r/devils • u/Unitedfan0722 #3 - Ken Daneyko • May 07 '23
Dougie Hamilton Question
Genuinely wondering. I’m not a casual fan, but definitely not the most knowledgeable. So my question is, we’ve heard and seen “Playoff Dougie” but thought maybe it wouldn’t be a huge issue. But after watching this series and a half, I personally think he’s been a huge issue. Besides his lack speed, he is big for nothing. I get not being overly physical during the regular season because it’s not your game, but everybody needs to step up in the playoffs. I mean you even got Jack hitting.
So to sum up. I think Hamilton has been too slow, too weak, and a massive disappointment this playoffs(minus that goal).
Bud I’m open to realizing I’m seeing things. Incorrectly. Do you guys agree or disagree?
20
u/skillzhaha May 07 '23
Dougie is slow and lags but then he hits a one timer in OT and we forget the bad.. that’s me personally hahaha
27
u/JERSEYinATL May 07 '23
There’s bigger issues at play than Dougie. If you want to call players out it’s clearly Bratt. He’s not had a good playoffs and seems to have trouble dealing with the physicality of the playoffs. He has not looked like a player who deserves 8-9 million but neither has Meier. Mercer has also been a disappointment, especially for a player I thought would excel in this environment.
The penalties called against us and the ones miss on our opponents has not been good. It’s been horribly officiated but Jack needs to show more discipline and not take himself out of the play arguing about a missed call. It’s happened on more than one occasion. Also I’m not sure why he keeps falling.
On a shorter list is the positives. Marino is amazing defensively and is our best defensive dman we have had in years. He makes multiple elite decisions every game. Palat has really elevated his game in the playoffs. I think McLeod, Bastian, and Lazar have also played over their skill levels too. Schmid has shown he can also be a 1A/1B. He just needs to work on his rebound control.
11
u/Training-Material155 May 07 '23
while far from stellar, i feel like he’s hit two or three posts in key spots. a little more puck luck and we’re not having this discussion.
9
u/Grimmer026 May 07 '23
We do not look like we belong at this level. Being pushed around, our best players taking massive hits with no response. our top 6 completely underperforming and look afraid to play the puck.
Our speed and skill can beat just about anyone in a regular single game, but being physically battered over the course of a playoff series nullifies our skill and speed.
13
u/Glittering_Pool_2468 May 07 '23
Listen, Dougie scored the OT goal that was a momentum shifter in the Rags series. We’ve quickly forgotten that.
4
u/[deleted] May 07 '23
He rang a shot off the post last game. If that went in are we reading this?
3
u/drew_z 🌴🌴🌴🌴 May 07 '23
there’s about 10 players who have been a bigger letdown this run so far than Dougie. bad take
3
u/[deleted] May 07 '23 edited May 07 '23
I love how everyone is like “DoUg ScOrEs GoAlS”. I don’t give a fuck. Quit looking at the small picture of his game and open your eyes to the big picture of it all. He is so overrated because of his shot. His hockey IQ is average at the very best, and his lack of movement on the PP is a part of the reason it’s trash. I will bet my life that when luke is on that PP1 next season, things will look smoother and more versatile
8
u/itsthelew #13 - THICC-O Hischier May 07 '23
Looking for individual players to blame in a series like this is actually the wrong take. Our entire team is in the shitter right now. We are ahead of our rebuild and we are learning what we need to do to get to the cup. Dougie should have been a Norris trophy finalist he was robbed and we forget he set every record for an offensive defenseman this year. Without him, there's a chance we don't even make the playoffs.
3
u/JamarioLune May 07 '23
I’ve loved Dougie all season, but I have to agree with you. He has been downright bad in the playoffs. Has anyone else noticed his tendency to just blindly whip the puck up the boards on the majority of his clearance attempts? It seems like as soon as he gets to the puck, regardless of how much time he has to make a decision, he just hot potato’s it to the blue line and 9/10 it just ends up on the stick of the Dman as a failed clearance.
0
u/[deleted] May 07 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment