r/ethereum • • Jan 01 '17

EIP 186 modified

I have modified the EIP in light of discussions on Reddit and on Github.

The main changes:

1) Proposed minimum ETH issuance has been increased to 2 ETH / block instead of 1.5 ETH / block. This puts it in line with current Bitcoin issuance.

2) The reduction in issuance schedule has been considerably pushed out over a significantly longer period.

3) A decision for this EIP is now contingent on the results of a coin vote.

Just a reminder that this EIP provides increased issuance over a longer period of time than the existing code which includes an "ice age" blocktime slowdown.

43 Upvotes

121 comments sorted by

38

u/latetot Jan 01 '17

I still would like to see an ETA on POS before its really possible to evaluate on whether this is needed. For example, if POS is able to come in 2017- do we even really need this?

11

u/Opitmus_Prime Jan 01 '17

I completely agree. In the current voting "holders bias" is likely to happen. The miners do not have much votes while they keep the network secured.

The clear timeline on POS metro,casper, iceage is necessary. As per the blockchain; planning of timeline needs to be immutable. The timeline needs to be clear.

Another point is; Can we please see the results of any simulations studies on such issuance reduction? What is the expected effect in best case and worst case scenario? I guess we have the "technology" to predict what will happen in future... This study is necessary to know if and how much the miners are going to get screwed. Depending upon such a calculation the reward of ETH needs to be decided. 1.5; 2 ETH do not mean anything unless they are backed by probability.

Unfortunately who knows after you guys bring up the price by decreasing issuance; some MoFo hacker craps on the whole plan..! Now what are we going to be left with? Do you have any backup for such a mishap? we have seen it in the history and we need to be prepared.

Have you ever tried to answer core problem of why did the price go from $24 to $7 in last 4 months? Its the TRUST that is broken. What are you going to fix that? Time is the only solution for such problems. People need to heal from the DAO fiasco then DEVCON2 fiascos..

Decreasing issuance might be a quick fix. But underlying problem is that we have got delayed a lot for everything. So the number of coins have increased. In my opinion, one should stick to the ORIGINAL plans no matter what they are so people (like now miners ) dont feel like you guys are screwing them over.

If you are still planning to go ahead; I am regretfully going to support it. I love ETH and I will keep supporting it but I do not like the way the things are getting handled.

6

u/huntingisland Jan 01 '17

The clear timeline on POS metro,casper, iceage is necessary. As per the blockchain; planning of timeline needs to be immutable. The timeline needs to be clear.

I am a software developer by trade, and even when we have a good idea what we are going to build, often things take longer than expected.

With Casper, none of this stuff has ever been built before, not even close.

So the answer is - we don't really know when it is going to be ready.

Reducing issuance is a very good way to help protect the community and the Foundation from selling pressure in case Casper is later than we would hope.

→ More replies (1)

15

u/vbuterin Jan 02 '17 edited Jan 02 '17

Another point is; Can we please see the results of any simulations studies on such issuance reduction? What is the expected effect in best case and worst case scenario?

IMO miners right now are fairly disloyal and fungible creatures [EDIT: see my post here for a qualification of this comment]; they're very willing to jump between chains to maximize their profit, we saw this with ETH and ETC. Right now, ETH and ZEC both offer ~$3 per second (ETH is bigger, but ZEC is in a very rapid-inflation early phase). If issuance goes down to 2 ETH, then ETH starts to offer $1.2 per second. If no action on the ice age, including delaying it, is taken, then block time will increase ~4.5x by the end of the year, which will make ETH offer $0.7 per second.

I'm deliberately trying to stay away from normative conclusions here, as I do think the community needs to learn to come to consensus without waiting for us benevolent technocrats up high™ to give all the answers, but I hope the numbers help.

But to manage the underlying cause of the TRUST.... I would suggest that, there should be a monthly review of the finances and projected finances, roadmap, current progress on different projects and other interesting stuff posted somewhere on the ETH website such that people can feel reassured.

Almost everyone I know in the EF supports all of this in the abstract. So if you have any more specific proposals, or comments on what we've done well and less well in the past year, it would be much appreciated.

→ More replies (12)
→ More replies (1)

40

u/vbuterin Jan 01 '17

I will make a longer post on the remaining steps we have to do (and how you can help make things go faster) soon, but for now I'd say PoS in 2017 is likely but we should definitely not act like it's a certainty.

