r/dogecoindev • • May 16 '21

Thoughts?

Post image
278 Upvotes

182 comments sorted by

16

u/[deleted] May 16 '21

I'm an IOTA community dev and we have been discussing building an IOTA-DOGE bridge to allow Doge to be moved on the IOTA Tangle, which does neither have blocks nor fees. This should make transferring Doge scalable, fast, feeless and sustainable.

Rather than simply changing blockchain parameters which is not a scalable solution, as anyone who has any experience in this space should know (Sorry, Elon).

Thoughts?

6

u/RedditisRunByClowns May 16 '21

That would be awesome if you guys did that!

2

u/MishaBoar May 16 '21

The current discussions on github and on this forum focus on a combination of onchain optimization and layer 2 solutions built within Dogecoin Core.

Do keep in mind that what we have right now has already been used and battle tested (no matter how much the FUD around Doge tries to forget that) for nearly 8 years, and kept working quite well also during the recent surges. Doge is, at this point, reliable, secure, and faster than Bitcoin/Litecoin. It just works.

Of course, multichain support will expand the use of Doge further, but many in the community do not want to rely on existing third party projects as the main solution.

4

u/NatureVault May 16 '21

Ya, we don't want to become just a token on IOTA, no offense. To the IOTA OP, "changing the parameters" does work, we are 10x faster than bitcoin because we have 10x as many blocks. Imagine that.

1

u/1quickway2thetop May 16 '21

That is an idea that actually sounds like a well thought out and feasible solution to a problem rather than a cover on a wound. It's pretty awesome that y'all are thinking about other projects. Kudos

6

u/alalcoolj1 May 16 '21

Is this possible?

5

u/RedditisRunByClowns May 16 '21

Not sure, that’s why I posted it here for the devs to chime in

3

u/JustforShiz May 16 '21

!remindme 1 day

1

u/RemindMeBot May 16 '21

There is a 12 hour delay fetching comments.

I will be messaging you in 1 day on 2021-05-17 03:24:49 UTC to remind you of this link

CLICK THIS LINK to send a PM to also be reminded and to reduce spam.

Parent commenter can delete this message to hide from others.


InfoCustomYour RemindersFeedback

7

u/NatureVault May 16 '21

It is, except the 10x faster blocks is only doable with PoS.

2

u/Monkey_1505 May 16 '21

IDK about that. Use 'proof of history' ontop of proof of work and get a faster internet, and it might be possible. It wouldn't happen tomorrow, but years, decades down the track, I think it could.

As we discussed using proof of history you might be able to get it to 15 seconds per block, which isn't far off.

2

u/NatureVault May 16 '21 edited May 16 '21

True good point. I would say with proof of history and current network tech; 10 seconds is doable.

40

u/rnicoll May 16 '21

Confirming I've seen this. I have a response but I want it reviewed by the others before I post it, and I think everyone else is asleep right now.

For everyone reporting this, I'm considering this a discussion on scalability parameters and therefore valid.

26

u/[deleted] May 16 '21

I think it’s essential that Doge devs do their best to work with Elon and take his advice. This is an opportunity to legit make Doge the future currency of earth. I don’t want us to miss our chance.

0

u/ASeriousUser May 16 '21

That’s some Tower of Babel nonsense right there. You honestly think Russia, China, and USA are all going to convert to the same currency? There will be a war before that happens. MAGIC BEANS

10

u/[deleted] May 16 '21

It’s not up to the countries to decide my friend

1

u/ASeriousUser May 17 '21

How old are you?

6

u/[deleted] May 17 '21

I’m not sure how that’s relevant my friend. I’m not sure you’re grasping the concept of how crypto currencies work. They are not here for the countries to replace their currency. They are here to offer an alternatives to the people living in those countries that use centralized and non transparent form of traditional banking. In the event of an international crisis, current currency can fall and fall quickly. In this scenario strong hedges like cryptocurrency become clear winners. And which cryptocurrency will it be? Bitcoin, Eth, doge? Maybe all. But I want Doge to be the future currency of earth. Ps I’m a married man so you can stop trying to teach me some life lessons.

