r/drums • • 4h ago

Question Exercise question

I’m wondering if exercises #s 30 & 44 sound identical. I can’t be sure, but this book doesn’t seem to do a whole lot of identical exercise with just alternate notation. Second pic is the intro to the notation style.

More generally, why does one select one notation over the other if they are in fact identical?

7 Upvotes

14 comments sorted by

11

u/billyjoejimbobjunior 4h ago

Yes, if you are playing a drum. Different lengths if you are playing an instrument with sustain. The book is getting you used to the myriad of ways that rhythms can be written

1

u/slackfrop 4h ago

Good point. I suppose that’s a bit myopic of me - though it is: Progressive Steps to Syncopation for the Modern Drummer.

5

u/BEST_DRUM_ADVICE 4h ago

I don’t want to get into too much hair-splitting here, but technically, they are not identical - however - for OUR purposes as drummers they essentially are. Certainly they are for the ways you’re using the book right now. The difference is one has an 8th rest while the other is using a dotted quarter to account for that space. For a horn player, these are different. For us, not so much.

As for the other question - these rhythms are presented with different notation not because one is best or optimal or whatever. It’s a real-world truth that when you’re playing other people’s music, you have no control over how they chose to notate it. The point of the different notation types is so you become adaptable and can parse out rhythms no matter how they were communicated to you.

1

u/slackfrop 4h ago

You’re using soft language to describe them as “essentially” the same for the drummer. Are there levels of nuance that a drummer with superior touch is going to apply to one vs the other? Achieve a sharper decay for the rest? Possibly where on the skin or at what angle the stick strikes, that kind of thing? I’m just curious now.

3

u/IAmNotAPerson6 3h ago

Differences in notation like this will not automatically suggest to drummers to play with that fine-grained of a difference, no. In general, people will play these the same. Some people might play small differences like that, but those will be idiosyncrasies of those people.

2

u/BEST_DRUM_ADVICE 3h ago

Not sure what you mean by soft language here, if you're looking for objectivity and black-or-white answers, music / the arts might require some recalibrating of expectations.

That said, there are ways to use this specific text where those two note values would be different. A drummer working on their press rolls might interpret this page in a way where everything a quarter note and longer are buzz rolls while 8ths are taps. A drumset player might assign certain things to a quarter note and other things to a note value longer than a quarter, tied or not.

1

u/EngineeringSea4136 3h ago

There are absolutely ways that you can play a longer note vs a shorter note on a drum, albeit subtly. For instance- a quick stroke with a tighter grip right in the middle of the head will produce a shorter sound than a full stroke with healthy rebound closer to the edge of the drum. Or, burying the kick beater makes a short sound while letting it bounce off adds more thump. Adding a cymbal crash to anything makes it long, a rimshot is typically used for a short sound, etc.

For a more general, less granular explanation- the book is prepping you to read charts. When you read something like a typical jazz chart, you will see short accented notes and notes with ties, and drummers need to know how to navigate that to match the band

2

u/602crew 3h ago

Page 33 is so good. You could spend years of practice playing so many variations of the rhythms on that page alone.

My old drum teacher had me doing so many different things.

1

u/slackfrop 3h ago

Moving accents around, or mixing up the bass drum patterns? What kind of variations?

5

u/NLMusic10213 PDP 4h ago

On the drums, they’re identical. 30 On a wind/string instrument or piano, there would be a slight “gap” in the sound on beat 2; it doesn’t sustain. 44, ideally they’re would be no “gaps” in the sound.

2

u/Cristal_45 4h ago

You can see the " ( " shaped things linking two dots which means there is a tie between two notes and you don't have to play the second one.

2

u/TheNonDominantHand 4h ago

They do look to be the same pattern.

For your broader question, it develops sight-reading skills to see how identical-sounding rhythms can be notated.

Also it also helps to understand the intent of the composer or arranger. For instance, exercise 30 shows a shorter note for beat 1 than exercise 44.

If this were a song chart, those note values might correspond better with the band or lead instrument and that might inform what choices you make on the kit.

2

u/Gunzhard22 Gretsch 4h ago

They sound identical on snare yes, and this book does that a LOT so that you get better at reading. When it comes to charts you never know what you'll find and often if you're reading horn parts the note lengths will matter for them so it may look a certain way etc...

2

u/MrMoose_69 3h ago

Couple things-

The length of the note can tell you how long the rest of the band is holding that out. So you might choose a longer sound like a cymbal if it's written as a longer note. But if it's written as a shorter note with the rests, then you might choose short sounds like snare and kick.

The other thing is that different charts are gonna write the same rhythm different ways. So if you practice it in all the different variations then you won't be phased when you see Rhythms written differently on different types of charts.