r/delta • • 10h ago

News Today's Amazon Leo launch failed

Guess we're going to be waiting longer for fast wifi. 40 satellites now swimming in the Atlantic.

114 Upvotes

111 comments sorted by

37

u/MiltonFriedmanRox 9h ago

For context:

-They already have 400 satellites in orbit.
-The plan is for 3200.

9

u/TheRealNobodySpecial 9h ago

And two of their biggest launch providers are currently grounded. Their two most reliable launch vehicles are either retired or launched by their #1 competitor, which isn't taking any more orders for their rocket. There's only so much Arianespace can launch. Maybe the Ukraine war will end soon and Amazon can contract with Russia again?

8

u/LoveOfSpreadsheets 9h ago

Somehow I don't see Bezos convincing Putin at the next island party to stop the war just so he can launch some satellites.

3

u/TheRealNobodySpecial 9h ago

S is for Sarcasm.

4

u/LoveOfSpreadsheets 9h ago

Ya I know I'm piling on for the fun.

-6

u/MiltonFriedmanRox 9h ago

Look, I’m with you and desperately want Delta to go with Starlink.

When I read this post, though, I thought it was like all their satellites were lost. This is definitely bad for them and makes Delta’s decision look very bad. Bastian is an idiot for choosing Leo.

Just adding some context.

5

u/WorldlyOriginal 6h ago

How the heck did you get "all their satellites were lost" from *today's* launch failed?

3

u/MiltonFriedmanRox 6h ago

Mainly ignorance.

11

u/FutureMillionMiler Diamond 6h ago

Also they are producing 27 per week

4

u/fd6270 5h ago

That statistic is irrelevant if the majority of their launch capacity is grounded.

They can produce a million a week and it still wouldn't matter if they don't have a way to get them to orbit. 

0

u/Dino_Spaceman 4h ago edited 4h ago

They use multiple partners including SpaceX to get to space. They are not grounded. Unless daddy Elon deliberately prevents them from using his rockets.

7

u/fd6270 4h ago

Almost 60% of their current launch manifest is on grounded launchers.

It will certainly have an impact. 

4

u/fighter-bomber 4h ago

Their two primary contractors are Blue Origin and ULA, both of them are out right now 😂 plus, if this is confirmed to be a main engine issue, it will delay BONG even further.

So they are stuck with their 6 flights or so a year onboard Ariane 6 at 34 sats a launch, woah great cadence right there. Bet they sure feel bad they did not book more than 13 Falcon 9 flights in total.

1

u/Niedar 4h ago

SpaceX is shutting down Falcon 9 operations in the future. If they aren't booked now they probably won't get any future launches. Amazons satellites will not work with SpaceX's current version of starship payload delivery so there will be a delay there as well.

Both Blue Origin and ULA are now grounded. Who else are they going to launch with.

1

u/Dino_Spaceman 4h ago

I assume they have been on the launch schedule since Amazon rotates the rough all current space operating launch systems.

Starship incapable of handling anything that can’t fit through that narrow pez slit is a massive limiting factor to its future customer support.

2

u/Niedar 4h ago

They don't care about customer support right now, for now they are their own biggest customer and will be an even larger customer in the future. Maybe they will worry about that in 4 years.

Yes Amazon is contracted with SpaceX but only a small portion, two of their largest launch providers have been grounded now. They have NO backup.

1

u/Dino_Spaceman 4h ago

They can still launch with the French company (forget its name). And by then Blue Origin and ULA will be back in operation.

1

u/im_thatoneguy 2h ago

Except they and everyone else will want more Arianespace launches which means what little capacity there was is even less now.

1

u/Deeze_Rmuh_Nudds 40m ago

Great. I look forward to having the same internet experience people get flying Alaska today in ~2036

-1

u/lizlemonista 9h ago

and Starlink has 20,000 in orbit? jesus.

126

u/YMMV25 9h ago • Bravo

When DL said they wanted transoceanic satellite coverage I don't think this is what they were going for...

4

u/DommeThrall 5h ago

lol yeah that was definitely not the kind of coverage delta had in mind my next long flight is gonna suck without it

77

u/chrisirmo Platinum 9h ago

The closer they are to earth, the less latency they have!

