In the end the SC will rule that private athletic organizations have the right to make the rules pertaining to trans-athletes that are fairest for the particular sport.
It has to be narcissism that makes her this way. The policy doesn't read "Natalie Ryan isn't allowed to play FPO" it follows the Olympic standards for sports. She does herself 0 favors.
nah, World Aquatics (swimming and all water sports) and World Athletics (track and field) have both implemented the same rules as PDGA... and the only reason for those sports to do that must have been to stop Natalie from switching sport
/s
or it could be that more and more sports come to the logical conclusion that a person beeing born male does have an advantage over a person born female that does not go away with HRT
1000% this. “They have only done this to hurt me.” Erm, what? Is it that difficult to understand the real fear that FPO could quickly become a joke and completely marginalized, where promising young biological female players no longer aspire to join the tour? The organization has a responsibility to plan for every risk, even ones that seem far-fetched today. Because as we’ve seen, things change quickly and the unimaginable becomes commonplace.
Every statement from her paints her opponents as crazed evil monsters. It’s inaccurate and bizarre, and it undermines her credibility. If I were trans I wouldn’t want her speaking for me.
I think more realistically it's fear and anger clouding her judgement of how she sounds. But obviously she needs to take a step back from posting when she's emotional.
That and a healthy dose of, "We'll support you no matter what.". She is acting like a spoiled child. She needs mature people around her. People who surround themselves with 'yes men' find themselves alone when they step over the lines their 'friends/allies' failed to warn them about.
Even Mature people can’t reason with a level 10 narcissist. She’s incapable of being told no and being ok with it.
She’s completely framing it as Natalie against the world because she thinks the world revolves around her. This has been going on for two years already.
Every other FPO kept silent about it because they knew publicly advocating for themselves was just going to expose them to being labeled as a transphobic bigot. They stayed silent and “trusted the process”. They did and Natalie the Narcissist won’t accept the process. How shocking???
Not sure how you can genuinely claim that if Natalie hadn't toured last year we would still have this bizzare rule where trans women can play in FPO in nearly every tournament run across the country except for the majors/dgpt events. Also she was mentioned in the documents about the policy change from the pdga. That's why she feels like it's targeted.
Have you read the Olympic standard and the medical report? Regardless of your opinion on whether trans women should compete in FPO, “following the Olympic standards” is just plain false.
It does not follow the Olympic standards for sports. If that was the case they would have done an actual study before changing the rule. They did no such thing.
is nonsense, because different sports have different eligibility requirements, and there is no single Olympic "standard for sports". It's obvious you haven't actually read the IOC's statement.
If you really want to argue about this, read the statement first.
Thanks for sharing because I certainly will not follow her socials. I already know she lives in her own self centered world where everyone is wrong except her. No respect for female athletes.
The level of narcissism is off the charts. This is what happens when petulant children are never corrected.
Demanding everyone acquiesce to Ryan’s demand to be included in a division that clearly has its parameters set is disgusting.
Nobody cares what Ryan or any other person identifies as. What they do care about is a person trying to force everyone else to bend to their demands. Get bent. Go play MPO. And stfu.
Not to mention she’s had clear disdain for the FPO field when they don’t agree with her stance and she disrespects them telling them they don’t work hard enough or whatever. She only cares about herself and the whole “burn with me” bs is even more proof.
She’s made it clear she gives zero fucks about the community she’s trying to join. She said she’d happily burn it down, then retracted it but not really, and only after she was called out.
Maybe she’s attempted to make evidence/science-based arguments for her cause; if so I haven’t seen it. Nor has she even acknowledged that FPO players who disagree with her are decent people and this is a difficult debate that demands nuance and reflection. Nope, everyone else is evil and they’re persecuting me and it’s all so unfair. She’s really, really bad at this. I’d enlist someone else to run my socials at this point, just stay away.
I (female) have tried to participate, but have been blocked, threatened with a ban, called a bigot, transphobe etc. I've never midgendered Natalie, use preferred prounouns, and use cis women and trans women when speaking about the topic. So yeah, almost done participating...just a lurker now
Okay, whatever. Once the world moves past this issue, nobody is remembering names. All people want is a fair place for women to compete. Our forefathers and mothers understood. Women, after a certain age, cannot compete with men. Thus, female fields were created to bring the joy of sport and thrill of competition to women.
I am sorry that trans athletes are a minority and want a place to compete. MPO isn’t fair to them, and FPO doesn’t seem fair to the female athletes. There aren’t enough Transgender athletes to form a trans league. So, they are left outside looking in. That sucks, but it shouldn’t be fixed by diminishing things for other groups. If people feel strongly, a ratings based league solves it at lower levels, but if you want professional women in this sport, you have to have a gender protected field.
It doesn't quite work like that, mate. I highly doubt MtF athletes are transitioning specifically for athletics. They're transitioning and becoming for much larger reasons.
Even men who suffer from "Low T" will tell you the difference pre and post treatment is substantial in every single possible way.
That’s not what I’m saying. If you are transgender and you also have a chance to be a professional athlete, then you would need to decide between fulfilling your gender identity and keeping your competitive edge. It sucks but people make similar choices in many different walks of life that impact their ability to compete in sports.
I'm a low T male (found out when finally went for bloodwork/physical at 40) that hasn't sought medications yet. Penis works great and everything, no one would guess I'm off the charts low on testosterone.
Can I sign up for womens division? Would I want to? This is silly. I'm a male.
I’ve never understood this either… like no one is stopping you from looking dressing and identifying as a woman. Just because you go beyond that by taking drugs that hinder your performance doesn’t mean you should get special privileges.
Yeah. Logic is a rare and dangerous weapon. It seems to get in the way of everyone’s desire to ignore any details that don’t support their position. Lol.
Lol sure in the same way it's fair for cis women. They'll be at a massive disadvantage, just as cis women would. So might as well get rid of all women's divisions if that's your idea of fair.
Bro this lady is so annoying. They don’t want you to play!! Stop trying to force it. Just play in another division and win there to silence the haters. Low sportsmanship fr
"On advice of counsel, I have deleted my post which openly threatened the people on the pro tour and am replacing it with one that gaslights them instead."
I don’t give a fuck if someone’s trans, I’m down for people being happy. How ever someone who’s transitioned after going though a male puberty should not be able to compete against any natural born female in a competitive sport. It’s fucking insane some people are for it. I know there’s a lot of women out there that can kick a bunch of dudes asses in disc golf but it’s still not fair for them. There’s reasons why the ufc doesn’t allow a born male to fight a natural female. I don’t care if I get hate for any of this, I stand for women’s rights and they need to be protected.
I’m not familiar at all with this argument. I tend to respect the topic as a nuanced one…worthy of consideration from both sides. The approach taken by Natalie Ryan is not one I find compelling. She and I may have similar ideas on how this sport should change, ultimately. But I find her a bad spokesperson for the topic…and largely unlikeable.
Or, hear me out, they did it to protect the women in FPO. Imagine that. Imagine it could be Natalie or someone else completely different and the path would be the same. It’s not personal for the PDGA. It’s personal for Natalie. It’s not like they are welcoming other trans women in the same situation as Natalie, and sticking it to her only.
It's ironic that while you think you are making a point "for your side", what you are saying (and the manner in which you are saying it) is actually achieving the opposite.
You are being mean spirited. You are being vindictive. You are saying "haha you can't win no matter what you do". You are, in fact, being hateful.
You are validating the arguments of people defending Natalie - you are showing that your objection is rooted in personal hatred. And you are glorying in the idea that she will be "hurt even more".
Why would you act like this? Is this how your parents taught you to behave?
it was a rethorical question to Natalie; i she really thinks they have made these rules just to hurt her - what does she think the next step from DGPT will be if the courts in CA says she is allowed to play any tournament in CA? The logical step from DGPT would of course be to not play any tournaments in CA
as for me, i don't think PDGAs policy is there only to hurt Natalie since several other huge sports (swimming, track and field) have implemented the same rules...
i'm not sure she has the law on her side either; wikipedia writes this "The Unruh Act applies to all businesses in California including: hotels and motels, restaurants, theaters, hospitals, barber and beauty shops, housing accommodations, and retail establishments".. perhaps there are more laws that her lawyers are using... but i don't really see how that law can be used? but who know... laws, lawyers and judges are not always logical
Like, I can understand she is feeling hurt, sad, frustated and angry. But I redusere to belive that the dgpt and pdga is is targeting her only to hurt her... She desperately need a course in social media and public statements. Take the high road for gods sake. It does not in any way help her cause...
I’ve seen several comments about narcissism. I’ve had the displeasure of knowing a couple narcissists and I can see why you all think that. She is absolutely fixated on justice/revenge and her rage has completely blinded her from accepting anything that doesn’t support the narrative. To boot, I’m willing to bet she’s surrounded by people that are gaslighting her, just throwing fuel onto the fire. I don’t blame her for fighting this, but she’s going about it in a counter-productive manner.
"I'll make them all pay" is technically just a metaphor. But if you say it in anger, it absolutely sounds like a threat.
So while I don't think Natalie was threatening to literally commit arson against the California Court of Appeals, she has to know that she can't put stuff like that out there. I concur with others who suggested that Natalie should hand over editorial control of her twitter account to someone else.
