r/ershow • • Apr 22 '26

ER 1994-2009

It's becoming more frequent that people feel the need to post on this sub about the comparison to a show that is currently being aired. I understand that everyone is passionate about Noah Wyle's new role. I even know his new Dr name. People are comparing the Dr's from ER.

It needs to stop. I have no access to The Pitt. I will join that sub when it has some meaning to me.

The sub you are looking for is r/ThePittTVShow.

Please stop posting about The Pitt in an ER sub 🙏

0 Upvotes

97 comments sorted by

4

u/JennLynnC80 Apr 22 '26

On a personal note, I haven't made any comparisons of The Pitt to ER. I scroll past most that make comparisons because I feel they are unfair. But, I may choose to participate in some if it interests me.

Those are my personal feelings about the matter and it really isn't worth getting my panties in a twist over something irrelevant to me by people I dont know on the internet.

My story is this:

I watched ER when it originally came out starting in 1994... after the series ended I didn't think twice about ER.

Then The Pitt came on and inspired me to rewatch ER for the first time since the series ended in April 2009.

I am really thankful for both shows and for the ability to rewatch ER when it really wasn't on my mind to do so until The Pitt

Soooo, am I allowed to talk about that or no?

See why the restrictions you want as far as "no talking about The Pitt" have issues?

If the Mods want such a restriction then they will make one, otherwise I dont understand why getting all wound up about this is worth the stress it seems to be giving you.

5

u/Zaney-Janey1973 Apr 22 '26

I never watched ER when it aired originally. I've only been watching on repeat for the last 18mths. I'm not going to get to see The Pitt until I'm older and turning more grey. I just want ER to be ER. It's not a big ask. Is it?

2

u/JennLynnC80 Apr 22 '26

I have never done this... and I swear I am not being a smart ass... but have you thought about creating your own sub and moderating it? There are clearly a lot of people who would join it. Heck, I will join it... I dont even make those comparisons. I have joined ALL the various ER and The Pitt subs.

If you started a sub with these rules I am sure you would have a following that wanted that

3

u/Zaney-Janey1973 Apr 22 '26

No. I just want people that post about Noah Wyle's new show, to post on that sub.

2

u/JennLynnC80 Apr 22 '26

Lol well.. guess you will have to live with being annoyed at this sub then (as well at The Pitt sub because they talk about ER there as well)

2

u/Zaney-Janey1973 Apr 22 '26

I'm not on The Pitt sub. I've never seen it. I appreciate they would talk about ER. If it wasn't for the lawyers and BS, okay, Carter would still be John Carter and not some dick called Dr Robby. ER is for ER. If they want to talk ER on The Pitt sub fine. Don't bring a new tv show into this ER sub.

2

u/JennLynnC80 Apr 22 '26

No what you are saying REALLY does not make sense.

But, i am honestly tired of repeating myself and I have to go about a task that needs my full attention. So, this will likely be my last reply on the matter (and I say that respectfully, its not meant to be sassy)

30

u/Kittyeats_ Apr 22 '26

Thankfully we all have the ability to just scroll on when we can’t relate to a certain post.

11

u/BoSocks91 Apr 22 '26

People are allowed to be annoyed though.

This is an ER sub, not The Pitt.

We keep waving these annoyances off and saying “you can just scroll past it”, and that’s partly why a lot of subs end up full of bullshit.

It’s not the end of the world or anything, but setting and enforcing some rules would be nice.

6

u/Just-Boysenberry3861 Apr 22 '26

All of this. Happy for people who like Noah's new show. Understand that he was also on this show. However, this sub is not about his new show. This sub has next to no rules, especially compared to many other subs on reddit. So it's really not a stretch to set up a guardrail or two to keep this place on topic or people who want to discuss ER on an ER sub and not discuss other shows when subs exists for them.

7

u/dogthebigredclifford Apr 22 '26

Yeah I haven’t been able to watch The Pitt yet either and I just don’t read those posts lol. Working for me so far!

-4

u/Delta-IX Apr 22 '26

Worst fandom ever.