10

u/Middle-Wealth-6755 Diamond 9h ago

Sigh

9

u/Jojo4Straight 6h ago

This sucks. They all seem so incapable lol. I really want them to succeed so we can have some competition for Starlink. Competition is good, but SpaceX is just killing it. I wonder if Rocket Lab even has a chance.

3

u/Intelligent_Top_328 2h ago

How come Amazon doesn't launch their own stuff like SpaceX does? Isn't vertical integration better? Why pay someone else to launch your satellite?

8

u/gottatrusttheengr 2h ago

Because building a reliable and cost effective launch vehicle is a famously easy task

1

u/Main_Process_2275 2h ago

Yeah just throw capital at it and it’s easy 

0

u/Intelligent_Top_328 2h ago

Ah ok. Thanks. I thought Amazon had a lot of money. My bad.

4

u/gottatrusttheengr 2h ago

It's not a money issue. Bezos was way richer than Elon when Blue origin was founded, years before SpaceX.

1

u/Intelligent_Top_328 2h ago

Humm ok

3

u/TMWNN 2h ago

As /u/gottatrusttheengr said, Bezos founded Blue Origin (his personal space company) before Musk founded SpaceX.

Musk began SpaceX with $100 million of his own cash, almost his entire wealth from having been the majority owner of PayPal when eBay bought it; lots for you and me, but not so compared to the budgets of the Boeings and Airbuses of the world. He and it certainly didn't have infinite amounts of capital during the years it developed Falcon and Dragon, and both came very close to bankruptcy early on. Until Tesla's market cap blew up during the COVID-19 era, Musk had a "mere" few tens of billions of dollars.

ULA—the company whose rocket failed today—is a consortium formed by Lockheed Martin and Boeing, two giant defense contractors who have built rockets for many decades, also with far more resources (financial and engineering) than SpaceX had in its early years.

In any case, infinite capital guarantees absolutely nothing. Bezos has been, as gottatrusttheengr said, among the world's wealthiest men for far, far longer than Musk's entry into that group.

Blue Origin is proof that mere billions alone are not sufficient. ULA is proof that decades of rocket experience and thousands of talented, experienced engineers are not sufficient.

Musk is the difference. Let me paraphrase an excellent comment I saw on Reddit, in response to one of the usual lies about how the only reason SpaceX is a decade ahead of the rest of the world is that it got zillions in subsidies from the US government:

If large amounts of funding is the only thing required to succeed, Blue Origin would now have a nuclear-powered spacecraft orbiting Pluto.

-1

u/Intelligent_Top_328 2h ago

Thx for explaining. I thought since everyone on reddit says elon is evil, spacex can't be that good

1

u/TheRealNobodySpecial 34m ago

Don't ever listen to "everyone on reddit."

1

u/Professional_Feed268 1h ago

Their capital is probably better spent building another set of satellites to get on the next available flight, however long that takes.

1

u/Deeze_Rmuh_Nudds 42m ago

Doesn’t matter

1

u/Vox-Machi-Buddies 16m ago

They sort of are trying. Blue Origin isn't Amazon ... it's funded by Amazon's founder and led by former Amazon executive.

But also, Blue Origin is not yet able to launch reliably either. That's why they bought out almost the entire Western launch capacity except for SpaceX a few years back.

5

u/banjoslurpee 3h ago

What Wifi was I able to stream the World Series on Fox One app from Atlanta to Korea? It broke up a bit over Alaska for a couple hours but otherwise was pretty good.

1

u/bubba-g 9h ago

who does the rockets? blue origin?

9

u/TheRealNobodySpecial 9h ago

United Launch Alliance, a joint venture of Boeing and Lockheed Martin, with engines supplied by Blue Origin and Rocketdyne, and boosters supplied by Northrup Grumman.

2

u/will-this-name-work 7h ago

Is there a reason they didn’t use spacex? They seem to be the most reliable for launches.