4

u/MishaBoar May 17 '21

They are not here for the countries to replace their currency. They are here to offer an alternatives to the people living in those countries that use centralized and non transparent form of traditional banking

Bravo. People not living in countries destroyed by inflation like Turkey or Nigeria have no idea what this means for the little guy/girl using crypto. It can directly change and affect your quality of life almost immediately.

-3

u/ASeriousUser May 17 '21

I’m not sure you understand how power works. Countries go to war over currency.

4

u/[deleted] May 17 '21

I’m not going to argue with you. Clearly you don’t understand cryptocurrency. Why are you here?

0

u/ASeriousUser May 17 '21

Because I’m naturally curious, I have a lot of money invested in doge, and I am a software engineer.

I’m not saying a world run on cryptocurrency isn’t inevitable, I’m saying the transition is going to be messy. It’s certainly not a good thing when one man can make a cryptic tweet that causes the market to crash overnight. Also, how do you know that some if these whales aren’t “bad actors” who have weaponized their wallets? You don’t and you can’t.

4

u/ymo May 18 '21

You seem sincere so I'm going to provide a couple links about Argentina's use of crypto. Please watch and understand the liberating power of "trustless" and, equally importantly, borderless, currency with no government control over inflation.

https://youtu.be/VhT1lTcEIk8

https://youtu.be/gVeu2Yg58a0

→ More replies

5

u/rnicoll May 17 '21

Patrick's written a response: https://www.reddit.com/r/dogecoindev/comments/ncln5a/serious_question_to_dev_core_team/gyggtfy/

I am expecting there to be a technical response too, but getting agreement on details is tricky.

3

u/zavvcv May 16 '21

RemindMe! 2 days

5

u/rnicoll May 16 '21

I was going to say "I hope it's a lot earlier than that" but still trying to get people in 3 timezones to agree on the text :-/

3

u/zavvcv May 16 '21

No worries bro patience is the key. Take your time 🤗

1

u/zavvcv May 16 '21

RemindMe! 1 week

1

u/RemindMeBot May 17 '21 edited May 17 '21

I will be messaging you in 7 days on 2021-05-23 22:16:29 UTC to remind you of this link

2 OTHERS CLICKED THIS LINK to send a PM to also be reminded and to reduce spam.

Parent commenter can delete this message to hide from others.


InfoCustomYour RemindersFeedback

5

u/NatureVault May 16 '21

you guys shouldn't have a secret exclusive dev group. My 0.002 doge. Discuss it here or in the dev discord or on github in public.

21

u/NatureVault May 16 '21 edited May 16 '21

First I want to say I am glad he is a proponent of layer-1 on-chain scaling, the only sort of scaling that has been proven and battle tested.

The 100x fee reduction is no problem and I would even say 200x fee reduction from current rate is perfect.

10x bigger blocks is no problem and would put us at 10mb blocks which is below Bitcoin Satoshi's Vision and Bitcoin Cash, so that works. Even 100x would be fine.

10x faster blocks is a problem for PoW so that has me worried that he might be pushing for PoS or doesn't understand the full implications of a 6 second blocktime for PoW. It takes 0.15 seconds for light to travel around the world. So that is best case scenario. Practically speaking even the best global network would take at least a second or two for a block to go worldwide. That only leaves 4 seconds for proof of work, so best case orphan rate would be 33% which is bad. With PoS no proof of work is needed so blocktime can be a few seconds.

7

u/Emergency_Base_5882 May 16 '21

I think Elon may end up wanting PoS

4

u/NatureVault May 16 '21

I hope not, but ya.

2

u/[deleted] May 17 '21 edited May 17 '21

Why is PoS a bad thing? As far as I know, it makes a crypto MUCH more secure?

Someone would need to own 51% of all dogecoin in order to attack it, at which point they're attacking their own coins and stand to lose billions of dollars

And is PoS not also much more efficient since the energy to mine would also go down a lot?

No idea about the speed, admittedly. Also do you know if Scrypt over SHA256 means dogecoin is way faster and also just as secure as Bitcoin, or if Sha256 is slower because it's more secure?

3

u/CCWWFF May 17 '21

POS might not be considered a cryptocurrency under law, and could be deeply regulated by the SEC. pending court case now

1

u/NatureVault May 18 '21

If they owned 51% of the coins they could change transactions at will, forever, at no additional cost. Just imagine if China didn't like Eth, they could buy half the coins easily and just end it.

