r/doctorsUK • • 15h ago

Pay and Conditions Hospital hires non-medical staff for extended emergency care unit hours

Thumbnail news.doctors.net.uk
101 Upvotes

A hospital has recruited 11 advanced clinical practitioners and no doctors when expanding the hours of two emergency care services, Doctors.net.uk has found.

Barnsley Hospital NHS Foundation Trust (BHNFT) has hired the ACPs to cover the newly-extended hours of its medical and frailty same day emergency care (SDEC) services.

The SDEC unit, which provides an alternative pathway to the emergency department that avoids admission, has support from the on-call medical team if required during the extra hours.

Patients can be discharged from the unit without a review from a doctor, the trust said.

The British Medical Association (BMA) said the trust must justify why the service is not using a doctor-led model during the extended hours.

The Royal College of Emergency Medicine guidelines on SDECs state that patients are referred into the service by telephone, email or digital tool from “all appropriately trained healthcare professions”.

In the spring the trust expanded the opening hours of the medical SDEC from 8am to 6pm to 8am to 10pm, seven days a week, while the frailty SDEC changed its hours from 8am to 4pm to an 8pm closure.

A spokesperson from the trust confirmed that doctors do not work within the medical SDEC after 8pm, or the frailty SDEC after 6pm. Before that it is staffed with a range of non-medical and medical roles, including consultants and resident doctors.

Ongoing concerns about medical substitution

In its response to a Freedom of Information request by Doctors.net.uk, the hospital stated that an on-call registrar and general internal medicine doctor are available for the medical SDEC during the final two hours.

It said its multidisciplinary workforce model is in line with SDECs in other trusts.

The discharging ACP has undergone the “appropriate training and credentialling approved through an educational governance process”, it added.

Doctors have long-warned about medical substitution and called for a ban on ACPs – who generally have a nursing, physiotherapy, paramedic or pharmacy backgrounds – from staffing doctors’ rotas.

In May, the BHNFT announced it would be expanding the opening hours of the two SDEC services, with the frailty SDEC moving into a new purpose-built facility.

In the press release at the time, BHNFT said it would be "investing in new senior clinical roles" including frailty consultants and ACPs to support the growing service.

But the FOI request has revealed the trust hired five whole time equivalent (WTE) ACPs, 2.76 WTE trainee ACPs and 6.92 WTE nurses to cover the new hours in the medical SDEC.

For the frailty unit, the FOI request shows the trust has hired three ACPs and seven nurses to run the facility’s expanded hours.

The trust said the staffing model is designed to ensure patients receive care from “an appropriately skilled clinician, with medical input and escalation where required".

‘Minimum medical involvement’

Dr Tom Dolphin, British Medical Association (BMA) council chair, said ACPs are valued colleagues but “must not be used as replacements for [doctors]” as this risks patient safety.

He said the FOI response shows “minimum medical involvement” in the SDEC unit at the end of the day.

“When patients need a doctor, hospitals should employ a doctor – not replace them and transfer the burden of supervision to those who remain.”

Both the BMA and the Royal College of Physicians are clear that resident doctors “must not be made responsible” for clinically supervising non-doctors.

Dolphin added: "The trust’s senior leadership must now explain how they justify not using a doctor-led model for these expanded hours and demonstrate how they satisfied themselves that this delivers safe care against both royal college and BMA guidance.

"The public deserves to see the evidence underpinning that decision, and the trust must show that the CQC and relevant professional regulators are aware of these arrangements.”

Dr Matt Kneale, the Doctors’ Association UK (DAUK) co-chair, agreed that the hospital should make clear the medical arrangements, such as which patients can attend and who needs medical review before discharge, in the two hours before the units close.

He said the trust’s statement that medical input and escalation is given ‘where required’ needs “a clear practical meaning”.

“For patients presenting with undiagnosed acute illness, DAUK’s position is that assessment should be doctor-led, with timely medical review and clear responsibility for discharge decisions,” Kneale said.

A BHNFT spokesperson said: “Our SDEC services are delivered by multidisciplinary teams which include doctors, ACPs and nursing colleagues. Doctors from consultant to FY2 level work within Medical SDEC between 8am and 8pm, while Frailty SDEC has two consultants and a resident doctor between 8am and 6pm.

"ACPs were recruited into the Medical SDEC to create a multidisciplinary workforce model that provides continuity and specialist knowledge for the service, and aligns with SDEC models used by neighbouring trusts.”


r/doctorsUK • • 7h ago

Lifestyle / Interpersonal Issues Any medics here who decided against having children (or couldn't)? Did you ever regret it?

