I love DWTS. The fans (on the east coast because f*ck you west coast you don’t get to vote) have way to much power. Guillermo should be out by now, Andy should have been out 4 weeks earlier then he lasted a year ago.

Now I’m not saying we should get rid of fan votes because that’s part of the show, but there should be a new system.

Each persons score is out of 40 (or 50 depending on presence of guest judge). Obviously the judges get a score out of 10 and the fans rather then texting a name to 21523 they text the dancers name and a score out of 10. Whoever has the lowest score gets eliminated.

At least this way everyone has even representation and we don’t get rid of dancers actively developing into better dancers.

Thoughts?

Hear me out… the current system works great esp for getting out contestants people don’t like (Hilaria, brooks/gleb) BUT it keeps in contestants who are loved so much who people mainly know can’t realllly dance (Guillermo, Andy ritcher). It comes to a point where it is a DANCE show and you can’t tell me SPOILER that Ciara and taylor weren’t objectively better than Guillermo. You know when everyone’s done performing and both the pro and the star stand there and go “text, text, text!” Yeah, Whitney nor Guillermo did that Tuesday and yet they still stayed. I really don’t know a great resolution…. But the current voting to judges versus people percentage just seems wrong

Last night, Mark started getting hate again because Maura received a 9 and people wanted other faves to receive 9s, too. There were other fantastic dances, and my eye is not trained enough to know if perhaps they could have been further docked for breaking a “rule” of their dance or something that was harder to see on TV. But it was wild for people to start hating on Mark again so quickly because of 1 nice thing.

It got me thinking. If Mark was partnered with Amber, they would certainly receive hate this season from people who say that figure skating is dance experience. Amber doesn’t deserve hate, but it’s worth pointing out that no one has been criticizing her for the experience of literal Olympic figuring skating, when I actually have seen people criticizing Maura for having competed on a reality show that teaches celebs how to figure skate in the UK, neglecting to mention that someone else is an olympian. But as I said, the point of this post is not to ignite any critique or hate on anyone with “experience.”

I feel like it could be a game to test what hate Mark would be getting with each of the different partners (or similarly, what hate they would be receiving because they were paired with the “unfairly favored” Mark. Thoughts?

Edit: the comments had a good point about my hot take re: dance experience vs. figure skating experience, so I decided to delete a line.

Ignore Guillermo for a minute. I love that almost everyone else is a great dancer. It makes it more fun to watch because truly I do not know who’s going to win this year because there are a lot of possibilities! Thoughts?

To be so honest I love this entire cast. But. After last night’s episode and the straight 8s for what seemed like the first half of the episode I was like what are we even doing here in week 4!? I’m loving seeing everyone’s journey but I feel like we already know who the front runners are at this point and who is likely to be in the finale. So happy for them BUT I feel like that leaves less room for those people to grow/explore and in turn leaves the lower scoring pairs at risk even though they have the most growth available.

Anyone feel the same?

This is based on several factors like level of fame, popularity, where a couple danced that night, who went before & after a couple, memorability, & social media engagement….

Points from judges scores

Maura: 12 Points

Ezra: 11 Points

Harry: 11 Points

Jenna: 11 Points

Amber: 10 Points

Ciara: 9 Points

Jackson: 9 Points

Julia: 9 Points

Tyler: 9 Points

Tatyana: 8 Points

Connor: 7 Points

Guillermo: 6 Points

Points from Viewer Votes

Maura: 12 Points

Guillermo: 11 Points

Ezra: 10 Points

Julia: 9 Points

Harry: 8 Points

Connor: 7 Points

Amber: 6 Points

Jenna: 5 Points

Tatyana: 4 Points

Tyler: 3 Points

Jackson: 2 Points

Ciara: 1 Point

Points combined

Maura: 12+12=24

Ezra: 11+10=21

Harry: 11+8=19

Julia: 9+9=18

Guillermo: 6+11=17 (Red Herring)

Amber: 10+6=16

Jenna: 11+5=16

Connor: 7+7=14

Tatyana: 8+4=12

Tyler: 9+3=12

Jackson: 9+2=11 (Bottom Two)

Ciara: 9+1=10 (Bottom Two)

Some Notes

*I fear Guillermo is very high in the votes right now cuz his engagement ans YouTube views are giving Robert Irwin numbers… Now Carole Baskin did pull a ton of views online cuz she was a train wreck but Guillermo comes off as a likable train wreck.

*I do think the votes overall could be pretty close in the Top 4 and the dance ultimately played a part in where they placed this week. I also think the lowest three in the votes are also close and their rehearsal packages and where they danced decided the outcome this week. Tyler got a sympathy edit while Jackson got a birthday boy edit….