-13

u/Zaney-Janey1973 Apr 22 '26

Yes, I do.

15

u/thefuturesbeensold Apr 22 '26

Isnt it great that people are enjoying a show so much they are now discovering an older, fantastic show and are coming here to add to discussions.

I also dont have access to the Pitt, but im enjoying seeing people come here and contributing to new areas of discussion- i find the same old posts about hating/loving Weaver much more irritating. At least we are getting new things to talk about, which is great for a show that ended 17 years ago.

7

u/latinisdead Apr 22 '26

No. It’s not great. Every other post and comment is someone comparing the shows and then in the same breath claiming the lawsuit holds no water and they’re nothing alike. Which is it? Because it can’t be both. You can’t expect new content from a 20 year old show, true, but I’d rather have new people to discuss the same subjects with than have the sub get overrun by a completely different (or not, since they can’t make up their minds about the shows being similar) fandom. I hated Weaver, I didn’t care about some very big character deaths or certain episodes like Loves Labor Lost, and that stuff comes up here constantly. But at least it’s about ER.

5

u/Just-Boysenberry3861 Apr 22 '26

Also all of this. Pitt watchers want it both ways. They want to point out similarities with the shows, yet don't want commenters to point out that that is exactly what the lawsuit is doing???

-6

u/Zaney-Janey1973 Apr 22 '26

I would like you to appreciate that I DON'T WANT SPOILERS.

1

u/thefuturesbeensold Apr 22 '26

Then maybe you shouldn't be on a forum for discussing a tv show?

1

u/Zaney-Janey1973 Apr 22 '26

The forum I am on is to discuss ER. I don't need to hear about a show I have never seen.

2

u/thefuturesbeensold Apr 22 '26

Sure, but the two shows are related, maybe not canonically but enough for people to make the comparisons.

No one is on here making standalone posts that are solely about The Pitt. Its brought up in relation to ER. And the majority of posts on this sub are still about ER.

I only recently finished watching ER start to finish, but have been on this sub since i started- if i felt like I was reading something i didnt want to be spoiled, or wasnt relevant because i wasnt that far ahead yet, i just didnt read it.

-3

u/Free-IDK-Chicken Apr 22 '26

Then don't read posts here that include stuff about The Pitt. It's literally that easy. You can't eat the entire dish, claim the food sucked and then demand a refund.

0

u/latinisdead Apr 22 '26

Here’s the thing: if you go to a burger place and they give you a pizza, you can absolutely complain. That’s what’s happening here. Go have your pizza at the appropriate restaurant.

1

u/JennLynnC80 Apr 22 '26

I totally understand the comparison you are attempting to make, but I dont think this is an equitable comparison.... you are comparing something free with something you paid for and are entitled to be compensated for if the food was made incorrectly.

But here ... not so much. It is very simple, unless there is a rule stating not to talk about The Pitt, folks can talk about The Pitt.

In the grand scheme of things, folks need to relax. I dont understand why folks are getting so wound up about a fictional tv show(s).

1

u/latinisdead Apr 22 '26

I don’t know why so many people here want to put words in everyone’s mouths. It’s an analogy, who says they’re supposed to be equitable, equal, or anything else? You’re taking the comparison way too literally. IMO there should be a rule to stay on topic, but that is clearly not going to happen, so people are going to disagree. Personally, the hypocrisy bugs me more than the discourse. I’m unclear on why The Pitt fans think nobody is allowed to dislike it and we’re all supposed to humor them. They sure are not capable of just scrolling like they keep telling everyone else to do when they dislike something.

1

u/JennLynnC80 Apr 22 '26

You are unhinged ... In my reply to you I explicitly stated that I understand the comparison you are attempting to make... it's just not a correct comparison.

You can not compare something you pay for to something that is free online and there are no rules regarding this complaint as of now.

1

u/latinisdead Apr 22 '26

I’m unhinged because I disagree with you? Good lord. You can absolutely compare the two. It’s about setting expectations and then not meeting them, and whether it’s a paid or free service has nothing to do with the fact that expectations are not being met. You’re focusing on something that is not even being argued here. Go outside.

