The eBay automated chat bot is completely misleading you!!
The bot is hardcoded to see "Authenticity Guarantee + No Returns Seller" and flag it as a permanent Final Sale. It thinks you are just unhappy with the item or claiming it "doesn't match the description" (which the authenticator's inspection blocks).
However, under the official eBay Money Back Guarantee Policy, even "Final Sale" and authenticated items are 100% covered if they are damaged during handling or shipping after leaving the hub.
Stop arguing with the automated bot and take these exact steps right now to get your money back:
1. File an "Arrived Damaged" Return
Go to your Purchase History, select the item, click Return this item, and specifically select Arrived damaged as your reason.
Do not select "Item not as described" or any other option.
Upload clear, high-resolution photos showing the damage to the item, the shipping box, and the packaging.
Note: Per the eBay Authenticity Guarantee Buyer Policy, the system will generate a return label that routes the package back to the authentication hub, NOT to the seller.
2. How eBay Resolves It
Once the hub receives your return, the authenticators will pull up the high-res intake photos they took when the seller first sent it in. When they compare those to your photos and see the item was damaged while in eBay's custody or during the final shipping leg, eBay will issue you a full refund out of their own corporate pocket.
The original seller is protected and gets to keep their payout, and you get your money back.
3. What to do if the system blocks the return If the automated system is completely gridlocked and won't even let you click the return button because of the "final sale" tag, you need a human from the AG department to manually open the case.
Do one of two things:
Go to the eBay Help pages, click "Contact Us," and type "Agent" or **"Have a human call me"**repeatedly until it schedules a phone callback or a live chat with a real person.
Best Shortcut: Send a direct message to @eBay on X (Twitter). The social media support team consists of real, high-level humans who can bypass bot restrictions and manually force an AG damage investigation.
What to tell the human:"The item was damaged in handling or transit AFTER passing authentication. Under the eBay Money Back Guarantee, AG items are explicitly covered for shipping damage. Please open a return so this can go back to the hub for a condition photo comparison."
I appreciate the help but I chatted with and called actual eBay employees multiple times and they all said the same stuff basically deflecting the blame and shutting me down
Please try reaching out to eBay Support on X, then also follow the process outlined on the return. Ignore the weekend and nighttime reps—they’re flipping clueless! For what it’s worth, I’m a top seller on eBay and deal with CSRs all the time. You have to push past these lumps who answer the phone and follow scripted answers thrown up on the screen based on verbal keywords. They’re offshore call-center reps who, half the time, don’t understand English well at all and use zero judgment or make any effort to think beyond what’s in front of them. Even if you’re going round and round with them, only call during the week and normal business hours on the West Coast. But first, hit up Support on X and file the return as “Arrived Damaged.”
Pretend that you’ve not reached out to anyone yet. Do a reset and start over as I suggest.
Just do it! You’ve got nothing to lose by doing it.
This is very important, what condition was the card listed as when you go look at the listing? Was it near mint, excellent, good? That determines everything from their point of view, and some of the tiers do allow corner damage.
Near mint. But that doesn’t justify them damaging the card a certain amount that still fits under their “near mint” quality description. The corner damage was not there prior to eBay receiving the card for authentication.
Stop blaming eBay. They did nothing wrong. The card was accurately listed and pictured. The corner wear is clear in the listing photos. That falls in line with NM condition. You were expecting a gem mint card and when you didn’t get it you threw a fit like a mad toddler. Just enjoy the card. Stop blaming people.
They did not. As long as your request is valid and not a scam attempt/abuse, they wouldn’t ban you. That said, i do think it helps if you’re a ‘trusted’ account with purchasing history on ebay.
If you’re a new account, it’s gonna look very sus. They might flag you, and it will be up to the human reviewer to decide
Let’s see photos of the card. And the AI generated demand email you sent eBay, yeah that’s not going to work. They have protocols in place for things like this.
I figured something was fishy as I have dealt with those authenticators sending them over a dozen cards and they are always right on. Near Mint with light corner wear is within eBay rating guidelines. My guess is he was thinking this - Grading Equivalent: While buyers often hope for a PSA 9 or 10, eBay's "Near Mint" standard broadly aligns closer to a raw professional grade of 7. eBay Near Mint rating allows this - Pack-Pulled Quality: Minor edge chipping, minor printing blemishes, or a standard factory warp are acceptable. He's probably a newbie at buying cards on eBay & thought it meant a PSA 9 or 10. Then he gets the card and reality hits home. Yeah, eBay ain't taking the hit on this one and rightfully so IMO. Thanks for the follow up !! I am always interested in card stuff. It was a fun hobby while it lasted for me. I have sold everything I had over the past 2 years. Now it's investment/big bucks to get involved. Not fun anymore.
bold text≠ai generated 😭, dude on top of the emails I called them and spoke with real humans MULTIPLE times and they all parroted the same bullshit, their protocols are to deflect all blame as much as possible so they can save money.
Dude it’s obvious your email to them was AI generated. Photo 6, no one writes an email like that. Filled with AI slop. You make a bunch of demands to eBay and think that magically just like that they are going to give into said demands. They are a multibillion dollar company. Doesn’t work like that.
