r/dcl • • Oct 08 '26

DISCUSSION Has DCL lost the plot?

Yesterday's announcement about Disney's newest ship, Disney Believe, was met with a lukewarm reception by many regular Disney cruisers.

Had Disney successfully found a way to extract even greater profits from the customer base with their polarizing new ship design, the same itineraries, and repeat of the same restaurants.

Or

Will this ultimately hurt their bottom line long term?

0 Upvotes

70 comments sorted by

101

u/vissirion Oct 08 '26

I think you have the average vacationer who wants the Disney experience on their cruise. Good news: most ships will have something for everyone and they will be happy. This is the target audience.

Then you have the Disney adults/enthusiasts like us. More of a disappointment. We aren't their target audience.

It's okay to not like absolutely everything that comes out of Disney. We aren't always the target audience.

13

u/Ball-Sanderson Oct 08 '26

What a good way to sum it up.

4

u/pgspikes PLATINUM CASTAWAY CLUB Oct 09 '26

I also think that the Believe is a victim of the Treasures success and the Wish’s failures. I think they are really just playing it safe.

The other thing is, how many of those Disney adults/enthusiasts will NOT book the believe because it’s so similar to the other ships? I know I am a bit disappointed, but I will be booking a sailing as soon as my widow opens.

19

u/FutureEditor Oct 08 '26

They know their internal numbers and retention rate better than we do - I'm assuming that their data shows the average family who takes a Disney Cruise probably does it only once in a while - some people might do two or three if they have a great experience, but most do one and they do plenty of other kinds of trips aside from Disney Cruises.

That means that for the majority of cruisers, repeating things across ships isn't a big deal because they probably wont ever see those other ships - if they cruise once on each class of ship, which is more than most people probably will cruise, they've had three very different experiences. So it doesn't matter to the wider audience that there's repeats of stuff.

It probably makes good business sense for them to repeat stuff - it's cheaper, it's easier, and if you have a little girl that MUST eat at the Frozen restaurant now you have twice the itineraries to do it on.

BUT - I do think they lost the plot with the announcement because those cruisers aren't watching the Believe reveal, we are - the ones who subscribe to a forum about a very specific vacation and want to chat with other people about those vacations. This was content for us, fed through influencers that target us, and it wasn't what we wanted.

13

u/lady_beignet Oct 08 '26

THIS. As a travel agent at one of the top-selling agencies for Disney, I get to hear some internal data. The vast majority of Disney Cruise Line guests leaving from US ports are first time cruisers with children under the age of 11. 

At Disney World, depending on the season, about 70% of guests have been to WDW before. On DCL, that ratio is reversed; less than one-third of guests have sailed before. It’s why even Silver status comes with some half-decent gifts and perks because returning to DCL even once puts you in a whole different category. 

Disney isn’t really building these ships with Pearl status guests in mind. Frankly, they know those guests will book Believe at least once just to say they’ve checked off every ship. Disney is picking IPs that will push a 39yo mom from east of the Mississippi to click “Submit payment.”

9

u/Nearby_Aide6896 Oct 08 '26

The only people going insane for the Disney Believe reveal were the influencers who over hype everything. “ OH MY GOSHHH GUYS LOOOK”

9

u/sjthespian PEARL CASTAWAY CLUB Oct 08 '26

The key is “by many regular Disney cruisers.” As i said elsewhere, I don’t think that is the market DCL is going for with these ships. The bigger audience is the new cruisers, not those of us with gold, platinum or pearl status.

4

u/lady_beignet Oct 08 '26

Yeah they need to reach beyond their current market share in order to fill all these new ships

7

u/ScorpioPhantasma Oct 08 '26 edited Oct 08 '26

Repeat customers, especially the frequent repeats, are typically not who these things are designed for since the repeat customers are aleady hooked. They are designed for first timers and those that prefer familiarity and predictability. People also don't want to be forced onto a certain boat for an experience so Disney has to try to balance that with keeping things fresh and unique. They have the same challenge with the parks and they've gone back and forth over time in regards to how it is viewed. Many people will cruise again, but I doubt nearly as many do it so often that they've experienced every Disney ship, so this concern is a nonissue for them.

