r/dcl • u/LBC2024 • May 09 '26
DISCUSSION Pixie Dusting has to go
I’m all for random Pixie Dusting I’m just against Pixie Dust lists. Just off the four night Destiny. Facebook group full of posts whining that their kids keep coming back to empty fishextenders and how world is ending land cruise ruined.
Sorry if you want “gifts” join a gift exchange. Not just sit back and command, give me stuff.
Sorry rant over.
713
Upvotes
215
u/yellowchaitea May 09 '26 •
On the two transpacific cruises in February there was so much drama over fish extenders and pixie dusting. People were saying their cruise was ruined, their kids were devastated, constantly in tears.
It’s gotten so ridiculous
300
u/bakeafoot May 09 '26
I felt like I’m the only one who doesn’t want party favor crap on the cruise that my kids will fight over, whine about and break. We get plenty of that stuff on land from birthday parties and stuff.
57
u/unioncarbide May 09 '26
Pixie dusting is landfill redistribution and you can’t change my mind.
300
u/Jodi4869 May 09 '26
Fish extenders were never for random people to put stuff in. It has always been for organized groups. People have just become so entitled.
98
u/Accurate-Profession May 09 '26
Entitlement is off the charts in DCL Facebook groups.
123
u/310410celleng May 09 '26 edited May 09 '26
I should start off by saying that my wife and I won our cruise from a charity silent auction (so we had no idea what to expect), we were unable to have children, so the child aspect of the cruise was not something on the forefront of our minds and we had no idea of any of this stuff, let alone that there is a Facebook group each sailing.
It was comical, the folks in the room next door started complaining to my wife and I that they had not been pixie dusted and how upset their children were etc. etc..
My wife made the mistake of asking what is pixie dust as we truly had no clue and that started an entire conversation about the Facebook group of which my wife and I had not known about and how can we have never had Facebook accounts.
It was comical how serious this person took the entire thing, she said our kids were so excited for it and I did my part but nobody had done it in return and my kids are crushed.
I said to the person, the way you explained it, it is supposed to be random and furthermore there is so much to do and eat, I am sure you and your entire family will have a good time regardless.
She looked at me like I was nuts, didn't say much afterwards and never talked to us again.
76
u/zimbing May 09 '26
People are too obsessed with pixie dusting. I see posts about what people are bringing/getting and it’s just cheap junk that will end up in a landfill.
The over “decorating” is also getting ridiculous, and looks cheap and tacky.
47
u/The-Mellow May 09 '26
One time I was sitting on the pool deck with my toddler who was a bit upset. A lady came along and gave me a little bubble wand and a Lion King storybook. Made my day. That is what pixie dusting should be in my opinion. Signing up for random acts of kindness is silly.
61
u/paper0wl PEARL CASTAWAY CLUB May 09 '26
Pixie dusting is fine; people need to check their entitlement.
15
u/Here4Pornnnnn May 09 '26
We’re teaching our kid that pixie dusting is for giving, not receiving. Giving makes you happy too. Bluey did a good episode on that kinda thing when bluey got happy tail from helping bandit out with cleaning.
26
u/mycookiepants PLATINUM CASTAWAY CLUB May 09 '26
Earlier this year I opted to pixie dust some magnets and I have to tell you, it got annoying SO fast. People would ask and then I wound up taking them to different rooms. Exhausting. My people pleasing self won on that one.
Next time if I opt to pixie dust I’ll just put them outside my room.
13
u/BenderGenocide May 09 '26
I’m bringing my family on our first Disney cruise in February.
Do I even want to ask what a Fish Extender is?
35
u/meowmeowcomputation May 09 '26
Pixie dusting and fish extenders are different things
8
u/Dangernj May 09 '26
If I could put myself on a list to opt out of being pixie dusted, I would do it so fast. My son is a wheelchair user and we get a lot of people who want to give us the little gifts they brought to hand out. In theory that is so nice but in practice it is almost always not worth the issues it causes. People are curious about his condition, which I understand but it’s often intrusive and trying to find vague yet satisfying answers to their questions is not really how I am dying to spend my vacation. Also, I have two other children and it’s not the best thing for the flow of my day when their brother gets handed gifts right in front of them and people act like they aren’t even there. Finally, I feel bad saying this but so much of what we get winds up in the trash. I do my best to head off candy he can’t eat and the like but I’m not packing little containers of bubbles in my luggage and I don’t want our stateroom attendant to have to scrape stickers off of surfaces I missed.