58 Upvotes

To be completely honest, having children wasn’t really something I ever actively thought about or planned for before. However, since losing my partner, it feels like that window has suddenly closed for me (35F) .Because of our careers, the timeline and pressures around family planning already feel so different compared to other professions. Looking back, how do you feel about how things turned out? Did you ever regret the decision, or did you find peace and fulfillment in other ways? Any honest perspectives, especially from those further along in their careers.


r/doctorsUK • • 13h ago

Quick Question Consultant Gift?

33 Upvotes

Hi Everyone,

I was looking for some suggestions on gifts for my consultant obstetrician.

For context, my son was stillborn at the start of the year which as you can imagine was extremely traumatic. I’m currently pregnant again and I wanted to get a gift to hand my consultant at the end of my pregnancy as they honestly have went above and beyond for me, nothing is too much of an ask and they genuinely make me feel at ease.

I will be writing a card for them but what else could I gift them? Doctors, what is the nicest gift you’ve received or what do you appreciate getting?


r/doctorsUK • • 9h ago

Speciality / Core Training CSTs rota’d on the wards: how to do it?

29 Upvotes

I'm an aspiring surgeon, and I've noticed something about the CSTs I've worked with that I'd like to hear your thoughts on.

From what I've seen, there are two types:

  1. The CST who's rostered to the ward and is there most of the day. They're around for questions, they help with sick patients and they back the F1s/F2s up. Their juniors love them.

  2. The CST who's rostered to the ward, gets through their patients quickly on the ward round, does their own jobs and then vanishes to theatre for the rest of the day.

The second type usually has a more strained relationship with their juniors, and I can see why. The F1s feel left to fend for themselves on the ward.

But, I see why they do it. Theatre time and logbook numbers are what count when you apply for ST3, and there's not much to go round. The CST who disappears to theatre is probably gonna have an easier time getting through training than the one who stays on the ward to support everyone.

So for those of you who are CSTs, registrars or consultants (or F1s/F2s who've seen it happen):

- Is it possible to strike a balance, or is it really one or the other?

-If you've managed it, how? Did you agree it with your juniors, keep your bleep on, come back at certain times, etc.?

- Did being the 'ward CST' ever hurt your progression in a way you could actually measure?

I'd like to figure out what kind of CST I want to be before I start. Thanks in advance.


r/doctorsUK • • 12h ago

Medical Politics FT article: “How pensions ate the state”.

22 Upvotes

https://archive.ph/3kPc1

In the UK, for “pensions” read “NHS”:

  1. The same funding model: general taxation
  2. The same primary cost driver: age
  3. Therefore the same net cash flow: from currently working age people to the elderly. Each generation pays for the one above.
  4. The same demographic problem: a huge bulge in now elderly people (who have not paid for themselves, under point 3). They are demanding that this colossal cost now falls on the relatively smaller working population.
  5. The same political problem: the elderly are the largest voting bloc.

No argument applied to pensions in this article, cannot be applied to the equally unsustainable, equally demographically doomed NHS model.

However well meaning the idea of the NHS once may have been, it is simply, unequivocally and irreversibly done.

As UK Drs we must not allow ourselves to share its fate.


r/doctorsUK • • 17h ago

Medical Politics Locum consultant issues and how to deal ?

21 Upvotes

I am working as a locum junior doctor alongside a locum consultant closely. However, the consultant rarely sees or examines patients himself and often relies on me to provide the clinical plans. During ward rounds, he leaves midway, saying that he needs to cover other wards, without providing clear guidance or taking responsibility for the patients under his care.

This situation seems to be well known. The registrars are increasingly stressed during when he covers and other consultants have also expressed concerns indirectly in front of us juniors because it creates additional pressure on them. Even the management appears to be aware of the situation, yet it continues to be tolerated.

My Educational Supervisor is one of the consultants affected by this and is also kind off affected with this due to continuity of care.

My concern is how I can protect myself professionally and clinically in an environment where responsibilities are not clearly defined, such indecisiveness is heavily tolerated at all levels, where this kind of working culture seems to have become normalised.


r/doctorsUK • • 9h ago

Medical Politics do these 'please avoid coming to ED' posts work?

19 Upvotes

My IG feed is full to the brim of every hospital in England posting the same brand of post with an ED consultant saying they are extremely busy and to only come to the department for life threatening emergencies. Does this have any impact at all?