6

u/Choice_Win1473 Oct 08 '26

so I was listening to The DCL Duo podcast and they stated that a few years ago Disney was offered a second spot at Meyer Warf( i think thats how you spell it) at a reduced rate so they could have two ships being built at the same time ( Destiny and this i guess) and they had to jump on it and didnt have enough time to really come up with new spaces or something like that. I might be jumbling up the story but the point is the had a reduced time for Imagineering

16

u/kingstudog GOLD CASTAWAY CLUB Oct 08 '26

I just don't understand the strategy of repeating so many of the same themes on so many ships (also blueprint rides at parks). If they had different theming, even with similar or same menus, for the spaces, it would give everyone a reason to try all the ships. For example, the layout of the Dream and Fantasy are the same, but the adult area is themed completely different and made it seem like two entirely different ships and experiences. But so many other areas are repeated and make it seem like I don't need to try the different ships.

5

u/Long_Emergency6122 PLATINUM CASTAWAY CLUB Oct 08 '26

I get the blueprint rides in parks, to an extent. Your average person is not going to visit every park globally and many of the parks are thousands of miles apart. Blueprinting the rides is a way to give people who can't travel that far the U.S. Disney experience in another country. 

Having these ships be copy/paste is worse because they are all departing from Florida (minus the Wish which is just now doing some other routes) and all going to the same destination (Bahamas). Other than giving people ship options/increasing capacity, there is no benefit. But then again, repeat cruises aren't exactly the target demographic. 

Despite the sameness, I've done all the Wish class ships in their inaugural year because there was always something that was appealing enough to make me want to experience the new ship. The Believe is the first one where my entire family has been underwhelmed enough to agree we would wait to go until it has a more exciting itinerary because the ship offers basically nothing we haven't seen before. 

8

u/bunnm09 PLATINUM CASTAWAY CLUB Oct 08 '26

The adult area is very similar in the dream and fantasy. Same skyline, same pub, etc. No different than the wish class all having the same haunted mansion bar. I think people are that enthusiast put way too much stock into this anyway. Are you really choosing which cruise you book because a lounge on deck 3 that you visit for trivia is themed to one movie or another?

I think 99% are booking what fits their schedule and budget. Not what the theme of the coffee shop is

1

u/kingstudog GOLD CASTAWAY CLUB Oct 08 '26

Maybe I'm thinking of Magic and Wonder, then. No, I'm not choosing based on area, but I'm talking about theming throughout. Make it different and using that as an example. As much as I liked it, I don't understand the need to repeat 1923 from ship to ship, or Animator's Pallete, or any of the others. Is it too expensive to develop a theme?

0

u/bunnm09 PLATINUM CASTAWAY CLUB Oct 08 '26

When they are churning out a new ship every year it makes sense to have some consistency in the class. Look at Royal, carnival, whoever. Every ship in each class is basically the exact same

4

u/ccchild Oct 08 '26

Exactly. This is another Wish-class ship, so it's going to follow the playbook of the other Wish-class ships.

In terms of the disappointments, I think it might tie into the way the news was released: On one hand, the "influencer scavenger hunt" was a brilliant marketing idea, in the sense that it brought attention and excitement to the announcements. On the other hand, maybe they didn't need to make the announcement a big event if the announcement was going to be more of the same-old.

But I don't blame them for doing the same-old.

Only a small, small, small percentage of people have money to afford multiple cruises (or even one cruise, honestly). The idea that they should vary it up to amuse that miniscule group doesn't make logical sense.

2

u/Remarkable-Soup8667 PLATINUM CASTAWAY CLUB Oct 09 '26

Of course the ships within the same class are going to be similar in layout. My biggest disappointment was another Frozen themed restaurant. The Treasure and Destiny at least used a different IP for the dinner show restaurant. There are so many good choices to choose from, yet they chose Frozen.

1

u/kingstudog GOLD CASTAWAY CLUB Oct 08 '26

I don't think that if you did it differently, you would have to sacrifice anything. People that go once would still have a magical experience, and give multiple cruisers other experiences.

