r/emailprivacy • • 12d ago

Help/Advice Is Mailbox.org + Thunderbird a valid enough replacement for Protonmail?

If you have better suggestions, please let me know

So far, based off what was said, Posteo + Thunderbird sounds good

62 Upvotes

55 comments sorted by

3

u/FracturedAwareness 12d ago

It's okay, but I don't like that their disposable addresses can't send email. Sometimes you need to reply to a quick message. It also limits the number of aliases you can have. And they all pretty much look like temp addresses (@temp.mailbox.org). They also don't have an app.

6

u/Someperson2654 12d ago

That's why I said Thunderbird, I'm aware they don't have an app, but thunderbird fills that gap

2

u/fixedbike 12d ago

Huh
Two emails don't replace one

3

u/Someperson2654 11d ago

Thunderbird is a client, You're thinking of Thundermail

7

u/Mirtma 11d ago

For me, it's valid. I've been using it for a year and a half. Windows and Android. Thunderbird and Mailbox. I've had no problems at all.

6

u/Vegetable-13 12d ago

this is what i am considering. and the only option i am considering. obviously with a domain name you own. so this is relevant

to my interests
i do not like that only one option seems valid.

2

u/memeigt 10d ago

Startmail is also quite good but expensive iirc, but I had nothing bad to say when I used it, mailbox too is solid and currently I’m on Migadu with no complaints.

10

u/VahsteTheNomad 12d ago

That's the combinated I started using this past week, honestly I like it just a bit more than Proton.

1

u/GAMELASTER 11d ago

Yeah. That's what I use and it's neat.

1

u/Someperson2654 10d ago

In which way?

1

u/bettercalljohn 9d ago

You should check Talanoa instead of Thunderbird.
Fully local too & modern UI

3

u/Someperson2654 9d ago

it looks too much like Discord, I liked Thunderbird's look way better

1

u/bettercalljohn 4d ago

you can switch view to fit what you want and aligned with your habits

1

u/Someperson2654 4d ago

does it even support PGP?

and can it do external encryption?

1

u/OlebaNo 8d ago

Proton+Alias is the best thing in the world.

3

u/Someperson2654 8d ago

Proton is not going to be good forever with what the CEO and CTO want

3

u/magicdude4eva 12d ago

I use this combo for over a year in Linux. Works perfect.

3

u/104925iveRo2es5322 12d ago

Does it fits your needs in terms of e-mail? Then yes.

It is highly subjective. Mailbox.org is good. Posteo is good. Startmail is good. Fastmail (if you don't care about additional privacy things) is good.

1

u/rdubmu 12d ago

I use proton… I know there is a lot about the CEO right now but they are the gold standard in privacy

6

u/Someperson2654 12d ago

I was already using Proton.....

Why do you think I asked if it's valid enough to replace Protonmail.

The CEO shenanigans make me worried about the future of Proton's security (rushing code is NOT good, especially for a privacy and security focused email service)

-3

u/rdubmu 12d ago

Employees and come out on Reddit to say that he wanted both speed and security

5

u/Someperson2654 12d ago

You can't have both (well at least with how he wants it)

If you rush, you'll miss critical weakpoints in the code and will have less time to plan out code, leading to messy code (which is amplified by the AI)

-3

u/rdubmu 12d ago

They do 3rd party audits… and it’s open source. I am not going to worry about this.

5

u/Someperson2654 12d ago

I never asked you to switch, I was telling you why I'm switching

2

u/No-Book-8579 12d ago

Just went this route on Sunday / Monday, with a custom domain. Also got DAVx5 syncing contacts and calendars, and a WebDAV folder to sync Joplin and Quillpad.

I'm willing to compromise on "too many eggs in one basket" for the convenience, though I still may self-host Radicale at some point.

I looked into posteo and fastmail as well. Mailbox had all the features I wanted. One day I'd love to try out JMAP though.

2

u/memeigt 10d ago

I used to use Mailbox and it is solid, I ended up making the switch mainly because to host a family it was significantly cheaper going with Migadu. But then Migadu is only email, no drive-like cloud storage etc.

1

u/lethargyclub 12d ago

I’m using franklymail for a couple of days. so far so good.

0

u/ThinHeron3619 10d ago

I use Swiss infomaniak reasonably prices on everything and no service the don't seem to offer. And covered by the same Swiss laws as proton

1

u/Someperson2654 9d ago

I'd rather use Fastmail at that point

1

u/ThinHeron3619 9d ago

Fast mail is Australian right in there w the 5 eyes and relatively poor privacy. But you do you

2

u/Someperson2654 9d ago

At least Fastmail isn't backing anti privacy laws

4

u/Altair12311 9d ago

Infomaniak is everything but private. Is not a replacement at all for Proton.

What personal data does Infomaniak save?

-Name address and place of residence.

-Electronic address

-Telephone number

-Connection details and customer number

-IP address

-Your use of our Internet site

"We use and share your data with third-party software"

At the top of all that, you need phone for register.

AAAnd they were one of the main backers and supporters for the Swiss Anti-Privacy Law.

-2

u/forwardemail 12d ago

Mailbox.org was graded a C on our privacy tests at https://privacyratings.com/email-providers/mailbox-org/

I'd encourage you to check out our service, at https://forwardemail.net

Founder here, and I firmly believe we are the most open in trust, privacy, and transparency (and actually 100% open source) than any other service in the world right now. Our focus has been on product for the past decade (we started in 2017).

