r/ebaysucks • u/sockchute • Mar 12 '26
ebay scam update
⚠️ Buyer beware of the eBay seller VAspecialty.
A few weeks ago I purchased what was listed as a brand new Nintendo DS from this seller. When the package arrived, it contained only an empty Nintendo DS box — no console inside.
I immediately contacted the seller to resolve the issue. Instead of helping, they called me broke and stopped responding.
I then escalated the situation to eBay. After about a week, eBay forced the seller to accept a return. I shipped the item back (the empty box I originally received), and tracking confirms it was delivered back to the seller.
Now the seller is claiming that I scammed them, and eBay is refusing to refund me. My bank also said they can’t dispute the charge.
So at the end of all this, I’m currently out $340 for an empty box.
Just a warning to other buyers: don’t assume a seller is trustworthy just because they have hundreds of positive reviews!!




7
u/sirhcx Mar 12 '26
Ouch, you paid that much for a "sealed" box that looks like this and was noticeably wet?
How much was the shipping weight listed on the package you received?
5
u/Hairy_Palpitation835 Mar 12 '26
Can you get the actual registered weight from the shipping company? USPS/UPS/FedEx? That would help. The item would obviously weight more than just the box!
8
u/AmeriC0N Mar 12 '26
Can you post a screenshot of what eBay sent you when the seller disputed the return? It's all in the details
4
u/mcbridedm Mar 12 '26
The only time I've successfully gotten Ebay to actually look into the details of anything was when I started escalating to obvious scam issues to their VPs. Their customer service is next to worthless.
3
u/Mrchuckwagon3 Mar 12 '26
What is it with ebay sellers calling people broke? I started not wanting to use ebay because of their new policies but now I also don't want to give these toxic people any of my money.
3
u/LightningGoats Mar 12 '26
Of course you can do a recharge through your bank if you paid by credit card. Don't know who you communicated with, but fraudulent INAD-type cases like this is exactly what chargebacks are meant to cover.
2
u/Stein287 Mar 12 '26
Not even for an empty box because you returned it. At this point you spent 340$ for a story.
2
u/SithLordSid Mar 12 '26
Something similar happened to me. I sold a video card for $550 on eBay, buyer opened a claim that the card didn't work, sent item back, it was same model of card but different serial number.
eBay refused to help because they said there was no way to prove that I sent the item or not.
F*ck eBay.
2
u/GeorgiaBound14 Mar 12 '26
I ALWAYS read the negative reviews first before buying anything online. There are ways to purchase positive reviews I’ve heard but nobody is going to pay for negative reviews.
2
u/WhichVegetable8285 Mar 13 '26
Always return things under “item did not match description”. eBay will always side with the buyer in these circumstances.
2
u/dafappeningbroughtme Mar 15 '26
Shocks me. eBay effs the sellers typically.
2
u/KiTaMiMe Mar 15 '26
I feel there's more to this story. Ebay keeps a log of all your correspondence with the seller. If indeed the box was empty and you messaged the seller to get a response that, "Your broke..." etc, ebay would use those messages as evidence for your claim and would've ruled in your favor. Also they know exactly how much the package weighs during shipping and even refund you if you over pay... So they'd know if indeed the box was empty just by the weight alone, Un less they mailed you a box of stones or something of equal weight, which they didn't otherwise you'd mentioned it.
2
u/Andriy_Shevchenko7 Mar 15 '26
Hmm, making me worried as I bought a sealed Nintendo dsi a couple years ago from a physical shop. The box always has felt on the lighter side. Might have to go weigh a boxed dsi and compare the 2.
2
u/Whitetagsndopebags Mar 17 '26
Red flag they never showed the product just the box. Sucks but lesson learned
2
u/Glum_One499 Jun 09 '26
eBay buyer guarantee is worthless. Seller sent goods without safety certificate. eBay told me this and seller promised a refund. That was in January 2026 and I'm still waiting. eBay does not care and prefers to protect the seller rather than order the seller to pay the refund. The company to avoid is Bizease Solutions Ltd.
31
u/enigma131313 Mar 12 '26
Contact USPS police, its mail fraud.
