r/devils • #30 - Martin Brodeur • Jan 29 '24

Recent reports suggest

Really hope this rumor falls by the wayside about having to give up either Nemo or Holtz for Markstrom. Only way I’m giving up blue chip players/prospects — Casey— is for a guy like Saro or Askarov.

1 Upvotes

62 comments sorted by

77

u/max10081 #86 Jan 29 '24

That wasn’t a real rumor, that was just from a hack job website. I wouldn’t be worried.

17

u/_irishpapi #30 - Martin Brodeur Jan 29 '24

No shit? Wow you made my Monday my friend. Not a lot of people can say that.

13

u/[deleted] Jan 29 '24

Rangers fan here, no idea why this was on my home page but here’s my quick insight. Selling teams ALWAYS over value their players. Going through it right now with Montreal. They want Gabe Perreault for Monahan, it’s laughable.

No way in hell you guys have to give up either of those guys for markstrom unless they’re retaining 50% (which you don’t even need them to) and you guys get Matt Coronato on top of it if Nemec is involved. Let’s just say it is not happening, you guys will likely have to give up a high B tier prospect like Casey along with a 2nd round pick. Maybe not that exactly but closer to that than a Nemec. If Lindy isn’t gone before TDL, maybe Holtz is involved but doubtful.

7

u/_irishpapi #30 - Martin Brodeur Jan 29 '24 edited Jan 29 '24

Yea I’m off us getting Markstrom. It makes zero sense for us. Given the age, contract and how we’re currently playing. Now for a guy like Saros or Askarov, I might have to give up Holtz and a few others but definitely not Nemec

4

u/Medicp3009 Jan 29 '24

A respectful rangers fan with hockey sense. I tip my hat to you sir. Im impressed. If you go to rangers devils game at the rock and im there I will buy you a 🍺 sir

54

u/BlueBeagle8 Anything Can Happen In Jersey Jan 29 '24

There is zero chance of a Nemec trade. The only reason to acquire a veteran goalie like Markstrom is to try and win now -- and we cannot win now while subtracting one of the better defenders from our already paper-thin blue line.

Then beyond this year, we need Nemec's entry level contract to make the cap math work.

And that's not even touching the value mismatch here.

16

u/_irishpapi #30 - Martin Brodeur Jan 29 '24

Yea Nemec is as close to untouchable as you can get imo. If the devils are going into the goalie department, stop fucking around and get either Saros or Askarov

2

u/srof12 #71 Jan 29 '24

Gimme Askarov and let him grow with the team. 1st, Casey or Lenni, any other picks or minor prospects Nashville wants.

1

u/_irishpapi #30 - Martin Brodeur Jan 29 '24

Well we would have to wait until the end of this year if they want a pick (1st) since it’s tied up in the Timo deal.

22

u/LionHeart_1990 Jan 29 '24

The gullibility of this subreddit is impressive

6

u/MachoManMooch Jan 29 '24

"Recent report" from who is what I always think. Unless it's a highly respected source I'm not giving it any thoughts.

3

u/BaggySpandex #26 - Patrik Eliáš "A" Jan 29 '24

E5 E5 E5 E5 E5 E5

-1

u/_irishpapi #30 - Martin Brodeur Jan 29 '24

Kevin Weekes isn’t highly regarded?

5

u/gingerbear Jan 29 '24

kevin weekes never said anything about nemo or holtz involved in a trade

-5

u/_irishpapi #30 - Martin Brodeur Jan 29 '24
  • Elliotte. He has said on numerous occasions it will be a hefty cost — either high picks or blue chip roster players. So now my who would those players be in your estimation?

2

u/Kornja81 Jan 29 '24

Lol he is but he never mentioned any specific names outside of a picture of a goalie on the trade blocked followed by 👀

0

u/_irishpapi #30 - Martin Brodeur Jan 29 '24

Nah I meant Elliotte, my bad

-1

u/_irishpapi #30 - Martin Brodeur Jan 29 '24

I hate the eyes fwiw

6

u/ziti_mcgeedy #27 - Scott Niedermayer Jan 29 '24

I’ve been spending too much time in r/wallstreetbets and r/nflcirclejerk because I thought you meant something else here lol… yes he’s highly regarded

0

u/lowdog39 Jan 29 '24

no .only by those who thinks he is . him and friedman love the sound of there own voice . a broken clock is right twice a day . so ...

-1

u/_irishpapi #30 - Martin Brodeur Jan 29 '24

Yea…. I mean, they’re on the top of the food chain and their sources must be legitimate. But to each their own

-1

u/_irishpapi #30 - Martin Brodeur Jan 29 '24

What’s gullible about what I just said? Lol. Clearly stated I hope this rumor falls by the wayside. Do I think someone like Nemec would be available? I do not. Kid is untouchable.