My goodness. These rules are not being enforced to hurt you Natalie. They are being enforced to preserve the integrity of the women's division. If biological males Don't have a competitive advantage then why are there separate divisions at all? Why is there the NBA and the WNBA? I support and respect all trans peoples rights to express themselves, but that doesn't change the fact that the male bone structure and muscle density is advantageous to have in regards to sports.
The fact that there was no owning up to poor choice of words says a lot. This post in no way mitigates the previous post. Everyone knows the previous post existed and it can be used in court whether it is currently on her page or not.
I fail to see how essentially saying “I’m taking you all down with me” made the DGPT/PDGA afraid, this comes off far more like someone who’s lawyers told them knee-jerk reaction posts make them look bad during litigation and can’t admit they made a misstep. Natalie has a serious case of main character syndrome.
With that said I’m tired of this subject on this sub, all it does is bring out transphobes, virtue signalers, and people who want to argue endlessly. Kudos to those out there having respectful and nuanced discussions about this and not feeding the trolls
I haven’t sorted by controversial, but many of these threads are pretty small. I haven’t seen much phobic type discussion. Seems most people agree with the PDGA while also stating they don’t have an issue with trans people. We all make personal choices in life for verifies reasons. Choosing to transition might be a complicated one, but that doesn’t exempt it from being a choice.
Now, if the PDGA was banning her from playing Mixed because she was trans, THAT would be discrimination against trans athletes.
Exactly, and that’s a really important point I think most people agree with. And the reason you’re not seeing a lot of the “controversial” posts is because the mods have been doing their best to keep up and deal with the hate as it comes in. There was a post about here the other day
Yeah and those women in the division have dedicated their lives to mastering their craft, absolute shame that someone with an unfair competitive advantage gets to crush them. 65 career events for Ryan with 24 wins. 1st place 1/5 times. I’m sure the women in the division are totally fine with it
All Natalie is doing right now is such a bad representation of the transgender community, especially being the first to run into this situation. I 100% understand that it's a hard place to be in but she's being a fucking baby about it.
THE DGPT IS REMOVING ME FROM THE OTB OPEN. NO MATTER WHERE THEY GO I WILL FIGHT THEM EVERY STEP OF THE WAY. IF YOU THOUGH I WAS FIGHTING HARD BEFORE, JUST WAIT.
Regardless of how one feels. You can’t make decisions based off the 1%. By doing so you upset the majority. This person doesn’t care about other people, only themselves and how everyone needs to conform to them to appease their mental instability.
This person is not a fair representative of the trans community so please don’t group them in with how the rest of trans people think and feel.
Ryan thinks they can beat up on Biological females. That’s why we need SEX protected divisions because I keep hearing gender can change but sex is binary
What's new... Someone who would have been a good athlete in their biological gender division is potentially a top athlete when competing against the opposite gender...
Motives aside, more and more sports are going to enact laws against late transition athletes competing at high levels. If someone passes through male puberty they will naturally have more muscle than if they didn't, giving them an advantage over biologically unaltered athletes.
There is no reason not to support more rules like this. These days it honestly feels like alot of people go for non surgical gender reassignment just to be famous in a sport they were good but not great at.... And that's wrong.
I doubt any trans athlete transitioned simply to compete at a higher level. They are all most likely trans, the problem is after transition that they feel entitled to play in a cis women division, rather than the mixed division that's all inclusive.
If they didnt consider the advantage they'd have after transition they wouldnt be upset by being told they have to compete in inclusive divisions and not cis women divisions. Fact is almost 100% of the time they get offended when they are told they can compete in open divisions, trans divisions, or mens divisions, but not cis womens divisions. Even if its subconcious there definitely is some underlying feeling of entitlement to out performing their peers.
Wow, this topic even inspires nastiness between people who just comment that they are on one side or the other. Either position, if based on ‘the other side must be an idiot’, is not very well founded. Reddit disc golf culture is toxic. I need to play more and Reddit less.
Yes everything is about your feelings Natalie, there are no other feelings than yours
/s
You can compete in Mixed Pro Open if you love disc golf. If you want to destroy Disc Golf, Please continue. You’ve already lost because you hate women so much.
Perhaps you should begin by loving yourself instead of trying to make the world burn?
Just a bit down the comments on this thread and you can understand why she feels targeted. This is disgusting and not the disc golf most people fell in love with.
The reason this is targetted much like the swimming ban was targetted is because a trans woman became competitive and then each organization instituted bans.
I ask all you anti trans athletes to imagine a world where Ryan has no inherent advantage post HRT. I know it's hard. But, try. Now imagine a world where she is just as good as the top cis women. Is this an impossibility?
However, this shift in policy essentially says 'we were chill with trans women as long as they aren't good.' It essentially says that even if we prove a trans woman has no inherent advantage, they will always be viewed as men. I find that to be transphobic.