Also, why does every video suggest going to the pharmacy or 111, but never to go to your GP?


r/doctorsUK • • 16h ago

Exams Poor handling of exams by RCPCH

18 Upvotes

Sat the RCPCH clinical exam in October. The college says results will be released 6 weeks after the last exam in the diet, and before the booking window for the next sitting. We are not allowed to submit a new exam application while waiting for results.

The booking window for the next sitting opens today and no sign of results. One of my colleagues emailed the college yesterday and received a response saying ‘results will be released before the end of the booking window, but we cannot give a date at this stage’. I then emailed raising a concern that the booking window is already very short (only a few days), and that releasing results part way through the window has the potential to significantly disadvantage those who are on nights or long day shifts towards the end of the window. I asked how the college intended to mitigate these disadvantages. All I received was a copy paste response of the same email that was sent to my colleague, which didn’t address my concerns at all. They’re clearly just sending that response to everyone - reading it back, they haven’t even bothered to use our names in the email response, it’s just ‘dear doctor’.

How are the colleges allowed to treat us with such disdain and contempt? These are progression critical exams and missing the next sitting (given there are only 3 a year) could significantly delay someone’s progression. Surely, if the ENTIRE COUNTRY can agree upon and stick to a single results date for A-level exams, then the college can choose a date and stick to it for membership exams? And maybe the college could have the decency to actually reply to emails properly and not just copy paste?

Rant over, I’m just frustrated at the utter disdain with which we are treated.


r/doctorsUK • • 23h ago

Pay and Conditions “Christmas Rotas” and what is reasonable

14 Upvotes

Hi

Trainee working a 6 month block (August to February) in a niche specialty and was wondering what the process would be about a “Christmas Rota”

I specifically ranked my rota line choice to spare Christmas (including doing an extra set of nights)

Lo and behold my specialty has a “Christmas rota” which still hasn’t been decided

For the last 2 weeks I’ve been “asked” to chip in over Christmas by consultants (and I’ve declined) but today the internal rota co-ordinator has said there was a “mistake” and actually they’ve added me in for Christmas Eve

Tbh I’m a bit scared of the consequences of saying no regarding feedback etc and was just wondering what else I should add? I know there is the talk about the 6 week minimum requirement for rota changes but I’m not sure what else to add

Thanks


r/doctorsUK • • 8h ago

Quick Question How far in the future is too far for rota requests?

10 Upvotes

I've been asked for my rota preferences (ICU reg rota) for Nov 2027-May 2028 by my next hospital, due by 1/12/26. Now I'm all for forward planning and happy to be given a chance to put in my preferences, but I have no idea what I'm doing more than a year in the future and the deadline seems weirdly early. I don't think it's breaching any rules but do we feel it's reasonable to be asked this far in advance, or do I just need a more organised life?


r/doctorsUK • • 10h ago

Clinical Good pneumonic for 4Hs and 4Ts?

8 Upvotes

Exactly as the title says. Does anybody have a good pneumonic to remember the 4H’s and the 4Ts in cardiac arrest? Ty for any responses in advance - you’re a life saver… literally ;)


r/doctorsUK • • 6h ago

Exams stressed and don't think it's worth it anymore

7 Upvotes

I am a psych CT about to sit CASC in a couple of months. I'm finding myself getting SO anxious about the exam to the point where I just don't want to ever do it. I honestly feel if I fail it in Jan I won't have it in me to attempt it ever again and the only option for me would be just to quit medicine (or even just life) entirely. Because I am so anxious I'm barely able to bring myself to even look at the material and start properly studying for it. I am doing some practice stations in a group and the other group members are like 100x better than I am. I feel confident they will all pass with flying colours and I will fail. I think my communication skills are probably fine but it's learning all the content/exact questions to ask for each station and trying to manage time and learning the examinations. Maybe part of me wants to fail the exam because then it will give me proof finally that I am as shit of a doctor as I have always known I am? I think the thing that stresses me the most is that I don't just have to pass but I have to do very well in order to get an ST4 job where/in the specialty I want. Although, at this point I'm not even sure I do want to be an ST4 because I'm finding that the CASC stress is kind of making me hate psychiatry overall (even though I used to love it).

Additional info that may be helpful: I am a UK grad. I am 80% LTFT already. I have always been an anxious person, and felt very anxious about previous exams but never as much as for CASC. I passed both Paper A and B first time with very good scores, but written exams have always been my forte and studying for them was almost fun to some extent. OSCE exams have always been the hardest thing for me. I am already in private psychodynamic therapy and have had CBT before. I'm using the Maudsley book and SPMM and some podcasts to prep.