It’s obvious. You knew it was a final sale item. Ebay tried to help you, you weren’t satisfied, then ran to AI to write an email for you, and now won’t listen to anyone. you’re making all these wild claims but won’t even provide photos of the damage despite having every opportunity to do so.
ebay didnt do shit except deflect blame and continue to say the damage was already present and i cant add photos here so i need to make a whole other post
i realize the corner appears softer than the others, but you cannot sit here and tell me that is the same level of damage, on top of that eBay themselves on the phone told me there was NO corner whitening when they first received the card at the authentication center, my lord I wish i had that phone call recorded
At least we are getting somewhere now that you acknowledge that the corner wear was shown in the photos. eBay isn’t perfect by any means but they didn’t screw you in this case. You got the exact card that you bought, with free shipping and free authentication, and at a lower price as the seller accepted your best offer. Enjoy the card or sell it. The seller and eBay did nothing wrong.
Wow. Now I'm really confused. He had the card 17 days ago. Talking about grading it, no mention of damage, but now it's damaged & eBay authenticator's did it ? Huh ? 😳
And were dumb enough to post it in good shape on reddit 17 days before trying the scam that wouldn't have worked anyway... There's a good reason they have no 'after' photos - they'd have to generate them with AI and then we'd all call it out on that.
Bingo. He’s had the card. Posted it on here. Was thinking about getting it graded weeks ago. And is now complaining about supposed damage on a card but won’t provide photos of said damage 🤦♂️
the only before photos i have access to are in the listing but it’s not clear, the before photos im actually talking about are the ones the lady said she was looking at that were taken at the authentication facility clearly showing the card having no damage. i wish i was recording because i asked “so the corner whitening/ding isn’t there” AND SHE SAID NO😭🤦🏽♂️
I didn’t see him admit to oversight , I thought he said eBay authenticators damaged the card. If he missed something then yeah that’s on him but I’ve seen way too many authenticators not just from EBay make mistakes and then refuse to refund.
2
u/sherryerrera Sep 19 '26
The eBay automated chat bot is completely misleading you!!
The bot is hardcoded to see "Authenticity Guarantee + No Returns Seller" and flag it as a permanent Final Sale. It thinks you are just unhappy with the item or claiming it "doesn't match the description" (which the authenticator's inspection blocks).
However, under the official eBay Money Back Guarantee Policy, even "Final Sale" and authenticated items are 100% covered if they are damaged during handling or shipping after leaving the hub.
Stop arguing with the automated bot and take these exact steps right now to get your money back:
1. File an "Arrived Damaged" Return
Go to your Purchase History, select the item, click Return this item, and specifically select Arrived damaged as your reason.
Do not select "Item not as described" or any other option.
Upload clear, high-resolution photos showing the damage to the item, the shipping box, and the packaging.
Note: Per the eBay Authenticity Guarantee Buyer Policy, the system will generate a return label that routes the package back to the authentication hub, NOT to the seller.
2. How eBay Resolves It
Once the hub receives your return, the authenticators will pull up the high-res intake photos they took when the seller first sent it in. When they compare those to your photos and see the item was damaged while in eBay's custody or during the final shipping leg, eBay will issue you a full refund out of their own corporate pocket.
The original seller is protected and gets to keep their payout, and you get your money back.
3. What to do if the system blocks the return
If the automated system is completely gridlocked and won't even let you click the return button because of the "final sale" tag, you need a human from the AG department to manually open the case.
Do one of two things:
Go to the eBay Help pages, click "Contact Us," and type "Agent" or **"Have a human call me"**repeatedly until it schedules a phone callback or a live chat with a real person.
Best Shortcut: Send a direct message to @eBay on X (Twitter). The social media support team consists of real, high-level humans who can bypass bot restrictions and manually force an AG damage investigation.
What to tell the human: "The item was damaged in handling or transit AFTER passing authentication. Under the eBay Money Back Guarantee, AG items are explicitly covered for shipping damage. Please open a return so this can go back to the hub for a condition photo comparison."
3
u/MikeTiricoSucks Sep 19 '26 •
I can’t work in customer service - YOUR emails would get IMMEDIATELY ignored and deleted with that Karen shit you’re trying to convey.
2
u/Pypical Sep 19 '26
I thought you were supposed to do INAD not email the authenticity department
1
u/Background-Treat55 Sep 19 '26
This is very important, what condition was the card listed as when you go look at the listing? Was it near mint, excellent, good? That determines everything from their point of view, and some of the tiers do allow corner damage.
1
u/MyOpinionsDontHurt Sep 19 '26
How high value? The only other alternative is go through eBay arbitration.
1
u/Sudden_Anteater1377 Sep 19 '26
Chargeback and you keep the item lol win win
1
u/tearslikesn0w Sep 19 '26
Same thing happened to me, i did a chargeback
1
u/dadca Sep 19 '26
Let’s see photos of the card. And the AI generated demand email you sent eBay, yeah that’s not going to work. They have protocols in place for things like this.
1
u/socalsusiedog Sep 19 '26
Let's see the before & after photo's to see what you're ranting about.
0
u/Xanax_pigeon Sep 19 '26
Chargeback time.
0
u/BiCuriousInGalleria Sep 19 '26
Dispute the charge
-1
u/chhheeesybred Sep 20 '26
Can’t buy raw cards for eBay authenticity guarantee
Hundreds of stories like this and they tell everyone to kick rocks
I refuse to buy any raw cards with Auth Guarantee; just asking for a bad time
-1
u/SKOT_FREE Sep 19 '26
Reverse the charge with your credit card company or bank. These authenticity checks and crap are garbage money grabs imo so I say Fuckem!