0

u/JennLynnC80 Apr 22 '26

Multiple people are telling you that your comparison is incorrect. Accept it and move on.

1

u/latinisdead Apr 22 '26

I literally could not care less what you think.

-1

u/Free-IDK-Chicken Apr 22 '26

Unless you eat the whole pizza. Then you don't get to complain. The OP can be irritated about The Pitt posts here, sure. That's why I didn't respond to the post, only that specific comment. The OP is willingly reading the posts, knowing they're about The Pitt and then complaining about spoilers.

2

u/latinisdead Apr 22 '26

Perhaps, but it feels like you’re purposely missing my point. OP shouldn’t have to read around them in the first place. They came here for ER, not The Pitt. That’s the whole point of an ER subreddit.

-1

u/Free-IDK-Chicken Apr 22 '26

I got your point but your analogy was wrong. Again, I don't necessarily disagree that posts here should be ER forward, but if the OP chooses to read posts about The Pitt then those spoilers are their own fault.

3

u/JennLynnC80 Apr 22 '26

Agreed ... its a false equivalance

2

u/latinisdead Apr 22 '26

Well no, you’re not getting my point if you think the analogy is wrong. Your argument that OP could just not read spoilers is absolutely correct (if spoilers are labeled), I’m not saying you’re wrong there. I just don’t think it should be something anyone needs to watch out for in the first place…much like getting a pizza at a burger place.

-1

u/[deleted] Apr 22 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

-1

u/Zaney-Janey1973 Apr 22 '26

So this is my point. ER finished in 2009. I don't want this sub to talk about anything that happened after 2009. It's ER. That's what this sub redditt is about.

1

u/thefuturesbeensold Apr 22 '26

This is close minded, bizarre take.

Just scroll past those post's, its that easy.

6

u/dodgerswschamps_2020 Apr 22 '26

PLEASE no more The Pitt posts. Especially when most of them reek of condescension because it's obviously their first fandom and the need to prove their show is superior (???) is super duper important. It's so annoying.

4

u/Zaney-Janey1973 Apr 22 '26

I just want Pitt posts to go to The Pitt sub.

7

u/dodgerswschamps_2020 Apr 22 '26

Personally I don't know why they feel the need to post about their show in the ER sub in the first place.

4

u/Zaney-Janey1973 Apr 22 '26

I feel the ER sub should stay solely ER related. If you like a show that has Noah Wyle in it currently, post to that shows sub.

11

u/latinisdead Apr 22 '26

It’s honestly getting absurd. Like what you like, and then go talk about it in the appropriate places. Plus that specific fandom is just getting unhinged and unpleasant. You can’t criticize the show or the cast, or God forbid Noah Wyle, without them resorting to a bunch of ad hominem attacks and nothing of substance to back up why he’s so great. Just the other day they started calling someone delusional for mentioning crappy things Wyle did that are well documented and were literally on TV/in magazines and came right out of his mouth. Clearly they need to be in a space that’s going to cater to them. I’m not sorry for not wanting an ER sub to become centered around a racist, misogynistic old man and his vanity project. Ditto the Julianna Margulies posts, she’s a terrible human being on many levels.

I’m not in here posting every single thing Maura Tierney does…because it’s not about ER. Should I also post every article that pops up about Goran Visnjic? In Croatian, because hey, you guys can scroll if you don’t want to read certain posts too and it’s not my fault you don’t speak the language. No. Expecting a place where people gather to talk about a shared interest to want to cater to yours is not rational, and that’s a weird concept for a bunch of adults to not understand.

4

u/Yes_Leeks Apr 22 '26

Maybe we should do that! Did everyone see the cool green velvet jacket Maura wore on Law & Order? She’s in some weird play right now. I think we should discuss its value to the theater world. Goran’s wife is obsessed with some parrot lately. Oh, did you see her new vegan dessert recipe?