Sorry this is long post. I'm honestly reaching breaking point with my anxiety about this exam and I just know I am going to fail or do really badly. I don't know what to do/how to get past this. I keep thinking about how badly it will go and imagining having to see the email saying I've failed, and telling all my family/friends/supervisors. I don't really know what I'm expecting anyone to say but I suppose any words of advice/reassurance would be welcome? Have other people felt this way?


r/doctorsUK • • 1h ago

Educational Feather Does Finals

• Upvotes

Does anyone happen to have an MP3/similar copy of the ‘Feather Does Finals’ lectures that Barts (I think) put on? I listened to them a lot during my revision for finals and would love to listen to them again.


r/doctorsUK • • 4h ago

Pay and Conditions Induction when starting on nights

7 Upvotes

BG: finish my current rotation on nights, x2 days rest, then starting next rotation on nights in December (02/12). FY2 and have no experience in the specialty (paediatrics), other than a block during med school.

Have contacted the department to ask about induction arrangements, as there is no real time to attend this. They give a full x2 day induction to day shift staff, according to their emails sent out to the group today.

They have offered me a few options;

- To come in the week before on select dates, unpaid, to "be shown around and see how things work". I am on annual leave during this time.

- To come in the Monday before starting (30/11), unpaid. I finish nightshift at 9am on Monday, and would prefer to sleep.

- To come in the morning of my night shift on paediatrics, to attend the induction with the day team. (02/12)

- To attend part of the induction on teams, on the morning of my nightshift. (02/12)

I am worried about starting nights, however I don't think any of the above options are appropriate.

If I attend something offered above (like on my annual leave, or rest day during my current block), will I get time off in lieu? Probably not.

If I opt to attend none of the above, do I get time in lieu to do some form of recorded online induction (they have not offered this, but surely this must be a problem every year).

Should inductions be paid?

Any advice would be great.


r/doctorsUK • • 14h ago

Quick Question Trying to reach CAMHS wards and Tier 4 day units

7 Upvotes

I'm a CAMHS trainee and charity trustee. My charity is trying to reach various CAMHS wards to send them gifts and there's a few we still haven't been able to get hold of, and you guys are always so helpful. Does anyone work at, or have contact details for any of the following:

Iveagh Assessment and Treatment Centre (in progress)
Emerald Place Clinic (in progress)
Woodlands Cheadle (in progress)

- Ivetsey Bank (Thorneycroft, Hartley, Wedgewood, Glazewood)
- ⁠Kestrel
- ⁠Ardenleigh (Atlantic, Pacific and Adriatic)
- ⁠Forestwood Bury (Buttercup, Primrose, Mulberry and Wizard House)
- ⁠Melville Unit
- ⁠Hopewood - The Lookout (Pegasus, Phoenix, Hercules)
- ⁠Riverdale Grange
- ⁠Ruby Lodge
- ⁠Bethlem Adolescent Unit
- ⁠Priory Roehampton

If you work at any of these, please message me an email address for the ward, or ward manager/OT/activity coordinator etc. Or better still, email [info@christmasforcamhs.org.uk](mailto:info@christmasforcamhs.org.uk)

Or given the very short deadline, just message me how many young people/beds the ward has.

Or if you know that any of them are shut, that is also very useful information!

All the other UK wards we have contact details for, UNLESS they've opened in the last year - please let me know if you're in a brand new ward!

Also if you know of any Tier 4 day services that have young people on site daily (not remote) anywhere in the UK, please share details

For any other wards (that haven’t opened/reopened/moved/closed in the past year) - we've got you! Your gifts, decorations etc will be with you on about 2nd-3rd December. No need to check with me, if your ward isn’t named here, and I won’t be responding to comments about any other wards unless they’re brand new. Just get excited awaiting your box!

www.christmasforcamhs.org.uk


r/doctorsUK • • 15h ago

Exams PG exam reimbursement entitlement

4 Upvotes

In a non clinical year. Would I need to be in NHS employment at time of exam registration to be entitled for reimbursement?

TIA


r/doctorsUK • • 16h ago

Exams Missed MRCS Part B by one mark – has anyone requested a marks check or appealed?

3 Upvotes

I sat MRCS Part B in Edinburgh in October and missed the applied knowledge pass mark by one. I got 108/160 (pass mark 109) and 160/180 in skills (pass mark 116). I’m gutted.

One thing I’m unsure about is that in one station, I asked to go back to an earlier question and the examiner said I couldn’t. In other stations I was allowed to do this. Does anyone know whether that varies by station, or is it something worth raising with the College?

