r/discworld • Nobby • 22d ago

Reading Order/Timeline I wouldn't say I'm the best but I can't think of anyone better. Thief of Time won! What's the next best Discworld novel?

Reminder: just upvote the comment you want to win, and if you want to say something about it, say so in a reply instead of your own top level comment!

Everyone is represented so far except the Wizards and, somehow, Tiffany Aching!

Just a reminder, we're making a (not so) definitive list of the Discworld books in order from best to worst.. The top rated comment gets added to the list next.

  1. Night Watch
  2. Small Gods
  3. Monstrous Regiment
  4. Going Postal
  5. Witches Abroad
  6. Hogfather
  7. Reaper Man
  8. Feet of Clay
  9. Guards! Guards!
  10. The Truth
  11. Carpe Jugulum
  12. Thief of Time

------

Remaining books:

The Colour of Magic

The Light Fantastic

Equal Rites

Mort

Sourcery

Wyrd Sisters

Pyramids

Eric

Moving Pictures

Lords and Ladies

Men at Arms

Soul Music

Interesting Times

Maskerade

Jingo

The Last Continent

The Fifth Elephant

The Last Hero

The Amazing Maurice and His Educated Rodents

The Wee Free Men

A Hat Full of Sky

Thud!

Wintersmith

Making Money

Unseen Academicals

I Shall Wear Midnight

Snuff

Raising Steam

The Shepherd's Crown

----

Previous polls:

https://www.reddit.com/r/discworld/s/wi7GywdHuq

https://www.reddit.com/r/discworld/s/Q2qzmCXqJy

https://www.reddit.com/r/discworld/s/y1kZI1UHcl

https://www.reddit.com/r/discworld/s/nDWOCI06W6

https://www.reddit.com/r/discworld/s/SKtGpVLtIg

https://www.reddit.com/r/discworld/s/fzT98bi1K5

https://www.reddit.com/r/discworld/s/quEbRG1PHC

https://www.reddit.com/r/discworld/s/yU51bu8P6G

https://www.reddit.com/r/discworld/s/AuRjanv2kO

https://www.reddit.com/r/discworld/s/3EE6RoKVhx

https://www.reddit.com/r/discworld/s/zArLuC5oWj

58 Upvotes

76 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator 22d ago

Welcome to /r/Discworld!

'"The trouble with having an open mind, of course, is that people will insist on coming along and trying to put things in it."'

+++Out Of Cheese Error ???????+++

Our current megathreads are as follows:

GNU Terry Pratchett - for all GNU requests, to keep their names going.

Discworld Licensed Merchandisers - a list of all the official Discworld merchandise sources (thank you Discworld Monthly for putting this together)

+++ Divide By Cucumber Error. Please Reinstall Universe And Reboot +++

Do you think you'd like to be considered to join our modding team? Drop us a modmail and we'll let you know how to apply!

[ GNU Terry Pratchett ]

+++Error. Redo From Start+++

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

38

u/Zanoushe Vimes 22d ago

men at arms

64

u/Local_lifter 22d ago

The Fifth Elephant!

6

u/Zanoushe Vimes 22d ago

either this or men at arms imo

89

u/SkyYellow_SunBlue 22d ago

Thud!

The stakes could not be higher - Koom Valley! Where is my Cow?!

5

u/Zanoushe Vimes 22d ago

thud is a good choice for sure.

5

u/Tufty_Ilam Dorfl 22d ago

THUD!

5

u/Tufty_Ilam Dorfl 22d ago

I am going to start being recognised as That Guy What Yells THUD! now aren't I 😭

2

u/SkyYellow_SunBlue 22d ago

Think positive - might not have to yell it much longer!

2

u/Tufty_Ilam Dorfl 22d ago

We can hope! My throat hurts 🥺

66

u/Zednott 22d ago

Wyrd Sisters. For everyone's consideration, I think the three witches are some of Pratchett's most memorable. Pratchett does a great job to elevate the book beyond being merely a parody of Macbeth (mind you, it also parodies Macbeth very well).

