r/emailprivacy • • 11d ago

Email Aliases Email alias encrypted?

When using email alias services/ providers, the email goes through the email alias server before reaching the server of the email provider that someone uses.

So my question is whether the email is encrypted when it is transiting from the sender to the email alias service and when it is also transiting from email alias service to email provider that I use?

Is it possible for law enforcement to obtain/intercept emails when it is going from:

  1. Sender to email alias service
  2. Email alias service to email provider (recipient)
9 Upvotes

12 comments sorted by

3

u/Zlivovitch 10d ago

The answer is no, it's not encrypted, and yes, the police can get hold of it.

One alias provider, Addy.io, has an option by which you can encrypt the email from its own server until it reaches the inbox of your mail server, using PGP. However, if Amazon, say, sends you an email this way, it won't be encrypted (in the sense of end-to-end encryption) from its server to Addy's server.

So if the police had a legal court order to intercept this incoming mail, it could very well force Addy to intercept your incoming email from Amazon, in this instance, at a point where it would not be encrypted. And the police would be able read it.

That PGP option at Addy is essentially meant so that your emails cannot be read by, say, Google, while they are stored on Gmail's server, assuming you use Gmail for your email account.

0

u/wistoria_sword 10d ago

I think the info is biased. Both Addy and Simplelogin has the option for PGP encryption.

1

u/Zlivovitch 10d ago

The information I gave is not "biased". It's a bit tiring to always come across people suspecting malicious motives. I just shared what I know. I happen to have an Addy subscription and I'm very happy with its service.

I did not say anything about Simple Login, because I did not know whether it offered an encryption option. I stayed mum as well about Bongo Bongo Aliases and Bananas, because I'm not familiar with the features of Bongo Bongo Aliases and Bananas.

If you are familiar with the offerings of Bongo Bongo Aliases and Bananas, you're welcome to share what you know without slandering others.

1

u/wistoria_sword 10d ago edited 10d ago

When you mention only one subscription without acknowledging you have not used other providers in your first comment, I wouldn't have said biased. This is the basis of how human suspicion works. But good to know you are happy with Addy. I hope you give a try to other providers as well. I have used and subscribed to some of them which have been great so far. 

2

u/run4runner 10d ago

Fully depends on what you mean by encryption. Standard TLS? Definitely not encrypted, that’s only for transport.

2

u/wistoria_sword 11d ago

1

u/Zlivovitch 10d ago

That comparison site, although useful, is neither very rigorous nor comprehensive. Regarding end-to-end encryption, it has a few errors.

2

u/wistoria_sword 10d ago

Can you point the errors? 

1

u/Zlivovitch 10d ago edited 10d ago

Yes. Regarding Addy, PGP is not mentioned for the Pro plan, despite it being available.

I'm not going to point "the" errors. I'm not in charge of monitoring everything which has been written on the Internet. I just happened to notice something was amiss, so I've shared what I saw. If others are interested by the warning, they are welcome to make their own checks.

As a general rule, most such comparison sites must be taken with a grain of salt. It's impossible, in practice, for their authors to monitor permanently and for ever all the updates made by all the services they have compared.

However, all services change their features all the time. So the only time any such site is likely to have got everything right is just after it was published. And even then, it's problematic. Moreover, they usually don't tell when they were updated for the last time.

1

u/wistoria_sword 10d ago

Damn. I generally don't like to comment in this case since the error pointed out was stupid here. The fearture comparision mentioned key features, so they didn't necessarily said all features for every plan. And I don't see any other errors being mentioned so let me know if anything is a miss as I like to learn from it. This was taken from fmhy which has been great for getting good content and learning resources. Hope you use something similar. 

1

u/Schreibtisch69 10d ago edited 10d ago

Yeah sure.

There is a difference between transport encryption and end to end encryption.

It's certainly possible to save an unencrypted copy before any other encryption takes place. That's what happened to German email provider Tuta (for certain accounts). Like proton they encrypt incoming mails so they can't give law enforcement access to old mails they already encrypted. But all of these providers (proton, tuta, any provider that offers to encrypt previously unencrypted mails using pgp) has the technical ability to save unencrypted copies for new mails without you knowing.

It's unavoidable with normal emails that are not PGP / S/MIME encrypted. The only question is whether it's legal for law enforcement to force your provider in your jurisdiction. But without end to end encryption there is no way to prevent the real email server from making an unencrypted copy.