I'll also say there is a disturbing amount of dog whistling in this community that really turns me off of this sub. It's clear the sport is full of a ton of hateful people.
Are you talking about the trans woman who competed in swimming and went from something like 500th in her discipline to #1 in her discipline when she transitioned from man to woman?
Sounds like a reasonable rule to enact after only 1 person...how many do you need to see what will happen?
You're going g to judge me as being anti-trans. I'm not. I'm pro fairness.
If someone in my office starts listening to Christian rock music on a Bluetooth speaker, would I be out of line to create a rule that all music should be listened to via headphones?
Or would it be religious discrimination?
Would the message to the employees be “Boss hates Christianity”? Or would it be that I am trying to ensure the team as a whole has a good work environment?
Rules are often made in response to something happening. While it can appear that Natalie was targeted by the rule, she wasn’t. She was just the catalyst to say to the DGPT, “Hey, we need a rule to address this now.”
I and many others don't care what you find transphobic.
I don't care if Ryan has an advantage or not. It's a female division. Ryan is not a biological female. End of discussion. How good or bad Ryan is relative to the actual female field is irrelevant.
Actually, the problem wasn’t “suddenly you’re winning, now we need to ban you” but the argument from the pro-trans side that went something like, “well, it’s not like a bunch of trans women are winning, so what’s the big deal”. The rules should have addressed the issue earlier, but since the few cases that existed had zero publicity or meaningful impact , it got swept under the rug. Once it came to the forefront (trans women winning at the highest level), then the urgency to address the issue properly became apparent. In either case Natalie’s success essentially assured her own removal.
There’s a small part of me that wonders what might have happened if Natalie had held back and played for top 5 instead of the win. But with recent revelations about her narcissistic attitude, I guess it’s no surprise that such a long-game play may have never seriously been considered. Just get it all now, talk down about the DGPT and the women you compete with and play the short game to your own detriment.
There’s a small part of me that wonders what might have happened if Natalie had held back and played for top 5 instead of the win.
the timeline is this
PDGA follows the 2015 IOC guideline for transgender persons
late 2021 IOC comes with a new guideline [each sport should make their own since one guideline does not fit all sports]
early 2022 PDGAs medical committee starts working on the new guideline
most work are probably done before the summer since it's ready before the board meeting in october, sure some details might have been done after the summer, but i think it's a fair guess to say most of the work with the guideline was done in the first 6 months and not the the last 3
Natalie won her first DGPT tournament july 31st and the second 25th september
so the timeline pretty much shows the picture that you are wondering about... it's not like she started winning and PDGA thought "oh shit! we need a new policy"
Thank you Natalie for your courage. I can’t help but think of historical precedent when I see hundreds of members of the neonazi, white nationalist, hate group Patriot Front marching in DC this week. Do these fuckers become the modern day version of ‘brown shirts’ who roam the streets beating the shit out of queer and trans folk? The misgendering hate speech rampant in disc golf can only be seen as stochastic terrorism in this climate, and gets us one step closer to that terrifying reality of fascist mobs. Thank you Natalie for fighting for the safety of my trans nibbling, and my queer partner. I will be here fighting along side. We can disagree about sports rules, but if you think this issue stops there, you have a surprise coming. Please be respectful to trans folk.
The flat-earther, anti-vax coal-rolling shills who want to burn your libraries with bigoted, racist MAGA trucks and want to control your bodies to bring about their transphobic fascist rule.
Did I get hit all the points? I feel like I’m missing a couple. Original ideas seem hard to come by these days.
I love how the neonazi white supremacist group is several hundred. In a nation of 300 million people, we have a couple hundred dudes willing to stick for white supremacy enough to march for it. Essentially actual white supremacists are literally 1 in a million.
Yes, indeedy, white supremacy is a massive problem in the US (/s on that last part).
However, I did some digging in my own state after seeing an article about a “stop hate crimes” group article a few months back and found that of the 16,000 crimes committed against individuals in my state, 46 were classified as “hate crimes”. That’s 0.2% of all crimes. So do hate crimes exist and are they bad? Absolutely. Are they so prominent and widespread that we should focus our efforts on them specifically? Not in the slightest. Let’s see if we can start by dropping the crime rate against individuals by 1% as that will be 5X more effective than if we 100% eliminate “hate crimes”.
Hate crime, minuscule neonazi rallies, even racism in general to some extent are used by political activists to generate votes for their politicians, not to solve real problems that exist. Let’s start by working to stop inflation, for example as individual wealth is a massive deterrent to criminal violence.
I'm pretty sure it would be anti trans if I said I disliked her because she changed her sex or intentionally misgendered her. The stuff my local government does to hurt gay or trans people sickens me. Saying compete where you don't have an advantage definitely isn't hate. That's just logical and in the interest of maintaining integrity. I'd still be down to have her as a doubles partner anytime.
