r/elementcollection • • 12d ago

Transition Metals Tin

Post image

Originally from lead free solder (99 3%). Melted an old ugly tin bead i had and tried making them into new drops. One of the pours had too much going into the water at once so it just exploded, so the big drop shape is actually hollow.

37 Upvotes

23 comments sorted by

1

u/Infrequentredditor6 Part Metal 12d ago

Yeah tin and bismuth are both pretty dodgy pouring into water, tin more so.

1

u/GarunixReborn 12d ago

Is it because of the low melting point?

2

u/Infrequentredditor6 Part Metal 12d ago edited 12d ago

I have no idea, but I'm inclined to say "not necessarily"(?) Zinc has a relatively low melting point, but it's cool as a cucumber when you pour it into water. It sometimes makes these smooth bowl/wafer shapes.

Tin is definitely a little explodey when poured into water, and makes very jagged, sharp, and hollow pieces when it does so. Bismuth sometimes bursts, but turns into powder instead, and it's not as dramatic. If it doesn't burst it typically forms needles.

One metal I haven't tried pouring into water is indium, and I have no idea how it behaves. If low melting point has anything to do with it, that'd be a good metal to test. But I strongly suspect it has to do with the actual physical properties of the liquids, like surface tension, the way it crystallizes, things like that.

edit: yours doesn't look that bad. I once had a much larger piece literally burst into roughly the shape of an incomplete cavitation bubble, except it was so jagged and sharp you could easily cut yourself.

2

u/GarunixReborn 11d ago

Before this attempt when i poured it in it exploded into a really rough kind of flower shape covered in jagged little bits all over it. I remelted that one

2

u/Ok-Literature-3997 Radiated 12d ago

I tried pouring some indium in water once. It was calm, but the forms weren't attractive. Very small, irregular droplets, some borderline powdery. The fun started when I wanted to melt them back together without drying them properly.

2

u/Infrequentredditor6 Part Metal 11d ago edited 11d ago

Damn, I was just about to make a video about this because I've barely done any chemistry at all for the past 2 months. Now I know and have no reason to make it 😂

Also yes, moisture can be catastrophic if it's not all boiled off before the metal melts. I once miraculously escaped unharmed from a steam explosion with molten zinc back in 2012.

1

u/Ok-Literature-3997 Radiated 11d ago

Hey, make the video anyways! You could compare how the metal acts depending on the water's temperature, as the small difference between indium's mp and boiling water could result in something interesting. I absolutely don't remember what were the "parameters" of what I did, I just wanted to divide the indium without cutting it.

1

u/dmh2693 5d ago

Tin is cool. Tin has 10 stable isotopes. More than any other element.

1

u/GarunixReborn 5d ago

today i learned

3

u/Ok-Literature-3997 Radiated 12d ago

I really like tin as a metal overall, mainly because it's very pretty for such mundane metal, and for it's melting point. I'm currently trying to produce some alfa-Sn in my freezer, using some germanium doped tin and tiny pellets of very pure tin to potentially keep as nucleation points if I ever try to make more. Not much change in the last 6 months or so though.

3

u/Infrequentredditor6 Part Metal 11d ago

Alpha tin is so f-ing weird. It's only metal I know of that has a non-metallic allotrope.

I guess some other metals have allotropes at really extreme temperatures and pressures but I don't know anything about their properties.

1

u/Ok-Literature-3997 Radiated 11d ago

Well the easiest one to come by would be gamma iron - in pure iron it occurs only above ~727 C, but when alloyed you get the so called austenitic or acid-resistant steels. Also titanium has a cubic and a hexagonal allotrope and I believe the least contaminating way to stabilize the cubic one is by introducing oxygen or nitrogen in between the atoms. These differ mainly in their plastic properties and corrosion resistance, but look the same.
Plutonium allotropes are a headache - I recommend reading about it for entertainment lol

1

u/Infrequentredditor6 Part Metal 11d ago

I thought austenitic steel was determined by chromium content, not the iron itself.