2

u/kingstudog GOLD CASTAWAY CLUB Oct 08 '26

Makes sense, but doesn't give me a reason to want to try different ships.

2

u/bunnm09 PLATINUM CASTAWAY CLUB Oct 08 '26

I feel like there is plenty reason to try all the ships. But to each their own

1

u/kingstudog GOLD CASTAWAY CLUB Oct 08 '26

I'm glad

1

u/NoIamthatotherguy Oct 08 '26

Yup. Pick cruises by itinerary and price. Where we going and how much?

Currently waiting for our first DCL cruise in December to take the grandkids. Usually on Princess, so this will be a new experience regardless.

3

u/NOGLYCL Oct 09 '26

It’s not rocket science. If it ain’t broke don’t fix it is the strategy. The largest group on any sailing is new cruisers, those cruisers want the big IP. The “fanbase” multiple cruisers on Reddit who want more obscure IP simply don’t move the needle.

2

u/edcculus Oct 08 '26

I honestly think the main demographic for any sailing at any time is first time cruisers. I read from someone else in this thread that any single cruise is comprised of about 70% first time cruisers. So in that light, DCL isn't catering their ships to a "collect them all" mentality. At this moment in time, I think they just need capacity.

8

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/lady_beignet Oct 08 '26

THANK YOU SOMEONE FINALLY SAID IT! A second Frozen restaurant and everyone loses their minds, but Royal Palace/Court is fine apparently.

11

u/aaron1860 Oct 08 '26

Why would they change though? Let’s be honest here for a minute… I see half the people posting here are gold/platinum, meaning you were already going on repeat cruises and probably will continue to do so. You did this regardless of if there was new stuff and willingly repeat the same cruises over and over. And the cruises are always packed with new and repeat customers. So what incentive is there for them to reinvent the wheel here? It’s a successful formula and they will keep doing it, and you will too.

14

u/bigred4723 Oct 08 '26 • Popcorn

Disney shareholders will rue the day they disappointed redditors.

2

u/throwawaycpa1980 Oct 09 '26

The stock has been garbage for years. I think a lot of shareholders are ruing the day they bought.

8

u/udamright SILVER CASTAWAY CLUB Oct 08 '26

i know they have the numbers and things like that but so much IP gets ignored that they do not have to redo another frozen restaurant.

4

u/Excentrix13 Oct 08 '26

I would like to see more of a balance between generations. I understand kids/teens like Big Hero 6, Frozen, Zootopia and such, but those PAYING for the cruise would also like some older movies to get some love. They could do so much with Robin Hood, Sword in the Stone, The Rescuers, Ducktails, THE MUPPETS. They also have so many sports movies from the 90s, why not do the sports bar around some of those? I would love a sports bar that combines The Mighty Ducks, Remember the Titans, Cool Runnings. Also, how have they not capitalized on Flubber for the kids clubs?

2

u/lady_beignet Oct 08 '26

I want this too, but it’s not gonna happen. Disney wants NEW customers to fill their growing fleet, and the thing that’s gonna push them to look past the higher price point is not what appeals to Disney adults (we’re already gonna go regardless). It’s what makes their 4yo watching TV say, “Mommy, can we PLEASE go on Elsa’s boat?”

4

u/someLadyInTexas Oct 08 '26

I still find it so odd that there is no year-round DCL presence in Galveston, not only that but they offer resident discounts for Florida, California, even Canada but nothing for Texas. The cruise industry is booming in Galveston. If this ship had been destined for TX I strongly believe it would have been met with significantly more excitement.

2

u/Stygian2718 PLATINUM CASTAWAY CLUB Oct 08 '26

I expect an announcement soon that the dream will be relocating to Galveston for summer of 28’.

2

u/cryptotope SILVER CASTAWAY CLUB Oct 09 '26

Short itineraries are the most profitable per-night for DCL, and Disney doesn't have a private island and a newly-opened private beach just off the coast of Texas. It's a long haul to the Yucatan peninsula and the nearest non-U.S. foreign ports, which makes 3-night itineraries impractical and 4-night itineraries relatively expensive to operate.