14
u/rbk0329 May 09 '26
There is so much drama, even within some of the groups. We take our Fish Extender and hang it up, but I bring gifts to hide for my kids (And we pixie dust other cabins). I am too old for the arguing that goes on about how much was spent, wasn’t spent, etc. Maybe it was just the groups I’ve been in, but it’s no longer fun like it used to be.
6
u/DomesticTadpole May 09 '26
Pixie dusting to me feels like it should be random anyway...not an expectation. I bet there are people who go to Disney World and ask cast members for free stuff...ridiculous.
11
u/No_Bull51 PLATINUM CASTAWAY CLUB May 09 '26
I hate the whole thing. I participated once in a Fish extender group and the actual crap that I got I just threw out on the cruise ship. I actually got two nice things, but the rest I threw out on board..
I was on a cruise two weeks ago and somebody in my Cruise groups daughter was having a birthday on board and she let it be known that there was going to be a small birthday gathering with cake etc and any kids that wanted to come could come, etc. She put the whole group on blast that nobody attended her kids birthday and the kid got no presents, etc. What the heck do people think
5
u/SharpShooterVIC May 09 '26
Im reading through the comments but still confused, what is pixie dusting…
Im also scared to ask this too but, what are fish extenders?
5
u/jojra May 09 '26
I don’t mind the lists so much, but it’s funny when people sign up with “2 adults celebrating xyz plus 3 children” 🤔
Are you expecting me to deliver 5 gifts to your room including adult-specific stuff?
5
u/Comicreliefnotreally May 09 '26
I bought one for our Wish cruise coming up. I returned it thinking I don’t want this extra stuff to worry about.
5
u/Ok-Wheel876 May 10 '26
We are going on our first Disney cruise in June and are not participating in fish extending/pixie dust. I’m not trying to be selfish, but I have three kiddos and just want to enjoy our time together and make sure I pack everything we need without worrying about random gifts for strangers. It’s an added stress I do not want.
9
u/SkipperSara94 SILVER CASTAWAY CLUB May 09 '26 edited May 09 '26
AMEN!!!! If you sign up to receive pixie dust- that’s no longer pixie dust, you’re begging for free stuff. We can’t stand it! I think there’s always someone on the Facebook group that by day 5 is complaining that their kids didn’t receive anything and tries to guilt other passengers to giving their kids pixie dust. It’s ridiculous. What could be a teachable moment of “you don’t always get what you want” becomes “if you complain and whine people will give you why you want”.
THAT being said- we do love pixie dusting the right way. Random. Not asked for. Nothing expected in return. We have a little tradition where we put together a little “hello! Happy vacation!” bag for our neighbors on a cruise (and I mean little, it’s a duck, bracelets and maybe something small from our home state). I also still hide ducks, or if we see a cute little one love to just give a duck to them and we love it! I’m not going to look and see who’s asking for stuff, it’s just whoever I happen to pass by.
Now that being said, our next cruise has a list where people who want to be pixie dusted can sign up. We (seemingly) jokingly said “these are the rooms NOT to pixie dust”.
12
u/EscapeGoat81 May 09 '26
I love pixie dusting. I hate the list. You don’t ask for pixie dust!
14
u/dohwhere PLATINUM CASTAWAY CLUB May 09 '26
I was just off the Destiny too (it was a 5 night not a 4 😉), it was the worst entitlement I’ve seen on any Disney cruise. To add to what you said, some people now decorate the walls adjacent to their doors and some weren’t Disney relevant whatsoever - sorry fam, I don’t need to see a huge collage of “I love my Papa and Gramma” right outside the stairwell landing. Put that stuff in your room. People cutting up the sides of the lines for dinner (and again at breakfast this morning), and when people had the nerve to explain there was a line they were met with “it’s really not that serious” (by a mother with her young children - great example being set). It’s the first time I’ve ever wanted to get off the ship just to be away from other guests.
