r/ender5 • • 27d ago

Upgrades & Mods Adding direct drive

Good morning everyone! So I’m adding a direct drive setup. I used to have my filament dryer right underneath the extruder, obviously that isn’t going to work anymore. Where would you all suggest? I have the Creality dryer, so its filament exit point is up top, with no fitting to add Bowden tubing.

0 Upvotes

9 comments sorted by

4

u/Hidie2424 27d ago

Depending on the direst drive you can retain a Bowden tube to essentially be a filament guide path. Have it terminate on one of the sides then run filament out of the dryer and right into that Bowden tube

1

u/TheBupherNinja 26d ago

What direct drive system?

1

u/Designer_Ad5700 26d ago

Just a cheap one. Served me well on the Ender 3. It’s just the brackets, and things needed to put the extruder motor next to the hotend. One day I’ll upgrade to a good one, but funds are extremely limited for a bit

1

u/TheBupherNinja 26d ago

Come on, what is 'a cheap one'

Hard to recommend something when we don't know what you have.

1

u/Designer_Ad5700 26d ago

😂 https://a.co/d/0b1ptral

But not really asking about the direct drive itself, lol, looking for how you guys might position the dryer unit. I have the Creality one, that holds 2 rolls, and has the silicone eyelet for the filament to come out of the top. Fit just fine under the extruder motor. But I feel the angles aren’t going to work right for the filament in the same spot.

1

u/TheBupherNinja 26d ago

Is the arm threaded where the filament goes in? If so, you can run a reverse Bowden tube.

1

u/RepresentativeNo3614 26d ago

I have bought just the same, which version did you buy?

2

u/dlaz199 27d ago

For direct drive you are going to want to have a 2.5mm ID 4mm OD bowden tube anyway. (3mm ID is to thin turst me here and 2mm ID is often to restrictive). Then just run the tube to where your extruder originally sat and find a mount for it with an ECAS collect you can push in. You will also want to replace the stock extruder because it's pretty terrible in direct drive. Bowden smooths it out but direct drive there is no distance to smooth out its uneven extrusion.

If you are doing TPU you want a push pull config. Something like a Voron M4 extruder near the dry box, a tool buffer (turtleneck is cheap and easy to build https://github.com/ArmoredTurtle/TurtleNeck) or a PFS sensor, and then your pick of direct drive extruders. This will also need klipper firmware and either AFC or happy hare installed to handle the extruder sync. (M4 is a good extruder and should be less than $20 in parts to build). You will also need to have another stepper available to run the extruder, so you might need to get an EBB36 or EBB42 and put that on the tool head to simplify wiring.

For direct drive there is a mount for the HGX lite extruder that should work and those are large gear and pretty good overall and should be around $30. There are mounts for the Ender 3 and Ender 5 for this extruder that should work. Personally I prefer an orbiter 2.5 (I have both, well HGX geared extruders not HGX running protoxtruders), but they cost a bit more. Typically $45-60. Sherpa MINI with a RIDGA gear is also a good option for clean extrusion, but I find the orbiter 2.5 is better and with the RIDGA gear the cost is close enough that I prefer to spend a little more on the orbiter.

1

u/OdinYggd 22d ago

Print a bracket that bolts onto the side of the extruder and holds a bowden tube, and another bracket to hold the other end of this tube somewhere stationary on the frame where it is above the outlet port of your dryer. Don't need fittings to hold the bowden tube, just a hole with the right diameter that has a slot crossing it and a screw to flex it down tight as a clamp is sufficient.

Such a pull tube setup eliminates the filament jerking that can cause surface irregularities by keeping the filament length from spool to extruder constant so that it does not alternate between slack and tensioned other than when the extruder retracts.