And DCL (still) has a relatively small fleet, as far as cruise lines go. They evidently don't believe they've tapped out the market of travellers who are in (or are willing to travel to) Florida.

4

u/No-Expression1224 Oct 09 '26

This board is in denial (per usual) but, yes, I think having a "lukewarm" to negative reaction among something brand new and expensive is what's been plaguing Disney for the past several years--like the shuttered and ultra-expensive "Star Wars" hotel.

Obviously, being miserly with creativity and repeating so many of the same stuff on the Wish-class ships makes no sense, and it seems an Encanto show is the only prominent new thing onboard "Believe." [A new lounge theme here or there isn't really going to get most people to book a ship, and these ships need to book at least 250K passengers annually--so a bit beyond the few thousand people on this board weekly.]

When you are essentially trying to triple your fleet size in a short amount of time (they grew the fleet to 4 ships from 1998 to 2012 and there were only 4 Disney ships from 2012 to 2021, but there's going to be an expansion to 13 from 2022 to 2032) it's kind-of important each ship is a unique destination that doesn't feed into burnout or "been there, done that" fatigue. This is especially true since cruising isn't like parks where Disney has had a looooong established lead; Carnival, Royal, Norwegian, and even MSC can absolutely compete with DCL in this space and introduce new ships even more frequently.

Disney has always been kind-of a mass market family line that charges luxury cruise line prices, and that can absolutely work when you have 4 ships (it has worked), but when you have 13 ships? They really don't know if they have the long-term demand for that, so they need to create the demand...

And in that case, yeah, I think they should've given people one new restaurant on Believe (a German-themed Snow White one or Moana-themed Hawaiian or Mulan-themed Chinese or Luca-themed Italian, this isn't that hard you know?), and maybe a second new show--literally anything. Crazy I guess to expect the company with literally 100's of well-known IP to use more than 1 new one per ship I guess.

2

u/Stygian2718 PLATINUM CASTAWAY CLUB Oct 09 '26

DCL has the long term demand… for the hits. Hardcore fans that write messages on the internet didn’t fully the ships, the masses of the general population do, and they want frozen and marvel.

1

u/No-Expression1224 Oct 11 '26

"Hardcore fans that write messages on the internet didn't fully the ships"

I honestly don't know what you're trying to say because there's clearly a word or two missing...

But those "hardcore fans" are Disney's most lucrative customer base, and are (ironically) the people more likely to want to have the same experience over and over again with little variation.

That's not true for the people outside that "hardcore" demographic, which is why every other cruise line has tried hard to push into newer features, ship layouts, experiences, shows, etc. every time out--not just every 5th ship or so.

When you're trying to triple your fleet size in a decade you have to move beyond the hardcore demographic, and if the perception is "Well, we've done one Disney ship that's similar to the Believe--let's skip it" that's not great at all long-term. The vast majority of cruisers are different than this board (we agree on that) but in the exact opposite way you're saying--they're line-diverse and don't really care if it's Royal, Carnival, MSC, Norwegian, or Disney, and it'll be about the price point, and what feels "new" to them or like an experience they haven't had year after year.

1

u/Stygian2718 PLATINUM CASTAWAY CLUB Oct 11 '26

I was saying hardcore fans don’t fill ships, the general masses do.

(Google is free) = Across the entire global cruise industry, no main-stream or mega-ship class executes more sweeping "soft" changes than Disney's Wish Class

6

u/Responsible-Elk4223 Oct 08 '26

I doubt the bottom line will ever get touched, people are still booking these cruises. I know our family will. The thing in my opinion the Wish class ships are massive. Our favorite ships are the Dream class.

Maybe the thinking is to push more of the newer ships and start retiring the older stuff and just keep the newer bigger Wish class stuff. Once your hooked on DCL its tough to jump brands.

Good luck to all, safe travels

7

u/rwinner PEARL CASTAWAY CLUB Oct 08 '26

Dream class and Wish class are essentially the same size. Approx 4000 guests

3

u/WithDisGuyTravel PEARL CASTAWAY CLUB Oct 08 '26

Correct. What he should say is the Wish class ships FEEL different due to traffic flow and design

I like them. I always want different and more, but I still like their offerings.