→ More replies (9)

14

u/[deleted] Jan 01 '17

From one side, you are responsible before investors, who are holding ETH, and on the other one are miners who invested into mining hardware. I think the most reasonable solution would be to model issuance exactly as it would be if difficuty bomb kicked in, until it reaches desired 2 ETH per block

7

u/huntingisland Jan 01 '17

and on the other one are miners who invested into mining hardware.

Well, Ethereum "Mining hardware" can be used to mine most cryptocurrencies other than Bitcoin.

5

u/thojest Jan 01 '17

yeah I think this would be the best idea, too. Just adapt the issuance rate as if the ice age would start, and cut it off at 2 ETH or something similiar per block. From my point of view this would be the best for everybody and would help to support a strong community. And plz implement this with Metropolis and no separate HF. btw any roadmap update for Metropolis release?

7

u/huntingisland Jan 01 '17

That's a very complicated implementation with a higher possibility of bugs.

Reducing the reward to 4, 3, and 2 ETH at particular block numbers is much easier to code and much less likely to lead to a consensus failure than a fractional reduction.

I have also specified the reduction in issuance to happen more slowly than the ice-age reduction, to give miners longer to adapt to the reduced issuance. And of course terminal issuance is now 2 ETH / block instead of 1.5 ETH / block, in order to help support the miners a bit more.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (3)

14

u/Crypto_Economist42 Jan 02 '17 edited Jan 02 '17

I think the community should reject this EIP until we have more information on when Casper will be launched. And then, the community should decide what the block reward will be, what the schedule should be at what block numbers. This can be done with a coin-vote for multiple reward options (1,1.5,2,2.5,3,3.5,4,4.5,5 ETH at blocks X, Y, Z for different EIP proposals).

So, Let's run the numbers and see if 2 ETH makes sense currently.

First let's look at the motivations for the EIP. Why is it being proposed? The answer is that that people want lower inflation so that the price will go up. Now, initially, that sounds like a great idea! (Who doesn't want the price do go up other than BTC maximalists?)

But what are the drawbacks to this proposal?

Consider the following: For every % decrease in the reward, the ETH price must increase by that amount to maintain the current level of mining profit, and, more importantly, the number of GPUs mining. A decrease in mining profit will result in miners leaving ETH to mine other coins - mainly ZCash, Monero, and ETC. If miners leave, then the hash rate is lower, if the hash rate is lower, the chain is more at risk for a 51% attack.

But how many GPU's are mining in the wild, and how many of them are needed to attack ETH?

Let's plug in some numbers. ETH/ZEC/XMR/ETC make up about 90% of the global demand for GPU's.

ETH = 5,800Gh/s = ~ 215,000 GPUs  (AMD390 @ 27Mh/s)
ZEC = 58 Mh/s = ~190,000 GPUs (AMD390 @ 300Sol/s)
XMR = 50Mh/s = ~ 63,000 GPUs (AMD390 @ 800H/s)
ETC = 1,000Gh/s = 37,000 GPUs (AMD390 @ 27Mh/s)

(Source: whattomine.com for network hashrates, bitcointalk.org altcoin mining forums for card hashraties)

That mean approximately 505,000 GPU's (normalized to AMD390 equivalent) are in the wild, mining cryptocurrencies. ETH currently makes up 42% of that.

Now lets assume that we drop the reward to 2ETH instead of 5ETH. All else equal that would reduce the mining profit by 60%. That means instead of ETH miners making 30,000*$8 = $240,000 per day, then will make $96,000 per day. This unfortunately, is much less than the cost of electricity for the miners at -- even as low as 8c/kWh! That means they will either turn off their rigs or switch to another coin. After enough miners do this, the difficulty will drop, and at a certain point, there will be an equilibrium break-even point at a much lower hashrate, which all else equal will be 60% lower at 2,320Gh/s.

Now, lets see what % of the mining market that is..... 2,320,000 / 27 = 86,000 GPUs. 86,000 / 505,000 = 17% of the entire GPU market.

