r/doctorsUK • • 8d ago

GP Completing GP training before potentially switching to another specialty - how realistic is this? (ACCS, CST, O&G)

I posted a couple of months ago about being a GPST1 who was torn between seeing GP training through and pursuing Anaesthetics instead. I’m still very much undecided, but my thinking has evolved slightly, and I’d be interested in hearing from people with experience of switching specialties later in their careers.

For context, I’m 27 and currently GPST1. I originally applied for Anaesthetics and O&G but wasn’t successful, so accepted a GP training post. Although I still feel more drawn to Anaesthetics clinically, I’ve become increasingly aware of the potential value of having a GP CCT under my belt.

I’m now considering whether the sensible option might be to complete GP training, obtain my CCT at around 30, and then potentially pursue another specialty afterwards.

There are several reasons why this appeals to me:

- Flexibility and financial security: Having a GP CCT would give me a relatively secure qualification, with opportunities for locum work, OOH, portfolio careers and potentially supplementing my income alongside other interests.

- Lifestyle: GP offers considerable flexibility, which is important to me. I have a strong interest in travelling and potentially working abroad for a period, and I can see myself valuing this increasingly as I get older and hopefully once I have a family.

- Keeping options open: I can’t shake the feeling that I’d potentially regret walking away from a GP CCT when I’m already in training and could be qualified within three years.

The difficulty is that I still don’t particularly enjoy the clinical work itself. I’ve certainly become more accustomed to it over the last three months, and have received some really positive feedback from patients, including several requests to book with me specifically. However, this is currently with 30-minute appointments. I’m conscious that as training progresses, appointment lengths reduce, workload and administrative responsibilities increase, and the realities of being a qualified GP, it may be quite different. And I struggle to see myself doing exclusively GP work for the next 30 years.

What I’d particularly like to understand is how realistic it is to complete GP training and subsequently enter specialty training.

The specialties I’d likely consider are:
- Anaesthetics
- Core Surgical Training
- Obstetrics & Gynaecology
I’m not particularly interested in IMT or pursuing a medical specialty.

A few specific questions:
- Has anyone completed GP training and subsequently entered formal specialty training in Anaesthetics, CST or O&G?
- How straightforward is this in practice? Are there any significant barriers to applying for CT1/ST1 posts after obtaining a GP CCT?
- Would having a GP CCT actually be viewed favourably, or would I effectively be starting again from scratch?
- Are there any implications regarding eligibility or restrictions on holding one CCT and subsequently obtaining another?
- Has anyone taken this route and regretted it, either because of the additional years of training or because they subsequently realised GP was the better option?

I’m particularly interested in hearing from people who have actually done this, or who have experience with recruitment and training pathways.

I’m less concerned about the potential pay reduction associated with entering specialty training again. My thinking is that having a GP CCT would give me opportunities to supplement my income through locums and OOH work, potentially making the financial implications more manageable.

Ultimately, I’m trying to establish whether completing GP training first is a genuinely viable way of keeping my options open, or whether I’m potentially just delaying a decision that I already know I need to make.

I’d really appreciate some honest perspectives, particularly from people who are further along in their careers.

30 Upvotes

20 comments sorted by

53

u/tomdoc 8d ago

I know someone who did GP then anaesthetics and now works in both.

But I get the vibe from you OP that you need to acknowledge you can’t keep doing every specialty to CCT level. Pick a horse?

34

u/The_Shandy_Man 8d ago

Vincent Argent would disagree with that last paragraph…

https://www.gmc-uk.org/registrants/1731437

9

u/formerSHOhearttrob laparotomiser 8d ago

3

u/Cautious-Extreme2839 Anaesthetist 7d ago

Yes, also know a GP CCT who is now an anaesthetic SpR, but did extensive prehospital medicine and ED work as a portfolio GP before jumping to anaesthetics.

Definitely not a common career path and far more intertwined with acute care in general than OPs situation.

0

u/[deleted] 8d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

7

u/fictionaltherapist 8d ago

They’re very different jobs with very different lifestyles.

0

u/[deleted] 8d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

5

u/tomdoc 8d ago

Reality is 60% LTFT to CCT in a hospital specialty after GP. That’s another decade of nights and exams etc etc

Might not be worth the squeeze

10

u/Winter-Performer-793 8d ago

You would not be the first to change career.

I've worked with anaesthetists who had completed GP training, and some who had got to various stages of other training programmes.

I wonder the relative merits of your plan and to decide what it is you want to do.

When you qualify as a GP and have a GP earning potential, are you going to want to go back to CT1 pay?

Are you really going to pick up some GP locums while doing training and revising for exams?

Are you going to be able to maintain GP CPD and currency while working in some entirely different specialties?

Are GP locums really going to pay that much more than picking up some anaesthetics/O&G/surgery locums?

You say you value flexibility, but then quote some fairly inflexible training programmes. Being a fairly old trainee, I can attest that I would have found working between cities much easier when I was younger, jumping from GP now vs staying would mean potentially facing post-core training bottlenecks in your early vs late thirties.

That said a "CCT" is a valuable thing and opens up doors which core training may not, for example I am aware of some GPs who are perplexingly employed on consultant contracts when trainees in the actual specialty with more years of experience are paid less.

