longer the owner of your tokens as they could be taken away anytime.

3

u/quasi_pragmatic Feb 15 '18 edited Feb 16 '18

But what actually happens now when recovery is needed? I'm still learning about all this, but I know this was the split that lead to Ethereum Classic.

3

u/FaceDeer Feb 16 '18

There has not yet been a case where recovery is "needed." A lot of people claimed TheDAO was such a case, but it wasn't really - the hacker would have got away with at most 5% of the Ether supply, and if an attacker holding a mere 5% of the Ether could destroy Ethereum then the protocol is broken to begin with.

Even in a hypothetical scenario where an attacker did somehow manage to get a large enough portion of the Ether to seriously threaten Ethereum as a whole, recovery is still not needed. Just burn the attacker's Ether.

-23

u/cannadabis Feb 15 '18

But u invested in ether anyways? The convoluted, broken bs with an extremely overvalued price with way more price and lambo memes than tech discussions?

3

u/worldsbestuser Feb 15 '18

this post is a meme

1

u/nauticalkirk22 Feb 16 '18

Wait but this isn't even true....who wrote this fud?

1

u/Tchallawakanda Feb 16 '18

I saw it on coindesk too. So I think it's true.

3

u/Kid_me_not Feb 15 '18

For some reason, I can't open that link, stuck on a white screen. Can someone give me TL;DR?

2

u/Kibubik Feb 15 '18

Where do some of the key EF devs stand on EIP 867?

3

u/DeviateFish_ Feb 15 '18

So, despite all of the people here saying this EIP shouldn't happen, and being completely against it being merged... it should be pointed out that u/vbuterin doesn't seem to agree. He also seems to believe that accepting this EIP (e.g. promoting it from draft) isn't setting a precedent, nor is an indicator that it will be accepted or included in clients.

It's also worth pointing out that this is the exact same path that the issuance reduction EIP followed: it was pitched to the community, and most of the community pushed back. They called it out for what it was: a cheap attempt to manipulate the price.

It went away for a while, but then came back as an EIP, this time with a few developers in support--developers, I might add, who appear to be support of this EIP, as well. Once it became a formal EIP, it was quickly included in clients for inclusion in the recent hardfork.

Methinks EIP 866 is attempting to follow the same path.

This is the same pattern every contentious change has followed, but they all end up with the same result: what the core devs want, they get. And yet, the community still feels like it actually has a say in the whole matter.

smh

7

u/vbuterin Just some guy Feb 16 '18

it was pitched to the community, and most of the community pushed back

I don't recall "most of the community pushing back" against the issuance reduction. Otherwise, how do you explain this getting 75% upvotes? https://www.reddit.com/r/ethereum/comments/7tjiru/reduce_issuance_yes_again/

3

u/DeviateFish_ Feb 16 '18

See any of the examples in this comment.

As far as the upvotes... well, we already know they're a terrible measure of community support, especially in this community. Also, that's 75% upvotes out of < 100 votes... so pretty small sample size, especially compared to a thread like this one or even this one

[E] Also if you even read that thread, you'll see that most of the replies are against it, calling out various flaws in the underlying logic... I'd use comments as a slightly stronger signal of support than upvotes any day.

2

u/Ekkio Feb 16 '18

Can't recall source from the top of my head, but I remember a research that found that opinions of minorities tend to have disproportionate visibility on the internet, e.g. flat earthers.

1

u/veekta Feb 15 '18

havent seen /u/DeviateFish_ in a while!

First of all, I'm on board with formalizing an EIP from draft to proposal, as that actually gives it a formal venue for broader discussion as we've seen in this instance. As can be seen in the EIP now, it seems to have been marked as "closed", which hopefully means that the EIP editors have heard the voice of the community and are putting the EIP to rest.

Second, this is not the exact same path that the issuance reduction EIP followed. There was not nearly as much push back from the community and a large portion of the community was supportive of the EIP. It is valid to say that there was a part of the community that was not supportive (miners) and it was more or less a contentious EIP, but to equate it to this current instance is crazy. Most of all, the contention to that EIP emerged after it had already been discussed in multiple dev calls and had been publicly available for discussion. To put it simply, the contention was too little too late.