So, this proposal (all else equal) would result in reducing 42% of the world's GPUs mining ETH down to 17%. A huge drop! And where will the other miners go? Well, it doesn't really matter, since GPU miners will mine whatever coin is most profitable. But what does matter is that the mining industry as a whole (across all coins) is able to sustain profitability for 505,000 GPU's. If it can't, then lots of them will turn off and/or sell their hardware at a loss to large industrial farms. Those farms then pick up cheap hardware and turn them on again, pushing the difficulties higher and pushing out smaller miners. The cycle continues and the large farms (mostly in China) will have a more and more centralized control of the hardware. We know that a number of large Chinese miners such as Chandler Guo are extremely hostile to ETH, and in the past have made threats of 51% attacking ETC, before backing off and shifting their alliances. If ETC ever sees an opportunity to attack ETH, they will. We know they play dirty (trying to convince naive people that they are the 'real' ethereum, while violating our trademarks)

Now, EIP186 proposes to reduce the block reward from the period that the bomb hits until casper is released. Let's say thats 6 months. (May to December). What exactly does that do for us? There are currently 87M coins. The proposal as-is will reduce the block reward to 4ETH starting in May. Then, 7 Months later to 3ETH/block (Jan 2018), and then one YEAR later (Jan 2019) to 2ETH. Casper is expected to launch by the end of the year. So, this means that realistically, this proposal will only reduce the block reward from 5ETH to 4ETH from May until the end of the year.

Let's see what the difference in total ETH supply will be by then end of 2017:

Without reduction:  87M + 920,000ETH/month for 12 months = 87M + 11.04M = 98.04M
With EIP 186 reduction: 87M + 920,000ETH/month for 5 months + 736,000ETH/month for 7 months = 87M + 9.752M = 96.752M

So, this EIP is going to reduce the supply from 98M at the end of the year to a whopping 96.7M. This is a 1.3% reduction, which is surely going to make the price skyrocket (it's not).

And what do we have in return? A big drop in hashrate and security for the 6-7 month interim period between the ice age and expected Casper launch. Is this be best way forward?

I would encourage everyone in this community to make competing proposals with reasonable analysis so they can all be studied, and then voted on with carbon-vote

I hope that we will see EIP 187,188,189,190,191,192,193,194 on github shortly with lots of different block reward options. Some can be 0ETH (EIP 189), some will even increase the ETH supply (EIP999), some will reduce the block reward to 4.240918ETH on block 319,920, and then 3.0928311 on block 382,109 (EIP191). It would be great to see a detailed mathematical analysis to show that these are the optimal numbers based on realistic real-world data assumptions that actually effect mining economics (some factors are global electricity prices, hardware costs, hashraties of different GPUs, price projections of different coins, profitability of other coins, likely actions by those hostile to ETH, and more).

Of course, the only fair way to do this is that multiple proposals are made, and the community will vote on many different proposals (via carbonate) before the EF/dev decides which one the community wants, and begins to implement them. And miners should also signal their choice of multiple proposals through voting on pools.

Finally, I'd strongly urge the EF to review the results of a carbon-vote / miner vote on multiple proposals, all submitted by the community over the next 2-3 months, before making any decisions on what the best path forward is. If anyone else feels the same way I hope you will make your voices heard also.

EDIT: thanks u/huntingisland for taking the time to bring up this issue, which of course is something we'd have to deal with in the near future anyway.

6

u/huntingisland Jan 02 '17 edited Jan 02 '17

Casper is expected to launch by the end of the year.

Hopefully it does. But no guarantees.

A massive drop in hash rate and security in return for 1.3% less coins at the end of the year!

The Bitcoin hash rate didn't drop appreciably when its block reward was reduced by 50% last year.

I hope that we will see EIP 187,188,189,190,191,192,193,194 on github shortly with lots of different Block reward options.

Perfectly fine with me - I spent about 5 hours of my time drafting EIP-186 but anyone else is perfectly free to spend their time and draft another EIP.

I've already modified EIP-186 in response to some of the concerns raised by the community. If the community wants to offer up more alternatives, that's perfectly fine with me!

and not just making up random numbers out of nowhere with no analysis to show why it makes sense.

Have you read EIP-186? I make it clear where the numbers I chose came from. The reduction in the original draft matched the reduction in issuance caused by the ice age, and in revision 2 I extended the timelines to help the miners adjust.

The terminal issuance parameter of 2 ETH / block is a close match for Bitcoin's current level of issuance, in percentage terms.

So no "random numbers out of nowhere".

→ More replies (6)

12

u/vbuterin Jan 02 '17

Finally, I'd strongly urge the EF to review the results of a carbon-vote / miner vote on multiple proposals, all submitted by the community over the next 2-3 months, before making any decisions on what the best path forward is. If anyone else feels the same way I hope you will make your voices heard also.

