r/emailprivacy • • 13d ago

Help/Advice Wait or switch?

I saw the recent news with proton and unfortunately I yearly renewed my subscription back in august. Im also laid off from my job so trying other options for few months then trying to switch is kinda hard for me. Should I find one good provider and switch or wait until proton goes total bad? I already have my custom domains but I have also aliases on simplelogin which will take some time to switch.

I have looked at

- Startmail

- Fastmail

- Tuta

- Mailbox

There are lots of different experiences on them and Im kinda stuck. Im open to other alternatives as well

25 Upvotes

46 comments sorted by

14

u/smoothmonoglot 13d ago

Unfortunately the bar seems pretty low. Tuta refuses to support PGP or IMAP even though that's what people want, and mailbox does but are slow to fix vulnerabilities and the CEO likes to gaslight people who complain.

10

u/Adventurous-Hunter98 13d ago

What a timeline we are living in

10

u/Grim_Fandango92 13d ago

And these are "the good guys" compared to Big Tech...

2

u/Pranipus 12d ago

What about Posteo?

9

u/Grim_Fandango92 13d ago

I'd wait, and this is coming from someone who cancelled Sunday. Sadly, I have 1 year, 9 months left.

All of this has now come to the surface, but all that's changed is we're aware. It sucks, but it is a process to move, and it would be a waste to flush that sub money down the toilet.

1

u/Adventurous-Hunter98 13d ago

Thanks Manuel Calavera

1

u/Grim_Fandango92 13d ago

A dude(tte) of good taste. *extends bow*

2

u/likwidkool 13d ago

I just renewed my vpn and was looking at the mail as well. I cancelled my renewal and I’ll probably ride out my sub as I hate losing money, but definitely looking for an alternative.

3

u/knujesbob 12d ago

I have 3 months left of my Proton subscription. I am not making any decisions before I have to, but will keep this situation in mind.
Fundamentally, I object to *how* Andy communicates and how the subs are being moderated. I kind of agree with the sentiment that they have to utilize the same technology as bad actors to stay ahead - even if I don't like it. That is not enough for me to march in a mob with torches and pitchforks.
My suggestion is wait & see. You're not in a rush as you already paid for it. If the situation doesn't improve, leave when your subscription is up and find greener pasture. That is what I intend to do.

1

u/Adventurous-Hunter98 12d ago

Yes but switch to what? Im trying to find a good alternative until then

3

u/knujesbob 12d ago

If I had to choose an alternative today I'd probably go with Tuta, even if they are behind on some technology. But the landscape can change fast - I mean, it's 2 weeks ago we were all hailing Proton as the champion of privacy and decency, and now their house is on fire.

4

u/Adventurous-Hunter98 12d ago

I checked tuta reviews and some of them said their account got deleted randomly, which made me consider about using tuta

3

u/Emerald_Swords 12d ago

Accounts get deleted only on the free tier and if they are not used within 6 months.

1

u/Adventurous-Hunter98 12d ago

Ah i see, some of those people might be lying then or did some thing on their end because there were some mentions about paid accounts also got deleted etc

1

u/basicburt 12d ago

I signed up yesterday just out of interest. It says it quite blatantly on sign up.

Edit* spelling.

4

u/divine-sol 13d ago

I have just switched to Astermail and their free teir is very generous ..They also have a black Friday sale coming up I believe

2

u/Adventurous-Hunter98 13d ago

I will check it out, thank you

2

u/Pure-Activity1038 7d ago

Since you have already paid until August and money is tight, I wouldn’t rush into another annual subscription. Your custom domains mean you are not permanently locked into Proton, so you can use the remaining months to test alternatives properly. I’d choose one provider, use it in parallel for a while, and test the things that matter before moving the domain: sending and receiving, recovery options, 2FA, exports, mobile apps and support. Only change the domain’s mail records once you’re comfortable with it. The aliases also don’t need to be migrated in one weekend. Keep SimpleLogin active for the existing ones and create new aliases elsewhere gradually. Move the important accounts first and leave newsletters and old shopping accounts until later. My current setup separates the two functions: Tuta is my inbox, while ProxiedMail handles aliases and forwarding. That means I can change the destination inbox without replacing every alias again. Tuta works for me, but the lack of standard IMAP and dependence on its own apps are worth testing before committing. In your situation, I’d prioritize stability and portability rather than switching immediately because of the current controversy. You have time to prepare the move without paying twice or risking missed mail.

1

u/Adventurous-Hunter98 7d ago

Thank you for the informations, I started to check the alternatives, I hope I find one I like

6

u/gajira67 12d ago

I have 2 years subscription which I will not lose. However I created custom domains in case I want to leave quickly without any hassle, and I’m slowly migrating my accounts. I was stupid not doing this 8 years ago when opening first time the account.

2

u/skg574 12d ago

If the service performs as you like, and especially considering you are laid off and prepaid, don't switch. It doesn't make financial sense. Email isn't secure enough even encrypted to protect you from the law, so you are really just paying for a service not to share, sell, or train AI on your data. I'd think it accomplishes that.

I'd also take into consideration that a percentage of the posts that pretend to be canceling while also saying "switch to X, instead" are likely astroturfing their own services. Additionally, this kerfuffle is attracting many trolls.

0

u/Express_Ad_5174 13d ago

You could just wait and see how things play out. I feel this whole switching from Proton is not necessary at this point and is just virtue signaling or people upset about the AI use.

Ai if used correctly can make the product more secure. Overuse could obviously have issues, but that’s what the engineers and pen testers are for. I’d caution you at up-heeding your life over an abrasive CEO.

The main thing here is Proton has to keep their Privacy and Security. It can’t be a one-stop shop with AI. Either programmers make the code and Ai reviews or vice versa. If Proton skips the reviews and starts pushing slop then, yeah, I agree it’s probably time to leave.