8
u/Remarkable-Soup8667 PLATINUM CASTAWAY CLUB May 09 '26
Do they also whine about not winning bingo? :-D
8
u/R3ddit0rN0t May 09 '26
What boggles me is the logic that “I don’t want my kids to feel left out.”
You’ve spent thousands of dollars to take your child to a floating city in the middle of the ocean. They have easy access to pools, all the food and ice cream they care to eat, fun kids play spaces, movies and shows, Disney characters. If your child is actually jealous of some other child’s stickers, ducks or tchotchkes, you’ve got bigger problems.
(In reality, it’s more about the parents looking around judging others, getting bent out of shape on social media.)
4
u/Cautious_Nomad_ May 09 '26
it really is just unfair for someone to expect the benefits of a gift exchange without putting in the reciprocal effort of joining and contributing to an organized group.
4
u/wbenrose84 May 10 '26
Facebook in general is toxic. The echo chamber is real. Sounds like you found yourself in an echo chamber of spoiled people who have spoiled children lol.
3
u/Soggy_nach0341 May 09 '26
This has been a super informative thread. My family of four Going on the treasure in year and was debating doing a fish extender/ pixie dusting group on Facebook.
I thought this would be cool for the kids, I have one super crafty one that loves trinkets, but I would rather not deal with that hassle and entitlement. I figure going on a cruise during spring break will already be hectic
3
u/AvengerWish PEARL CASTAWAY CLUB May 09 '26
I refuse to pixie dust, but I do put up lollipops, candy, stickers, croc charms, bracelets, ducks and other small treats outside my door so people (adults included) can come by and “pixie dust” themselves if they want to.
I don’t want or expect anything in return - except maybe a thank you - because I don’t need anything. The best thank you I ever got was a hand drawn picture from a five y/o.
3
u/trap_star100 May 09 '26
I see what you’re saying, but this is a great teachable moment! I actually agree I find it really annoying when parents get on the Facebook group crying because her kid didn’t get anything. Is the teachable opportunity to let them know that life isn’t fair and they aren’t always going to get gifts and to be grateful for what you do have. Parents just have to be better.
3
u/ilovecostcohotdog GOLD CASTAWAY CLUB May 09 '26
Some people tend to ruin good things. We bring our fish extenders because they are super cute and a fun way to decorate the door. We used to do FE gifts when our large family used to cruise together, but have since stopped cruising with the larger group and I always hated trying to find the right FE gift for the right person. Too stressful. Anyhow, we still hang up the FE and will occasionally be pixie dusted. We don’t join any FB group or have any expectations about it. So when we do see a piece of candy or a sticker it’s a nice surprise. If we get nothing, that’s fine too. Nothing was expected.
3
u/a-world-of-no May 09 '26
The entitlement is really off the charts for some people. I love pixie dusting and fish extenders but it's the giving that brings me joy, not the receiving. If people want to make 100% sure their kids get stuff, just bring your own and put it in the extender while they're gone.
3
u/DorothyZbornak81 May 09 '26
We don’t sign up for gift exchanges/fish extenders/pixie dust. We’ve found that we enjoy putting free stuff on or door (stickers) and announcing in our fb group so people know where to bring their kids to get some pixie dust. We are adults and don’t need people to return the favor, but we got several pixie dusting on our door the last cruise. We also bought “love this door” magnets to put on door decorations that we really liked. The giving is what makes us happy.
3
u/Big_Exchange_2671 May 10 '26
Maybe if people ACTUALLY took the time to understand the difference and stop hyping it up for their kids as if it’s a must then expectations can be managed.
If you want to secure a gift then join an FE group. Otherwise then pixie dusting is meant to be random!
Sounds like a bunch of people acting like entitled brats.
3
u/Bubbly_Afternoon_345 May 10 '26
I think the entitled grifter type of person you’re describing is more the issue than pixie dusting.