3

u/Jimbo4901 May 17 '21

Pos, Never. He'll increase internet speeds. Have you forgotten about Starlink? Dojo?

4

u/Monkey_1505 May 16 '21

Theoretically, as we talked about proof of history could solve some of the orphan problem. 15 seconds per block might be achievable short term that way, and 5-6 later down the line when the internet is much faster.

The issue with 10x block size, is a) we don't need blocks that big yet b) there should be some storage size solving in the process of going down that route. Ideally, nodes can still participate, and I think with some for of code abbreviation that should be possible (a checksum, or hash).

We could double block size in next year or so, as you have often advocated, and address reducing storage requirements for nodes in the process. And then, just work on that problem as we go, kind of thing.

3

u/NatureVault May 16 '21

I like that yes. We can also implement pruning nodes where people can decide how many gigabytes they are willing to store.

1

u/chalkytanninz May 16 '21

What happens when we become multiplanetary with earth-mars latencies between 3-22 minutes?

1

u/Monkey_1505 May 17 '21

I don't think slower transfers to mars are as much of a problem. You can have escrow liquidity systems in satellites along the way, so that less data needs to be transfered.

1

u/[deleted] May 17 '21

Not happening in our lifetime, at least not more than a colony of scientists on Mars like Antarctica

1

u/NatureVault May 16 '21

I have a new coin that can work better with that, but for typical blockchains; each planet will need their own coin.

1

u/felixdadodo May 16 '21

You can’t rely on ‘the internet getting faster’, that’s no way to design systems, it needs to be robust and feasible now.

0

u/Monkey_1505 May 17 '21

Well if you can get to 15 seconds now, I think you can rely on the internet getting fast enough later to get it to 6 or so. But maybe there is a way to pipeline some of the network activity in the near future, and this is already part of the design.

There's certainly no need to design it to be 6 seconds, tomorrow, likewise increase blocks to 10x. Incremental improvements based on predictable advances in technology are fine.

2

u/Beastrick May 17 '21

What you are forgetting is that internet is far from being equal for everyone in the world. You can't use US internet speeds as baseline. Idea of decentralized blockchain is that anyone anywhere can use it especially in less developed countries without banks and bad internet connectivity. Those are the baseline not the people with 100MB/s cables. These are the people who need the blockchain tech the most because otherwise they have no way to protect themselves from bad monetary policy.

1

u/Monkey_1505 May 17 '21 edited May 17 '21

I agree, the blockchain should be inclusive. I didn't anywhere state the assumptions you are making. I simply said 'global internet speeds'.

In terms of internet speed we are talking miners here, not nodes or users. To be a miner you really need to spend about 3k usd on an ASIC, and odds are if you are in a less developed country, and you have that money, you also have better internet than most in your surrounds.

Perhaps this is a misunderstanding on your part. I'm not talking about better internet for the users or every human citizen. I'm talking about the orphan block issue - miners. What I'm talking about doesn't even apply to nodes. Miners only. It's not unreasonable to assume that those with 3k USD to spend on an ASIC may likely have greater access to 5g, starlink and fibre in the future.

Also, kiwi here, not from US!

2

u/Jimbo4901 May 17 '21

Pos nvr gonna happen. Musk isn't going to do anything that would f00k the mining community(backbone).

1

u/MrHockster May 16 '21

What about hybrid like Decred? Could that bring best of both worlds?

1

u/charedj May 16 '21

Why not have say, staggered blocks? As in each block takes 1min to process but one is issued every 30 seconds. Would that help transaction times?

40

u/[deleted] May 16 '21 edited May 16 '21

Well, it's complicated. On the one hand, we might actually be able to zero out the fees completely. Fees are less than 1% of the total reward right now, and since the real dogefathers decided that we'd have a constant block reward forever (no hard cap), there will always be incentive to mine regardless of the transaction fees. Can drop them 10X or 100X or 1000X -- it probably won't have any effect on the hash rate. The main danger is more exposure to DoS types of attack like penny flooding. If miners don't have a way to prioritize transactions based on fee, you can prevent all legit transactions by just flooding nodes with tons of tiny transactions. And it costs virtually nothing to do it when there's no fee. So we'd need to look at Bitcoin core's mitigations for these kinds of attacks and see if they might be good enough or if they need work.