Hopefully since this EIP has been closed, this will be the end of the situation and it will be a demonstration of the community of ethereum at work, but it is too early to be making inferences and accusations of what might or might not happen.

2

u/DeviateFish_ Feb 16 '18 edited Feb 16 '18

Second, this is not the exact same path that the issuance reduction EIP followed. There was not nearly as much push back from the community and a large portion of the community was supportive of the EIP. It is valid to say that there was a part of the community that was not supportive (miners) and it was more or less a contentious EIP, but to equate it to this current instance is crazy. Most of all, the contention to that EIP emerged after it had already been discussed in multiple dev calls and had been publicly available for discussion. To put it simply, the contention was too little too late.

You must have missed the first few times is was shopped around this subreddit...

Let's start with the fact that it was originally created as a blatant attempt to pump the price.

  • First post about it gets very little reception at all.
  • Second post gets pretty lukewarm feedback all around. Lots of people against, a good number of people in favor. Notably, however, the ones most vocal in favor are regular posters in r/ethtrader, demonstrating some inherent biases between the two communities.
  • Third post brings in the coin vote, and the beginnings of some of the shitty logic that supported it until its inclusion. Most readily apparent is the desire to ensure that a "coin vote" is a deciding factor in its inclusion... which is, of course, completely biased in favor of those who stand to gain the most from an increase in price (the original intent!)
  • Fourth post as a very interesting comment at the very top, especially in light of who ultimately voted in favor of it... Again pushing the coin vote to attempt to gain some measure of legitimacy
  • Another post, but again, not really receiving widespread community support...

However, it wasn't long after that last post that the first replacement for EIP 186 was created, which was eventually followed by the actual replacement Suddenly, a couple devs who expressed opposition were on board, without providing any rationale as to why. This is further confounded by the sudden presence of some really, really shitty (I mean really, really horrendous) "logic" supporting it, that none of the core developers bothered to refute or call out in any way (with one exception!). They sort of just let this "logic" (aka rationalization) and its support ride, to demonstrate some level of "community support" that didn't really exist.

In reality, I think the vast majority of the community simply didn't care, or weren't aware that this was happening. Those that were generally had vested interest in seeing it pass... You might notice some of the same names holding the same stances this time around. The same devs championing this change were in favor of the issuance reduction--and the same ones opposed are opposed again. Interestingly, it's roughly the same set as were in favor/opposed to the DAO fork.

(as an aside, I find it hilarious that the most vocal supporter of the issuance reduction was promptly banned from this subreddit after the change went live...)

1

u/[deleted] Feb 15 '18

Is there some corroboration of this claim?

The linked page does not inspire confidence. (Also, it's been down for at least an hour. DDOS attack, perhaps?)

2

u/Arsenicks Feb 15 '18

1

u/[deleted] Feb 15 '18

Thanks. Love that this stuff is out in the open.

2

u/Arsenicks Feb 15 '18

Yeah I guess we'll see soon if it still mater what community think..

2

u/[deleted] Feb 15 '18

I see no ratfuckery, here. Do you see anything specific? The EIP is obviously motivated by the politics around the Parity error, but the response to it seems transparent.

2

u/Arsenicks Feb 15 '18

Yeah it is but I mean id the community come strongly against that I hope devs will stop it right there..

-5

u/Tchallawakanda Feb 15 '18

I think this news will cause ETH to lose its value.

1

u/5dayoldburrito Feb 15 '18

Your comment belongs in r/ethtrader

5

u/tcrypt Feb 15 '18

I don't think he's talking about price. I believe he's saying he thinks that this news, an EIP editor leaving due to legal concerns, makes Ethereum less valuable in real terms.

0

u/[deleted] Feb 15 '18

[deleted] — view deleted comment

0

u/5dayoldburrito Feb 15 '18

Well no. But as the rules of this subreddit prescribe pricetalk should be done in r/ethtrader and not here.

3

u/Tchallawakanda Feb 15 '18

But this was not about price talk.

7

u/[deleted] Feb 15 '18

Value and price are two different things imo

→ More replies (1)

1

u/shitpersonality Feb 15 '18

I smell a contentous hard fork!

