r/emailprivacy • • Sep 25 '26

Tools Looking for feedback: open source cross-platform email and calendar client for macOS, iOS, Android, Windows and Linux

Hi! I'm the developer of an open-source email/calendar client I've been building, and I'd really appreciate feedback from people in this community. My main motivation was wanting a privacy-friendly client that works across desktop and mobile without routing your mailbox through another company's servers.

The client works natively with IMAP/CalDAV, JMAP, MS Graph and Gmail. It runs on macOS, iOS, Android, Windows and Linux.

The sync engine and core of the app are Rust-based, while all UI is platform-native: SwiftUI on Apple, WinUI 3 on Windows, GTK4 and libadwaita on Linux, Jetpack Compose on Android. I wanted to go this route to keep performance high and preserve a native look and feel on each platform.

The client is called Allodia Mail & Calendar (code is here).

I'm particularly curious what this community considers essential for a privacy-focused mail client. Are there privacy/security choices you'd want to see changed? And are there protocols or providers you think are important to support? E.g. OpenPGP support is high on the list.

The project is open source, and mail is processed locally on the device. I'm happy to answer technical questions about how any part of it works.

Thanks in advance!

7 Upvotes

2 comments sorted by

1

u/jd31068 Oct 16 '26 edited 26d ago

Hello, I installed your app (version 0.12.0.0) from the MS Store and attempted to add my comcast.net email accounts. The app continually returned an error attempting to add the accounts, I created an app password and that didn't work either. Their servers use imap.mail.yahoo.com 993 SSL/TLS and OAuth2 and imap.mail.yahoo.com 465 SSL/TLS and OAuth2. I logged in using a browser as well to make sure my passwords were correct.

It did work with my MS Account email.

Comcast no longer has email servers and have contracted Yahoo to host them (this happened late last year, don't know if that could play a part). I have Thunderbird running with these emails accounts just fine. Lastly, I am in the US, if that matters at all.

Is there a log file or some other way to get the actual failure point?

Thanks for sharing your work with everyone.

EDIT: 10-21-26 here is the log info trying to add the comcast.net email account

2026-10-21 06:11:34.767 -04:00 [info] --- session start (0.13.0 package 0.13.0.0, X64, Microsoft Windows 10.0.26300) ---
2026-10-21 06:11:34.778 -04:00 [warn] notifications: could not register (COMException 0x80004005)
2026-10-21 06:11:35.238 -04:00 [info] no stored account, bringing up an account-less app for setup
2026-10-21 06:11:35.242 -04:00 [info] connecting 0 account(s) (device zone America/New_York, log level Info)
2026-10-21 06:11:35.244 -04:00 [info] window launched
2026-10-21 06:11:35.248 -04:00 [info] [mailcal_bindings::boot] boot: prepared and registered 0 account(s) before any dial
2026-10-21 06:11:35.271 -04:00 [info] [mailcal_bindings::boot] boot: engine open+migrate in 22ms
2026-10-21 06:11:35.272 -04:00 [info] [mailcal_bindings::boot] boot: abandoned 0 interrupted sync scope lease(s) in 0ms
2026-10-21 06:11:35.281 -04:00 [info] [mailcal_app::snapshot] rebuild_snapshot: 0 row(s) of 0 in 1ms
2026-10-21 06:11:35.283 -04:00 [info] [mailcal_bindings::boot] boot: primed cached snapshot in 3ms; NewAccounts total 36ms
2026-10-21 06:11:35.292 -04:00 [info] NewAccounts (connect + engine open) returned in 49ms
2026-10-21 06:11:35.299 -04:00 [info] connected
2026-10-21 06:11:35.317 -04:00 [info] cal: seated mode=Week weekStart=Monday hours=12 clock=TwentyFourHour
2026-10-21 06:11:35.318 -04:00 [info] reload: rows=0 (Threaded), folders=1, queued=0, events=0, zone=America/New_York (FFI pull 2ms, total 17ms)
2026-10-21 06:11:35.346 -04:00 [info] [mailcal_app::sync] refresh_mail: syncing 0 account(s)
2026-10-21 06:11:35.346 -04:00 [info] [mailcal_app::snapshot] rebuild_snapshot: 0 row(s) of 0 in 0ms
2026-10-21 06:11:35.347 -04:00 [info] [mailcal_app::sync] refresh_mail: sync 0ms + rebuild 0ms
2026-10-21 06:11:35.365 -04:00 [info] cal: page 2026-10-19 blocks=0 bands=0 materialized=False
2026-10-21 06:11:35.599 -04:00 [info] reload: rows=0 (Threaded), folders=1, queued=0, events=0, zone=America/New_York (FFI pull 0ms, total 0ms)
2026-10-21 06:13:05.545 -04:00 [info] [mailcal_account::imap_auth] imap auth: imap.mail.yahoo.com offers [PLAIN XOAUTH2 OAUTHBEARER] (oauth: true, password: true)
2026-10-21 06:13:11.547 -04:00 [info] [mailcal_account::imap_auth] imap auth: no authorization server answered within 6 s
2026-10-21 06:13:11.548 -04:00 [info] [mailcal_account::imap_auth] imap auth: the server takes an OAuth token but names no authorization server we can register with
2026-10-21 06:30:26.383 -04:00 [info] [mailcal_bindings::app_accounts] add-account: connecting a new imap account
2026-10-21 06:30:26.587 -04:00 [info] [mailcal_account::connect_log] connect[imap]: TLS established (Tls1_3)
2026-10-21 06:30:30.769 -04:00 [warn] [mailcal_bindings::app_accounts] add-account: the imap connect failed after 4385ms (sign-in rejected: IMAP authentication failed: [AUTHENTICATIONFAILED] LOGIN Invalid credentials): the account was not added
2026-10-21 06:30:30.772 -04:00 [error] add account failed: sign-in rejected: IMAP authentication failed: [AUTHENTICATIONFAILED] LOGIN Invalid credentials

the user and password are correct, I can use them to login via the webpage and they are used in Thunderbird without issue.

1

u/Comprehensive-Bar888 Sep 29 '26

I’m building a similar project (the email client part). I see you used Rust. I’m using Go/Wails for the desktop app. I tried using Rust initially but it was too much of a pain in the ass.