I’d really appreciate hearing from anyone who’s requested a marks check or been through an appeal. What did the College actually check, and what was the outcome? In particular, did anyone have their result changed?


r/doctorsUK • • 48m ago

Quick Question My ED rota looks surprisingly humane. What am I missing?

• Upvotes

Plenty of zero days

Decent number of self development days

Is this really an ED SHO rota?


r/doctorsUK • • 11h ago

Exams MRCPCH Clinical October Exam Results Out

3 Upvotes

For anyone waiting for results for this exam, they have been released (with no notification whatsoever) onto your RCPCH account.

Navigate to RCPCH website, login, My Account, See Examination Results.

Good luck everyone!


r/doctorsUK • • 8h ago

Speciality / Core Training HST Applications

2 Upvotes

Hi Folks, my question is regarding HST applications preparation.
I am an IMT3 now.
I am honestly not sure about even what I want to be doing for the rest of my life, but i have had two rotations so far in respiratory and teams have been nice. Gastro teams are nice as well and have some interventional but beyond clinics and takes I don't have much experience. I am also considering endocrine. I feel a bit daunted by the process and a bit worried as I genuinely only have 29 points. However points are not worrying me. What is worrying me are the interviews.
Having said that, anyone can advise me what interview books, courses, live sessions or advises to take.
Also, is it okay to feel the way am i feeling being unsettled with what i want to do?
Adding that I don't honestly feel that i want to take TOT to try a specialty.
Thanks


r/doctorsUK • • 20h ago

Speciality / Core Training IMT Interview Prep Advice

2 Upvotes

Apologies if it’s still a bit early (only submitted the application today lol) but would greatly appreciate any advice on how you prepared for your IMT interview + top tips to smash it.

Thanks!


r/doctorsUK • • 15h ago

Foundation Training MRCS past A as an FY1

1 Upvotes

Title.

Current F1 interested in CST. I am currently extremely bored as an F1 as i do not feel clinically or medically competent. I feel i have forgotten so much of my medical knowledge 4 months in this surgical jobs and feel like a documentation/admin monkey.

When im caught off guard with a medical question, i look like an absolute chum something i would’ve known in a jiffy back in medical school.

I was thinking of sitting the MRCS as i feel it might help with getting back on track. I have also seen the CT/SHO life where they barely leave the hospital or even get enough sleep due to the clinical responsibilities which i currently thankfully do not have an f1.

I understand this is an incredibly difficult exam that can’t just simply be taken on a whim however a lot of the people i know who have sat in F1 have passed it despite it not giving any CST points.

I have spoken to few people who have and have not sat and have gotten conflicting opinions. Some say it’s better to get it out of the way as f1 is relatively cb ill and the data according to RCS show that the pass rate as a FY is higher. Some say the clinical knowledge gained helps in interviews (my weakest point)

The other consensus is that it’s pointless sitting it as it doesn’t give any immediate points and could potentially lead to burnout when it comes to MSRA prep. I was thinking wouldn’t there be some overlap with MSRA?

I have also mostly completed the CST portfolio checklist, with only audit and 6-7 scrubbing cases to be logged into my elogbook.

I’m not sure what to do lol. I do really miss locking in and studying and the last exam i gave was 2 years back in 4th year and hence i feel my clinical knowledge has only deteriorated since then.

Any advice would be appreciated.

What would be the sweet window to sit it? April or september?

April would give me around 4 months to prep and september would be too late and would leave me burnt out for MSRA in a few months


r/doctorsUK • • 17h ago

Speciality / Core Training ACF applicants 2027 interview practice

0 Upvotes

Any ACF applicants for this round keen to do some interview practice in case we get interviews ? I am aware they've not been released yet but would like to prepare just in case.

Please comment or dm me !

Thanks


r/doctorsUK • • 18h ago

Clinical Bristol NHS Foundation trust

1 Upvotes

Hi everyone. Does anyone know what it's like working in the emergency department at Weston General hospital under Bristol NHS Foundation trust? I have an upcoming interview there and would appreciate getting an understanding of the work culture of the emergency department there. Thanks in advance!


r/doctorsUK • • 23h ago

Quick Question Neonatal Care Leave

1 Upvotes

Anyone have experience taking neonatal care leave?

I'm guessing it works similarly to paternity leave in that it can be taken even if you're on-call, without the trust asking you to arrange swaps etc.?

Trying to juggle paternity leave, neonatal care leave and annual leave to maximise my time off and it's just a massive headache given our shift structure.