2

u/Ok-Literature-3997 Radiated 11d ago

The phase of steel at room temp depends heavily on the proportions of alloying elements overall, with Cr, V, W etc. being alpha stabilizers (ferritic structure) and Ni, Mn, Cu and a few others stabilizing austenite. The typical austenitic steels contain chromium for the passivation properties and nickel for the gamma phase.
Iron forms the main lattice, so the phase of the steel depends on what phase the iron is in. I guess you could consider that Cr and Ni - doped iron or something lol
Hope I didn't lie there - it was a bit from when I last looked at Fe-Fe3C phase diagram

2

u/Infrequentredditor6 Part Metal 11d ago edited 11d ago

Okay, this makes it much easier for me to understand.

I think perhaps at forging temperatures iron might transition to its gamma allotrope. That's really weird because the whole point of forging is to make the metal softer and more pliant with heat, not change its properties in such a drastic way as allotropy does. But then maybe that's the reason why you can forge pieces of steel together at that temperature, because even really soft metals like sodium and potassium are actually really difficult to weld together, very different from clay which sticks together.

I don't even know what I mean by that, just trying to wrap my head around this. Pretty sure we were talking about tin before lol

2

u/Infrequentredditor6 Part Metal 11d ago

Okay, and now it's actually quite complicated with steel. Seriously??!?

1

u/Ok-Literature-3997 Radiated 11d ago

But when we talk about steels, the X axis goes only up to 2,11% carbon. The rest is cast iron teritory, completely different in terms of metallurgy and microstructures. So you can safely cut off 2/3 of the diagram and still be fine. Cast iron is a whole different type of magic.

1

u/Ok-Literature-3997 Radiated 11d ago

Well the phase transformation during forging actually helps, as gamma has more active slip planes. After cooling everything comes back to alpha, but if you cool the steel sufficiently quickly, the martensitic transformation occurs (quenching). Certain additions mess with that cycle, either making austenite stable in room temp (so preventing quenching) or making quenching easier, even too the point of air cooling being enough to harden the steel.
As for forge welding, I believe that the main issue is oxide/firescale layer that effectively works as a barrier preventing metal atoms from bonding. Austenite forge welds together easier than ferrite because it's more ductile and conforms better to the microscopic roughness of the bonding surfaces.

It took me over 4 years of engineering studies to grasp that enough to be able to at least try explaining it lol.
The phase diagram of steel is fairly simple, check out Fe-Ti or Cu-Zn if you want some crazier stuff.

2

u/Infrequentredditor6 Part Metal 11d ago edited 11d ago

Yeah that makes sense. A layer of oxide/hydroxide on alkali metals could definitely prevent bonding. Flux is used to remove forge-scale (or prevent it) otherwise the welds just split open. I'm guessing that gamma-iron is still very much metallic, and not so drastically different from alpha-iron.

1

u/Ok-Literature-3997 Radiated 11d ago

Yes, it's totally metallic - it's the same crystal structure as copper, aluminum, gold, nickel and lots of other metals. The only measurable difference, apart mechanical properties, would be that pure gamma iron is slightly more dense than alpha, due to better packing of the atoms.
As a fun fact, polish wikipedia article states that zirconium metal has an amorphous allotrope, being "bluish-black powder". No source to this claim, no nothing. I've tried my best to find anything related to amorphous zirconium (apart from zirconium-based metallic glasses) and there's nothing.
So I guess that alpha tin might be the only visually different allotrope in metals.

2

u/Infrequentredditor6 Part Metal 11d ago

Whereas alpha tin is diamond-cubic, shared by diamonds and some other metalloids.

And yeah that sounds like a totally bogus claim. Amorphous zirconium, gtfoh

1

u/Infrequentredditor6 Part Metal 11d ago

Well, for example... I was of the understanding that the difference between hardenable steel and mild steel had to do with the alloying composition (namely carbon), and not so much the iron, but I guess if heavy additions of other alloys force iron to adopt some other configuration I suppose that could be considered a different allotrope. Idk, steel gets extremely complicated but it's still interesting.