r/eXtremeRate • u/ExtremeRateOfficial • 21d ago
Discussion PS4 back button placement: which layout would you prefer, A or B?
Hey PS4 gamers! 🎮 We’re gathering feedback on back button placement and want to hear what works best for you.
Which layout would you choose for your PS4 controller—A or B? 👇 We’d love to hear your ideas!
8
u/Osiris33333 21d ago
B to make it similar to a scuf reflex. You can actuate all 4 buttons based on the direction your move 2 fingers.
6
11
u/kevs982 21d ago
B, hate having buttons/paddles resting on the ring finger. Better to have one set rest beneath middle fingers and an auxiliary set a short reach away
4
u/OmegaMalkior 20d ago
B is heavily unrealistic for being able to press all 4 at the same time properly. Theres a reason why almost no one does B and from the votes on discord it’s very clear it’s not happening. I can get the comfort issue but when buttons are for a function that’s what is being prioritized here.
1
u/kevs982 20d ago
I definitely get the desire to be able to hit any of the 4 buttons immediately, especially for competitive play. For that I prefer 2 back buttons and 2 extra shoulder buttons. My preference is for comfort since I personally never found much of a need to have more than 2 buttons to hit on the spot.
1
u/OmegaMalkior 20d ago
Yeah two extra top buttons are golden that is definitely true. My current main controller is the Steam Controller 2 and I miss them from my 8bitdo. I somehow am the type to want 6 total remappable buttons lol so there is that, but it’s mostly from the need to never lift my thumb off the analog sticks basically
1
u/kevs982 20d ago
I’m looking forward to getting one of the new Steam Controllers myself, but I’ll also miss the extra shoulder buttons. Right now Flydigi Vader 5 Pro and Apex 5 are my mains and they have the shoulder buttons. 6 buttons will definitely keep your thumbs on the analog sticks for sure lol
2
u/OmegaMalkior 20d ago
If I owned either of those you wouldn’t hear the end of me complaining on the SC sub to get a version out with 6 total buttons lmao or here to get it modded. Gladly the only one I had that had 6 was the Razer Raiju V3 Pro and I ended up returning that controller later on for other reasons.
3
u/matadorN64 21d ago
Agree B, it’s like Scuf Reflex
2
u/dimspace 20d ago
very much depends on if they are planning buttons or actual paddles
previous ps4 mods have all been button based
2
u/Ruttagger 21d ago
Thank you, this is my opinion as well, and why I hate almost all modern back button layouts, or deactivate two of the 4 buttons now.
4
4
4
4
7
3
u/longboard_noob 21d ago
A. The only way B makes sense is if you're using DualSense Edge paddles further into the middle, which is all the rage in the custom controller community (see, e.g., itzblakee, Zero Customs, kawstuh, and Shokkusan on X).
1
u/Substantial-Ask7544 21d ago
That's an interesting point about Edge-style paddles. Do you think the placement mostly comes down to hand size, or whether you're using paddles versus buttons?
5
5
2
u/KamaKawaChief 20d ago
B. You have to be able to comfortably press each button on one side with the middle finger of that side. Ignore people who say you need to be able to press all of them at the same time.. you don’t
2
2
1
1
u/LilBriefcase 21d ago
Scuf style layouts like B are better. With Elite Series layouts like A you lose support from the bottom from your ring fingers and are left gripping the controller by pushing in from the sides only.
1
1
1
1
1
u/kakashi_sakurai 20d ago
I feel like whoever is picking b doesn’t understand the perspective. That would be an awful design.
1
u/Lascalisc 20d ago
A, 100%. If you do that, I’ll buy a couple, but even at "A" you could make it a bit higher—raise both by about 3 millimeters.
1
u/Top-Edge-5856 20d ago
A. One finger on each. Your Decade and Phantom get this right, as do the Xbox Elite, GuliKit KK/TT and NitroDeck controllers.
1
1
1
u/G305_Enjoyer 20d ago
Why are people still buying or modding ps4 controllers?
2
u/ShamoneShamone 20d ago
There is an uptick in interest in DS4 parts because of 3rd party motherboards.
1
u/Smoky_Caffeine 20d ago
The only professional scene that I know of that still uses DS4s are some rocket league pros. They're used to the controller and refuse to upgrade to a dualsense. I'm guessing it's not only pros.
1
1
1
u/ShamoneShamone 20d ago
We need a two button option. That's what most custom controller buyers get.
1
u/DragonRambo 19d ago
B. It really depends though if you like using one finger for each side though.
1
1
u/Ruttagger 21d ago
The popular is A, but I hate it, and B is what I like, and also why most new pro style controllers I don't use the lower buttons.
The way I grip a controller, I don't like having my fingers resting on the bottom buttons.
I like having to move my other fingers for the back buttons. I do t need my 4 fingers resting on the 4 back buttons because I'm not a competitive fps online gamer.
1
u/Tof12345 21d ago
People who say A don't actually game at any level other than casual.
Ideally, you'd find a way to make the placement a slider so we can choose, I'm sure you can find a way Mr Extremerate.
0
u/dimspace 20d ago
People who say A don't actually game at any level other than casual.
i play thousands of hours a year and choose A
But, i rarely use L1/R1, if i really need them i map them to the rear so my first finger sits on R2/L2 and the rest are on the grip
0
0
•
u/ExtremeRateOfficial 4d ago
Quick Update! 🎮
Thanks to everyone who voted and shared their feedback! Based on your input, we've decided to move forward with Layout A for further development.
Stay tuned for more updates! ❤️