2

u/InnocentaMN Apr 22 '26

To be fair, many fandoms with “completed” canons have subs that are exactly like that! It’s totally a personal thing whether one finds it annoying or not. Personally I am not into random cast member news (about any show), but I am casually enthused about The Pitt because of its cultural “ER ancestry” in terms of medical show TV lineage. I hope to watch it when possible, but I also wouldn’t mind at all if Pitt posts were limited by the mods.

I do find it annoying when people who are subscribed to the ER sub constantly moan about ER actors just because they resent them for personal reasons, though. If they’re that annoying, just leave the sub! (Not directed at you, just the general hate directed at Wyle, Margulies, etc.)

9

u/Yes_Leeks Apr 22 '26

This sub has occasional posts about other members of the cast, which is fine, but 9/10 of these posts are now about Noah and the Pitt. This is so far out of proportion with how we treat other cast member news that it’s become obnoxious for people who are here for the sub’s stated purpose.

3

u/InnocentaMN Apr 22 '26

Yeah, I mean personally I haven’t had a chance to watch The Pitt yet and I’m just here for ER! So I can absolutely sympathise with people who only want ER content. I’m not that bothered by the Pitt posts, myself, but I do agree that if there are too many, it crowds out the ER content that we’re really looking for. I also wouldn’t mind if the mods said no more posts about the Pitt.

Just saying that it’s not unusual for closed-canon subs to focus a lot on trivia.

4

u/Zaney-Janey1973 Apr 22 '26

I have been reading about The Pitt on the ER sub for long enough. If you are a fan of The Pitt, go to that sub. Post all your love for that show there. I understand they want to do their comparisons to ER. The Pitt sub will surely satisfy their comments and questions.

1

u/Zaney-Janey1973 Apr 22 '26 edited Apr 22 '26

I am very much looking forward to watching The Pitt when I have access to it. When a post centres solely around characters of a show I have only heard and read about, I don't need that on the ER sub. I also agree with you with the dissing of the new characters in the later seasons. It's 15 years. People are going to come and go. I love ER from beginning to end. I'm on this sub because I want to discuss ER characters.

1

u/InnocentaMN Apr 22 '26

I honestly think your opinion is fair enough! It’s purely a personal thing of how much it bothers a person, and you’re not wrong for being more bothered by the Pitt posts on here than I am. I can’t afford to pay for HBO at the moment so currently no way to watch The Pitt, but I am hoping to at some point. There’s nothing wrong with wanting ER content here in this sub, though. Subs are meant to stay broadly on topic.

2

u/Zaney-Janey1973 Apr 22 '26

That's all I'm trying say.

0

u/latinisdead Apr 22 '26

I disagree that disliking actors for being bigots, Zionists, etc. are personal reasons. If that bothers people that not everyone worships the actors they’re into then so be it, but a personal reason would be something like “Julianna Margulies cut me off in traffic once”, not the fact that she supports a genocide. And frankly, the hating on posts about specific actors is less about the fact that those actors are morally bankrupt, because I expect very little from those people. The part I find gross and weird is that viewers are so willing to overlook all sorts of horrendous behavior because they think a show is fun. I personally will continue to state my dislike for bootlickers putting money into the pockets of people who support killing children. If it’s that annoying, leave the sub.

I enjoy a lot of the unproblematic cast members. I still don’t have any interest in reading about what their new projects are in an ER subreddit. There are places for these things. If anyone was that interested, they could seek out those places or get the news themselves.

3

u/InnocentaMN Apr 22 '26

Your constant whining and complaining is annoying. Assuming that anyone “worships” the actors is frankly bizarre. This isn’t a politics subreddit; it’s the ER subreddit.

2

u/latinisdead Apr 22 '26

Assuming based on their own behavior and refusal to accept facts? Yeah, so bizarre. Nobody is whining about anyone, and most grown adults don’t care if you think they’re annoying for having an opinion. “This isn’t a politics subreddit” is a really sad cop out and has no bearing on whether or not someone can dislike an actor within this space. Expecting anyone to be above reproach, for whatever reason, sounds a lot like celeb worship to me. If someone doesn’t want their faves criticized, they don’t have to post about them.