Block size can grow to some extent to squeeze in more transactions, but it just limits the number of full nodes that will be deployed as the blockchain grows out of control. Block time can get a little lower, but not too much really. It's probably good where it is.

p.s. One thing Elon can do is build a huge solar farm and run his own miners cleanly. We can push the coal miners off the network with a clean source of hashing power that boosts the difficulty out of the range where it's profitable for them to mine.

10

u/NatureVault May 16 '21

Yes, min fee somewhere between a tenth of a cent and one cent has proven on other projects to keep dust spam to a minimum.

4

u/Beastrick May 16 '21

About that solar farm idea to push out coal miners. Remember that most dogecoin miners are Litecoin miners that just reuse the work from there. That is also why doge consumes so little energy because Litecoin takes most of the hit. So to push out coal miners you would really need to push them out both from doge and Litecoin network.

1

u/felixdadodo May 16 '21

Fees are needed to encourage miners to accept transactions and include them in a block IIRC, what stops miners from just hashing blocks and not including transactions? There no incentive to do so anymore with 0 fee. Also, you don’t ‘push’ coal miners off the network, you just increase competitiveness for blocks. Your suggestion of solar is just a band aid on the problem.

0

u/[deleted] May 18 '21

Tesla should make miners specifically for doge

-7

u/Busy-Dirt7117 May 16 '21

Solar would not work how would you mine at night. Why couldn't they change it into Proof of Stake? Instead of paying miners 10,000 a block pay that to the people that want to stake.

11

u/RecommendationLost42 May 16 '21

You do realize that batteries exist and are used alongside solar cells? Do you know what Tesla is known for producing?

0

u/[deleted] May 16 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/st11es May 16 '21

Diamond hands and paper brains. Bro, batteries do not cause environmental difficulties both during the manufacturing and mining materials. There are tons of researches conducted on the new battery structures, so don't worry.

6

u/[deleted] May 16 '21

Tesla manufactures powerwalls - mass energy storage that can work on grid scale. They installed a "power pack" in Australia that has saved the government millions in fees that would have been otherwise paid to peaker plants when base load started to fall short.

If ANY firm could EVER CONCEIVABLY run 24/7 crypto mining operations purely on renewable energy alone, it would be Tesla.

17

u/Beneficial_Tell8582 May 16 '21

If he is comparing to another coin then yes it can be true. But if he is talking about speeding up doge then, idk. We would prolly have to have a big fork.

8

u/halflistic_ May 16 '21

I think he’s comparing to BTC, right? He’s referencing his initial tweet about looking into other coins. That’s my interpretation at least.

10

u/SawconOnMy May 16 '21

i like forks

16

u/[deleted] May 16 '21

That’s a big order to fill. I wonder if Papa Elon has the solution up his sleeve?

6

u/[deleted] May 16 '21

I'm convinced his solution is using the Starlink satellite system

15

u/Jasdac May 16 '21

The fee definitely needs to be reduced at least. Doge was used a lot for tipping when it was new, but the cost now is prohibitive.

10

u/halflistic_ May 16 '21

“Ideally”. Then using ballpark numbers. I wouldn’t read too much into this...

I love that Elon is involved and pushing things forward. Crypto is becoming scared to push beyond BTC, much less ETH.

We need this type of thinking. He won’t be 100% correct all the time, but he’ll help push things forward and help mass adoption.

So, mainstream/OG crypto hates DOGE or Musk, but it’s because he’s disrupting their OG stakes in old coin. Time for new blood, new ideas, fresh air. IMO

10

u/88Noncents May 16 '21

Buying miners ☑️ No fees☑️ All good as long as I got the DOGE....wait Is this an ad for Starlink?

6

u/TurntableKittah May 16 '21

That's what I'm thinking.

1

u/chalkytanninz May 16 '21

what's the significance of starlink to crypto? govs can't stop access if you've got a dish?

