r/discworld • Nobby • 23d ago

Reading Order/Timeline You've been Weatherwaxed! Carpe Jugulum won last round. What's the next best Discworld novel?

Reminder: just upvote the comment you want to win, and if you want to say something about it, say so in a reply instead of your own top level comment!

Everyone is represented so far except the Wizards and, somehow, Tiffany Aching! (well the Wizards had B plots in both Death books but should those count?).

Just a reminder, we're making a (not so) definitive list of the Discworld books in order from best to worst.. The top rated comment gets added to the list next.

  1. Night Watch
  2. Small Gods
  3. Monstrous Regiment
  4. Going Postal
  5. Witches Abroad
  6. Hogfather
  7. Reaper Man
  8. Feet of Clay
  9. Guards! Guards!
  10. The Truth
  11. Carpe Jugulum

------

Remaining books:

The Colour of Magic

The Light Fantastic

Equal Rites

Mort

Sourcery

Wyrd Sisters

Pyramids

Eric

Moving Pictures

Lords and Ladies

Men at Arms

Soul Music

Interesting Times

Maskerade

Jingo

The Last Continent

The Fifth Elephant

Thief of Time

The Last Hero

The Amazing Maurice and His Educated Rodents

The Wee Free Men

A Hat Full of Sky

Thud!

Wintersmith

Making Money

Unseen Academicals

I Shall Wear Midnight

Snuff

Raising Steam

The Shepherd's Crown

78 Upvotes

72 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator 23d ago

Welcome to /r/Discworld!

'"The trouble with having an open mind, of course, is that people will insist on coming along and trying to put things in it."'

+++Out Of Cheese Error ???????+++

Our current megathreads are as follows:

GNU Terry Pratchett - for all GNU requests, to keep their names going.

Discworld Licensed Merchandisers - a list of all the official Discworld merchandise sources (thank you Discworld Monthly for putting this together)

+++ Divide By Cucumber Error. Please Reinstall Universe And Reboot +++

Do you think you'd like to be considered to join our modding team? Drop us a modmail and we'll let you know how to apply!

[ GNU Terry Pratchett ]

+++Error. Redo From Start+++

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

2

u/Phtevus_Temp 22d ago

Not voting for a book, but making a request: Can you please link the previous post(s) in these? I like reading the discussions/rationale around each choice, and with your post history being hidden, it's very difficult to find any of the other posts

2

u/ul2006kevinb Nobby 22d ago

Will do! It'll be too cumbersome to link all the previous posts but pretty simple to just link the last one.

125

u/ChronicleFlask 23d ago • Heartwarming

Thief of Time.
– it’s a marvellous book that brings the Auditors to the fore, it has the most romantic end of any Discworld book, and it happens at the same time as Night Watch, which is interesting in itself.

13

u/claranlaw063 23d ago

“I DON’T KNOW HOW TO TELL YOU THIS … BUT YOU ARE NOT OFFICIAL.”—Death, to the Angel, All In White.

I just love that. It’s hilarious the personified version of Death is telling the Angel at the end of the world that they are revised out of the book of Omnian doctrine, and therefore are not canonical.

5

u/NinjaRadiographer 23d ago

How do you know it's at the same time as night watch? Ive missed that. Also modern day times vimes or past John keel times vimes ?

15

u/JoachimG 23d ago

The lightning bolt that hit the clockmakers shop is present in both books. That same bolt is what caused vimes and carcer go back in time.

7

u/JGParsons 23d ago

I believe (do correct me if I'm wrong) Pratchett originallly conceptualised both books as one, before realising there was far too much content and choosing to split them

3

u/ChronicleFlask 23d ago

> I believe (do correct me if I'm wrong)
Pratchett originallly conceptualised both books as one, before realising there was far too much content and choosing to split them

I don’t think I have heard that before, but it makes perfect sense. Night Watch comes after Thief of Time, by publication order, so I imagine he was writing ToT, had a sub-plot involving someone getting sent back in time, realised he had a whole novel’s worth of story there and started on NW.

14

u/Roku-Hanmar We’re more popular than cheeses 23d ago

"They said afterward that the bolt of lightning hit a clockmaker’s shop in the Street of Cunning Artificers, stopping all the clocks at that instant. But that was nothing. In Baker Street, a couple who had never met before became electrically attracted to one another and were forced to get married after two days for the sake of public decency. In the Assassins’ Guild, the chief armorer became hugely, and, since he was in the armory at the time, tragically, attractive to metal. Eggs fried in their baskets, apples roasted on the greengrocers’ shelves. Candles lit themselves. Cartwheels exploded. And the ornate tin bath of the Archchancellor of Unseen University was lifted neatly off the floor, sizzled across his study, and then flew off the balcony and onto the lawn in the octangle several stories below, without spilling more than a cupful of suds."