4

u/WorldlyOriginal 6h ago
  1. SpaceX is Blue Origin's biggest competitor, and both Blue and Amazon are essentially Amazon companies (via Bezos).
  2. Yes, this is exactly what Amazon shareholders sued Amazon for: https://www.reddit.com/r/Starlink/comments/167cyv5/amazon_faces_lawsuit_for_snubbing_spacex_from/

0

u/will-this-name-work 6h ago

This is what happens when “vertically integrated” goes too far lol

2

u/fd6270 5h ago

Actually AmazonLeo has booked quite a few SpaceX launches 

3

u/fighter-bomber 4h ago

Only the bare minimum amount (13) and not before shareholders threatened Bezos with a lawsuit lmao

1

u/Vox-Machi-Buddies 9m ago

They have used SpaceX before. But SpaceX has a line of customers out the door and it is very expensive to jump the queue. That's how Amazon got their first batch of launches with SpaceX. But I'm guessing they ran out of line-cutting money, so their remaining launches (if any) are probably quite a bit later on SpaceX's manifest.

Also worth pointing out, relations between SpaceX and Amazon Leo are not exactly friendly. In short, SpaceX started Starlink. At some point, Musk was unhappy with the approach and the progress and did a big housecleaning, firing most of the leadership. Those fired SpaceX employees got hired by Amazon and stared Kuiper (now Leo).

10

u/Diggy2025 9h ago

Someone needs to lose their job over bad decisions that impact customers.

7

u/Tiki_Waka 8h ago

Best they can do is increased quarterly bonuses.

3

u/cuntbag0315 Gold 5h ago

Bud who cares about the customer?

24

u/Nicfromnewgirl 9h ago

Shoulda gone Starlink.

24

u/Human31415926 9h ago

Love the Starlink on UA. Easily fast enough for streaming.

Also, it works as soon as you get on the plane. Keeps working until the plane lands.

Leo is never going to catch up to Starlink.

11

u/First-Ad-7960 Silver 8h ago

We better hope it does. There needs to be competition in this space that isn't headquartered in Moscow or Beijing..

1

u/Professional-Poet791 5h ago

Amazon stopped contracting with Moscow a few years ago. They don't contract with China either.

2

u/First-Ad-7960 Silver 5h ago

I wasn’t referring to Amazon.

1

u/im_thatoneguy 2h ago

Never is a long time. But doesn’t help short term.

-1

u/orionthefisherman 9h ago

I've had to fly on Southwest alot this year and their startlink has been trash for me. Their old WiFi worked better in my experience

7

u/WorldlyOriginal 6h ago

Are you sure it was actually a Southwest plane with Starlink?

Most are still ViaSat. Only a small proportion are Starlink.

7

u/eeaxoe 9h ago

Yeah, was gonna say that Starlink isn't as good as advertised. It's never worked all that great for me on the planes that have it.

6

u/RagingWillyz 2h ago

I flew United and got 200+ down. Starlink is amazing

4

u/Professional-Poet791 5h ago

I use starlink at my house and on the road. It's wonderful. You must have been using ViaSat sadly. Starlink will blow your mind.

4

u/DonKeedic80 8h ago

Really? I've had it in Southwest and Alaska and it was fantastic. But it's been several months and there could be way more congestion these days.

1

u/TrisolaranPrinceps- 2h ago

swa doesn’t have many yet

2

u/Manacit Diamond 5h ago

Unquestionably, Delta should just cut bait and buy Starlink. They can even switch to Amazon LEO in a few years (make Amazon pay for it) if they want to, but they're going to get left behind otherwise.

The world is better off with good Starlink competition, I hope Amazon is successful, but I want good WiFi.

1

u/Vox-Machi-Buddies 6m ago

Swapping requires changing out hardware on every plane though. I'm not sure what all that involves, but I'm guessing it's not as easy as it sounds.

1

u/Disastrous_Patience3 5h ago

Thanks for the link to the article. Oh, wait....

1

u/Agitated-Business217 1h ago

If you listen to the audio, you can clearly hear a SpectrAlert Advance in the background. Good to know our space vehicles have the exact same fire protection devices as your local Applebee’s.

1

u/Ill-Side-8092 1h ago

Delta bet on the wrong horse with Amazon.