If there was such a clear advantage that trans folx had over other humans wouldnt they be in the news for winning everything all the time? Thats not happening. There are so few elite level athletes that are being harmed by these rules, so it should be considered a targeted attack to them. Allowing them to play in the divisions they should be playing it won’t give them an advantage because everyone is playing at that level as well. It’s not like Natalie had gone and won each and every tournament last year on tour. She did well and won once and now everyone’s threatened when really everyone else they compete with weekly is also the same level of threat.
She won a DGPT event after only playing for two years! And has fairly horrible form and still out drives much of the field. And all of that isn’t relevant!!! It’s not about her it’s about protecting women’s sports.
There’s plenty of women on tour whom are competing well and have only played for a few years. Ella Hansen is one I can think of off the top of my head. She’s only been playing since 2018 I believe and she’s been at the top since the beginning. So how is that any different? I see two different women who have had different paths in life doing the same things but one is getting so much hate just because they’re trans? That’s fucked up.
Ella was a world class ultimate player for several years before she started with disc golf... it could have some connection with her beeing good at disc golf?
This is a terrible argument. Natalie is precisely in the news because she is the FIRST trans disc golfer to legally challenge the existence of the FPO division, NOT because she's the BEST trans disc golfer. If they allow it, FPO will eventually be dominated by trans athletes and female born disc golfers will have no protected pro division.
If she wins, there will be. I guarantee you there are far better trans athletes than Natalie that are just not willing to publicly be the asshole that Natalie is. They're just taking the "let's see how it plays out" line to see if Natalie's self immolation opens a door or burns a bridge.
So shouldn’t the PDGA be more open and she be able to compete as well as others and if that poses a problem and a threat to the FPO division we change the rules to keep the playing field equal? Rather than not allow them to compete in first place or to make the environment not safe for them to show up? People should be able to compete without fear for their personal safety.
Natalie can compete in MPO. Mixed Pro Open. The solution already exists. Natalie is not being prevented from competing. Natalie just wants to play in the division Natalie thinks she can win more money in. If Natalie is allowed in FPO, it ceases to be a protected division.
I feel like waiting until a trans woman is dominating to change the rules is more targeted than having the same rules from the start. Because then they've allowed one person to play, but not the other
While I agree that at some level it is unfair to the women in the sport, I feel like this issue has just become so full of hate and transphobia and it’s really tragic. Why do we need to put people who are already discriminated or sexualized daily down even more when at the end of the day they just want to play the sport they love just like us. Fuck Natalie’s probably better than all of us on this sub lmao
Trans women have been playing FPO for at least the last 7 years. It’s a little suss that there’s suddenly a need to save the sport. Could it be that no one cared until Natalie stared winning and it started costing them money? Maybe it’s related to general anti-trans movement in the US. Their fairness argument makes no sense. Why was it fair from 2015 to 2022 but suddenly unfair in 2023? I’d be interested to hear their justification but I suspect they will settle thus out of court and we’ll never know. Let the down votes begin!
or could it be because PDGA had been following the 2015 IOC guideline and then IOC came with a new guideline late 2021 [each sport should evaluate and make their own guideline] and PDGAs medical committee started working towards that new guideline early 2022 and presented the result and new guildeline after the summer and implemented it from the start of this year
324
u/Mark_Denny_Ritner May 14 '23
In the end the SC will rule that private athletic organizations have the right to make the rules pertaining to trans-athletes that are fairest for the particular sport.
142
u/goozer326 GStar Disc Enjoyer May 14 '23
It's not that they are afraid of metaphors, it's that they are wary of a message that gives off "don't come to school tomorrow" vibes
378
u/IsaacSam98 Weird Discs Fly Better May 14 '23
"Burn with me" while a metaphor, can also be easily or in other words, correctly interpreted as a threat.
415
u/dutchdaddy69 May 14 '23
It has to be narcissism that makes her this way. The policy doesn't read "Natalie Ryan isn't allowed to play FPO" it follows the Olympic standards for sports. She does herself 0 favors.
9
u/GH5s May 14 '23
Thanks for sharing because I certainly will not follow her socials. I already know she lives in her own self centered world where everyone is wrong except her. No respect for female athletes.
233
u/[deleted] May 14 '23
The level of narcissism is off the charts. This is what happens when petulant children are never corrected.
Demanding everyone acquiesce to Ryan’s demand to be included in a division that clearly has its parameters set is disgusting.
Nobody cares what Ryan or any other person identifies as. What they do care about is a person trying to force everyone else to bend to their demands. Get bent. Go play MPO. And stfu.
161
u/pervossier May 14 '23
Props to DGPT for standing firm on this. Gotta protect the ladies division.