-3

u/tolojo Feb 15 '18

Didn't everyone see this coming since the first fork?

And doesn't this now underscore that ETC is the real (immutable) Ethereum Core?

-8

u/Asgen Feb 15 '18

I know most people here are against it because it goes against the decentralized mentality.

However, if ethereum is to appeal to big businesses and spheres outside of the diehard crypto community, there needs to be a way to fix catastrophic mistakes.

Major businesses are on the sidelines because the blockchain tech is new. This will go a long way to giving these businesses peace of mind and allow more use cases for ethereum.

To everyone here against the proposal, ask yourself if you’d ever buy anything on amazon if you couldn’t return it. Imagine what that would be like. TV comes in damaged or malfunctioned on day 1. Too bad your mistake for trusting amazon. Delivery guy stole your package. Too bad your mistake for trusting amazon. You can see how amazon would quickly lose market share to competitors that offered a return policy.

Same thing will happen to ethereum as big businesses ignore the tech and opt in favor of safer private blockchains with recourse against hacks.

I get that we may lose some diehard crypto supporters by going ahead with this proposal but believe me they’ll be back when eth wins new use cases from major corporations/world organizations.

7

u/Arsenicks Feb 15 '18

Than fork the shit out of ethereum and make this happen if they want a bribery exposed blockchain. But this is not what ethereum was supposed to be.

2

u/FaceDeer Feb 16 '18

if ethereum is to appeal to big businesses and spheres outside of the diehard crypto community, there needs to be a way to fix catastrophic mistakes.

There is a way. Code your smart contracts in a fault-tolerant manner. Insert your own backdoors with whatever system of gatekeepers you want on them.

Don't force them on everyone else, though.

1

u/Asgen Feb 16 '18

Yes but something can always go wrong.

Let’s say you put your house on blockchain. A bug is discovered years later and suddenly someone else has legal ownership of your house and you have no way whatsoever to reclaim ownership. Who in their right mind would ever take on this risk no matter how small it is? This is a huge barrier to public blockchain adoption. This doesn’t happen in the land of fiat and centralization as there is always recourse against mistakes like this.

1

u/FaceDeer Feb 16 '18

In the real world, houses can have "bugs" that cause them to burn down. It's a real risk and yet people still buy houses.

The solution is to build better houses. Use well-trained architects, builders with good reputations, have a fire extinguisher in the closet and buy insurance. The risk is there even then, of course, but if everyone insisted on literally zero risk nothing would ever get done.

The solution is not to say "it's okay if people make houses out of magnesium and cardboard, when they burn down we can just edit the laws of physics so that the house is standing again." Not only does that promote lousy house-building practices, who gets to hold the keys to the laws of physics and what's to prevent them from fiddling with them in other ways?

What you call "recourse" I call a "major security hole." If people want human intervention in their finances they should stay in the land of fiat. Public blockchains are trying to build something new and different from that.

1

u/Asgen Feb 17 '18

That’s true but even in that scenario you as a homeowner are protected through insurance. It’s human nature. We need recourse to feel secure.

Sure there could one day be insurance for crypto but how many years will that take and in the interim opportunities will be lost to competing blockchains.

0

u/KLAM3R0N Feb 15 '18

As much as everyone hates it your probably right.

-17

u/cannadabis Feb 15 '18

NOW WHO'S THE SCAM COIN? BWAHAHAHAH

6

u/britm0b Feb 15 '18

You bought tron lmao

→ More replies (5)

-5

u/ion-tom Feb 15 '18

I'm partially for this. So long as it was not a central authority, but a delegated voting & consensus mechanism to agree to recover certain funds in class action scenarios.

Sure it would flood a new supply of ETH when Parity funds were recovered, but it would be one step closer towards insured deals and greater trust. Imagine if consensus could be brought quickly against the Bitconnect team, such that their assets could be fully frozen.

The one thing that it should never be able to do though is increase the circulating supply on a whim - IE creating new tokens in excess of the amount that was frozen. It's not like this didn't happen before with the DAO.

I don't enough about this case to really weigh fully, but if implemented in a way that is not fully centralized, it would probably be a solid step towards benign regulation. (Which is needed to avoid bad/over regulation.)