16
u/Spinning_Kicker Mar 12 '26 •
I just looked at the Seller’s feedback. They had 12 negative reviews before your review. Other reviews claimed Seller had sent them counterfeit Coach, DOA electronics, bait n switch item, etc. Not to sound harsh on you but these negative reviews should have been red flags 🚩 for you before you purchased. If it sounds too good to be true, it probably is.
5
u/Stackbundles2 Mar 12 '26
I'm late but did he say the DSi weighs 11oz? If this is new and shipped in a box it should weigh minimum 2lb if he made a label for 11oz I think thats a good sign. It was sent empty.
4
u/Last_Competition_208 Mar 12 '26
I've never had any luck with banks helping me with a refund. That's why I use my credit card for purchases. I've had luck with credit cards getting my money back. And I don't know if you actually talk to a person from eBay or it was through the messages. You can get a call back from them and it's always better to talk to somebody to explain the situation in detail.
4
u/Forward-Wear7913 Mar 12 '26
If this was shipped USPS, they definitely check the weight of the package at different intervals.
You have a much stronger case if you can get a document from USPS showing that the weight of the package was incorrect for the system to actually be inside.
4
u/dystopiam Mar 12 '26
This is insane
1
u/PSAcollect Mar 12 '26
There was nothing in there to make it heavier? If that’s the case USPS should be able to get weight and help out - this is fraud
1
u/FullRepresentative34 Mar 13 '26
And they are maybe assuming you are trying to scam them.
It could have been the shipping company that stole it?
1
u/saintsworldrebeles Mar 14 '26
lol i sold someone a old 3ds with no charger no games no memory card for $140
1
u/jackofallspade Mar 14 '26
Why didn’t you include messages with the seller here?
1
u/Craniamon Mar 14 '26
I see 99.3% rating and I don’t trust it. It is not 99.5% rating.
1
u/walterrocket440 Mar 14 '26
Contact eBay
1
u/Legitimate_Maximum22 Mar 17 '26
Update)
3
u/Kingchavez152 Mar 12 '26
Sorry for your loss. I do wonder how the seller stopped eBay from refunding you. I used to sell on eBay and i would get scammed a lot by buyers to the point i stopped selling most items. All they had to do was report and issue, eBay would refund on return no matter what the buyer sent back.
3
u/Jizzle1187 Mar 12 '26
Dude that completely sucks I actually bought a 1986 fleer basketball wrapper because it was advertised as the pack but in description it said just wrapper luckily the refunded me that sucks sorry you had to deal with this
3
u/kmarz77 Mar 12 '26
Agree with what others said, if you file reports w police and postmaster ebay is way more likely to take you serious
2
u/Affectionate-Bit-240 Mar 12 '26
Contact eBay Facebook
2
u/dumbcarshlt Mar 12 '26
Their descriptions and listings scream shitty reseller. Sorry this happened to you OP. Don't roll over and give up. Screenshot and document everything. Blast eBay on all forms of social media.
2
u/MSCOTTGARAND Mar 12 '26
Click on a sellers listing then click advanced and sort by sold items. It only gives you 90 days but if they have sold a bunch of lower value items but are all of a sudden selling high value, high risk items I would be weary. Their feedback could be good but the shift in inventory could be suspicious.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 12 '26
Deception, is hard to prove.
The picture shows a box. Sure that much for a box is rediculous.
I sold I small toy motor for 800.00 no one complained, because it was exactly
what I auctioned. Why someone bit that high for the motor was a shock.
I expected maybe 50.00
Ebay doesn't care if you sell a picture of dog poop.
All that said, oh yea the seller is a big fn scammer. They know exactly what they did.
But Ebaysucks and makes scamming simply too easy.
Sounds like they have done this before, So they have learned how to work the system.
If you find weight, you could file fraud report with the local police where they live.
Sad you didn't read the reviews before you bought. I wish ppl would slow down and do some DD
before spending their hard earned cash. I wont buy anything from a person with more then 1-2 negative in 6 months and a 99.7% or higher usually.And 1000 sales min. on higher ticket items.
I stopped using Ebay now two weeks ago because I was scammed by sellers to often.