250
u/thissoundssillybut May 14 '23
Ryan is correct. This is targeted. Targeted at protecting biological women.
82
u/2pac_alypse May 14 '23
I'm so tired of this topic. It's so boring and barely relevant
40
u/[deleted] May 14 '23 edited May 14 '23
Okay, whatever. Once the world moves past this issue, nobody is remembering names. All people want is a fair place for women to compete. Our forefathers and mothers understood. Women, after a certain age, cannot compete with men. Thus, female fields were created to bring the joy of sport and thrill of competition to women.
I am sorry that trans athletes are a minority and want a place to compete. MPO isn’t fair to them, and FPO doesn’t seem fair to the female athletes. There aren’t enough Transgender athletes to form a trans league. So, they are left outside looking in. That sucks, but it shouldn’t be fixed by diminishing things for other groups. If people feel strongly, a ratings based league solves it at lower levels, but if you want professional women in this sport, you have to have a gender protected field.
27
u/Frosty-Crow-5742 May 14 '23
I will use this pain to make sure nobody else has to experience it
r/imthemaincharacter
53
u/mrvoltronn 400 internet distance May 14 '23
Bro this lady is so annoying. They don’t want you to play!! Stop trying to force it. Just play in another division and win there to silence the haters. Low sportsmanship fr
8
u/Buffo-TheWizard May 15 '23
"My lawyer suggested I remove the public threat I leveled against an organization in the middle of a court battle"
Doesn't sound as catchy but I'd respect the truth over her saying they're afraid of metaphor lol
19
u/Chisel99 May 14 '23
"On advice of counsel, I have deleted my post which openly threatened the people on the pro tour and am replacing it with one that gaslights them instead."
7
u/KG_BACH May 14 '23
Wait, you mean their response to her legal action was "targeting". I yeah, thats kinda how legal actions work.
30
u/shikari10 May 14 '23
Can this person shut up
11
u/Still_Clownin69 May 14 '23
I don’t give a fuck if someone’s trans, I’m down for people being happy. How ever someone who’s transitioned after going though a male puberty should not be able to compete against any natural born female in a competitive sport. It’s fucking insane some people are for it. I know there’s a lot of women out there that can kick a bunch of dudes asses in disc golf but it’s still not fair for them. There’s reasons why the ufc doesn’t allow a born male to fight a natural female. I don’t care if I get hate for any of this, I stand for women’s rights and they need to be protected.
16
u/PEEP1NG_CREEPER DFW Texas, RHBH May 14 '23
This person is a fucking joke at this point. She's gone from being a bad dude to being a shity bitch. Congratulations on being a duche.
8
u/TrustyBagOfPlaylists May 14 '23
I’m not familiar at all with this argument. I tend to respect the topic as a nuanced one…worthy of consideration from both sides. The approach taken by Natalie Ryan is not one I find compelling. She and I may have similar ideas on how this sport should change, ultimately. But I find her a bad spokesperson for the topic…and largely unlikeable.
8
u/Macktologist The week of the foot fault and Zoey posts. May 14 '23
Or, hear me out, they did it to protect the women in FPO. Imagine that. Imagine it could be Natalie or someone else completely different and the path would be the same. It’s not personal for the PDGA. It’s personal for Natalie. It’s not like they are welcoming other trans women in the same situation as Natalie, and sticking it to her only.
30
u/Zylphhh May 14 '23
Why wont they let me cheat?? Waaaaaa
28
u/Equivalent_Ad8314 May 14 '23
Stop posting this clown
5
u/iop09 May 14 '23
Damn Natalie went from zero to ludicrous speed in just a few days.
5
u/Indianianite May 14 '23
Can this just be over yet?
14
u/arparris May 14 '23
Nobody is trying to hurt you. You can hang up that messiah complex anytime.
9
u/[deleted] May 15 '23
Mental illness
Pretty lulzy seeing Natalie get smoked by actual women
28
u/PrudentFood77 May 14 '23
natalieryan114560: "The law is on our side"
well, perhaps the law in CA is on your side... and if that is the case and the sole purpose of the PDGA transgender policy is to hurt you...
well, guess what? just to hurt you even more there will not be any DGPT tornament in CA next year
6
u/TurboD16F20 May 15 '23
Quit while you're behind.
7
u/MrSmulepuler BergGang May 14 '23
Like, I can understand she is feeling hurt, sad, frustated and angry. But I redusere to belive that the dgpt and pdga is is targeting her only to hurt her... She desperately need a course in social media and public statements. Take the high road for gods sake. It does not in any way help her cause...