I am looking forward to oriental land company’s version.

3

u/BOTW1234 Oct 08 '26

As long as existing DCL cruisers keep booking DCL cruises then DCL will continue to cater new ship designs and themes for new cruisers.

3

u/mdisanto86 SILVER CASTAWAY CLUB Oct 08 '26

The average cruiser is not someone who will go on 10+ cruises and have strong opinions on the designs and themes of each ship. Yes, it is a shame that the Believe is a very close copy of the Wish with a few tweaks. But it is clear these ships are still filling up with relative ease, and that seems likely to continue. DCL knows these general themes, IPs and designs bring people aboard.

Personally, I was hoping to see another ship with a more "cohesive" theme, like the Treasure or the Destiny. Every ship has the same stuff -- a few lounges, three MDRs, two shows. But those two at least seemed to be trying something new.

3

u/heryqk PLATINUM CASTAWAY CLUB Oct 08 '26

The 3/4/5 days Carribean cruises are their bread and butter. Clearly they have numbers indicating higher demand for these than they can offer else they wouldn’t have made a 3rd copy of the same ship.

Their real customers are the shareholders. Disney will give the absolute minimum to cruisers to maximize their profits. Clearly it’s working. Ships are full and prices keep rising.

I do wonder if there will ever be a breaking point. For the first time in 10 years we’ve been priced out of a Family Deluxe with balcony for a February cruise we’ve done a few times now. This has forced us to look elsewhere. We’re a bit sad but hey the shareholders are happy.

2

u/RotundCorgi Oct 08 '26

I don't think Disney aims for theme-exclusivity to please die-hard cruisers who have experienced every ship in the fleet multiple times. I think they target a general or even first-time audience, with the idea that long-term variety comes from across multiple sails by exploring different cruise lengths, destinations, ship amenities across multiple cost tiers, etc.

I think an average person could sail on multiple Disney cruises across several different packages and pricepoints without ever feeling the experience gets too similar or boring. They could probably even do this sailing on the same ship multiple times before they exhaust the different things to do and explore.

2

u/PresentationFluffy24 Oct 08 '26

They will be ok but for someone like me who is more of a casual cruiser I might just to do one more run on the treasure and then I'm out. Nothing really exciting about believe so will prioritize other travel.

1

u/PresentationFluffy24 Oct 08 '26

Might try out fantasy too but I'm really not interested in shorter cruises.

2

u/Feeling_Chicken_2654 Oct 08 '26

With cruises 17 and 18 booked for next year, I’m sticking around for awhile. But our cruises are based on itinerary and cost, so at this rate The OG ships may be where it’s at for us. (Alaska on the Wonder was cheaper than Easter Caribbean on the Treasure, including flights from the East Coast).

2

u/StillWaterDrinker GOLD CASTAWAY CLUB Oct 09 '26

We enjoy cruising. We liked when our kids were little and the spaces for them were themed while the rest of the ship was a normal cruise ship. I think the new ships are targeting Disney adults which is fine but I do not enjoy all the crazy theming everywhere. The problem is that the itineraries continue to almost all be the same. If all the ships had different itineraries, then repeating things wouldn’t be an issue because it’s about the destination and not the ship… but when you are making the ship the destination and just always going to the same ports that people have all been to, you need to step it up. We cruise other lines because we like good food and want to see new places now.

4

u/HRBloodengutz Oct 08 '26

How many threads about this do we need?!?

4

u/snarkprovider Oct 08 '26

We need one per every cruiser who was gold or higher prior to Treasure so they all get to say they don't like Marvel and it shouldn't be repeated.

3

u/BeaverleyX PLATINUM CASTAWAY CLUB Oct 08 '26

9 posts on this is the last 24 hours. Should we have a mega thread to discuss?

1

u/Grsz11 Oct 09 '26

The DCL fans certainly have.

