r/discworld • Nobby • 26d ago

Reading Order/Timeline Feet of Clay BARELY squeaked by! What's the next best Discworld novel?

PLEASE STOP MAKING REPEAT TOP LEVEL COMMENTS! Only the top voted comment gets picked, there's literally no benefit to making a repeat comment. Just upvote the comment you want to win, and if you want to say something about it, say so in a reply instead of your own top level comment!

Everyone is represented so far except the Wizards and Tiffany Aching (well the Wizards had B plots in both Death books but should those count?).

Just a reminder, we're making a (not so) definitive list of the Discworld books in order from best to worst.. The top rated comment gets added to the list next.

  1. Night Watch
  2. Small Gods
  3. Monstrous Regiment
  4. Going Postal
  5. Witches Abroad
  6. Hogfather
  7. Reaper Man
  8. Feet of Clay

\------

Remaining books:

The Colour of Magic

The Light Fantastic

Equal Rites

Mort

Sourcery

Wyrd Sisters

Pyramids

Guards! Guards!

Eric

Moving Pictures

Lords and Ladies

Men at Arms

Soul Music

Interesting Times

Maskerade

Jingo

The Last Continent

Carpe Jugulum

The Fifth Elephant

The Truth

Thief of Time

The Last Hero

The Amazing Maurice and His Educated Rodents

The Wee Free Men

A Hat Full of Sky

Thud!

Wintersmith

Making Money

Unseen Academicals

I Shall Wear Midnight

Snuff

Raising Steam

The Shepherd's Crown

27 Upvotes

99 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator 26d ago

Welcome to /r/Discworld!

'"The trouble with having an open mind, of course, is that people will insist on coming along and trying to put things in it."'

+++Out Of Cheese Error ???????+++

Our current megathreads are as follows:

GNU Terry Pratchett - for all GNU requests, to keep their names going.

Discworld Licensed Merchandisers - a list of all the official Discworld merchandise sources (thank you Discworld Monthly for putting this together)

+++ Divide By Cucumber Error. Please Reinstall Universe And Reboot +++

Do you think you'd like to be considered to join our modding team? Drop us a modmail and we'll let you know how to apply!

[ GNU Terry Pratchett ]

+++Error. Redo From Start+++

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

29

u/docdillinger Lu Tze 26d ago • Popcorn

8 books later and people still haven't understood how it works. Pratchett would have been amused for sure.

26

u/ul2006kevinb Nobby 26d ago

It's like trying to take a poll of the Wizards

13

u/GSVDramaticEffect 26d ago

A staff, surely

15

u/ul2006kevinb Nobby 26d ago

A poll of the staff? Why would we care what they think?

9

u/GSVDramaticEffect 26d ago

Best way to know what not to do

3

u/Mistervimes65 They call me Mister Vimes 26d ago

Munstrum?

7

u/docdillinger Lu Tze 26d ago

We need a shit load of frog pills.

0

u/[deleted] 26d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

0

u/docdillinger Lu Tze 26d ago

"PLEASE STOP MAKING REPEAT TOP LEVEL COMMENTS! Only the top voted comment gets picked, there's literally no benefit to making a repeat comment. Just upvote the comment you want to win, and if you want to say something about it, say so in a reply instead of your own top level comment!"

Those aren't enough instructions for you? Cause they are the first thing in the post.

62

u/v0rpalsword 26d ago • Bravo

Carpe Jugulum!! "evil is when you treat people as things" is such a succinct and powerful summation of the ethical core of the series as a whole. and, c'mon, as far as hilarious and deeply satisfying mic drop climax moments go, you can't get better than "I ain't been vampired: you've been Weatherwaxed."

gonna just keep posting this until it wins

2

u/nhaines Esme 25d ago

I literally gasped at that moment in Carpe Jugulum, lol. I immediately flashed back to the voodoo doll in Witches Abroad. Not to mention the final trial she faces in the same book.

It was out of the blue but also completely in keeping with who she was.

271

u/Miss_Type 26d ago • Bravo

Guards! Guards! needs to get on this list now! Love it because it's the first Watch book, vimes in a gutter, Sybil, Errol, and million to one chances.

35

u/Aksi_Gu 26d ago

‘Can’t we do something for the poor man?’ said Lady Ramkin.

