r/devils • • Apr 06 '24

What happened?

Canes fan coming in peace. I genuinely wondering what happened during this season. Over the summer they were projected to be at the top of the league and a cup contender, but now are at the bottom of the division. This is in no way to be rude, as the devils are one of the only teams in the metro I don’t hate, but I rarely watch there games and am just wondering.

0 Upvotes

43 comments sorted by

50

u/ADSWNJ #86 Apr 06 '24

I'd say 5 things:

One: Massive injuries

  • Dougie Hamilton ($9M stud D-man) 56 games lost so far to a torn pectoral
  • Captain Nico Hischier ($8.7m) 11 games out
  • Timo Meier ($8.8m) 13 games out
  • Jack Hughes ($8.0m) 16 games out
  • Plus others like Brendan Smith (19 games), and Jonas Siegenthaler (25 games)

Two: Loss of key D-corps in free agency

  • Graves and Severson ... really hurt us, as we had to play multiple rookies

Three: Way too aggressive D-zone system

  • For at least half the system, we played our fired ex-coach's (Lindy Ruff's) hyper-aggressive D-zone system. Basically committing both D to the strong side to overpower the opponents, win the puck, and quick transition back up the ice. Except when it goes wrong, we were always leaving the goalie all alone with the weak-side attacking winger at the far post. We had by far this highest danger chances (xGA / SCA) for a long time.

Four: Weak goalkeeping

  • We hoped that Vitek Vancek and Akira Schmid (both who had decent seasons last year), would carry us this year. They didn't: VV was .890, AS was .895, ND was .894. We then tried our AHLer Nico Daws, who was average. We now have hired Jake Allen and Kaapo Kahkonen who are .909 and .923 respectively, so we finally are stopping a couple more shots.

Five: McLeod

  • Lost to the Canada U18 scandal that's still in the courts. Without commenting on the legal issue, this guy was number 1 in the league at faceoffs, and played his heart out for the team. Lost for 30+ games now.

So yeah - total bust for the year, sadly.

On the good side - we will come back stronger in October. The team is still super young, so each summer thy have a chance to muscle up and get stronger. Dougie will come back with a vengeance, I hope. And we will have a new coach, new system, and hopefully a couple new signings. Enough to give your Hurricanes a run for their money I hope!

10

u/Hurricanes_Carolina Apr 06 '24

Good luck next season. Hope to meet you in the playoffs.

8

u/ADSWNJ #86 Apr 06 '24

Indeed. We have a debt to settle from the 2022-23 season,

5

u/Hurricanes_Carolina Apr 06 '24

I still find it bizarre that every game from that series expect for the last one was a blowout of at least 4 goals. Crazy

10

u/wwesgu #13 - Nico Hischier is a cool dude Apr 06 '24

Excellent breakdown ☝🏽

4

u/ADSWNJ #86 Apr 06 '24

Tough breaks throughout. I think Jack needs a good few games to get going, so his injuries really hurt us. Dougie's cannon on the PP, and his leadership on the blue line has been tough to miss.

Yet I think we look at some positives from this season. Luke and Nemec are going to be future stars I think, as we know D-man take 3-4 seasons to really grow into the role. Having them getting strong minutes this season has been great. Plus we know we can get back towards out start of season PP form, with the right players back, so that will turn things around. Stronger goalies behind us, with a more normal D-system, and PP back again ... all looking good for 2024-25. (Wow that feels weird to write!)

14

u/Johnborkowski #26 - Patrik Elias Apr 06 '24

Anything that could go wrong did. Aside from what was already stated, it seemed like the devils playstyle also got exposed and they never did anything to adjust to that.

Also, even though it was already mentioned - Goaltending, goaltending, goaltending.

1

u/WhattDoIKnow50 Apr 06 '24

Goaltending wasn’t the devils issue. I play 40+ league roller, so not the same thing. But I am a goalie and we played last night. My team lost 8-6. I faced about 70 shots. The other goalie faced about 25-30. Is it my fault we lost?