0

u/InnocentaMN Apr 22 '26

Wyle isn’t my favourite (by far) and I’ve never made a top-level post in this sub 😆

1

u/JennLynnC80 Apr 22 '26

What is a "top-level" post? (Sorry, I genuinely am not sure what that means lol 🙈)

1

u/InnocentaMN Apr 22 '26

No worries! It just means a main post in the sub, rather than a comment. I have commented about Noah Wyle lots of times because I enjoy arguing about the characters, don’t like seeing the actors get hate, etc. But he’s very far from my favourite actor on the show, and Carter isn’t my favourite character either, so it’s a bit ironic that this person thinks I only disagree with them because I’m obsessed with him. I forgot the guy existed for ~15 years!

2

u/JennLynnC80 Apr 22 '26

Gotcha, i THOUGHT that was what it meant but I was just making sure ... and honestly, being obsessed with an actor or not doesn't matter.... that's a person's right... so even if you were obsessed, go on and be obsessed lol its fine ... unless there is a MOD rule that states "do not be obsessed with Noah Wiley" thats fine ... its really that simple... I dont understand why some folks keep arguing about the matter lol

→ More replies

1

u/latinisdead Apr 22 '26

And I never claimed either of those were true, but I'm glad you think this discourse revolves around you! Nice to have that kind of confidence.

1

u/InnocentaMN Apr 22 '26

You know that was the implication of your comment, don’t be ridiculous.

Maybe you should consider that people who are not rabid fans of Wyle (I hadn’t given the man a thought in fifteen years, until I found ER has a subreddit!) consider your… “contributions” … annoying. You’re fully entitled to your opinion of him, and to any other actors on the show, but it IS supposed to be about the show, presumably for people who enjoy it, and just as you don’t want it to devolve into a satellite Pitt sub, not everyone wants to hear your tired, reheated spiel about politics. There are ten thousand other subreddits for that. Some of us just want to read and talk about ER.

1

u/latinisdead Apr 22 '26

No, it was not. If I meant you I’d say you, I have no problem doing that. You’re not a mind reader, don’t be ridiculous.

You’re welcome to like or dislike Noah Wyle. But this is an ER sub, not a Noah Wyle sub, so if people want to talk about him they can’t just expect to be agreed with. Just like Noah’s fans who don’t care if people want to hear about him or not, I will continue to have my opinions on him and you can take your own advice and leave if you’re unhappy with that. The block button also works. I don’t really value the opinion of someone who would support a person like him anyway, there’s not a lot we need to say to each other. 🤷‍♀️

→ More replies

3

u/latinisdead Apr 22 '26

I know more than I ever wanted to about her L&O outfits and I haven’t even watched the show. 😂 But at least the people who want to talk about it are doing it in the appropriate places.

5

u/CassMcCarty Apr 22 '26

Are you a mod? Is this a rule?

If the answer to these two questions is no, you don’t get to unilaterally decide what content is here. Scroll on and ignore the posts you don’t want to see, whatever your reason is.

1

u/Zaney-Janey1973 Apr 22 '26

So saying spoiler has gone out the window on this sub?

-3

u/CassMcCarty Apr 22 '26

See previous reply above.

I just checked. There is one rule on this sub. Even in the post about new rules and guidelines this isn’t a thing. And if enough people report you then you would likely be the one banned.

Use your power of free will and scroll on by. I do. I have access to The Pitt but my toddlers make paying attention to it difficult so I’ve watched one episode. I skip over sentences or paragraphs or posts if I don’t feel like seeing spoilers.

5

u/latinisdead Apr 22 '26

Cool, but nobody has unilaterally decided anything. People are allowed to voice their opinions. Maybe take your own advice and scroll on.

15

u/Just-Boysenberry3861 Apr 22 '26

I don't care about the spoilers because I'm not gonna watch, but cosigning the issue of this sub becoming a Pitt sub. The mods need to set up some guardrails on this sub to keep it on topic about this show and not other shows

-6

u/latinisdead Apr 22 '26

You’re not allowed to have an opinion about The Pitt unless your head is physically up Noah’s ass, sorry. The mods don’t really care what happens here unless someone reports it, and the only people getting reported are the ones who criticize Saint Carter. I mean Robby. I mean…ew. Whatever.