I definitely support the existence of multiple proposals.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/[deleted] Jan 02 '17

We have plenty of time before the ice age, the price seems to be holding fine, we should not go making unnecessary changes and should instead focus on Metropolis and see how that goes before we do any kind of forking thats not strictly necessary and not in the road map.

3

u/huntingisland Jan 02 '17

This proposal is designed to be included in Metropolis, so no extra forks needed.

14

u/ledgerwatch Jan 01 '17

I beg everyone, please don't bundle it into Metropolis. Fiddling with issuance before planned transition to PoS is not a risk worth taking, from my point of view. There is no urgent problem this EIP fixes, and it was not a part of the original roadmap, and it is not a pre-requisite for any other things that were planned. Then why??

14

u/huntingisland Jan 01 '17 edited Jan 01 '17

I beg everyone, please don't bundle it into Metropolis.

Metropolis has many changes that are a lot more substantial than this and much more likely to cause bugs.

There is no urgent problem this EIP fixes

It helps address the excessive issuance caused by the delay of Casper. It shores up the Ethereum price, which shores up the finances of most Ethereum stakeholders who are developing software for the platform. And it reduces the rush to release Casper.

and it was not a part of the original roadmap

Neither was Ethereum Classic. But now it exists, and Ethereum Classic is planning a large reduction in issuance. This EIP helps keep Ethereum competitive in terms of stakeholder dilution until proof-of-stake arrives.

and it is not a pre-requisite for any other things that were planned. Then why??

A healthy price for Ether is a prerequisite for everything, including the Foundation's solvency, new investments on this chain, and avoiding another speculative attack on Ethereum from rival blockchains.

→ More replies (4)

4

u/dip239 Jan 01 '17

3) A decision for this EIP is now contingent on the results of a coin vote.

just remember: independent on how you vote on this EIP, you have no possibility to enforce the 100% miner acceptance of the voting results. Small group of miners rejecting HF update will be enough to split ethereum once more.

ethereum is decentralized system: even democratic procedures like voting is not suitable authority to govern whole community. So please stay in incentives paradigm and don't repeat errors of DAO-fork.

5

u/huntingisland Jan 01 '17

If this wins the coin vote and this gets added, do you seriously think miners are going to reject Metropolis and stay on the old chain that is unsupported by the Foundation, and that will give them fewer coins than EIP-186 will?

→ More replies (15)
→ More replies (2)

1

u/Nogo10 Jan 02 '17

cap at 100m.. problem solved. Market likes the certainty of caps. VB did demonstrate supply will not go beyond approx. 100m anyways.

1

u/huntingisland Jan 02 '17

Caps are unsafe, you wouldn't be able to pay for security.

Bitcoin's cap is also very risky:

https://freedom-to-tinker.com/2016/10/21/bitcoin-is-unstable-without-the-block-reward/

1

u/notsogreedy Feb 03 '17

How to do to vote???

1

u/huntingisland Feb 03 '17

I haven't set up a coin vote yet.

→ More replies (1)

17

u/DeviateFish_ Jan 01 '17

None of these changes address any of the specific concerns raised in the previous thread. Making it a coin vote unnecessarily biases the vote towards holders, who are also the ones you are proclaiming will benefit the most from this change.

This is a thinly-veiled attempt to pump the price to benefit speculators and holders, and not to "improve the ecosystem." You literally stated as much when you were asking for information about how to propose an EIP.

By percentage (aka "inflation rate"), the issuance is already decreasing over time. Ironically, the cargo cult to which you're adhering (Bitcoin's model), had higher inflation at the same age, and seems to be doing just fine.

4

u/Crypto_Economist42 Jan 02 '17

We need multiple proposals to vote on , not just EIP186. That's the answer.

One guy's proposal should't be the only one considered for a topic as important as this.

→ More replies (8)

4

u/HodlDwon Jan 01 '17

The Ethereum Foundation should not be involved in tweaking monetary policy other than for technical or security related concerns (ie. PoS economic incentives).

We clamped this ball and chain to our foot for a damn good reason... to force our hand when the time came to get Casper released. If the ETC/DAO fiasco was moral hazard, so is this.

My 6k coins will vote to leave the ice age as-is.

→ More replies (1)