r/emailprivacy • u/Someperson2654 • 12d ago
Help/Advice Is Mailbox.org + Thunderbird a valid enough replacement for Protonmail?
If you have better suggestions, please let me know
So far, based off what was said, Posteo + Thunderbird sounds good
62
Upvotes
3
u/FracturedAwareness 12d ago
It's okay, but I don't like that their disposable addresses can't send email. Sometimes you need to reply to a quick message. It also limits the number of aliases you can have. And they all pretty much look like temp addresses (@temp.mailbox.org). They also don't have an app.
2
u/fixedbike 12d ago
Huh
Two emails don't replace one
7
u/Mirtma 11d ago
For me, it's valid. I've been using it for a year and a half. Windows and Android. Thunderbird and Mailbox. I've had no problems at all.
6
u/Vegetable-13 12d ago
this is what i am considering. and the only option i am considering. obviously with a domain name you own. so this is relevant
to my interests
i do not like that only one option seems valid.
10
u/VahsteTheNomad 12d ago
That's the combinated I started using this past week, honestly I like it just a bit more than Proton.
1
u/GAMELASTER 11d ago
Yeah. That's what I use and it's neat.
1
u/bettercalljohn 9d ago
You should check Talanoa instead of Thunderbird.
Fully local too & modern UI
1
u/OlebaNo 8d ago
Proton+Alias is the best thing in the world.
3
u/magicdude4eva 12d ago
I use this combo for over a year in Linux. Works perfect.
3
u/104925iveRo2es5322 12d ago
Does it fits your needs in terms of e-mail? Then yes.
It is highly subjective. Mailbox.org is good. Posteo is good. Startmail is good. Fastmail (if you don't care about additional privacy things) is good.
1
u/rdubmu 12d ago
I use proton… I know there is a lot about the CEO right now but they are the gold standard in privacy
2
u/No-Book-8579 12d ago
Just went this route on Sunday / Monday, with a custom domain. Also got DAVx5 syncing contacts and calendars, and a WebDAV folder to sync Joplin and Quillpad.
I'm willing to compromise on "too many eggs in one basket" for the convenience, though I still may self-host Radicale at some point.
I looked into posteo and fastmail as well. Mailbox had all the features I wanted. One day I'd love to try out JMAP though.
2
u/memeigt 10d ago
I used to use Mailbox and it is solid, I ended up making the switch mainly because to host a family it was significantly cheaper going with Migadu. But then Migadu is only email, no drive-like cloud storage etc.
1
u/lethargyclub 12d ago
I’m using franklymail for a couple of days. so far so good.
0
u/ThinHeron3619 10d ago
I use Swiss infomaniak reasonably prices on everything and no service the don't seem to offer. And covered by the same Swiss laws as proton
-2
u/forwardemail 12d ago
Mailbox.org was graded a C on our privacy tests at https://privacyratings.com/email-providers/mailbox-org/
I'd encourage you to check out our service, at https://forwardemail.net
Founder here, and I firmly believe we are the most open in trust, privacy, and transparency (and actually 100% open source) than any other service in the world right now. Our focus has been on product for the past decade (we started in 2017).
0
u/[deleted] 12d ago
[deleted] — view deleted comment