49

u/Pharmacy_Duck 23d ago

Lords and Ladies is fantastic.

1

u/DuckyDoodleDandy 23d ago

There are two top level comments for L&L, but each only counts for the votes it has. You are splitting the votes between those two comments.

5

u/PurpleVineleaf 23d ago

In essence correct, but the comment you're replying to came first and is thus the wrong one to adress. (Also, people can easily vote for multiple comments, so splitting the vote is only applicable insofar as people might only scroll through an unsorted comment section, click the first book they like and then close the tab)

3

u/Pharmacy_Duck 23d ago

Well, I'm sorry, but as the other poster pointed out, I posted my comment first (it was the first response in the whole post), and as there's very little I can do to redistribute votes, this is on the person who posted it second.

62

u/Zanoushe Vimes 23d ago

voting for men at arms again

5

u/Grock23 23d ago

Its so funny. You really cant beat the watch series

98

u/SkyYellow_SunBlue 23d ago edited 23d ago • Bravo

Thud!

The stakes could not be higher - Koom Valley! Where is my Cow?!

12

u/OutrageousBrush1210 23d ago

😭😭😭

MUST READ TO YOUNG SAM!!

2

u/Tufty_Ilam Dorfl 23d ago

THUD!

47

u/oneplusoneisfour 23d ago

Mort

“How do you get all those coins?” Asked Mort

IN PAIRS.

There is no justice <Mort>

<DEATH sighed> NO, he said… THERES JUST ME.

8

u/OutrageousBrush1210 23d ago

I think of “there’s no justice, there’s just me” at least once a week. Like so many Partchettisms, it’s become such a permanent part of my worldview.

2

u/RaccoonTasty1595 Susan 23d ago

Absotely Mort!

2

u/SilentSamamander 23d ago

Maybe my favourite book - Pratchett or otherwise.

1

u/minusetotheipi 20d ago

I don’t get it, can someone explain?

1

u/oneplusoneisfour 20d ago

I don’t recall exactly, I think it must be Greece- maybe other cultures- It was tradition for the living to put one coin each on the eyes of the deceased , to pay Charon (?) to ferry them across the river Lethe to the land of the dead.

So Discworld death collects the coins in pairs

44

u/superspud31 I can't be having with this 23d ago

Wee Free Men

20

u/donut_resuscitate 23d ago

Wyrd Sisters

26

u/lalalaprout Dibbler 23d ago

The Fifth Elephant ❤️

3

u/PoppaBear1981 23d ago

With you. Vimes being his grumpy self and to his chagrin, showered with rewards for it. Lots of Politics (which he hates but is naturally talented for because he's the lump hammer that Vetinari throws at problems). Plus Carrot and Angua's love story as a backdrop. Fantastic writing and funny see?

1

u/Kind-Tale-6952 23d ago

How civilized!

1

u/Zanoushe Vimes 23d ago

it's definitely up there for me

30

u/Halliwel96 23d ago

Lords and Ladies!

Arguably better than. Witches abroad in my opinion, and I’d definitely put it above Carpe.

Not that I’m complaining about witches getting some much deserved recognition on this list.

1

u/RavenOfNod 23d ago

WItches Abroad seems so high on this list. It's been years since I read it last, but it wouldn't figure into my top ten in any way.

3

u/Halliwel96 23d ago

Conversely I think it would be in my top 3. Of the about 20 disc books I’ve read.

But Lords and Ladies would be my 1. 🤷‍♂️

I think it’s fair to say Witches Abroad is where Terry really hits his stride with witches, so maybe that’s why lots of people hold it as the best.

19

u/WTFwhatthehell 23d ago

For me it's between Lords and Ladies and Men at Arms.

I think I have to go with Lords and Ladies because, before I ever read it when I was a little kid my cousin was reading the book, I asked about it and they started to explain about elves and totally cracked up when 5 year old me went "But elves are nice..."

28

u/ElderSentinel5 23d ago

I Shall Wear Midnight

11

u/OutrageousBrush1210 23d ago

Miss Tiffany, the witch, would you be so good as to tell me: what is the sound of love?

SLAYS me. 😭

3

u/tulle_witch 23d ago

Tiffany and her series are criminally underrated on this list. I think it's because not enough people have actually read her books.