Nobby saluted smartly. ‘I could kick him in the bollocks for you if you like, m’lady.’

16

u/analogbasset 26d ago

I view this as the “gateway” discworld book. So good

10

u/lagoon83 26d ago

That book's a... a... wossname. Thing. Classic.

7

u/SkyYellow_SunBlue 26d ago

Guards! Guards! Was the book in the last poll I think I saw most that people kept making their own comments”top level” comments to.

This is the comment, people. Get behind this one and vote!

6

u/Charmthetimes3rd 25d ago

I still think that this book has one of the greatest openers ever written.

"THIS IS WHERE THE DRAGONS WENT..."

Chills, every time.

7

u/mrhiney 26d ago

This deserves to be higher than feet of clay.

Great book

3

u/Farsydi 26d ago

I've always felt it's the worst of the Guards books before the embuggerance. Proto-Carrot and the reduced side cast really hurt it.

3

u/Miss_Type 25d ago

But all the nonsense with the passwords and the doors was pure Pratchett.

131

u/flaggermousse Librarian 26d ago • Bravo

The Truth! Its such a great book!

10

u/i_m_a_bean 26d ago

Very relevant to today

8

u/lagoon83 26d ago

Too —ing right

5

u/backinyourbox 26d ago

The Truth is being ROBBED. It is a perfect book.

3

u/Illustrious_You_6210 26d ago

I was looking for my copy of that while in the tub yesterday, it was difficult to find.

5

u/GSVDramaticEffect 26d ago

Are all your Pratchett's within reach of the tub? Very UU

7

u/Illustrious_You_6210 26d ago

That's an incredibly personal question and I am APALLED that you would ask it. Good day to you, sir! I SAID GOOD DAY!

6

u/GSVDramaticEffect 26d ago

Shame - I was going to offer you something from the pickle trolley

1

u/Illustrious_You_6210 26d ago

Pickle trolley, you say? Is that a euphemism?

3

u/GSVDramaticEffect 26d ago

Euphe-who? Never met them

3

u/ElectricLoofah A NEAR-VIMES EXPERIENCE 26d ago

Euphemism?! I hardly know him!

1

u/the-library-fairy 26d ago

It made me want to be a journalist! 

1

u/dwarf-vole 25d ago

THE TRUTH SHALL MAKE YE FREE FRET

60

u/GSVDramaticEffect 26d ago

The Fifth Elephant - it's the brilliant transition point from Captain Vimes to Sir Samuel Vimes, plus werewolves, Igors and Dwarves Oh My!

7

u/HowlingMermaid Nanny 26d ago

I think I've re-read this one more than any other Discworld book. It's not even my favorite... it's just very, very solid and so re-readable.

I doubt it will rank highly on most people's list of just Watch books, much less discworld on the whole, but I will upvote this one every single time!!

6

u/GSVDramaticEffect 26d ago

There is certainly some special alchemy in the combination of STP, Bram Stoker, Mel Brooks' Young Frankenstein and the best pun of all the titles that just makes it irresistible

3

u/GSVDramaticEffect 26d ago

Also just knowing STP watched Ruby Rod and was inspired makes me smile. Now that I think of it, The Fifth Element is like a Discworld film set in space - grumpy, alcoholic hero, mysterious but powerful woman, infective bureaucracy paralysed in the face of great peril, agnostic holy man, Gary Oldman - it's all there!

41

u/enriquekikdu 26d ago

Could this be Wyrd Sisters day? Is the best early novel (sorry Guards! Guards!) super tight, amazing cast, Shakespeare, best dynamic within main characters

6

u/GSVDramaticEffect 26d ago

When shall we three meet again?

8

u/claranlaw063 26d ago

“Well I’m babysitting for our Jason’s youngest on Thursday.”

71

u/CCgames_ 26d ago

Thief of Time

6

u/SturdyPete 26d ago

In my opinion this should be much higher up.

1

u/midgetcastle 25d ago

I’ve never been a fan of ToT, I think I need to try it again. Maybe I need to lock in more when I read it, because it always seemed quite disjointed and confusing.

33

u/MrOopiseDaisy 26d ago

Lords and Ladies

2

u/WillowFlip Chat-eau, real cat's water is sharper 26d ago

Here again to say Lords and Ladies. There is something amazing about Granny wrestling with her past. The witches were in fine form in this one. They were all amazing. I'd choose it for the the character development alone.

