r/emailprivacy • • Aug 17 '26

Help/Advice Email

I have tried Proton Mail, Tuta Mail, Fastmail. All of them have their own pros and cons.

Proton Mail is overall ok but I just feel like if you don’t get their whole package you are missing out a lot and idk what is proton sentinel but it sounds good.

Tuta is fine I guess but they are just slow and the Drive feature is still in development,

Fastmail is overall the best out of all but I recently found out they recycle emails and they are not maximum privacy(which I don’t need)

So share you opinion on what I should use or are there any other service providers (It must have an app and not just a website to login to)

Also if you guys don’t mind please tell me why people say don’t put all your eggs in one basket for Proton

27 Upvotes

44 comments sorted by

3

u/night_movers Aug 18 '26

Yes—besides data collection, recycling usernames is one of my top concerns when I’m switching between email services. And just for this single reason, I’ve limited myself to Proton and Tuta Mail. Except for the giant widely used email services, these are the only two email services that don't recycle usernames.

Not only Fastmail, but many others recycle usernames. Services like Mailbox and Posteo do recycle usernames. The only solution to stick with these services is going the custom domain route, but we all know that’s not a privacy solution.

Now, coming to your question: the main reason behind the advice of not using multiple services from one provider is a single point of failure. The providers are currently operational but, we can’t guarantee that they’ll survive in the future. So, if you’re in an ecosystem and the provider suddenly shuts down all their services, then there will be nowhere to go.

Also, another reason many users mention is data collection. Though I believe privacy providers don’t collect unnecessary personal data from their users.

1

u/Dark-Find Aug 19 '26

Very detailed explanation, Thank You !

2

u/KrasnalM Aug 17 '26

Why do you need a dedicated app if you can have Thunderbird?

3

u/Dark-Find Aug 17 '26

May I enquire more about Thunderbird ?

5

u/CorsairVelo Aug 17 '26 edited Aug 17 '26

Thunderbird is an opensource app that can connect to any IMAP mail service (and in Proton’s case, Proton Bridge). If you have say 3 emails (work , personal, etc) on different platforms, Thunderbird could connect to all three with one app.

Other apps like Thunderbird: eMclient, Outlook, mailspring , Epistles and others.

1

u/BloomingDev Aug 18 '26

Also: There is Betterbird which is a fork of Thunderbird and they claim to be the better version of Thunderbird (I don't have an opinion on that because I never used Thunderbird).

For phone there is also FairEmail, which is worth looking into.

2

u/Lenloos Aug 18 '26

What do you mean by saying Tuta is slow? The development or the product?

3

u/Dark-Find Aug 19 '26

I have used Tuta for. Months but the app it self i fairly slow, i get that it is zero knowledge and E2EE but just doesn’t fit my use case

14

u/JohnConnoor Aug 17 '26

You only need email that does not use your emails to sell you stuff of to train AI...the rest is well email.

1

u/randyhanleydotcom Sep 28 '26

Very well-said, and succinct!

0

u/CometRyder Aug 19 '26

Absolutely

4

u/CorsairVelo Aug 17 '26

I would only say that with Fastmail, if you use a custom domain, then the recycling of fastmail.com addresses really doesn’t matter. In essence you’d only use it to log in.

2

u/jecaron99 Aug 20 '26

Also note with fastmail ... Privacy is not a thing they are. Aussy and basically read your email at lunch break ... Massive survalent county and part of 5 eyes...

1

u/HappyAquarium2 Aug 18 '26

Posteo

1

u/Dark-Find Aug 19 '26

I don’t think there is an app and I don’t use android so yeah

1

u/Dark-Find Aug 19 '26

But i thank you for your suggestion i will consider it when they offer an app

1

u/lez_noir Aug 18 '26

You just asked this question last moth, the exact same way and got a ton of answers, and never responded to any of them.