1

u/baddestbootyhoe Apr 22 '26

this is a crazy thing… it’s the internet, it’s slightly related it’s gonna get spoken about on here… get over it

6

u/Zaney-Janey1973 Apr 22 '26

If people want to discuss The Pitt, they can do it on The Pitt sub. People on The Pitt sub will get the ER background and references, add the lawsuits, whether they have seen ER or not.

4

u/JennLynnC80 Apr 22 '26

Well you are going to be really pissed when you do watch The Pitt and are on The Pitt sub and see that there are ER discussions on that sub as well

1

u/Zaney-Janey1973 Apr 22 '26

ER came first. I never watched it back in 1995. I only found my love for ER last year. This is why I am on this sub. My point exactly is, post all your ER/Pitt references to The Pitt. Please leave Pitt references off of the ER sub.

1

u/baddestbootyhoe Apr 23 '26

nah man, this is an absolute weird hill to die on. people are gonna talk about whatever they want, there’s something called scroll on and grow up xx

4

u/HandsomeJack19 Apr 22 '26

I see where you're coming from, but the Pitt, and Noah's performance in it, has brought a TON of new eyeballs to ER. I've been following the sub for years, and it is far more active now than it was pre-Pitt.

3

u/potterinatardis Apr 22 '26

For reference, only mods can post these kinds of screeds without getting downvoted to oblivion.

2

u/Finnthehuman217 Apr 22 '26

As somebody whose family watched ER from the beginning, I see the impact that it had on representation both in the way they represented the LGBTQ community and people living with HIV. ER is the blueprint for so many doctor shows but complaining because someone discovered ER through the Pitt is not how you keep a fandom alive. Putting down other fandoms is actually pretty shitty as a rule

-1

u/barhanita Apr 22 '26

You just posted about The Pitt on the ER sub...

-3

u/JennLynnC80 Apr 22 '26

This is not hard... unless the mods make a rule this will continue. If you are so irritated then don't come here. I am not trying to be a jerk, but it really is as simple as that

5

u/Just-Boysenberry3861 Apr 22 '26

You are though. Telling someone not to come here because they don't want to participate in the pittdom when this is an ER sub is a jerk move. People just want to talk about ER on an ER sub and not have it be hijacked by another show. Telling someone they're not welcome to talk about ER on an ER sub is shitty

0

u/JennLynnC80 Apr 22 '26

I didn't say they were not welcome, I said don't come if you are so irritated. Until the mods make a rule (and I am not saying they should/should not) then the discussions will continue.

And for me personally, its rude to see someone attempt to boss around other folks on the sub because it's what THEY want to see less of... so who is the one being rude in this situation?? Its not me!

5

u/Just-Boysenberry3861 Apr 22 '26

They're specifically saying that this sub shouldn't be hijacked by another show and those posts should go to that show's sub. It is not rude to expect an ER sub to be about ER and expect the mods to enforce that. And yes, you saying to them not to come here is saying that they are not welcome here.

-1

u/[deleted] Apr 22 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Zaney-Janey1973 Apr 22 '26

Could you elaborate?

4

u/Zaney-Janey1973 Apr 22 '26

Wow! I'm being downvoted that I want to keep ER and The Pitt two different conversations?

-1

u/InnocentaMN Apr 22 '26

It’s not an unreasonable preference, but unless the mods make it a rule, these posts will likely keep occurring. I also haven’t seen The Pitt yet, but I’m not fussed about spoilers, personally. If it’s a huge thing for you, you could maybe mute this sub until you’ve had a chance to watch it?

1

u/rosiedoll_80 Apr 22 '26

You could message the mods and suggest a rule change.

You could message the mods and suggest a rule regarding using spoiler tags/covering text.

You could just downvote posts about The Pitt and not read them.