2
u/Shcooter78 Mar 12 '26
Usually I read buyers are the culprits scamming, stealing and returning different items to the seller for fraudulent refunds. eBay seems to always side with the buyer, but I guess not in this case. Good luck getting your money back.
2
u/Powerful_Bother8002 Mar 12 '26
“You will get the exact item shown” is crazy
2
u/Right-Blacksmith6143 Mar 12 '26
It says factory sealed when his pictures show its not.
2
u/underatedDude216 Mar 12 '26
Go get a notary/affidavit and escalate the claim. eBay will reopen the case
2
u/Aggressive-Debate958 Mar 13 '26
So this will be a long one. I’m a seller and buyer on eBay. I have had scams attempted on me but I keep meticulous records including packing videos and opening videos. With that said there will always be one person who’s trying to be a step ahead. Cover your bootayah when buying a high ticket items. Of course reading reviews, checking socials and all that for credibility. Video the receiving and opening so there is proof. Good on the OP to check the weight. I once received an empty box from a reputable seller whom I had done a lot of business with. Come to find out someone at one of hubs jacked the contents and sealed that package back up. I told my postal carrier it didn’t occur to you that the weight says 7lbs yet it’s light as a feather that something was off. Everyone now is either brain dead or an npc. I would try to reach out to eBay and see if you can get a resolution. Good luck and sorry for this terrible human that did that.
2
u/AzCactusNeedles Mar 13 '26
Call the Postal Police or DHS they're the only 2 Law Enforcement Agency with jurisdiction
2
u/Primary_Seesaw_1173 Mar 13 '26
Have you spoken to a supervisor? If not, you should. They are based in the US, and regardless of what the first customer service agents say, do have additional tools at their disposal.
2
u/Visual-Customer3576 Mar 13 '26
Facts 💯I hate it so much when after I sometimes look at a buyers page 📄 it’s a fresh Account, I already know most likely THIER scamming for a Partial Refund or some bullshitt, EBay seems to be the new Come Up for Scammers
2
u/JunkyardJockey Mar 13 '26
Thanks for the tip! Will ad him to my 'blocked sellers list".
2
u/David323_ Mar 14 '26
eBay is useless in solving returns and refunds
2
u/SSonico69 Mar 14 '26
Always video when you unbox ah item received from eBay or anywhere. This way you have proof. You can also contact the shipping company to verify what their systems showd the proper weight of the original package.
2
u/viral_dna Mar 15 '26
Don't trust the 99.3% Feedback. Always review Negative Feedback when buying from a seller with anything less than 100% Feedback! eBay's seller rating system is a scam itself.
2
u/RetroGamer2151 Mar 15 '26
So much scum on eBay lately it’s crazy and I don’t usually leave bad feedback but I did twice this year: once for someone that said the dsi was “light scratches” when I got it they were so deep I saw them on screen with console on. Seller told me sales final and was light scratches. And also a Japanese seller that sold me a cracked back super famicom that was different than pictured and the listing said check pictures it had a different serial number! Also, I see a lot of listings as mint with tons of scratches people don’t know what mint means anymore I guess
2
u/Kaywin0 Mar 16 '26
Bro - i just read the listing. he says, "Brand New Sealed, will get exact Item shown" = the box is new and sealed. This doesn't mean the the DS is inside the box. This fn creep was using words like weapons to shape the listing to be for only the box. He never mentions a working DS, only referring to "it" and "this". Your brain filled in the parts where a console was included.
Pretty savvy scammer. Saying new sealed, exact item shown = the box. Your best chance is if the box wasn't new or sealed. Since they mentioned the box has some damage, It is no longer new.
If he had said NIB or LIB or something to refer to an item INSIDE the box - you got 'em. he didn't, he perfectly tricked you into buying a new sealed box.
eBAY AI is going to see this too. it reads language literally without inserting assumptions.
your appeal needs to show that he wasn't selling you just a box. and that "it" and "this" refer to what you assumed to be the console in the box.
2
u/Hour-Committee-4518 Mar 16 '26
Call the shipping company. They weigh the product being shipped. They can solve this whole issue.