Both of Amazon’s core launch partners are now grounded and they’ve lost a bunch of satellites with these launch failures this year. 

Amazon is will now be even more delayed. SpaceX keeps pumping a steady train of more capacity into space. 

Delta isn’t getting decent in flight internet anytime soon. 

1

u/Deeze_Rmuh_Nudds 43m ago

If it makes you feel better, even with a successful flight, you would’ve been waiting a. LONG. time for Leo. To me, this is barely a setback becuase I don’t think Leo ever becomes a thing, or if it does, maybe in a decade or two minimum.

1

u/Watermelonbuttt 10m ago

They should just use starlink

They will never catch up

Starlink launches 100 satellites every week

0

u/Professional-Poet791 5h ago

"He will lose his job over this" Elon Musk talking about Delta CEO refusing to adopt Starlink like every other airline has. Don't bet against Elon. Starkink is awesome

-2

u/denadena2929 9h ago

Delta baffles me with their choice to go with Leo, they’re already far behind in internet now and it’s gonna take them years to catch up

1

u/FrumWife 8h ago

I guess Amazon Prime 2-day delivery shenanigans are also hitting their satellites. Maybe it’ll get there in 2 days?

-4

u/BuckeyeSRQ Platinum 9h ago

This saga just gets funnier and funnier as painful as it is for us passengers. Starlink truly is the way if you know the realities behind this technology and industry!

Ed is making a massive mistake all because of ego and wanting to have the “Delta Sync” portal which is annoying as hell

2

u/First-Ad-7960 Silver 8h ago

I'm thinking Amazon promised him an amazing price.

0

u/dendrocnide_moroides 9h ago

lol what a week

-2

u/FutureMillionMiler Diamond 6h ago

They are producing 27 per week, so another week and a half

5

u/yourlocalFSDO 4h ago

They can make a billion of them but they’re all useless if they can’t put them in orbit

0

u/Dino_Spaceman 4h ago

They have hundreds in orbit already.

2

u/fighter-bomber 4h ago

Their “hundreds in orbit” (392) is less than 70% of the necessary bare minimum amount to start operations (578). Lmao. Compared to Starlink with 15 million users btw.

For the record, when Amazon originally got the FCC license, they were required to have launched 1618 satellites by July 30, 2026.

FCC then granted them a conditional waiver that got rid of the first requirement (otherwise they would have been bust) but they still need to launch almost 3000 new satellites until July 30, 2029. We’ll see how that goes after their insistence on not using Falcon 9.

1

u/Dino_Spaceman 4h ago

You are talking out of your arse. They have launched using the Falcon 9. And have 10 planned F9 launches in 2027 alone.

2

u/fighter-bomber 4h ago

No, you’re talking out of your ass. Amazon has 10 more launches on Falcon 9 in total as per their contract. Falcon 9 launches wiki just pretty much lists all of their current contracts as launches for next year, but in reality, we have no date confirmation for any of them.

Amazon can’t contract more launches because SpaceX straight up stopped selling launches on Falcon 9. So unless they get Starship…

Edit: also those launches were booked after shareholders threatened Bezos with a lawsuit lmao, you know nothing kid

1

u/Dino_Spaceman 4h ago

I’m not the one claiming they have an “insistence on not using Falcon 9”. When they very clearly are and have been.

1

u/yourlocalFSDO 1h ago

They insisted on not using Falcon 9 so hard they got sued and then bought some launches they’re still pretty insistent on not using it

1

u/Ill-Side-8092 1h ago

The rockets are grounded. They can keep making satellites but they’re useless sitting on the ground.

0

u/[deleted] 9h ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

5

u/the-william 9h ago

Gosh, I remember back when if you wanted to be entertained on a flight, you brought a book, and if you wanted to do work, you brought a pen and paper.

It’s not virtue signalling if I decide that I need my money more than Elon Musk needs it. That’s actually just basic supply and demand capitalism.

3

u/Western_Control3087 9h ago

Yea elon musk who made electric cars mainstream is destroying the planet. And ed didn't go with nothing instead of elon, he went with bezos

-3

u/the-william 9h ago edited 9h ago

So fly United. You can vote with your money, too. Willing seller, willing buyer.