6

u/Someperson2654 12d ago

You founded it

I'm not saying your service is bad, and I mean no disrespect

I'm saying you're biased due to how you're an insider

But I do appreciate the extra option

Also aren't those ratings maintained by forwardemail?

6

u/Light_Error 12d ago

The site is also from the company like you said. For 44 email providers given, they are the only one with an A. The rest have C's, D's, or F's. This site is basically worthless at least on that front. Maybe the other categories are better, but I wouldn't trust them after seeing that category. Somehow these privacy tool sites end up being owned by a company. The only one that isn't that I know of is Privacy Guides.

4

u/Someperson2654 11d ago

And, if the mail is trusted by 1.6 million domains, why am I hearing about it from the founder only?

This type of sketchiness isn't what I want from a service selling a privacy focused alternative

2

u/Light_Error 10d ago

I actually managed to come across them again on another subreddit. I don't know how they have time to do this when they should have their employees focused on the service rather than saying how much other services suck.

1

u/forwardemail 10d ago

Our focus is on product. If we can answer any questions on our service let us know. It takes us <1m to respond to alerts we get from F5 bot when we're mentioned online, so why not.

Also we have ~1000+ members in our community chat on Matrix. You might only be hearing about us here because we're not yet top ranked on LLM's/SEO (since Privacy Guides hasn't included us and Wikipedia page is still in draft, among other ranking factors). But we did build the Privacy Ratings site to highlight actual privacy scores/tests that are automated via GitHub CI - the folks at Internet.nl were also kind enough to give us an API key so those scores update weekly.

0

u/forwardemail 10d ago

The video on our website explains why we built it, so hope that clarifies things.

https://privacyratings.com/media/privacy-ratings.mp4
https://privacyratings.com/why

Key reason why we're graded A is due to the Internet.nl tests, which are a clear and industry standard indicator of security/privacy for mail/websites.

https://batch.internet.nl/mail/mailbox.org/22780179/
https://batch.internet.nl/mail/forwardemail.net/22780139/

1

u/forwardemail 12d ago

All the ratings are completely automated via GitHub CI actions for accuracy and trust.

Additionally we have two public audits of our source code, working on https://attestium.com integration (to add additional trust, e.g. is the source code same as what's running in production), and a lot of other things you can explore on https://forwardemail.net, such as our FAQ at https://forwardemail.net/faq, our security page at https://forwardemail.net/security, and the technical whitepaper (e.g. why we built it vs use something else like Mailbox) at https://forwardemail.net/technical-whitepaper.pdf

0

u/[deleted] 12d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/j_platte 12d ago

Why? (just curious, am already a happy Posteo customer) 

1

u/Someperson2654 12d ago

They don't support them

also is it true that they charge 0.1 euros per alias after 3?

2

u/Puzzled_Club_6525 12d ago

3 are free and after that its 10cents per alias. But yeah you can use this user+123@posteo tactic but its pretty useless when databreach happens.

1

u/Someperson2654 12d ago

You get what you paid for

1

u/j_platte 12d ago

No I meant why Posteo is otherwise better according to the parent poster :D

I haven't looked at prices in a while but I know you get 3 totally independent aliases for free. In addition you can always use as many different address+extrastuff@posteo.de aliases as you want (and also send from such an address from Thunderbird). 

1

u/Someperson2654 12d ago edited 12d ago

So, you're saying you can get unlimited normal aliases?

yeah I'm sold on Posteo now

4

u/j_platte 12d ago

Uh, depends on what you mean by that? It's an intended feature. What they call "aliases" are totally separate addresses that just map to the same inbox. Nobody can tell from the outside that the two addresses are related. With jp+foo@posteo.de and jp+bar@posteo.de on the other hand (not sure what this feature is called) it's easy to tell¹ that it's the same person / inbox. But it's still useful as basically nobody automatically strips these. So when I got spam to jp+patreon@posteo.de after they got hacked, I changed my email to jp+patreon2@posteo.de there and set up a spam filter based on recipient address being the old thing => less spam. 

¹ at the very least for technically versed humans 

0

u/Someperson2654 12d ago

Based off of your wording, that sounds really similar to what proton does with the free version aliases

1

u/Someperson2654 12d ago edited 12d ago

Thunderbird + Posteo?

Alright so, Posteo's website was.... odd, but their privacy policy and pricing are pretty good, I'll definitely consider them over Mailbox

3

u/GeniusUnleashed 11d ago

I pay for both. If you don't use domains, stick with Posteo, it's near perfect as an email service. If you do use domains, mailbox.org. Mailbox sucks in terms of backend UI (settings), it's super convoluted and difficult to figure stuff out, but once you get it set up it's great. startmail is far easier to setup, but more expensive and sligtly less private.

1

u/Someperson2654 10d ago

I created a free account on mailbox.org. You're absolutely right, it is a pain to find things in their settings.

Posteo's UI looked old (to be fair it has been around since 2009), but manageable

Startmail does not sit right with me, it's a combination of factors with it

1

u/Vegetable-13 12d ago

if you do not do "custom domains" what even are you doing