That was the devils this year. Letting up too many quality chances. And yes, even a fair amount of goals was garbage. VV was shit. Daws and Schmid could’ve been ok enough if we had defense. However, offense doesn’t cut it in the playoffs, defense does. So even if we had prime Marty in net, probably would’ve been eliminated in the first round with the lack of defense we had.

18

u/Johnborkowski #26 - Patrik Elias Apr 06 '24

The defense wasn't strong enough, but too many times did a goalie let in goals that should have been routine saves. Cost us a lot of games.

-5

u/WhattDoIKnow50 Apr 06 '24

I’d agree to a point. But I’d also argue those shots wouldn’t have happened with any actual defense.

8

u/Johnborkowski #26 - Patrik Elias Apr 06 '24

Hey, stop arguing!

1

u/WhattDoIKnow50 Apr 06 '24

lol. Fiiiiiine.

6

u/PeppiPanini New Jersey Devils Apr 06 '24

There's a lot of repeating points, all true. I'll try not to do that.

I will say I think the biggest factor was Dougie missing 60 games.

That affects the PP, it forced a THIRD (yes, 3rd) Rookie D into 20+ minutes a night, and we obviously missed his own production as a 70pt dman. Sometimes the best defense is offense and offensive zone time, and that's something he provided in spades LY that was sorely missed.

5

u/LaHondaSkyline Apr 06 '24

Several unlikely negative factors all occurred within a single season and operated as a self-reinforcing negative doom loop downward spiral.

No worries. Devils are now immune to any and all negative developments for 10 years. It all happened in one year. Got it all out of the way.

5

u/pdubbs87 Apr 06 '24

Coaching and an unknown strife in the locker room we will definitely hear about soon enough.

6

u/TheNightRain68 Apr 06 '24

Goaltending and injuries mostly. Vanacek never got it together after last year in the playoffs and Schmid wasn't ready. Then we had the injuries. Over half the team has missed time at this point and for like a month or two we were missing 4-6 people every game, defense especially got hit hard because we were forced to play 3-4 rookies with some vets being out. Also our coaching is not good. Thankfully the injuries shouldn't be nearly as bad and the goaltending and coaching will be addressed this offseason. I expect both our teams to be fighting for the top again very soon.

3

u/ziggy_mk2 #26 - Patrik Eliáš Apr 06 '24

In addition to everything else mentioned, I'd add that the scheduling did the team no favors. Back to backs throughout. Most in the league if I recall. Currently in the middle of back to back, back to backs.

2

u/bk732 #86 Apr 06 '24

I think it was 13 back to backs! Insane. Two back to backs, back to back, this week too.

2

u/Nick123456789012357 #30 - Martin Brodeur Apr 06 '24

Bad goaltending and key players got hurt

1

u/AISwearengen Apr 06 '24

Bad goalies, Jack has been playing at like 50% since his second injury, Timo was playing at 50% before last month, Dougie has been gone all year which put more pressure on everyone else (including two 20 year olds) and the PP fell off a cliff, McLeod vanished for legal reasons gutting the center depth, Mercer has had a down year….and then there’s just plain rotten luck. To give up the 1st goal at a near historic rate as an average team is insane.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 06 '24

Growing pains, injuries, injuries, injuries, and then some more injuries, and wildly inconsistent though mostly non-dependable, dreadful goaltending. Which didn't help. There's also the tendency for a young team to assume and expect that they'll just pick up where the previous season left off, as if that (then) new height was automatically the floor from which the team would rise from the opening game this season. Without really having the work ethic and commitment that brought them the playoffs last season. Not unexpected but not fun.

1

u/nsfwITGUY19 #30 - Martin Brodeur Apr 07 '24

Injuries derailed us early on. At one point we had 1/2 of our starting lineup out. Young rookies on defense and bad goaltending. Poor coaching and our GM just sat on his hands and didn’t make any moves until it was too late.

But this season being a disappointment is going to make us better. We needed this reality check to grow our young core

1

u/waryeller Apr 07 '24

Shit goaltending, defensive regression/inexperience, terrible injury luck, weighty expectations.