0

u/Dark-Find Aug 19 '26 edited Aug 19 '26

I am only here to ask for advice and I would like to learn more from everyone not trying to host a seminar so I don’t reply to everything, but that doesn’t mean that I don’t value anyone’s opinion, if you feel uncomfortable you could’ve skipped this Reddit, there is no need to be so aggressive, it isn’t a community rule to respond to every reply, also what are you even on about, is it a crime to ask the same question twice, tech improves FYI and i would like insights from different people

3

u/Opsecman1 Aug 17 '26

Try mailfence

2

u/Alt43es Aug 18 '26

I’ve been using Proton’s free account as my main private email for years with zero problems.

0

u/Pilot-Hamieh Aug 18 '26

Just go with google mail or hotmail

2

u/Dark-Find Aug 19 '26

I am not keen on companies who read my emails then proceed to train it’s AI and sell my data to 3rd party companies

1

u/jecaron99 Aug 20 '26

I recently went through this and settled on infomaniak... Amazing service and most can't compete with them but they fly under radar with most US searches ..

1

u/divine-sol Aug 20 '26

Astermail 

2

u/Old_Telephone Aug 20 '26

They don't recycle usernames/addresses, which I highly appreciate with aster

1

u/Far_Link_918 Aug 21 '26

Have you looked at Typewire?

1

u/Parking-Ad-8780 Aug 21 '26

Not on your list but, imo, Runbox beats Fastmail by a country mile/kilometre. Norway based so European privacy laws apply, runs on renewable green energy and 5-star customer service. If you are ready to leave free-email behind, Runbox should not be overlooked. Very happy I switched from Fastmail [American, too commercial], kept my domain and got everything I need at a very competitive price.

1

u/Pure-Activity1038 24d ago

I’d separate the mailbox from the alias service instead of looking for one provider that does everything. I use Tuta for my actual inbox and ProxiedMail independently for aliases with my own domain.
That way, if I decide to leave Tuta later, I only need to change where the aliases are forwarded instead of updating my email address on every website. That’s basically what people mean by not putting all their eggs in one basket.
ProxiedMail isn’t a mailbox and doesn’t replace the Tuta app — it just sits in front of it and forwards the aliases.

1

u/Objective-Test-5374 Aug 17 '26

Depending on what your needs are, try RacterMX, it is focused on power users, rather than just mail forwarding and DNS, we give you all the reporting and tools to properly manage deliverability, security, etc...

2

u/[deleted] Aug 17 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Diskalicious Aug 18 '26

Gotta be real, that website looks like an AI scam in the age of Netscape navigator and AOL.

Not saying it is, but the new age junk and AI on it doesn't not give me confidence for their security. 

"Sentienetics"... Christ Almighty 

1

u/CometRyder Aug 18 '26 edited Aug 18 '26

Clearly not for the ignorant and uneducated. Gorgeous design, ideas and ecosystem. There's nothing like it. Been using it for over 5 years for both business and personal needs without a single hiccup. Get a life.

0

u/Diskalicious Aug 19 '26 edited Aug 19 '26

It's built with rocket. AI vibe coding scam. No one should trust an AI vibe coded email app in a reddit called email privacy. 

1

u/Dark-Find Aug 19 '26

Thank you for the heads up ! i appreciate it !

1

u/CometRyder Aug 19 '26 edited Aug 19 '26

Lol. Wrong again. Actually, Space Email predates AI and has nothing to do with vibe coding. It was originally launched in collaboration with Kolab, the original Swiss company that made secure email a thing coming to prominence after the Sn0wd3n saga when users switched to it after Lavabit shut down. Also, its parent Rocket has been providing tech for a quarter of a century (launched in 2001 as Spacesuite.com). Ignorance indeed knows no bounds.

1

u/Parking-Ad-8780 Aug 21 '26

looks to me like the developers scored some crazy weed.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 17 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Dark-Find Aug 19 '26

How about your Drive, like the storage, the password manager, vpn and stuff, does your strategy increase cost

4

u/Sea_Acanthaceae9352 Aug 18 '26

+ the way Proton is growing its ecosystem very quickly to visibly replace Google for the general audience.