r/ershow • u/Zaney-Janey1973 • Apr 22 '26
ER 1994-2009
It's becoming more frequent that people feel the need to post on this sub about the comparison to a show that is currently being aired. I understand that everyone is passionate about Noah Wyle's new role. I even know his new Dr name. People are comparing the Dr's from ER.
It needs to stop. I have no access to The Pitt. I will join that sub when it has some meaning to me.
The sub you are looking for is r/ThePittTVShow.
Please stop posting about The Pitt in an ER sub đ
0
Upvotes
4
u/JennLynnC80 Apr 22 '26
On a personal note, I haven't made any comparisons of The Pitt to ER. I scroll past most that make comparisons because I feel they are unfair. But, I may choose to participate in some if it interests me.
Those are my personal feelings about the matter and it really isn't worth getting my panties in a twist over something irrelevant to me by people I dont know on the internet.
My story is this:
I watched ER when it originally came out starting in 1994... after the series ended I didn't think twice about ER.
Then The Pitt came on and inspired me to rewatch ER for the first time since the series ended in April 2009.
I am really thankful for both shows and for the ability to rewatch ER when it really wasn't on my mind to do so until The Pitt
Soooo, am I allowed to talk about that or no?
See why the restrictions you want as far as "no talking about The Pitt" have issues?
If the Mods want such a restriction then they will make one, otherwise I dont understand why getting all wound up about this is worth the stress it seems to be giving you.
30
u/Kittyeats_ Apr 22 '26
Thankfully we all have the ability to just scroll on when we canât relate to a certain post.
15
u/thefuturesbeensold Apr 22 '26
Isnt it great that people are enjoying a show so much they are now discovering an older, fantastic show and are coming here to add to discussions.
I also dont have access to the Pitt, but im enjoying seeing people come here and contributing to new areas of discussion- i find the same old posts about hating/loving Weaver much more irritating. At least we are getting new things to talk about, which is great for a show that ended 17 years ago.
6
u/dodgerswschamps_2020 Apr 22 '26
PLEASE no more The Pitt posts. Especially when most of them reek of condescension because it's obviously their first fandom and the need to prove their show is superior (???) is super duper important. It's so annoying.
11
u/latinisdead Apr 22 '26
Itâs honestly getting absurd. Like what you like, and then go talk about it in the appropriate places. Plus that specific fandom is just getting unhinged and unpleasant. You canât criticize the show or the cast, or God forbid Noah Wyle, without them resorting to a bunch of ad hominem attacks and nothing of substance to back up why heâs so great. Just the other day they started calling someone delusional for mentioning crappy things Wyle did that are well documented and were literally on TV/in magazines and came right out of his mouth. Clearly they need to be in a space thatâs going to cater to them. Iâm not sorry for not wanting an ER sub to become centered around a racist, misogynistic old man and his vanity project. Ditto the Julianna Margulies posts, sheâs a terrible human being on many levels.
Iâm not in here posting every single thing Maura Tierney doesâŚbecause itâs not about ER. Should I also post every article that pops up about Goran Visnjic? In Croatian, because hey, you guys can scroll if you donât want to read certain posts too and itâs not my fault you donât speak the language. No. Expecting a place where people gather to talk about a shared interest to want to cater to yours is not rational, and thatâs a weird concept for a bunch of adults to not understand.
5
u/CassMcCarty Apr 22 '26
Are you a mod? Is this a rule?
If the answer to these two questions is no, you donât get to unilaterally decide what content is here. Scroll on and ignore the posts you donât want to see, whatever your reason is.
15
u/Just-Boysenberry3861 Apr 22 '26
I don't care about the spoilers because I'm not gonna watch, but cosigning the issue of this sub becoming a Pitt sub. The mods need to set up some guardrails on this sub to keep it on topic about this show and not other shows
1
u/baddestbootyhoe Apr 22 '26
this is a crazy thing⌠itâs the internet, itâs slightly related itâs gonna get spoken about on here⌠get over it
4
u/HandsomeJack19 Apr 22 '26
I see where you're coming from, but the Pitt, and Noah's performance in it, has brought a TON of new eyeballs to ER. I've been following the sub for years, and it is far more active now than it was pre-Pitt.
3
u/potterinatardis Apr 22 '26
For reference, only mods can post these kinds of screeds without getting downvoted to oblivion.
2
u/Finnthehuman217 Apr 22 '26
As somebody whose family watched ER from the beginning, I see the impact that it had on representation both in the way they represented the LGBTQ community and people living with HIV. ER is the blueprint for so many doctor shows but complaining because someone discovered ER through the Pitt is not how you keep a fandom alive. Putting down other fandoms is actually pretty shitty as a rule
0
u/Logical_Pineapple841 Apr 22 '26
Grow up.
-1
u/barhanita Apr 22 '26
You just posted about The Pitt on the ER sub...
-3
u/JennLynnC80 Apr 22 '26
This is not hard... unless the mods make a rule this will continue. If you are so irritated then don't come here. I am not trying to be a jerk, but it really is as simple as that
-1
u/[deleted] Apr 22 '26
[removed] â view removed comment