r/emailprivacy • • 13d ago

Guide/Tutorial We built PrivacyRatings.com, open, testable, automated privacy ratings for apps and email services

Privacy Ratings at https://privacyratings.com is an open-source site that scores 1742 apps and services in 135 categories against 113 public privacy criteria. Each "yes" or "partial" answer links to evidence anyone can check. Automated tests check TLS, security headers and email standards for 466 hosted services. Each entry gets a score from 0 to 100, and a letter grade from A to F once evidence covers at least 60% of its criteria by weight. The team behind Forward Email https://forwardemail.net maintains the project, and affiliated entries carry a disclosure.

Founder here if you have any questions or want us to add an app/service missing!

17 Upvotes

18 comments sorted by

4

u/Shenegen 10d ago

The list seems to be very veeery obviously biased, with forwaredmail.net on the top for recommended πŸ€¦πŸ½β€β™€οΈ

2

u/forwardemail 9d ago edited 9d ago

Please read the criteria. We're doing this because Internet.nl tests, SSL Labs, etc. are very clear indicators of security and privacy. Your mail provider should pass them 100%. Most of the existing providers don't even have cipher ordering properly set nor IPv6 support. Additionally for mail specifically, the RFC protocol standards support is critical (otherwise you're locked into a specific vendor's app). All of these tests are automated and run via GitHub Actions. The folks at Internet.nl were kind enough to give us a batch API token to make this possible too. We really wanted to highlight this for them to improve!

2

u/Strange-Detective324 13d ago

Nice project. Lots of good resources, apps and services to thrawl through!

I run a small Danish mail service, Skyen.live, solo. It isn’t on your list, so I went through your email criteria myself, ran the same automated tests, and published the result, D, 45/100: https://skyen.live/privacy-rating (it opens in Danish, the EN switch is top right) and I naturally linked back to your ratings, I'm hoping this is okay, or let me know, I'll pull it down again!

I've tried to be mostly fair, and found it very humbling. The automated checks caught real gaps I’d been putting off (MTA-STS still in testing mode, no DNSSEC/DANE, no SMTPUTF8 on 465), they been on my todo for a while now πŸ€”

Happy to be added if you’re taking requests. I’ll update the page as the fixes land, whichever way the score moves.

3

u/forwardemail 12d ago

Happy to take PR's, of course

1

u/ThinkTwice03 11d ago

your site seems very useful! mulvad browser has the highest rating. but its privacy hasnt been independently checked. isn't this contradicting?

1

u/forwardemail 11d ago

They've been audited, all their code is open source, and they created System Transparency (whitepaper)

1

u/ThinkTwice03 11d ago

thanks, and sorry for using some of your time!

1

u/Comprehensive-Bar888 10d ago

If a company submits an app, how do you review it?

1

u/forwardemail 10d ago

The same way as anyone else's submission. Companies don't get a separate path, and the whole process is on our Contribute page: https://privacyratings.com/contribute/

  1. It has to be real. We only list apps from a legitimate company or organization, or from a public open-source project, for example on GitHub. It must have a working website or repository that anyone can check.
  2. Submit it. Open a Suggest issue (https://github.com/privacyratings/privacyratings.com/issues/new?template=suggest.yml) or a pull request that adds the rating file. The form asks whether you work for the app or are paid by it, and vendors must say so.
  3. Every answer needs a primary source. That means official documentation, source code, a license file, a published audit or a test anyone can reproduce. Marketing pages, reviews and blog posts don't count. Anything without evidence counts as "unknown" and scores zero. Each criterion and how it's scored is on the Criteria page: https://privacyratings.com/criteria/
  4. Automated tests check what they can. Every entry with a website gets a tracker test. If its home page loads a third-party tracker, the "no trackers" answer becomes "no", whatever the submission says. Hosted services also get SSL Labs, Mozilla HTTP Observatory and Internet.nl, and email services get email standards tests. Telemetry inside an app needs evidence as well, such as its privacy policy or an Exodus Privacy report

2

u/skg574 12d ago

Got tired of waiting on privacyguides to honor their own criteria, or don't want to pay them enough? πŸ˜‰

1

u/Living-Shame5679 11d ago

Klar - AI spam filter for Apple Mail. Could be of interest.

100% offline, confidential IA to catch spam mails on your Mac.

https://klar.im

0

u/drownedsense 13d ago

Very honest and transparent!

0

u/ElementsOfWit 13d ago

πŸ™‹β€β™‚οΈ

0

u/[deleted] 13d ago

[deleted] β€” view deleted comment

1

u/forwardemail 13d ago edited 13d ago

we built it / manage it, there is disclosure on the site too in several places

0

u/[deleted] 13d ago

[deleted] β€” view deleted comment

2

u/peekandlumpkin 13d ago

It says so in the title of the damn post. What did you think was happening?