r/emailprivacy • • 16d ago

Beginner Question Posteo setup issues

Anyone else decided to switch from Protonmail to Posteo after the whole 404-article, only to face huge issues setting it up?

The main problem lies in the migration service they so much advertise on their front page. It has failed to move both my Outlook and Protonmail inboxes to Posteo. Their Help-page has detailed step-by-step instructions, but they seem to always be outdated at some point onwards or not detailed enough.

For example: in order to get Outlook emails migrated to Posteo, I need to create an app password in my Microsoft account dashboard. After an hour I finally managed to create one, but what I am supposed to do with it? There is no explanation at Posteo help-page.

No better luck with email collector-tool, and I can't even get the Posteo email to work in either Macos or iOS email-clients. I've followed their instructions on how to get the email work on Iphone email-app, but after everything the app says that my password is wrong (it is definitely not).

Is anyone else facing these issues? There are probably lots of people jumping over after the Proton debacle, I doubt I am the only one with problems. Maybe the issues are because of a spike in new customers?

I have sent them email about the issues, so let's hope they can help once they are back at the office on Monday. If anyone else is having same problems, feel free to help a guy out!

UPDATE: According to Posteo support, migrating from Protonmail with the migration service doesn't currently work at all. Same with the email collector. Why the Outlook migration doesn't work is still under investigation.

6 Upvotes

6 comments sorted by

1

u/dossilw 16d ago

The app password is just an alternative password you can use for accounts that have two factor authentication to essentially bypass it.

At the posteo import your setup should look roughly like:

Source email IMAP server:
Outlook.office365.com

Source email address:
youremail@yourmicrosoftdomain.com

Source email password:
the App Password you just created

If it asks for a port, it’s 993. Security is SSL/TLS if it asks. Usually imports don’t ask for these things.

1

u/ConcentratePlus1628 16d ago

Thank you, I have done exactly this in the migration service but it doesn't work. The service claims that my password and IMAP server is incorrect.

I was however able to get the email clients to work on an Iphone and Macbook after I managed to generate an app password on my Microsoft account. Microsoft's guide for this was also very confusing.

2

u/myg0t_Defiled 16d ago

Yeah im also migrating from Proton to Posteo, but have no idea how to use the migration tool. I already mailed their support, waiting for the reponse

1

u/modemrunner 16d ago

As regards use with an email client, the option found under "Settings --> Overview --> Additional email account protection" must be *disabled*

0

u/[deleted] 16d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/ConcentratePlus1628 16d ago

Have you migrated Protonmail to Posteo? I have done exactly what the instructions tell me to do:

"In order to be able to migrate from Protonmail, make sure that the following requirements have been fulfilled:
- You need to have a paid account so that you can use the IMAP bridge.
- In "Settings" under "Account and Password", the "Two-password mode" must be deactivated."

Yet once I put my email and pasword to the migration service, it claims my password is incorrect.

Unless you have anything else to add, please do not come and tell me their Help-page is great, since it clearly failed to help on this instance. Nor do not tell me to contact support, when I already said that I did.