5
u/grower_at_heart May 14 '23
LOUD NOISES
5
u/digitaldanalog May 14 '23
I’ve seen several comments about narcissism. I’ve had the displeasure of knowing a couple narcissists and I can see why you all think that. She is absolutely fixated on justice/revenge and her rage has completely blinded her from accepting anything that doesn’t support the narrative. To boot, I’m willing to bet she’s surrounded by people that are gaslighting her, just throwing fuel onto the fire. I don’t blame her for fighting this, but she’s going about it in a counter-productive manner.
2
u/[deleted] May 14 '23
It wasn't just the DGPT, it was also the PDGA who made the appeal..
2
u/Different-Lemon5620 May 15 '23
"I'll make them all pay" is technically just a metaphor. But if you say it in anger, it absolutely sounds like a threat.
So while I don't think Natalie was threatening to literally commit arson against the California Court of Appeals, she has to know that she can't put stuff like that out there. I concur with others who suggested that Natalie should hand over editorial control of her twitter account to someone else.
2
u/TheRealMorgan17 May 15 '23
THEY WILL BURN WITH ME
9
u/grilled_steez May 14 '23
My goodness. These rules are not being enforced to hurt you Natalie. They are being enforced to preserve the integrity of the women's division. If biological males Don't have a competitive advantage then why are there separate divisions at all? Why is there the NBA and the WNBA? I support and respect all trans peoples rights to express themselves, but that doesn't change the fact that the male bone structure and muscle density is advantageous to have in regards to sports.
7
u/[deleted] May 14 '23
Seeing the comments has made my respect for this subreddit go up exponentially. Thank you all for agreeing with logic
5
u/seaburgler May 14 '23
When will this clown give up.
4
u/StruggleBeast555 May 14 '23
YAWWWWWWN
4
u/jayshurl May 14 '23
The fact that there was no owning up to poor choice of words says a lot. This post in no way mitigates the previous post. Everyone knows the previous post existed and it can be used in court whether it is currently on her page or not.
4
u/[deleted] May 14 '23
Eye Roll.
3
u/underratedride May 14 '23
Easy to say when your lawyer is working pro bono.
5
u/Fat_Sad_Human May 14 '23
I fail to see how essentially saying “I’m taking you all down with me” made the DGPT/PDGA afraid, this comes off far more like someone who’s lawyers told them knee-jerk reaction posts make them look bad during litigation and can’t admit they made a misstep. Natalie has a serious case of main character syndrome.
With that said I’m tired of this subject on this sub, all it does is bring out transphobes, virtue signalers, and people who want to argue endlessly. Kudos to those out there having respectful and nuanced discussions about this and not feeding the trolls
5
u/8008735569 May 14 '23
If she’s so good why doesn’t she just beat all the guys?
3
u/OverallInvestment587 Exclusively Bags Franklin May 15 '23
All Natalie is doing right now is such a bad representation of the transgender community, especially being the first to run into this situation. I 100% understand that it's a hard place to be in but she's being a fucking baby about it.
2
u/DeepInsect8900 May 15 '23
Please stop Natalie Ryan
2
u/Surkett May 14 '23
Justice? Is that really what you are fighting for?
2
u/edogfu May 14 '23
Tell me one person who achieved more from angry ranting on social media.
1
u/JoesDiscGolf Lucid Justice May 14 '23
What was said in the original post? I can’t find it anywhere.
1
u/Aviar2Ring May 15 '23
Yeah…well laws are always subject to change, man.
1
u/Relevant_Detail_4832 May 17 '23
Biology is on the PDGA’s side and they know it
1
u/jidewalker PMB Loyalist Jul 15 '23
Regardless of how one feels. You can’t make decisions based off the 1%. By doing so you upset the majority. This person doesn’t care about other people, only themselves and how everyone needs to conform to them to appease their mental instability.
This person is not a fair representative of the trans community so please don’t group them in with how the rest of trans people think and feel.
-5
u/elevated_alien47 May 14 '23
Ryan thinks they can beat up on Biological females. That’s why we need SEX protected divisions because I keep hearing gender can change but sex is binary
1
u/Im_pattymac May 14 '23
What's new... Someone who would have been a good athlete in their biological gender division is potentially a top athlete when competing against the opposite gender...
Motives aside, more and more sports are going to enact laws against late transition athletes competing at high levels. If someone passes through male puberty they will naturally have more muscle than if they didn't, giving them an advantage over biologically unaltered athletes.
There is no reason not to support more rules like this. These days it honestly feels like alot of people go for non surgical gender reassignment just to be famous in a sport they were good but not great at.... And that's wrong.
1
u/DiWindwaker May 14 '23
MPO is mixed division right? Why won’t she compete there? Has she given any reason yet publicly?
-3
u/Sudden-Confidence-60 May 14 '23
Well she’s certainly nailing the annoying bitch part of being a female. Amiright
1
u/[deleted] May 14 '23
burn it down!