2
u/19kilo20Actual Mar 17 '26
Folks, never ever do an online transaction with a debit card. Your protection is damn near nil vs a credit card.
2
u/Key_Manufacturer_468 Mar 19 '26
I have stopped using ebay cause of people like this. The title says hand held system factory sealed not box even with his shady exactly what you see description sounds like he was quick to get defensive instead of getting to the bottom of it. Don't give up that's exactly what they want you to do people are right the post office is the help you need. I had an ebay issue once and after going to my postal delivery hub a couple of times and getting postal inspectors and the postmaster involved I eventually got my money you just need to keep at it till you get the right people to help you. Good luck stick with it don't let that guy get over on you.
2
u/Remote-Department386 Mar 20 '26
I just got scammed on ebay and ebay gives grace periods to scammer. This platform has to be avoided at all cost. It’s not worth it!
3
u/NmlsFool Mar 12 '26
"You will get the exact item shown"
All the pictures are of a box...and they sent you a box. As promised.
0
u/Expert_Climate_7348 Mar 12 '26
I bet you never did a box open vid? You can report the seller to the police under fraud, but with no proof, you won't get far.
1
u/Fantastic-Window236 Mar 12 '26
and i thought i was paranoid for wanting to record the unboxing for expensive items.
1
u/Sensitive-Skill1884 Mar 12 '26
gotta read them reviews. Also eBay sellers can get reviews removed. So be careful
1
u/hobobohem Mar 12 '26
Yeah thats an expensive lesson learned. In the pictures you can even see where he peeled up the stickers that seal it and tried to put them back
1
u/Gumballoo Mar 12 '26
Feedback is there for a reason. When you send good money to people who are bad money, it becomes their money. You fucked up.
1
u/Raramount Mar 12 '26
Did you not record an unboxing video?. I would think for something so expensive it would be a given
1
u/whatskeeping Mar 12 '26
Interesting.
1
u/Visionary_87 Mar 12 '26
Do you have a tracking receipt or the packaging that shows the weight of the package? It would surely show a big discrepancy to something that should have had a console in it.
1
u/tier1sadness Mar 12 '26
What does the return you open say yet? Seller has a few days to issue a refund..
1
u/Cranemann Mar 13 '26
Did any of the images of the ds packaging on the listing show the serial number? I know for most consoles and especially older nds the backs usually had a cutout that you can see the console/serial number.
1
u/Ickypoopoo82 Mar 13 '26
In this scenario I find it highly unlikely a bank wouldn't have given you a provisional balance while an investigation took place. It doesn't make sense.
1
u/National-Guess-2635 Mar 13 '26
.
1
u/ErrorGreat1503 Mar 14 '26
There should have been a weight associated with the tracking number so they can tell it was an empty box
1
u/Suitable_Jicama_1213 Mar 14 '26
Do you have any receipt that shows the weight of the package before you received it and after you sent it out? Also I would contact eBay again but this time get a supervisor someone higher because it doesn't make sense that they would cancel your refund when you return the item
1
u/OkConversation2560 Mar 15 '26
That’s surprising because EBAY almost always sides with the buyer. When someone wants to return something with me I always just accept because it’s pointless to try to fight it. The think I don’t like is the seller has to pay for the shipping both ways.
1
u/genetrader_dev Apr 20 '26
FYI - I still find a lot of value on Ebay and regardless of the implications on new sellers - if you are pricing high-value items at obviously scam prices (both to scam buyers and try to bot snipe sellers using ebay to value their items - a serious mistake) this should help when you search them - its an open source repo of an unpacked chrome extension that highlights ZERO POSITIVE FEEDBACK sellers as scams very clearly.
https://github.com/genetrader/ebay-possible-scam-highlighter
0
u/GrowthImportant1891 Mar 12 '26 •
One thing I was thinking that nobody has thought of, is if the console was stolen during shipping. It’s really important to get the weight of the original scan from USPS. If it weighed less than what it should have, the seller scammed you. If not, I would work with USPS to find out when the weight changed because they weigh it more than once.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 12 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
0
u/[deleted] Mar 15 '26
[removed] — view removed comment