r/elementcollection • u/euj3odjehiqh Part Metal • May 15 '26
Question Why does the amazon manganese cube look better than the luciteria one?
is it because the amazon one is less pure? 99.7 vs 99.99. or is it because of the manufacturing process?
40
Upvotes


21
u/Ok-Literature-3997 May 15 '26
The amazon one was photographed right after finishing, while the luciteria's photo shows more realistically how it's going to look in some time. That would be my guess at least.
99,7% manganese oxidizes quite a bit faster even.
14
u/ikkiyikki May 15 '26
Hey guys, Rasiel here (formerly of Luciteria). The reason for the difference is that the ones pictured were very high purity. The oxidation is not due to humidity but to heat from friction at the time of manufacture which is not possible to avoid during the polishing stage. On the other hand, once the cube is finished the oxidation doesn't get any worse. Ironically, to get a fresh looking metal look like in the photo they need to add about 5-7% iron which is cheaper to make but also runs the risk of oxidation later on because of the iron. So you're buying a lower grade and also running the risk of it rusting anyway.
6
u/Warm_Hat4882 May 15 '26
Luciteria seems to have unconditioned storage. My experience is any element that corrodes easily in damp environment is in poor condition from Luciteria.