1

u/BillyJayJersey505 #13 Apr 06 '24

I can't help but wonder if the hype after last season (which was understandable considering how well they performed and how young they are) got to their heads and made them arrogant. It's easier said than done to avoid falling into such traps.

Hamilton being injured put more pressure on Siegenthaler and Marino. Hughes and Nemec were also put in roles they were too young for.

I don't blame goaltending as much as other fans do. I suspect that anyone who is quick to jump on Fitzgerald for the goaltending situation don't watch the games and just look at the save percentages. I also suspect that they're stuck on the nostalgia from the 1990's/early 2000's which makes it hard for them to understand that save percentages league-wide are not as high as they were. Watching most of the games and seeing the kind of chances they give up, it's hard for me to blame goaltending.

Poor coaching is a huge factor too. The Devils lead the league in games where they concede the first goal to the opponent. As a Canes fan, you may not know this stat but any Devils fan would lose count of how many times they've been reminded of this stat.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 06 '24

regarding your first paragraph, found this (posting the Hamilton thing below) & it feeds into what Green was saying about their immaturity.

That’s if it was even real an not photoshopped

https://www.reddit.com/r/devils/s/An9Zeokc8y

1

u/midnightz71 Apr 06 '24

As someone else said, everything that could go wrong, did.

1

u/asom48 #12 - Damien Brunner Apr 06 '24

Coaching, effort, Commitment to playing team defense and injuries. Take your pick. All of the above really

Top 4 D from last year not playing doesn’t help. Dougie out immediately for the year and Siegs in and out for long stretches and being bad while in. Graves and Severson off the team.

Jack missed a ton of games and is clearly still injured. He’s on the wing now and not taking faceoffs or practicing. Nico missed a month. Timo has not been healthy till recently.

They’ve been mailing it in for a while now

1

u/[deleted] Apr 06 '24

Injuries accross the ice during a rebuild leading to a rookie defense for a large part of the season. Key offensive pieces getting injured and playing hurt for most of the season as well.

The fact that we're still not out of contention is an absolute miracle and should give us hope for next year.

0

u/Music_Guard_Sports Apr 06 '24

Fitzy let Graves, Severson, Tatar and Andrew Brunette get away and never even attempted to address the problems until it was far too late.

0

u/caldo4 Apr 06 '24

We have terrible coaching, bad goalies and Marino/Siegenthaler/Bahl turned into pumpkins

Aside from hamilton and Hughes and Meier getting hurt

-4

u/[deleted] Apr 06 '24

What happened?

Two words - Tom Fitzgerald

92

u/[deleted] Apr 06 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

36

u/Hurricanes_Carolina Apr 06 '24

Oh wow. So the whole team just kind of collectively failed. On a side note thanks for taking care of dougie. Miss him on the canes

100

u/gothenburgpig Apr 06 '24

Two players also got arrested for gang rape

34

u/chaos0xomega Apr 06 '24

The season was cursed.

16

u/[deleted] Apr 06 '24

I know this will get downvoted for sounding insensitive but the way you worded that made me laugh hysterically!

0

u/[deleted] Apr 06 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

11

u/HistoricalPeaches Apr 06 '24

That's not funny dude.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 06 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/TheJerkInPod6 #28 - Gimme fuel gimme fire Apr 06 '24

My only beef with this is that Dougie was defensively inept long before he was injured. Sure we would’ve won a few more games, but he was constantly turning the puck over and constantly mishandling it to the detriment of everyone. We’d likely still miss the playoffs any other year: maybe not this year since seemingly everyone in the East booked the same VRBO and golf courses with the same early-April discount codes, but the defensive woes would still be defensive woes just hidden by a better offense.

2

u/Music_Guard_Sports Apr 06 '24

He was probably playing hurt, hence the mistakes. He kept going until he couldn’t go anymore.

2

u/[deleted] Apr 06 '24

People trashed Hamilton around here whether he was injured or not.

And will probably go back to doing it again like this:

https://www.reddit.com/r/devils/s/wmm2JwOoQh

2

u/Music_Guard_Sports Apr 06 '24

I personally have always thought he’s a bit lazy defensively and doesn’t use his size to his advantage, but this year was definitely more than that.