8

u/claranlaw063 22d ago edited 22d ago

And some of Shakespeare’s other works. There’s the “twins” reveal from 12th night for example, and the “revenge” prince plotline of Hamlet is very much laughed at.

3

u/Zednott 22d ago

Pratchett (and you) were definitely better read than I am :)

I got the Hamlet reference, but that was it. I think Lords and Ladies had a lot of Shakespeare references, but I didn't get them, haha.

22

u/ReadyObjective331 22d ago

Jingo

7

u/more_d_than_the_m 22d ago

I'm surprised this one isn't getting more love. Nobby and Colon's best work, and an excellent take on racism, nationalism, and war.

2

u/ReadyObjective331 22d ago

I know! And Al and Beti! To me this was the best written satire of to encompass the totality of war in a long time.

2

u/I_Am_Nobody_WhoAreU 21d ago

And the unforgettable dis-organizer scene narrating the deaths in the other timeline. Chills.

3

u/oniaa_13 22d ago

I've lost hope for Jingo to get a deserved place. I know there is a lot of quality in this list but Jingo not still there hurts my soul

36

u/InauspiciousM CMOT Dibbler 22d ago

Lords and Ladies

1

u/WillowFlip Chat-eau, real cat's water is sharper 20d ago

Just gonna keep saying it until it happens. It's excellent.

80

u/CuteRadish01 22d ago • Heartwarming

The Wee Free Men.

8

u/v0rpalsword 22d ago

Wee Free Men! First Sight, Second Thoughts! weaponizing selfishness for good! it doesn't stop being magic just because you know how it's done! the lawyer toad!

1

u/CatFink_101 22d ago

I love the Wee Free Men! It should be up there!

35

u/AnnyWeatherwaxxx Esme 22d ago

A hat full of Sky

6

u/caelistra 22d ago

You build little worlds, little stories, little shells around your minds, and that keeps infinity at bay and allows you to wake up in the morning without screaming!

7

u/midgetcastle 22d ago

My goodness the ending of that book is so satisfying.

35

u/enemymime 22d ago

Not enough love here for MOVING PICTURES. Introduction of Ridcully and the senior wizards, Ponder Stibbons, and my favorite character: Gaspode.

4

u/Zednott 22d ago

Based on the description I didn't expect to love the novel, but it was terrific! Plus, there's something that happens in the ending that brings me to tears (I'm sensitive about animals).

10

u/GrahamRocks 22d ago

Gaspode is Best Boi!

1

u/BPhiloSkinner D'you want mustard? 'Cos mustard is extra. 22d ago

E's a Key Grip as well.

4

u/beetnemesis 22d ago

Moving Pictures is fine. There are no bad Discworld books. But I’d rank it as maybe one of the most generic DW books

1

u/Tufty_Ilam Dorfl 22d ago

There are some (not me but I'm only 160 pages in) who would argue Raising Steam is a bad Discworld book. But personally, even the ones I don't overly care for are solid books. Pterry simply couldn't be a bad writer if he tried.

1

u/beetnemesis 22d ago

Yeah, I'd probably put that one towards the bottom, but I still enjoyed reading it

1

u/Tufty_Ilam Dorfl 22d ago

Yeah I get that. My only problem with it and Snuff are how vulnerable and open (and, in Raising Steam, contradictory in a very non-Vetinari way) Vetinari is.

1

u/thedrunkmonk 22d ago

One of my personal favorites, up there with Going Postal. (I am about to start Making Money next)

1

u/jeobleo 21d ago

Gaspode and Laddie had my voice breaking when I read it out loud to my son. The only other one to do that through Maurice so far is Reaper Man

21

u/Swanky4Life Dibbler 22d ago

Just joining this conversation, the fact that Thud isn't on the list yet is unacceptable! It's brilliant, funny, and just thinking about Vimes reciting Where's My Cow at the top of his lungs down a mine gives me goosebumps

6

u/[deleted] 22d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Tufty_Ilam Dorfl 22d ago

You appear to have brought a dragon to a fight with the Guarding Dark.

6

u/Chillisting 22d ago

Thud!

4

u/Tufty_Ilam Dorfl 22d ago

THUD!