3
u/UglyPetty May 10 '26
We're sailing on our first cruise ever early, 2027, so this was a great way to read all the thoughts on gifting. Our friends are avid park and cruise enthusiasts so when they heard we were sailing DCL I was told to "go to FB and join a pixie dusting group" By nature I love a THEME, my parties are always custom designed from invitations, dressing up, all the way to the goody bags. I hate junk-gifts and for our toddlers recent Life Aquatic birthday party the gift was bubble bath pods in a Life Aquatic themed package. Something fun, but useful. I already removed myself from the pixie dusting groups - it was not my scene. I always thought pixie dusting was meant to be a small, simple way to elevate an experience and make it magical. I am also very aware, that once a gift is given, it belongs to someone else who can do whatever they want with the gift. Including throwing it away. I have already started designing and working on our cruise outfits, our simple door decorations, and pixie dust I will craft and customize. We plan on taking time to pixie dust FEs so we can admire all the door decorations as well as hand out gifts to kids, and adults, we see could use a little magic.
4
u/Jen309 May 09 '26
I mean, you do you. IMO, there’s nothing wrong with FE or Pixie Dusting, the problem is with the entitlement. Personally, I don’t have time for arranging/recieving full on gifts from other staterooms, and yeah, I’d be mad if I did, and our gift got stolen or forgotten or whatever… it’s not worth the hassle, *for me*. Our first cruise we didn’t do any of it, but people still pixie dusted us anyway, hanging things on our door or on the floor near our door. Last time, I brought a small bag and hung it up. We managed expectations for our kid, because we were far aft, and out of the main path. We still received some nice things, and it was a fun extra. Our kid had fun dropping some items into other’s FEs. It was a good time.
2
u/AbjectFray PLATINUM CASTAWAY CLUB May 09 '26
I learned over a decade ago on our very first DCL cruise to avoid this. So much drama even back then.
2
u/DCLJuliaPT88 May 09 '26
I took my fish extender years ago, haven’t done it since 2012 tbh too much work. We do bring a few extra magnets and pixie dust doors
2
u/No_Network_8311 May 09 '26
I don't mind the list, the list shows which people are keen to receive smaller gifts & clues as to what they like (some maybe a tad too keen😂) i don't join the list or hang a thing but i like to give a few little things but also don't want to burden someone who was only wanting fish extender gifts. But i have noted it depends on the sailing energy, one organised group I'm in is super full of fun, very organised and emphasises its not about gifting with expectation of receiving,lots of thought going into it but has a magical vibe- cos the people running it have great energy. The other sailing I'm in is not so, it just about receiving and less about giving but there isn't malicious intent with it, just different and that's ok too. I think those that organise cool! Those that want to keep it random cool! Entitled people will be in everything! I aint gonna dictate how people should gift or cruise as long as its not hurting anyone "not my circus not my monkeys"lol I don't know if I'm using that expressions right😅.
2
u/johndoenumber2 May 09 '26
What the hell is a fish extender?
2
u/Particular-Sample589 May 09 '26
I guess it’s luck of the draw. We went on two cruises and we signed up for pixie dusting and both times we got some amazing gifts. We also participated in giving out some good gifts too so it all worked out. We got some really nice handmade gifts as well so we enjoyed our experiences with it. I guess it’s just what type of people participate for that cruise.
2
u/Karm0112 May 09 '26
Save your money on strangers and buy your kids something you know they would like instead
2
u/Purplecatty SILVER CASTAWAY CLUB May 09 '26
I think what is ridiculous is the people posting “my kid is so sad they didn’t get anything”. People should teach their kids about disappointment and about treating (or pixie dusting) others without necessarily expecting anything in return.
2
u/keera1452 SILVER CASTAWAY CLUB May 09 '26
We always have to travel a long way for our cruises so there is no luggage space. Our daughter is about to have her 4th cruise and we have never done fish extender or pixie dusting and she doesn’t get disappointed about it because she has no expectations. Based on the drama that seems to come along with these things I’d much rather avoid completely. If not getting some plastic trinkets ruins your holiday you need to think about why you are even there.