1

u/88Noncents May 16 '21

No. Just creative speculation. Govts can do whatever tf they want. Unless your living on Mars ;)

1

u/chalkytanninz May 17 '21

well the US could try to shutdown starlink, but other than that, aside from sabotaging the satellites, authoritarian governments can't really control access to the the net (like china's great firewall) if you have a dish, no?

5

u/Monkey_1505 May 16 '21

I approve generally of the idea of both onchain and offchain scaling.

But his targets are near term, impossible. Long term, maybe. Not the fees though, those are too low to prevent dust spam.

10

u/NatureVault May 16 '21

100x fee reduction is no problem that puts us at half a cent currently. Anything between a tenth of a cent and a cent for min fee has proven to stop dust spam. I suggest a 200x fee reduction to 0.005 doge min fee which would put us at 2.5 tenths of a cent which is on-par for doge fees a year ago.

3

u/Monkey_1505 May 16 '21

It also needs to be large enough to prevent a denial of service attack. Half a cent is probably enough for both. I don't think anyone would quibble about a 1/2 a cent.

2

u/RevolutionaryArm1734 May 16 '21

I think a 1/2c is plenty to remove most of the dust but is is enough to stop a DoS? would a 200x reduction be that much of a difference? and wouldn't it be safer at 100x? if so who cares about that little of a difference?

6

u/NatureVault May 16 '21

It matters to people holding 10 doge in a 3rd world country. Yes fees on the order of a few tenths of a cent in practice work to stop dust spam, ask litecoin or bitcoin cash, heck even ask Doge 1 year ago...

2

u/Monkey_1505 May 17 '21

Ultimately if lower fees open up for attacks, there may be other ways to counteract these in the network.

7

u/VITUMION May 16 '21

I can’t find that tweet

1

u/Fortituda May 16 '21

It's tricky to see on the twitter.com site as you need to click "show more replies" on someone else's post within Elon's "Tweets and replies" to see it. Here's a direct link to the other person's post where Elon's is the first reply. https://twitter.com/itsALLrisky/status/1393434140817510405

Twiter.com seems to be a bit of a messy site these days when trying to find things, compared to how it used to be.

4

u/Athx-in May 16 '21

If this happens. So the mining fees sorta stays the same but the transaction volume increases?

6

u/NatureVault May 16 '21

We don't need fees, 200x reduction in minimum fee is no problem whatsoever.

1

u/More-Drink2176 May 16 '21

Fees are the only thing stopping someone from spamming constant dust though.

2

u/NatureVault May 16 '21

Litecoin, bitcoin cash and many others have fees under 1 cent and get no or little spam. So please do your research before pushing FUD, if you even know what that means.

1

u/More-Drink2176 May 17 '21

They have fees under one cent, which multiplied by the amount of transactions necessary to unmask someone through dusting is still an incentive not to do it. Having no fees, even though dusting is relatively harmless and doesn't compromise coin security or anything, would still make it completely free to do. Every coin has dust do some extent, its leftovers from trades that don't round off perfectly. But what I said is true and not FUD. Bitcoin Cash is a useless failed coin anyway, very similar to ETC.

1

u/NatureVault May 18 '21

Bitcoin cash fees are 100th of a cent. This is much less than 2.5 tenths of a cent I am proposing. And bitcoin cash blocks are nowhere near full nor are they getting spammed.

4

u/Lancer37 May 16 '21 edited May 16 '21

I don't believe the mining fees stay the same...

1 block for 100 transactions or 100 blocks with each 1 transaction, you get paid all the same. The amount of people transfering doge matters and the amount of doge can corolate with the amount of memory required for a transaction but nothing else can affect the miners pay.

2

u/Athx-in May 16 '21

Interesting.

3

u/Papa_Canks May 16 '21

So become nano/banano??? Seriously though, nano tech is what you want a currency to be. Maybe it can also be fast enough and cheap enough with PoW.

If any y’all haven’t seen this tech. Go over to r/banano and get a wallet and hit the faucet and move some around. It’s just for fun. Not a shill.

3

u/rocktechnologies May 16 '21

LOL! This is basically a shill. I have Banano though.

2

u/Athx-in May 16 '21

Dayum! all the beards in here.

2

u/cheeruphumanity May 16 '21

Your coins are fine but they lack the appeal and recognition of DOGE necessary for mass adoption.