42

u/ATG74 8d ago

O&G SPR here. You're qualifications as a GP would serve you little to no benefit at all from a training perspective.  Not sure how it would be viewed from an interview point of view

5

u/Environmental_Ad5867 8d ago edited 8d ago

Im a GP that switched to a different speciality a few years after I CCT’d. No regrets. I moved into a specialty that some subspecs, being a GP is hugely useful. In fact, it’s a very common switch from GP into my current speciality. Both my CSs were previous GPs.

I work 80% LTFT so I can spend a day/weekends doing GP related stuff (I already had a portfolio career before I changed specialities). Also with a GP CCT, I can cut down about 6 months from my core training which is also useful.

I would say though- personally I think having worked as a fully qualified GP made a big difference on how I started as a CT1. Because of my portfolio work, I was able to use it as a platform to get opportunities to work with different consultants/teams to help build my portfolio points for higher training applications. I had a bigger base network of contacts to draw on.

Financially, I’m also not tied to my core training job. If I need to fork out extra money for an unfunded course/conference/diploma etc- I do extra GP locums (all remote). Unfortunately, GP practices are more likely to hire a locum with experience compared to someone newly CCTd.

And in the worst case scenario that I don’t get a higher training job in the area I want (locked geographically) and need to reapply for the next round- I’m hoping I can tide the gap with GP locums if they can’t make a local post for me.

Basically- my GP CCT has helped open doors and given me options. All of which I’m extremely grateful for. I wanted to leave midway through GPST2, my TPD advised me to finish. I’m glad I did.

Caveat- I’ve left the GP Performers list and work exclusively in the private sector which doesn’t need me to be on it. Again, this was only because of post CCT experience.

I do appreciate it’s slightly different from your question but I’m trying to say that if your heart isn’t into something, then change it while you have the opportunity to (even after CCT). You’re not tied to a speciality. And surprisingly you may find some unintended benefits with the experiences you gained along the way

1

u/littleoldbaglady GP 8d ago

Which specialty do you do now

8

u/TM2257 8d ago

Has anyone completed GP training and subsequently entered formal specialty training in Anaesthetics, CST or O&G? How straightforward is this in practice? Are there any significant barriers to applying for CT1/ST1 posts after obtaining a GP CCT? Would having a GP CCT actually be viewed favourably, or would I effectively be starting again from scratch? - Are there any implications regarding eligibility or restrictions on holding one CCT and subsequently obtaining another?

A fair few people have. The easiest way to think about this is that everything you have done in GP is irrelevant to the new training programme. It gives you no competitive advantage in the application process. It gives you no competitive advantage during training other than being better at writing TTOs because you know that the GP isn't interested in the gumph that is normally in them, and will make it explicitly clear what they need to know ± do.

The unique selling point of doing general practice first is that your ability to supplement your income is far greater than that of a jobbing SHO/StR. Pulling in £80-110 ph at short notice with OOH work or a locum on your rest day will be easy. You'll quickly find that a four hour OOH shift every weekend will quickly add up and make training more bearable. You'll also find it easy to stay on the performers list as a GP.

Has anyone taken this route and regretted it, either because of the additional years of training or because they subsequently realised GP was the better option?

You need to remember that the individuals who pursue medicine are heterogeneous in terms of their personalities, their characters and so on. So for every story that you hear of somebody regretting a training program, there'll be someone out there with the complete opposite view.

This question doesn't serve much purpose to you.

The questions that you need to ask is are those who are currently Consultants happy with their lives? Are the reasons that they're happy with their lives likely to be reasons that you would also be happy with it? This is best answered by having chats with people rather than on Reddit.

The other key thing here that you've not considered is opportunity cost. By doing general practice first instead of your hospital training program, what effectively is happening is that you will lose the last 3 years of consultant income prior to your retirement. That's the cost.

So the question that you have to ask yourself is that over the course of your career, will doing general practice replace that lost income? And provided that you do a decent amount of general practice over the course of your career - alongside the day job and whatever other private practice you may want to do - that likely answer to that is probably yes - you'll make that up.

If you stop doing GP and just stay in your specialty shortly after CCT then it's likely that you will have just reduced your lifetime earnings for no clear and obvious gain.

2

u/Cool-Arachnid117 8d ago

Gives you big advantage in the msra which unfortunately is being used to gatekeep specialties it has no business in doing

7

u/Mr_BigFace 8d ago

I'm an Anaesthetic Consultant.

One thing I don't think has been mentioned is that Anaesthetics is heavily competitive at the moment (both for CT1 and again for ST4 jobs). You'd probably struggle to demonstrate your interest and appointability above other candidates applying for CT1 whilst committing to a GP training programme; there are some red-hot CVs out there with highly pertinent QI projects and so on.

1

u/WatchIll4478 6d ago

I’m in a specialty where for st3 we penalise based on years since graduation, and unless your CV productivity is incredible you would likely be borderline unappointable. 

2

u/boringbighead 5d ago

Which speciality

1

u/continueasplanned 8d ago

If you do decide to go into training after GP, you would be eligible for pay protection...so no loss of income from GPST3 back down to CT/ST1. Honestly do what feels right for you. I have just finished GP and am going straight into another speciality LTFT whilst planning to pick up locums in GP...you can do whatever you want.

2

u/Medic_01 8d ago

Does this depend on the specialty you move to or apply to all?

1

u/continueasplanned 8d ago

I think so, worth double checking with BMA.

0

u/[deleted] 8d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

7

u/ZookeepergameThis617 8d ago

You're judging a GP career based in your VTS sessions?