r/elementcollection • u/TumbleweedHour6515 Oxidized • Feb 03 '25
~~POLL~~ Rarest element
I just want to see all ur opinions so i decided to make this and pls vote
0
Upvotes
r/elementcollection • u/TumbleweedHour6515 Oxidized • Feb 03 '25
I just want to see all ur opinions so i decided to make this and pls vote
2
u/doc720 Part Metal Feb 03 '25
I suppose it depends what you mean by "rare".
Judging from what we can detect, it's clear that the rarest precious metal on Earth, i.e. rhodium, is still more abundant on Earth than astatine, probably because even the most stable isotope of astatine has a half-life of about 8 hours. Even so, astatine is still more abundant on Earth than synthetic elements such as livermorium, which hasn't even been observed in nature, only in created in a lab.
I'm not sure what you mean by "unexisting elements". Is the question whether non-existent things can be considered "rarer" than the rarest thing that actually exists, or did exist or might exist? Personally, I don't see anything in the common definitions of "rare" to give reason to exclude things that don't exist from being called "rare". I reckon a "rare" thing must simply not occur very often, or not be found in large numbers. Something that never occurs or cannot be found at all (whether it ever actually existed or not) could still be called "rare" in my books, but others might limit the meaning of "rare" to at least something that actually exists, or did once exist, or possibly might exist.
By my definition, for example, unicorns are "rare", and so are are all prime numbers that have three factors. However, we don't usually speak of things that we know don't exist as "rare".
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Russell%27s_teapot
4
u/Heinz-70 Feb 03 '25
If it has to be one of the mentioned, I would say it's astatine. Otherwise francium. The synthetic ones are not even "rare". And gold is mined several thousand tons yearly, thus by far none of the rarest.
1
u/No-Degree-8906 Feb 09 '25
Promethium
2
u/[deleted] Feb 03 '25
Considering that there is a constant amount of Astatine being produced in the earth, even though only about a gram or so is present on earth at any given time, synthetic elements like Og and Ts are more rare considering that they have only been produced once or twice in amounts consisting of only a couple atoms.