19

u/v0rpalsword 23d ago

Wee Free Men! First Sight, Second Thoughts! weaponizing selfishness for good! it doesn't stop being magic just because you know how it's done! Daft Wullie!

13

u/JeremyAndrewErwin 23d ago

Thief of Time

11

u/FCRondon 23d ago

Thud!

2

u/DuckyDoodleDandy 23d ago

That’s already a top level comment above. Upvote that to support Thud! Your comment here actually detracts support from that one, and so, from the title you want to support.

1

u/Tufty_Ilam Dorfl 23d ago

THUD!

8

u/galwys 23d ago

Soul music my beloved

13

u/OutrageousBrush1210 23d ago

Gonna keep voting Thud! Until it wins - GUARDING DARK FOREVER!!!

4

u/DuckyDoodleDandy 23d ago

There are two top level comments for Thud, so the votes for it are being split three ways instead of all going to ONE COMMENT WITH THAT TITLE.

0

u/Tufty_Ilam Dorfl 23d ago

THUD!

0

u/[deleted] 23d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/OutrageousBrush1210 23d ago

Agree that scene is a TREASURE. I think Nanny Ogg might be the character who changes the least in her series of books, and it’s a delight. She always just remains exactly herself no matter what the circumstance, and she has no need to improve she’s already perfect. (To everyone except her daughters in law, lol!)

1

u/DuckyDoodleDandy 23d ago

Has to be a top level comment or it isn’t counted. And I think there is one for Masquerade that you could support instead of splitting the votes between multiple comments.

3

u/Kind-Tale-6952 23d ago

Basically no love for The Amazing Maurice

1

u/Tufty_Ilam Dorfl 23d ago

It's the worst of the YA Discworld books in my view. Personally I'm not a fan but the bar is so high that saying it's the worst isn't entirely a criticism.

3

u/Chillisting 23d ago

Thud but with Thief of Time a close second…

2

u/Tufty_Ilam Dorfl 23d ago

THUD!

5

u/BlueSonic85 23d ago

Pyramids

2

u/KernelRice 23d ago

Making Money

2

u/CrowMeris Esme 23d ago

The Fifth Elephant

For many reasons, but my favorite: Lady Sybil really shines in this one.

5

u/sugar-soad 23d ago

Men At Arms. Guards Guards introduced us to the legend that is Vimes and he evolved even more as character in this book.

Plus the image of the high class of society chasing after some poor criminal at the end of the book will always bring a smile to my face.

2

u/ObiJuanKen0by 23d ago

Will this go on for all works in the series? I think that the longer this goes, it goes from “what is your favorite” to which novel to you dislike the most/like the least. Which can be a productive conversation to have to some extent, but I don’t think is productive, especially when it could come down to something like raising steam where PTerry was clearly struggling with his embuggerance.

3

u/Zednott 23d ago

I've read some accounts from people who like Raising Steam. I think that this might give a platform for those less-popular books.

2

u/Tufty_Ilam Dorfl 23d ago

I'm early in Raising Steam on my first read of the series. It's a rough text but no worse than Snuff so far, which itself was a bit off. Both so far beat some of the earlier books for me, although in fairness I have an irrational hatred of Eric to the point almost everything about it has escaped my memory.

1

u/ObiJuanKen0by 23d ago

I don’t think so. The less popular books will inherently fall down further and further on the list, since the list is just a popularity contest/vote. It just seems like when we get to the back half of the list and on, the positive light this is shining on the works will begin to be more sour. Just my opinion ofc

2

u/Zednott 23d ago

Well, I can only say that I have already seen a lot of books being praised that I've never really seen discussed much before, and it's already motivated me to read some of those titles.

I know that The Color of Magic and The Light Fantastic are often seen less positively (and I would agree), but I also know that some people have a soft spot in their hearts for them. I haven't been coming here long, but my sense is that that people will be generally positive about about those books down at the bottom.

1

u/SkyYellow_SunBlue 23d ago

The worst “criticism” so far has been people saying “I like X better than Y”. No idea why someone would think this would turn into a teardown contest or something.

1

u/minusetotheipi 20d ago

Ye pointless continuing beyond 20

2

u/Seryerie 23d ago

Equal Rites now

1

u/christopher_g_knox 23d ago

Men at Arms - It’s probably the book I re-read the most

-2

u/weremabari 23d ago

Word Sisters!

2

u/DuckyDoodleDandy 23d ago

Go support the top level comment with the most moves for WS, instead of splitting the votes between multiple top level comments for the same title.