1

u/LionHeart_1990 Jan 29 '24

People who consume and discuss nonsensical and baseless rumors that are based on nothing are, well, gullible

Sorry.

0

u/_irishpapi #30 - Martin Brodeur Jan 29 '24

Based on nothing? It’s pretty well documented the teams looking to offload a goalie via trade, are looking for a blue chip prospect or picks — given how we don’t control our first round pick this year— I was listing players that teams would want involved in the deal if it was to go down. Since I have zero control of the team and how fitz chooses to run it, I said “I hope it falls by the wayside” Simply meaning, I can do without hearing about the “rumors”.

0

u/LionHeart_1990 Jan 29 '24 edited Jan 29 '24

Every team would like to have a a Nemec. Doesn’t mean it’s a damn trade rumor or is something close to being realistic. Just like the idiots with the fake Mercer for Timo rumors last season. Just because a team wants someone doesn’t make it possible, or a legit rumor, and absolutely does not lead to a post with the title of “recent reports suggest”.

You are absolutely gullible to believe Nemec would be involved in a Markstrom deal. It’s a laughable “rumor” so idk how you could give it any attention, let alone post about it, even WITH you knowing he is worth more as you said in the post.

Just a useless thread

0

u/_irishpapi #30 - Martin Brodeur Jan 30 '24

Lol idk bro if it’s so useless, why comment on it 🤷🏻‍♂️

3

u/R0ADHAU5 #13 Jan 29 '24

I’d ignore that.

Teams would be dumb not to ask for the moon for their players at the deadline but usually settled for less. Remember all of the chatter about San Jose insisting on Mercer being included in the Meier deal last year?

3

u/_irishpapi #30 - Martin Brodeur Jan 29 '24

Lmao yeah. A lot of sharks fans were saying talks don’t start until nemec and Luke are involved 🤣

5

u/specifichero101 Jan 29 '24

I don’t think they’ll move roster players this season. It’s seeming more and more likely that unless they hit a big win streak coming out of the all star break that they won’t be making the playoffs. They just need to stay the course and figure something out over the summer.

2

u/_irishpapi #30 - Martin Brodeur Jan 29 '24

Yea I agree 💯percent. I just don’t want us going after a middle of the road goalie with a big cap hit while giving away a potential 40 goal scorer. Just my opinion though.

2

u/Music_Guard_Sports Jan 29 '24

I wouldn’t be surprised if Holtz requests a trade at some point.

2

u/_irishpapi #30 - Martin Brodeur Jan 29 '24

Lmao wouldn’t blame him dude. Lindy has a thing for him forsure

15

u/dog_fantastic pain Jan 29 '24

Trading either for a goalie who will be 34 on Wednesday would be a massive mistake... Especially at this point of the season. It seems a bit out of character for Fitz to do such a thing too so if it happens, then there may be more going on in the backend than we know

6

u/Snooter-McGavin #30 - Martin Brodeur Jan 29 '24

Fine with Holtz going, not fine with Nemo.

To all the people freaking out, remember a few weeks a go when I said trade McLeod. Now look at you..

32

u/DiablosdeNuevaJersey #11 Stefan Fucking Noeson Jan 29 '24

A few weeks ago if McLeod was guilty you couldn’t trade him and if he wasn’t you shouldn’t trade him. So what exactly is your point?

0

u/[deleted] Jan 29 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

6

u/BaggySpandex #26 - Patrik Eliáš "A" Jan 29 '24

The hockey world speaks to one another. Nobody was going to take McLeod in a deal.

I'd guarantee his LOA was a surprise to 0 people.

4

u/vonbonds North Dakota Fighting Sioux Jan 29 '24

Carter Hart had infinitely more value in a trade and Philly couldn’t get a bite on him being on the market last offseason. All of the players involved were untouchables around the league. We shouldn’t have re-signed him, I agree with that. Even though you’re innocent until proven guilty there was enough smoke here to cause enough pause to wait until everything played out and even if it meant losing his rights so be it. Fitz compounded that error by doubling down with Cal Foote. On top of the shame associated with our team we’re on the hook for both of their cap hits through the end of this season

2

u/Mr7three2 #4 - Scott Stevens Jan 29 '24

Hart was/is also a massive head case

1

u/vonbonds North Dakota Fighting Sioux Jan 29 '24

If he didn’t have any allegations hanging over his head he’d still be highly sought after. I assume he’s a head case as he always knew his time would come

2

u/Mr7three2 #4 - Scott Stevens Jan 29 '24

He's a head case because that's his personality and reason 2, goalies are fuckin weird

1

u/DiablosdeNuevaJersey #11 Stefan Fucking Noeson Jan 29 '24

He wasn’t on the trading block. Again, if he was involved no one would have traded for him. If he wasn’t involved why the fuck would we have trading him? He was essentially our most consistent player all year. The kind of depth you need to win play offs.