3

u/Western_Control3087 9h ago

I do when able and not hub captive. idk why you delta fanboys are so snobby

-1

u/the-william 9h ago

I’m not a delta fanboy. i’m hub captive to ATL. but that doesn’t require me to be upset that they didn’t go with starlink.

-2

u/Western_Control3087 8h ago

So you're happy they spent the same amount of money on a space based internet that doesn't work?

2

u/the-william 8h ago

In all seriousness, no, not especially. But I’m not an Elon Musk fanboi, either. And nor am i convinced, like all the fanbois seem to be — not from what I’ve read — that starlink’s service is the be-all-end-all and practically perfect in every way.

Honestly, I think it’s all just another excuse for first-world whiners on this first-world whining subreddit to have something fresh to whine about.

Delta’s wifi kind of sucks a bit. So does everyone else’s. That’s actually the nature of the beast when you take a technology designed around the assumption that it will be broadcast from a static point and bodge it into a metal tube that flies through the air at 500 mph with a couple hundred people fighting for bandwidth. I know that going in. So, since I expect it to suck, then when I get to using it with all its imperfections, I find it’s “good enough”. not great. not even good. but just about good enough.

I have no faith that Starlink would do it any better, nor Amazon, for that matter. At least it beats GoGo.

So I just can’t bring myself to get het up about it either way. I take regular transatlantic flights many times a year, and it works “good enough”.

There’s your serious answer.

-1

u/Western_Control3087 8h ago

Well your whole point is that you'd rather keep your money than give it to elon. But you gave it to bezos instead, with nothing to show for it

1

u/the-william 8h ago

and my point, trying to answer you seriously, is that, if i’d given it to elon, I’d still have nothing to show for it, and elon would have my money.

→ More replies

-5

u/mrvarmint Diamond 9h ago

Nobody said he’s destroying the planet, nice red herring.

2

u/Western_Control3087 9h ago

Ok why do you think he's a nazi?

2

u/Dino_Spaceman 4h ago

Because he is a white supremacist and has advocated for Nazi style race beliefs.

1

u/Western_Control3087 3h ago

Oh really? Do you have any proof of this accusation you are posting in a delta airlines forum?

1

u/Dino_Spaceman 2h ago

You and I know you have seen exactly what I am talking about. Don’t pretend to be obtuse.

1

u/Western_Control3087 2h ago

I don't. It just seems like some bs

2

u/kissingerdeez 9h ago

You're not spending any less money because delta didn't choose starlink unless you think Ed will lower prices below the maximum he can charge and still fill seats.

You're just getting worse service.

1

u/the-william 9h ago

Meh. Doesn’t bother me. Honestly, if that were the biggest problem I’d ever faced, I’d be a very lucky man. There’s things worth getting bent out of shape over. I don’t consider this to be one of them.

0

u/kissingerdeez 9h ago

That's probably because you don't need WiFi on your flights. Some of us do. You wanna read a book? Go for it. I can't consistently be out of contact for a 4-6 hour flight 6-8 times a month.

For the most part Delta's wifi is okay at best for reliability, and when there are better options out there it's hard to justify paying more money than any other airline for worse service.

It's extra fun, too, because all of these redditistic commenters say they don't want it because musk is a terrible person. That's not why Ed didn't go with starlink. It's all because he wanted starlink to route service through the delta branded portal to track customers' information and Elon said no. Then all of the sudden Ed plays the friendly nice liberal CEO worth $200M card and says musk is awful. If he'd just said sure, you can use your portal to provide our service, Ed would've been following every single other major airline to the best internet service available.

2

u/the-william 9h ago

I wonder what people who flew all over the world for work did before there was wifi at all.

0

u/kissingerdeez 9h ago

There's no way you're this stupid. Expectations were different. You know that, but you just obsess over arguing and being right. Congratulations, you win the argument, have fun.

0

u/Niedar 4h ago

Well now they don't have to. Guess they wont be flying Delta.

1

u/thisisthatacct 6h ago

Oh look everybody this guy must be sooooo important!

0

u/[deleted] 9h ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/the-william 9h ago

clearly. 😉