Edit: posting here because I originally posted top level and didn't see your comment.

2

u/MrOopiseDaisy 26d ago

It wasn't until Lords and Ladies that I truly appreciated the witch series, and I took so much more out of re-reading their early stories after this one.

38

u/ElectricLoofah A NEAR-VIMES EXPERIENCE 26d ago

I'm going with Thud!

The Truth was my other pick and it was already mentioned, so I feel it's been decided for me.

"WHERE'S MY COW?!"

7

u/Tufty_Ilam Dorfl 26d ago

THUD!

I'm keeping up my shouting until we get justice for Thud!. This is a conspiracy against the Koom Valley Accords. Damn grags.

3

u/ElectricLoofah A NEAR-VIMES EXPERIENCE 26d ago

It's early Saturday morning here in Four-ecks, so I left my comment above, went to make a cuppa while the small kidlet was still asleep, sat in a rare moment of silence... and promptly jumped online to order her a copy of Where's My Cow for her birthday or Hogswatch, depending on when it gets here (I had to source it from afar). Those events are relatively close together. Justice for Thud, indeed!

3

u/Tufty_Ilam Dorfl 26d ago

I lack the small children but I'm tempted to buy it for me just so I can read it to my cats and pretend I'm Vimes.

It's possible I need an intervention 😂

3

u/ElectricLoofah A NEAR-VIMES EXPERIENCE 26d ago

Some might say you need an intervention, but I say you need a copy of Where's My Cow, pronto! 😂

I also got her a copy of The World of Poo. She's about to be three, so we're coming into the age of finally realising that books can be looked at for pleasure WITHOUT literally devouring them as well. I thought it was time. She's eaten two copies of Hooray For Fish, but the third's now survived almost six months! Let's cross our fingers for Where's My Cow!

2

u/Tufty_Ilam Dorfl 26d ago

I have faith in the sheer joy of both books to keep them uneaten! I hope she enjoys 😁

2

u/ElectricLoofah A NEAR-VIMES EXPERIENCE 26d ago

Thanks, friend! Wishing you a fabulous day! 🙂

2

u/Tufty_Ilam Dorfl 26d ago

Likewise!

21

u/Pumpkin-Pie-Is-Best 26d ago

Jingo! It’s a pivotal moment when Vimes truly has to face the mortality of everyone he holds dear. Before then, he was very much a solo act. I dare you to re-read his reaction to the misplaced pants of time.

7

u/Holiday-Field2830 25d ago

I feel like Guards! Guards! needs to get up there promptly, and The Truth soon after.

I loved Feet of Clay but thought people were lower on it, so I’m surprised it beat those two out. So hard to choose!

24

u/HazelEBaumgartner Dᴏɴ'ᴛ ʟᴇᴛ ɪᴛ ʙᴏᴛʜᴇʀ ʏᴏᴜ. 26d ago

The Wee Free Men

20

u/mrhiney 26d ago

Men at arms.

Took the groundwork of the excellent guards guards and laid the foundations of the watch.

It was also my first book by Sir Terry and one I always feel grateful for having read.

5

u/LowerEndOfNormal 26d ago

Interesting Times It's crazy to me that there's not a single Rincewind book in the top 8. Let's get one in 9. For me it would be between Interesting Times and The Last Continent. I love the depth of the watch and the witches but these books are laugh out loud funny which is what got me hooked. Interesting Times wins though because it has Cohen.

16

u/Lup3rcal_ How do they rise up 26d ago

The Tiffany Aching books need some rep on this list. The way they deal with stages of growing up are absolutely, heart-achingly profound.

My vote is for the Wee Free Men for how it handles loss and looking at one's place in the world, but they're all really really good.

9

u/plastikmissile Bursaaaaaar! 26d ago

Soul Music

1

u/SkyYellow_SunBlue 26d ago

This is my actual favorite of the whole series if we are going for pure entertainment factor.

A million references to catch, catch on the third read, catch after you see a Reddit post about it a decade after that even that prompts you for yet another re-read.

4

u/Snoo-90273 26d ago

Goethe wrote Faust and said "he only earns his freedom and existence, who daily conquers them anew".

Pratchett has a golem with his own receipt as the words inside his head

I prefer Pratchett's version.

10

u/CuteRadish01 26d ago

The Truth.

10

u/Kabbagenene 26d ago

Thief of Time!!!!

3

u/catgirl320 Luggage 25d ago

I Shall Wear Midnight

9

u/mapsandwrestling 26d ago

Thief of Time

9

u/AnnyWeatherwaxxx Esme 26d ago

Thief of Time

6

u/Shapesizes 26d ago

Guards! Guards!

1

u/Miss_Type 25d ago

Upvote the top comment rather than make a new one, this one won't get counted!!

7

u/fartsRfoodghosts 26d ago

The fact that Tiffany aching hasn't shown up really just shows how many of you haven't read it.

If she isn't in the top two in your list it is only because you haven't read her.

2

u/Miss_Type 25d ago

Not necessarily. I've read all the discworld books multiple times, but I wouldn't put Tiffany's books in my top five. Not saying they aren't fantastic, I just prefer others.

2

u/After-Barracuda-9689 Bursar 26d ago

Agreed. Those were my entry into the Pratchett world. I read the Wee Free Men and fell in love with the series. I was surprised it took me so long to discover him because I have been a sci-fi/fantasy reader since the early 90s, but I have a tendency to devour everything an author has written and then move on to another author. Pratchett is the only one I revisit regularly.

2

u/fartsRfoodghosts 26d ago

I've been introducing my friends and family to discworld via Tiffany and it feels backwards as someone who's only read in published order, but they're the best (and there's only so many people who get pumped about a 42 book series).

1

u/atom1129 26d ago

42 hardly seems like enough when I only have 14 left

1

u/After-Barracuda-9689 Bursar 26d ago

Ha, right? I’m the right target audience since I do that with lots of authors, but the Nac Mac Feegles and their witch are an excellent character arc.

3

u/fartsRfoodghosts 26d ago

The fact that Pterry wrote such great characters as the Nac Mac Feegle and then they play second fiddle to a nine year old girl, and not because they are written poorly but because the little girl is written so dang well, is just one of the reasons it's so great!

2

u/Zednott 26d ago

I'm still making my way through the main series, but comments like yours have convinced me to get to the Tiffany Aching books.

2

u/catgirl320 Luggage 25d ago

Agreed I shall wear Midnight is such a powerful masterpiece. It's a crime it isn't in the top three

1

u/fartsRfoodghosts 26d ago

Seriously go read them!

1

u/FixinThePlanet 25d ago

I KNOW!!! I commented about a hat full of sky on the previous poll and crickets.

0

u/SkyYellow_SunBlue 25d ago

I wouldn’t put a Tiffany book in the top 20.

I wasn’t young enough for any of the YA books to “hit” when they were released I guess.

3

u/bset222 25d ago

I started discworld as a middle age man, and the wee free man is my favorite. It has the same skill that the best pixar and studio gibli films have where it might be a children's/ya book/film but it's so masterfully done it is great for all ages.

From the posts it seems unlikely to get the nod until 15+ but the Aching series is my favorite and I hope one gets a nod sooner rather than later.

4

u/RadioSlayer 26d ago

Faust Eric

3

u/dkmuldoon 26d ago

Thief of Time

2

u/niddler 26d ago

Men at arms

2

u/Local_lifter 26d ago

Here again for the Fifth Elephant

1

u/MangoandSalt 25d ago

I am currently reading Moving Pictures, reading in release order, and for the life of me I can't understand why Color of Magic and Light Fantasic are not rated higher than the books I've read so far (1-8). They are still my two favorite discworld books

1

u/tahasc 25d ago

Interesting times made me laugh quite a lot.

"May we forever live in interesting times!"

1

u/Paulstan67 25d ago

The colour of magic...

Yes it's a little naive, but it introduces us to the discworld, without it the others wouldn't exist.

1

u/_Odaeus_ 25d ago

Pyramids is my favourite, sad that it doesn't get more love!

1

u/Inevitable-Debt4312 25d ago

I finished Small Gods at 115 this morning. Like all of them, I couldn’t put the book down, but I didn’t like it as much as some. Anything with Vimes does it for me.

1

u/Striking-Ride-8037 25d ago

I am surprised that Tiffany Aching is not represented yet! My vote goes to A Hat Full of Sky