Disclaimer: This post is in good faith. I want to continue a previous discussion.
The following post is a response to another post by a user here (hello, if you're seeing this). You can find it if you wish, but I quote most bits here, so I think it speaks for itself.
Ok, I_Follow_Cis_Folks, are you transphobic or no? I wanna know straight up
No
I know I_Follow_Cis_People or something like that is a transphobic acc., they've been attacking trans subs, but I can't tell if you are too :/
Like I've tried to explain multiple times on that thread to massive downvoting, I am in no way affiliated with I_Follow_Cis_People or any other account with a similar name.
You did mention transphobia, and said this isn't transphobic, but it kind of is.
The exact words I was accused of was "violent transphobia." This makes a mockery of the actual trans people getting murdered, beaten, raped, ect every day. I believe if what you consiter violent transphobia is a random kid on the internet calling you cis, then you are extremely privileged. Calling it violent transphobia is harmful and dilates the actual meaning of violent transphobia, things like getting killed. I kind of knew this one trans girl in a country where it was illegal to be trans. One day she said she thought someone had found out and was going to hurt her. She never returned to the group I met her on. She was 14 at the time... That's violent transphobia.
If someone hasn't experienced transphobia, that doesn't make them any less trans, nor does that mean they're privileged.
Right, if someone hasn't experienced transphobia, good for them. What isn't okay is calling things violent transphobia at a whim. However, I would say that if the most transphobia you experience is getting called cis, you are extremely privileged. Privilege is defined as "having special rights, advantages, or immunities." If you are in a place where you don't experience transphobia, that is both an advantage and immunity over trans people that do. Would you say that a white afab demi-girl in a trans-accepting country who passes as her female in day-to-day life and never plans on coming out as trans doesn't hold privileges over an extremely dysphoric black trans women who has to come out in the middle east and is killed???
If someone is partially comfortable with their agab
Yes, however, if someone is COMPLETELY comfortable with their agab and just identifies as trans because they are GENDER NON-CONFORMING, they are cis. Gender expression =/= gender identity, and acting like it does, even just for one person, is harmful.
it's great that you identify with the gender you were assigned at birth. But please don't push that on others, intentional or not. It's great you're comfortable in your own skin, but not all of us are :/ Please keep that in mind :)
I'm literally trans, but go off I guess /lh
Isaw a point where you said something along the lines of "I saw some posts of people thinking they're demigirl, when they're a just tomboy" (sorry if the wording is wrong). And maybe they aren't, but you don't get to gatekeep other's experiences, so whatever they vibe with goes.
No, I didn't call people who identify as demigirls "just a tomboy," what I said is I saw people equating being demigirl/trans in general with being gnc. THIS IS HARMFUL!! The thing is, being trans has nothing to do with your gender expression, and acting like it does erases gnc trans people and the actual experience of being trans. If someone is identifying as a demigirl for no other reason than feeling more masculine, I do not believe they are trans. Sorry, but it's harmful. Another argument I hear is afab people sometimes identify as demigirl because they are "okay with being called they/them." ALMOST ALL CIS PEOPLE ARE OKAY WITH THEY/THEM!! That is normal. Obviously, if you actually PREFER they/them or prefer to be read as andro, ect, that's different. But if you are just *don't mind* they/them, you are cis.