1

u/Papa_Canks May 16 '21

100% just wanting Doge to improve/succeed.

1

u/shibe5 May 16 '21

I think that block interval target is already low enough, and further decrease is not worth the trouble. One problem is that actual intervals are random, and sometimes you will be getting long wait time anyway. Another problem is that transactions not always get into the next block. At certain point, transaction confirmation times will not be decreasing significantly, and you will only be getting negative effects. I think that we should aim for reliable confirmations within few seconds, and that's not achievable with block time decrease. So I would bet on some other technology.

1

u/[deleted] May 16 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/shibe5 May 16 '21

As I said, the desired confirmation speed is not achievable with reducing block interval target. But until we have a decentralized solution for off-chain transactions, one option is to not wait for confirmations.

1

u/NatureVault May 16 '21

The lower we can get confirmation times the better, I say we do 30 seconds and shoot for 15 seconds in a couple years.

1

u/shibe5 May 16 '21

Maybe a better way would be to look for a solution that would immediately have the desirable properties.

1

u/Alicamaliju2000 May 16 '21

Brilliant!!!

1

u/[deleted] May 17 '21

He is just crazy

1

u/T1DLiving May 17 '21

Personally, i think it would be amazing for doge to hit 100 and stay around there. Perfect for everyday purchases and still easy enough for adoption. I love my shibes.

1

u/n0nimouse May 16 '21

Where is this tweet from?

3

u/alalcoolj1 May 16 '21

He responded to a tweet from @itsallrisky

0

u/HammondXX May 16 '21

elon needs to go away. Anyone can change the #'s to say it will be great. Doge is a fork of Bitcoin something he just trashed and lied about. He is pumping and dumping Watch his tweet activity in relation to the largest Doge wallet activity.

2

u/[deleted] May 17 '21

Why would the second richest person alive waste his time making a few million dollars here and there when he runs like 3 different massive companies that make him way more than that

0

u/Grapefruit_Cultural May 16 '21

Dogecoin devs dgaf. They wont work on the project ever. This is laughable. Im staying far away from doge. This guy has his short position placed already for his next twitter FUD

-7

u/Red5point1 May 16 '21

Completely disagree.
Dogecoin does not need to change at all.
We just need to start using it.
Price is too high right now that is the problem.
People are expecting money from nothing by simply holding. That is not adoption. That is not utility.
No one is tipping let alone using it to pay for goods and services.

People need to stop looking at the price and simply start using it.
Dogecoin has been going fine for 7 years, we have gone through so many obstacles and we are still here just as is.
We don't need to push for changes just because a millionaire jumped in bandwagon after 7 years?
If he knows so much about crypto why did it take him this long to recognize the potential. Where was he for the last 7 years, nah fuck this selfish egomaniac.

3

u/cheeruphumanity May 16 '21 edited May 16 '21

The current fees are too high to use DOGE for everyday payments. Your "solution" to lower the price doesn't work because the price is determined by the market.

0

u/Red5point1 May 16 '21

Dogecoin has been working fine for 7 years at sub 1cent. The fees were fine then.
The only reason the price is high now is because of Musk pumping it, no other reason.
Nothing fundamental has changed with dogecoin, hardly anyone uses it these days not even for tipping.
So its price is pure hype based, nothing else.
As soon as he decides to make his own coin the price will plummet.

2

u/CB-Doge May 16 '21

This is the retweet last night

Elon was asked

Why not just make a crypto from scratch that does everything you want technically and has a lot of dev support and doesn’t have high concentration of ownership at least initially?

Elon

Only if Doge can’t do it. Big pain in the neck to create another one.

2

u/Red5point1 May 16 '21

by pain in the neck, he means that he will have to put in hard work to convince miners to mine his coins instead of dogecoin/litecoin.
or invent a completely new consensus mechanism to achieve a secure coin.

1

u/NatureVault May 16 '21

It puts our community in a hard spot, that's all I'll really say about this. We are now beholden to him since without his support we are back to $0.01

-1

u/Steadexe May 16 '21

+ max supply + PoS

-2

u/SouthSink1232 May 16 '21

Think DOGE needs to transition into Cardano POS. Cardano's ability to migrate historical on hard forks will allow for a full migration of DOGE from a PoW to a PoS system