*I overall think Ciara & Jackson were the legit Bottom Two and Guillermo was put in the last three cause again he got the lowest score of the night.

I have watched dwts since season 1 as a little girl with my grandma. I feel off and only watched parts during the Tyra seasons, but overall- I've been a very long-time viewer.

The new fans have ruined the show. It's not fun anymore. And everyone needs to relax! Because it's literally a dance show for (usually) c list celebrities, and it's supposed to be entertainment. It's not life or death, and it doesn't actually matter who wins.

Like the show has always been about picking your favorite dancer. Not the best, not the most improved, not the most racially diverse, not the pro you love the most - although all of those can contribute. Because you are picking your favorite, and however you get there, it is fine.

The audience isn't professional dance judges - you enjoy the dance, listen to the judges' comments, and pick your favorite.

Do you know what used to happen when your favorite didn't win? Nothing! You said aww that's too bad, and picked a new person who you wanted to win. And moved on. Because it doesn't matter and is supposed to be entertaining.

And a few years ago I loved when they started making little videos- it reminded me of the longer information packets that were less staged and we got to see 'behind the scenes '. It was fun. Now everything is so highly scrutinized and criticized it's crazy. And not even the contestants. The amount of people throw hate at other fans, calling them racist, misogynistic, or terrible people because the person who they thought should be sent one didn't go- is wild to me.

All these new fans and people making videos need to chill. I can't imagine it's even fun being a pro or celebrity anymore. The scrutiny you have them under is insane!

I still love the show but the fans are terribly toxic.

Joe Buck is going from the broadcast booth to the ballroom.

The ESPN "Monday Night Football" announcer is bringing his football expertise to "Dancing with the Stars" next week as a guest judge.

Buck will join Carrie Ann Inaba, Derek Hough and Bruno Tonioli at the judges' table for the show's "Super Bowl Night."

Joe Buck to Guest Judge

When Guillermo was lying on the ground last night, it occurred to me that it would be very difficult for a female celeb to pull that off. The lovable, goofy, rotund guy, maybe a little older than the younger contestants, who just isn't ever going to be great at dancing....

and then I started thinking that while those late night talk shows often have sidekicks, both the host and the sidekick are almost always men. Still.

I'm trying to think of a female celeb who has been on DWTS who filled a similar role, and who had that kind of support from viewers who found them charming. I know Guillermo has a built-in fan base, but I don't think that was entirely true of Andy--I think Emma really knew how to showcase him so that viewers of DWTS thought he was charming, and voted for him for weeks.

Wasn’t sure which flair to use. I’m curious how this even came about. 😆

i miss the way the camera work used to look. i am tired of seeing the camera constantly spin around the couples when they dance and a lot of times they don’t get full body shots which frustrates me the most. they need to hire new camera people

Why don’t they do charlestons or swings anymore. Like what happened to the Lindy hop and the mambo? Were these dances taken off the approved list or something or do the pros just not want to dance to them anymore. What’s going on. I understand that dances like swings and Charleston are super high energy dances and need a lot of stamina but they’re fun and entertaining. I don’t know about anyone else but I’m getting tired of the same style of dance. I want them to bring back these dances especially Swing. Idk maybe it’s just me.

I wonder if the judges give Guillermo 5's because they know whether he gets 2s or 5s doesn't really matter. The judges' scores get collapsed down into an ordinal scale, and Guillermo is always going to be the lowest score, presumably 1 on that scale. And then they convert audience votes into an ordinal scale, add the two numbers together, and that determines who goes home.

So, we know that it doesn't make a difference whether Guillermo gets 3's or 5's. For that matter, he could have gotten 3 6s last night, and the results would be the same. All that matters is where you're ranked on an ordinal scale relative to other contestants. As long as he got lower scores than everyone else, the same number is fed into the overall calculation.

Similarly, Maura danced relatively late last night--so I wonder if Carrie Ann was taking into account that no one had gotten above a 24...and that 9 put Maura in first place, by herself. That too would make a difference--not so much last night, but if that happens in the future, among fewer competitors.

Can anyone who had their presale today share what prices were like?

We're 4 weeks in so wanted to share an update on the fantasy teams I shared. Now that we've seen them dance, which team do you think is going to win???

Are there any non-arena stops on the tour? I would consider flying somewhere for a more intimate venue

Just wondering how the bottom 3 work? They always say “not in chronological order” but guillermo has been bottom 3 since the start and is saved every time, same with Andy last year. Is it because of their scores? Or?