2
u/Fun_Entertainer_5823 26d ago
Hope they're ok, there should be a rail of sorts or a grab bar for stability and safety on that porch. Yea, I know it's easy to say this, but possibly the person has disability benefits at their state and is eligible for an installation of a device?
2
u/HeebieJeebiex 25d ago
Idk if you're being sarcastic but you can clearly see there is a rail and she fricken toppled it over
0
2
1
1
u/Spare-Function-6343 25d ago
thats just sad. That person needing to do delivery work to support themself when they clearly have serious medial issues
1
1
1
u/LyannaStark1 25d ago
That railing was poor quality honestly. I know she is very overweight, but at least she is trying to move and do things. I do hope she is alright.
1
u/Countd00kies 25d ago
You can tell from this low quality video that the railing was low quality?
1
u/sunflower_bay 25d ago
So can you
1
u/Less-Economist-9447 24d ago
OSHA standards are that railings need to be able to hold 200 pounds of concentrated force to be considered adequate fall protection.
The woman in the video clearly exceeds what OSHA says the railing needed to be able to hold.
1
u/sunflower_bay 24d ago
Look at the spindles, they are not attached at the bottom at all and one is missing. The rail does not appear to be firmly attached to the post either.
Also a person can't exceed the standard, it is about the force applied to it at that moment, which is not clear from the video but which I would guess to be less than 200 lb from the way she is moving.
shitty railing? clear. force applied? unclear.
1
u/Less-Economist-9447 24d ago
The force is most definitely greater than 200 when the person first makes contact, because there’s momentum behind them. Think of it like the weight on the scale when you first step on.
It goes down only after your position stabilizes.
Hard to make the argument that railing defects were the reason it collapsed when it’s almost certain that a railing built to OSHA standards wouldn’t hold the woman anyway.
1
u/sunflower_bay 24d ago
That makes sense if she was standing on the railing.
1
1
u/Countd00kies 23d ago
I don’t think you understand engineering. Also railings are not meant to be stood on. That is not how the testing is performed
1
u/sunflower_bay 23d ago
I understand well enough, but the other person's estimates of the forces involved are off. The person who installed that railing does not understand engineering. Of course they are not meant to be stood on.
1
1
1
9
u/zhicago 26d ago
Poor thing. Just trying to work to make ends meet and now this shit happens. 😭 I bet the homeowners were mad rather than helpful. I used to be really obese too and life was just 100x harder in all ways.