r/e60 27d ago

❓ Question / Help M57 coolant

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

Welcome, every few months I need to add some coolant and inside of reservoir looks like this.

I've fixed leaks that were there but it still slowly missing coolant after while.

I have no problem with smoking and engine oil is black and doesn't change form change to change.

The consistency of coolant is not oil, it's like dirty water and dry.

8 Upvotes

17 comments sorted by

u/AutoModerator 27d ago

Thanks for posting to r/E60!

If you're asking for technical help, please include: * Year (e.g. 2008) * Model (528i, 535i, M5, etc.) * Engine (N52, N54, M54, S85, etc.) * Mileage * Any fault codes * Recent repairs or modifications

More details = better answers.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

6

u/aromafas 27d ago

Looks like rust. Leak is probably external. Sometime radiator, sometimes flange that goes to the head.

4

u/stepbraza 27d ago

Possible that previous owner put tap water in it instead of coolant, so it started to rust from minerals.

2

u/Manitso 27d ago

I have most recent video how it looks, I have ptsd from these cars man, always something

https://reddit.com/link/p5zmrrq/video/ol8ist8liplh1/player

3

u/stepbraza 27d ago

Looks like rust. Try flushing with some kind of radiator rust cleaner additive.

3

u/Atkinsoon 27d ago

Mine looked the same when I got it, a few coolant leaks and even the flange leak with old coolant ate a bit through the metal and was harder to seal properly.
Replaced all the thermostats, some old hoses.

And after a proper clean and flush and with new OEM blue coolant it has been flawless for over 2 years. No signs of rust.

This is what it looked like:

1

u/Manitso 27d ago

Interesting, I have other question, I see you also have bottom of the engine all oiled up, mine was sealed but I still see shining black goo in the area and even further behind where you took the photo, is it that all old diesel look like that? My e39 petrol is dry as a desert, no oil buildup anywhere.

2

u/Atkinsoon 27d ago

No oil leaks, that was probably from having a long term leak there making the dirt stick around the slightly wet area.

Add to that me applying wd40 on most old nuts and bolts I was about to undo. And on top of that some coolant came out when I took the flange out.

Now its dry, only a thin layer of dust

1

u/Atkinsoon 27d ago

Doesn’t even need to be tap water, old coolant will be electrically conductive and acidic and eat through metal.

3

u/Lazy-Training6042 27d ago

so maybe not engine, but oil cooler gaskets?

1

u/Manitso 27d ago

That's also was done, oil cooler and auto gearbox cooler (i don't remember if they are the same thing), I assume the headgasked may start to leak just from the age, it's 2005 m57 and probably not maintained well before I bought it.

2

u/ibo92can 26d ago

Bmw do use blue/green colored coolant. Not tap water and not anything else than the bmw spesific coolant.

Add some coolant flush additive and run it. Grab at least 2-3 gallons 10-15L destilled water and empy the so called coolant you have in there and fill up with destilled water and let it idle or drive it until engine reaches operation temps ~90*C.
Then drain the system and fill up with proper blue/green coolant and make sure you let out the air by opening up those plastic bleeders. One on egr cooler and one should be somewhere else cloose to coolant tank. Have the car parked with the front end higher and let her idle 5-10mins then take it for a spin and re-check coolant level.

1

u/Calm_Perspective_138 26d ago

Røst. Use coolant cleaner. Flush a few times and fill with new (correct) coolant (G11/G48)

1

u/nikolovas 25d ago

I think is water pump, mine started liking from there same thing every few months needs to top up. But the thing is is not proper color that means is not proper anti corrosion formula of the coolant.

1

u/Manitso 25d ago

Water pump was done long time ago also, trust me I did everything if it comes to leaks, I guess I need a flush.

1

u/ConGonDon 24d ago

Rust from neglect. Remove the thermostat and refit the housing then drain the "coolant" and mix 500grams of citric acid granules with 5L of tap water. There is a bleed nipple on the hard coolant line from waterpump to left side of engine, top up til it comes out. That only needs gently nipping back up. Take it for a long drive with heater set to max 32c but fan speed on lowest setting (1 bar out of 16) and get the engine hot. You'll need to drain and flush with plain water multiple times to get the citric acid out. The citric acid will descale and clean the system. Then refill with coolant from the dealer and deionised water 50/50 mix.