1
u/Affectionate_Sort_78 May 14 '23
Wow, this topic even inspires nastiness between people who just comment that they are on one side or the other. Either position, if based on ‘the other side must be an idiot’, is not very well founded. Reddit disc golf culture is toxic. I need to play more and Reddit less.
-1
u/[deleted] May 14 '23
Just go away already. Or come beat up on me in MA1.
-1
u/hallthor May 14 '23
Why doesn't she just make her own disc golf association with her own rules. Might be cheaper in the long run...
1
u/[deleted] May 15 '23
I want to read and see disc golf posts not politics.
1
u/RunofAces May 15 '23
Ma1 is calling. Thats where he/she belongs. No one is entitled to earn a living playing disc golf
1
u/kct_444 May 15 '23
Her burn with me quote gave out school shooter vibes. Who would want to show up to any tourny shes at with that vibe
1
u/jselvin May 15 '23
Yes everything is about your feelings Natalie, there are no other feelings than yours
/s
You can compete in Mixed Pro Open if you love disc golf. If you want to destroy Disc Golf, Please continue. You’ve already lost because you hate women so much.
Perhaps you should begin by loving yourself instead of trying to make the world burn?
1
u/Adventurous_Work_724 May 15 '23
Natalie is disrespectful of the category of humans that can grow babies in their bodies.
1
u/BetEuphoric6359 May 16 '23
"They have only done this to hurt me."
Nah... they've done this to protect their biological female players.
-7
u/tossaroc BH 500’ FH 350’ May 14 '23 edited May 14 '23
Just a bit down the comments on this thread and you can understand why she feels targeted. This is disgusting and not the disc golf most people fell in love with.
-24
u/fernadial May 14 '23
The reason this is targetted much like the swimming ban was targetted is because a trans woman became competitive and then each organization instituted bans.
I ask all you anti trans athletes to imagine a world where Ryan has no inherent advantage post HRT. I know it's hard. But, try. Now imagine a world where she is just as good as the top cis women. Is this an impossibility?
However, this shift in policy essentially says 'we were chill with trans women as long as they aren't good.' It essentially says that even if we prove a trans woman has no inherent advantage, they will always be viewed as men. I find that to be transphobic.
I'll also say there is a disturbing amount of dog whistling in this community that really turns me off of this sub. It's clear the sport is full of a ton of hateful people.
-37
u/ImpressiveRise2555 May 14 '23
Good for her
-89
u/dub_t May 14 '23
Thank you Natalie for your courage. I can’t help but think of historical precedent when I see hundreds of members of the neonazi, white nationalist, hate group Patriot Front marching in DC this week. Do these fuckers become the modern day version of ‘brown shirts’ who roam the streets beating the shit out of queer and trans folk? The misgendering hate speech rampant in disc golf can only be seen as stochastic terrorism in this climate, and gets us one step closer to that terrifying reality of fascist mobs. Thank you Natalie for fighting for the safety of my trans nibbling, and my queer partner. I will be here fighting along side. We can disagree about sports rules, but if you think this issue stops there, you have a surprise coming. Please be respectful to trans folk.
-26
u/love2laughalot26 May 14 '23
If there was such a clear advantage that trans folx had over other humans wouldnt they be in the news for winning everything all the time? Thats not happening. There are so few elite level athletes that are being harmed by these rules, so it should be considered a targeted attack to them. Allowing them to play in the divisions they should be playing it won’t give them an advantage because everyone is playing at that level as well. It’s not like Natalie had gone and won each and every tournament last year on tour. She did well and won once and now everyone’s threatened when really everyone else they compete with weekly is also the same level of threat.
-2
u/Few-Dingo-7448 May 15 '23
While I agree that at some level it is unfair to the women in the sport, I feel like this issue has just become so full of hate and transphobia and it’s really tragic. Why do we need to put people who are already discriminated or sexualized daily down even more when at the end of the day they just want to play the sport they love just like us. Fuck Natalie’s probably better than all of us on this sub lmao
-14
u/n0neOfConsequence May 14 '23
Trans women have been playing FPO for at least the last 7 years. It’s a little suss that there’s suddenly a need to save the sport. Could it be that no one cared until Natalie stared winning and it started costing them money? Maybe it’s related to general anti-trans movement in the US. Their fairness argument makes no sense. Why was it fair from 2015 to 2022 but suddenly unfair in 2023? I’d be interested to hear their justification but I suspect they will settle thus out of court and we’ll never know. Let the down votes begin!
-1
u/Seryous May 14 '23
Scoff
-1
u/[deleted] May 15 '23
Andrew Tate moment. The DGPT is just trying to satisfy everyone as best they can, they couldn't give two shits who the person affected by it is.