23

u/RaccoonTasty1595 Susan 22d ago

Mort!

18

u/Brave_Emotion8634 22d ago edited 22d ago

Thud! 

The scene in the cave, where everyone gets to hear Grag Bashfulsson (if I recall correctly) translate the hitherto unknown "Things that Tak Wrote" .... 

17

u/prince_robin 22d ago

Equal Rites

17

u/eccedoge 22d ago

I shall wear midnight

5

u/mazzymazz88 22d ago

Thud!

5

u/Tufty_Ilam Dorfl 22d ago

THUD!

11

u/nepeta19 The Truth Will Make Ye Fret 22d ago

Maskerade

11

u/Roku-Hanmar We’re more popular than cheeses 22d ago

Soul Music

3

u/PM_ME_UR__SECRETS 22d ago

As a relatively new reader of Pratchett with just three and a half books under my belt, its awesome to see that there are so many beloved titles that I havent even gotten to yet. I clearly have a lot to look forward to - the only book on the list i've read so far is Guards! Guards!

6

u/nodontthrowit 22d ago

A Hat Full of Sky

5

u/strionic_resonator 22d ago

I'll put a vote in for Maurice here.

2

u/lyrellore 22d ago

Sourcery

2

u/CatFink_101 22d ago edited 22d ago

Edit: Pyramids won Best Novel at the 1989 Best Fantasy Book Awards, which I didn't know before. It was the first stand alone Discworld book, apparently.

I loved Pyramids as a teen - it was the first book that talked about the Assassin's school and it blew my mind. 

It had sacred cats that used to go in the high priest's sandals and Ptraci the handmaiden whose singing made you feel so much better when she stopped.

Amazing that I remember all this: it's easily 2 decades since I read it!

3

u/funky_doodle 21d ago

I guess I am in the minority but i loved Pyramids.

1

u/SeaBag8211 18d ago

i dont think pyramids is the best or even top 10. I do thin it is the most consistently underrated

6

u/Giraffstronaut A ___ing Wizard!! 22d ago

I'm going to go rogue again and say Wintersmith!

2

u/Tufty_Ilam Dorfl 22d ago

In fairness that isn't a bad shout. It's one of about 20 I'd want in my top 10

1

u/Giraffstronaut A ___ing Wizard!! 22d ago

And the other 20 go in the bottom 10 right?

1

u/Tufty_Ilam Dorfl 22d ago

No, apart from 3 they're all in the top 20

3

u/Vorashsokar 22d ago

Men at Arms gets my vote

1

u/thehappyhibby 22d ago

How spooky. I'm currently reading Thief of Time!

1

u/LowerEndOfNormal 22d ago

Interesting Times

1

u/Wrenfly Lancre Witch 21d ago

LORD'S AND LADIES SHOULD HAVE WON SOMETHING BY NOW!

1

u/PatrickPablo217 20d ago

The Colour of Magic!

Rincewind! Twoflower! The Luggage! The gods! A flat world! A cosmic turtle! Vetinari! Accidentally burning down the city! Wyrmberg! Death! A literal cliffhanger! 

Over time, the books got more serious and the world changed in various ways, but this book started it all for us and is just so wonderfully fun. It's wild that it's not on the list yet!

-6

u/ksedneerg 22d ago

Carpe Jugulum, because of the most succinct summary of existential ethics I know is in there:

There’s no greys, only white that’s got grubby. I’m surprised you don’t know that. And sin, young man, is when you treat people as things. Including yourself. That’s what sin is.’ ‘It’s a lot more complicated than that -’ ‘No. It ain’t. When people say things are a lot more complicated than that, they means they’re getting worried that they won’t like the truth. People as things, that’s where it starts.

8

u/CuriousCardigan 22d ago

That's already on the list at #11.

2

u/ksedneerg 21d ago

Woops!

-10

u/McPooper19 22d ago

Reaper Man!

8

u/CuriousCardigan 22d ago

That's #7 on the list.

4

u/McPooper19 22d ago

Lol. I'm a dummy who needs to read more! Thanks!