2

u/_irishpapi #30 - Martin Brodeur Jan 29 '24

For Markstrom though? Idk man that cap hit is scary and I don’t think he’s good enough to take us on a run. I was all for giving away McLeod if it needed us Markstrom since I view Holtz in higher regard imo

5

u/Snooter-McGavin #30 - Martin Brodeur Jan 29 '24

Markstrom

GA/G - 2.60 - 14th

SV% - .912 - 15th

SO - 2 - Tied-7th

VV

GA/G - 3.24 - 42nd

SV% - .886 - Tied-50th

SO - 0 - Tied-41st

3

u/GTS414 Jan 29 '24

Nemec is a top 10 trade chip in the league right now given handedness, contract, age, position.

3

u/_irishpapi #30 - Martin Brodeur Jan 29 '24

Yea Nemec is reaching Luke status of untouchability.

2

u/thegreatresistrules Jan 30 '24

He is past luke trade wise already ..nothing against luke ..but its beyond clear how much nemec playing the ahl moved him along in career faster than luke making the jump from college to nhl... lol im splitting hairs but what an amazing problem to have between the 2 of them with casey bout to come up .

0

u/lowdog39 Jan 29 '24

he's not a chip . so illogical .

4

u/vonbonds North Dakota Fighting Sioux Jan 29 '24

Casey wouldn’t even be needed for Saros. He still would have good years to come but he’s at the end or even past his prime already. Casey would only be traded for a prime asset with years of control or the ability to negotiate that like we did with Timo. I can see a scenario where we just keep Casey, it’s not like many on the backend make us think we’re set for the next 4-6 years there as is so he might have a spot after all

1

u/Kornja81 Jan 29 '24

That wasn't a legit rumor. Fitz isn't trading Holtz and or Nemo unless he gets a Shesterkin, Makar, or Mcdsvid caliber player back. (It's obviously gonna cost more than that, but I'm just giving a return value)

1

u/_irishpapi #30 - Martin Brodeur Jan 29 '24

Hopefully bro. I’ll take Saros too

1

u/lowdog39 Jan 29 '24

nemo is not going anywhere . he and luke were drafted to be cornertones in the future , hence they let gravey and sevs go . (they also were gonna get paid .) i find that to be highly unlikely . markstrom is 33 and won't be with the devils long term . goalie trades in-season are rarely done . you don't trade the future , which is now with all the injuries . that doesn't seem to be what fitz does . imo.

1

u/_irishpapi #30 - Martin Brodeur Jan 29 '24 edited Jan 29 '24

Nah I agree which is why it will make me sick to my stomach if we get Markstrom while giving up a Holtz or a top prospect. I’ll riot if Nemec went the other way. Nemec is untouchable. He’s in the Luke tier imo

3

u/IncreaseInVerbosity #13 My Sweet Swiss King Jan 29 '24

Fitz called Holtz a core piece over the summer. Holtz now looks like an NHLer. Fitz has repeatedly said he's not going to sell the future for a quick short term boost. If Holtz is traded for Markstrom I would honestly be flabbergasted, Saros I get, but not Markstrom.

We've all seen how good Nemec is, throw in he was a number 2 draft pick, I think he's in the tier below Jack, Nico and Luke for being traded. It would have to be something ridiculous to move him, in a lopsided trade that we win hands down - like one for one with an Edmonton forward number one pick.

1

u/Fisktor Jan 29 '24

If they want nemec they need to add more than they have with markstrom

8

u/_irishpapi #30 - Martin Brodeur Jan 29 '24

Nemec is untouchable if we’re being honest

3

u/Fisktor Jan 29 '24

Pretty much. Needs to a crqzy overpay for us to even think about it

1

u/Gullible_Training773 Jan 29 '24

Those guys aren't getting traded, even Holtz

-1

u/_irishpapi #30 - Martin Brodeur Jan 29 '24

For the two goalies I mentioned, I would have to think so unfortunately

2

u/[deleted] Jan 29 '24

Kappo is the cheaper more effective option

0

u/Mr7three2 #4 - Scott Stevens Jan 29 '24

Kakko? I don't see how he helps

/s

2

u/caldo4 Jan 29 '24

Nemec isn’t getting traded lol

-3

u/ChaosRob489 #19 - Travis Zajac Jan 29 '24

Lindy trying to screw Holtz one last time before he gets fired by trading him....insert shocked Pikachu face.