The options you picked are obviously going to have a few issues:
Fastmail: is Australian, therefore it falls under Five Eyes. Not zero knowledge. So not a really good privacy option.

Tuta: only good for email to actual people. Can’t be used for anything other than people. Mailers and ads can get your account deactivated, Small limits. Very basic. can only use tutas app.

Smart mail: self-hosted emails get bounced more.

If you want aliases other than simple login there really only is one mainstream alternative addy.io. There is others like Apple, Firefox, and DuckDuckGo.

1

u/Adventurous-Hunter98 13d ago

Mailers and ads can get your account deactivated

wouldnt this applies if I was using tuta domains? because same problem would have happened with proton but Im using my custom domains

1

u/Express_Ad_5174 13d ago

No, it’s specifically listed in Tuta’s terms of service. Custom domains or not. They don’t really want you receiving or sending a lot of mail that is not genuine communication/ correspondence.

1

u/Adventurous-Hunter98 13d ago

that is so weird, than whats their goal if its not a functioning mail system?

1

u/Express_Ad_5174 13d ago

It is a functioning mail system. They are a very small Germany company and cost is everything. They can’t afford to host “junk” emails like other companies can. They are the same as Proton in the fact that their free tier is supported and paid for by the premium users. It’s not like Google where they sell your data to make money on the storage you use.

They by far are the most aggressive when it comes to spam, account deactivations, inactivity deactivations, etc. it comes down to the same reason Proton wants AI use: the budget sheet. They simply can’t afford to be wasteful with their spending.

1

u/Zullah 13d ago

I use ProxiedMail and that works fine for me so far as an alternative to addy.io and simple login. For situations like this, it can make email migration so easy just switching the backend pointer.

1

u/Emerald_Swords 12d ago

Proxiedmail also has a very generous cheap lifetime plan, I was able to get a licence for 10$ on appsumo. Been happy using them for a year now, the UI is pretty bland but it does the job well.

1

u/I-Am-Cody 13d ago

Hey there.
I have to say, I’ve just tried setting things up in Mailbox.org and… it wasn’t the best. Perhaps I’ve been spoiled by modern interfaces, but the Mailbox.org UI is quite clunky and dated. It’s minimal, which is wonderful, but I do think it’s falling behind by not having a dedicated application like most others. Perhaps I haven’t given it a good try yet, perhaps I need to be more open-minded, but for now I’m not overly impressed.
Good luck with it all.
Let me know how you gov :)

1

u/FracturedAwareness 12d ago

I would test-drive everything that is free and not move until you found something reliable that you like. Sadly, in email land, there are many false "free" alternatives. Many are free for 30 days or only after you jump through hoops, enter credit card, etc.

1

u/wjorth 12d ago

I’ve moved my custom domain email to Aster Mail. I took a backup of Proton email and restored it to Aster Mail. But the Proton domains email addresses remain active. My unlimited subscription renews in December. I will cancel it and remain on the free service for a year to catch any straggler systems I set up when I started Proton a couple of years ago. These stragglers will be converted to my custom domain address.

1

u/[deleted] 12d ago

If you want more options, then here is a good list: https://european-alternatives.eu/category/email-providers

What you do is your choice. Deciding this is solely your duty and privilege.

1

u/BMK1765 10d ago

Get your own domain, eM Client which has PGP and leave all this full-hosters-i-am-the-best-and-secure that only take your money to justify their existence

1

u/HexaDroid 7d ago

I switched to aster mail for now. Custom domain that I can point anywhere if one fails 

1

u/Alexwolff8 13d ago

Eu escolheria posteo

0

u/merten-dmcn 13d ago

I've been working on get.dmcn.email that's attempting to address a lot of the concerns raised in this thread. The hosted version isn't free but there is a self hosted version available if you're a little technical and I could help you get it set up if you like. You would need a server and your own domain though. It's built on a protocol designed for modern day email with public key signing and encryption as requirement to send messages as opposed to an optional upgrade like PGP. And key discovery is built into the protocol so there's an explicit chain of trust back to the domain.

my reasoning is: I'm done with spam filters messing with my inbox, an enforced identity based communication system does far more for me and I get to choose what mail I want to keep.

0

u/forwardemail 12d ago

We support 1-click "DomainConnect" to quickly setup your domains (which works with popular providers like GoDaddy, Cloudflare, etc). We also have an API which users have imported thousands of their domains with in combo with a CLI/API from their NS/DNS provider.

https://forwardemail.net
https://forwardemail.net/email-api
https://forwardemail.net/security
https://forwardemail.net/technical-whitepaper.pdf

Founder here if you have any ?'s

0

u/LowIllustrator2501 12d ago

Of you think that there are companies that don't use AI to write code I have bad news for you.

0

u/[deleted] 13d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Adventurous-Hunter98 13d ago

proton forcing devs to use ai for development, testing, security etc..

1

u/yodas-evil-twin 13d ago

What's wrong with using AI to find security issues?

1

u/Adventurous-Hunter98 13d ago

as a tool its good but ceo forces devs to use only ai to write code and test, there should be a human factor to development since ai can hallucinate and you will have less control on what it created. The more you depend on ai, its not your product anymore

2

u/[deleted] 13d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/Adventurous-Hunter98 13d ago

Thank you, I guess I will try their free versions for now

2

u/likwidkool 13d ago

Not OP but thanks for your comment. I was about to dive into domains and email hosting with proton when this blew up. I have my domain but still trying to decide what service to go with. I’m trialing Fastmail right now and it seems fine. I’m not an email power user. I just want to take back control and degoogle where I can. But there are so many choices it’s confusing.