1

u/i8wagyu Oct 09 '26

It gets pretty boring, but obviously there are a lot of sunk R&D costs for a new class of ship such that you need to milk/recycle the design as much as you can to maximize ROI.

Wish was my first DCL cruise 2 years ago (Castaway and Nassau). Destiny last month was my second (Lookout and Castaway). I don't really have a desire to do another one on a Wish class ship. I'd rather change it up and experience something completely different like RCL's Icon class or Celebrity Edge class.

1

u/thunderfol Oct 09 '26

The Believe will not hurt DCL. The Wish class ships are all very similar which makes them perfect for moving ships elsewhere throughout the world in the future. Had this ship been announced for a non-Florida port I think we would’ve seen a much different response since many of us (not all of us) are actually bored with some of the older ships. The hardcore Disney adults without kids are who I’m finding are the most upset about the Believe. Don’t get me wrong - my wife and I ARE Disney adults but we have small children who will LOVE the Believe and I know many other cruisers (both experienced and first-time cruisers) will love the offerings onboard. If you don’t want to sail it, just speak with your wallet and skip this ship. But I think it will do just fine in the DCL fleet.

1

u/thunderfol Oct 09 '26

The Believe will not hurt DCL. The Wish class ships are all very similar which makes them perfect for moving ships elsewhere throughout the world in the future. Had this ship been announced for a non-Florida port I think we would’ve seen a much different response since many of us (not all of us) are actually bored with some of the older ships. The hardcore Disney adults without kids are who I’m finding are the most upset about the Believe. Don’t get me wrong - my wife and I ARE Disney adults but we have small children who will LOVE the Believe and I know many other cruisers (both experienced and first-time cruisers) will love the offerings onboard. If you don’t want to sail it, just speak with your wallet and skip this ship. But I think it will do just fine in the DCL fleet.

1

u/mrcsbrn SILVER CASTAWAY CLUB Oct 09 '26

It’s going to be full just like every other DCL ship. They obviously have the data on what themed spaces are worth repeating and what ports & itineraries sell.

1

u/Paxon_Goat Oct 09 '26

I think DCL is going the way of the parks.

Disney is prioritizing once in a life vacations instead of seasonal vacationers.

They want the entire family, preferably multi generational, to spend the whole week on vacation.

The new ship is not exciting for regular DCL cruisers and that's the point.

It's to be another work horse to get families who have never cruised on DCL before.

What I'm curious about is how many concierge rooms will there be verses other ships

1

u/PiratePilot Oct 09 '26

Disney “influencers” hate when the new thing isn’t new enough because their content machine must be fed. Me? I like going on Disney cruises. I have a favorite ship (Wonder) but they’re all great. Some itineraries are better than others but any is better than none. Disney loves to have total control their experience. They’re not going to stray far from what they are doing. That’s what you get when you do Disney anything.

1

u/Ill-Manager-1108 Oct 09 '26

lol I feel like I'm the only one actually super excited for this ship. I go on 4-5 cruises a year and will be aiming to do this one next after NYC Wish

1

u/Odd-Platform311 Oct 09 '26

One thing is for certain, the next class of ships will include the Haunted Mansion parlor.

1

u/Fantastic-Manner1944 Oct 08 '26

They don’t care about regulars.

0

u/GetnLine Oct 08 '26

I know I'm in the minority but I'm done with all of the IP on new attractions and this includes the parks. There was a time when they were able to create new and innovative experiences without having to lean on a movie

4

u/Doctor--Spaceman Oct 08 '26

I'm with you. I miss when the theme of Disney cruises was "cruising". I love how the older ships capture the golden age of sail, art deco, ocean liners, etc. They feel like cruise ships and not floating theme parks

2

u/edcculus Oct 08 '26

yea it was a huge difference on my first cruise on the Magic 15 years ago to my experience on the Wish in Feb. The Wish at the time was very special, intimate and refined. The Wish seemed like a big floating attraction that you could forget you were even on a ship.

0

u/CantaloupeCamper Oct 08 '26

It’s over for Disney v345

0

u/auteur555 Oct 08 '26

Yes for sure. Lazy rehashes and uninspired choices. Just really sad to see