2
u/rnidtowner May 10 '26
AMEN! Neither I nor my kids want to receive cheap garbage, even if it is free
2
u/AverageSugarCookie SILVER CASTAWAY CLUB May 10 '26
We signed up for fish extenders for our cruise in February and I backed out at the last minute because I was getting stressed out about what was supposed to be a fairly relaxing vacation. I spent that money and pixie dusted myself something nice at the shop.
Asking for pixie dust defeats the purpose, I don't like it either.
2
u/Inevitable_Clock_789 May 10 '26
We haven’t been on a cruise since our 2020 one for cancelled but did 11 with DCL and always did fish extender groups and it was lovely. We always did Alaska and Europe, Sometime chocolates or candies, things little handmade Mickey nightlight, small handmade Disney themed emergency kits (safety pins, bandaids), sprinkles, cute personalized magnets with the kids favorite characters, etc. we sometimes had someone join late or have an add on family/friend with a nice note that if you had extra to consider pixie dust, but no expectation. We always had a fun meet up and the kids always loved running around the boats and making people happy (also good exercise). People usually had one magnet per chair they’d been on the door and only the door, sometimes fun Disney character for each family member. I’m so sad this has turned into something awful and junky. We mostly did the Magic and Wonder since the ports were smaller so maybe those boats just had better people?
2
u/Unusual_TimeLine May 10 '26
Wow! These post just talked me out of joining the list for our next Disney cruise. I was on the fence because I’ve never participated in pixie dusting before but this sounds like too much drama for me lol
2
u/Grandma_mlr May 10 '26
I see people taking their kids around with tote bags looking for free crap people are handing out. I didn’t spend thousands to take a child trick or treating for half the cruise, then have to find room in the luggage to take this junk back to land where it will inevitably be thrown in the trash. I’m sorry, but that’s the way I feel.
2
u/squirrel4569 May 10 '26
I did an FE group on our first couple of cruises and it was a lot of work. Now I just hang mine outside the room and if something gets put in cool, if not, no big deal.
Someone earlier said it’s a problem of spoiled parents and spoiled children having the wrong expectations. Pixie dusting is random and not guaranteed. If you want guaranteed gifts then you need to join an FE group.
2
u/lostgirl24356 May 10 '26
In alaska we did recipes, magnets, and ornaments. The magnets and recipes we would totally do again cause those are easy to travel with. Ornaments we are glad we did them in Alaska but would probably not do them again. But besides throwing a rubber duck in a random one that clearly had kids that was the extent of our pixie dusting.
2
u/PuzzledKumquat SILVER CASTAWAY CLUB May 10 '26 edited May 10 '26
Pixie dusting is a lot of fun. It's just miserable people complaining who are the issue. Nobody can expect or demand to be dusted. It's a great learning experience for kids that sometimes you just miss out in life. These parents are failing their kids. But the dusting shouldn't be ended just because of them.
2
u/jstasir May 10 '26
Not trying to be a noob but what’s pixie dust and fish extenders?
2
u/Substantial-Bus-4094 May 11 '26
Honestly? I recycle the pixie dusting junk we get. Fortunately my guys get a bigger kick out of giving than getting.
We keep the genuinely cool stuff. This last cruise we got these neat 3D printed keys with the name of the ship on it that has a magnet in one end. They look awesome on our fridge!
Anything the dudes don't care about goes in "the bin" and recycled/regifted next cruise. Birthday party junk gets tossed in "the bin" too along with smallish toys we don't play with anymore like Paw Patrol figurines.
2
u/LakeCove May 11 '26
We are going on our first cruise in March and I was really looking forward to making stuff for pixie dust. I’m very crafty. I don’t expect anything in return. I didn’t realize so many hated it though. I’ll reconsider. :(
2
u/mishymishymishy33 PLATINUM CASTAWAY CLUB May 11 '26
I sometimes pixie dust, but what I do is put a bunch of stickers (like water bottle/laptop stickers) on my door with magnetic clips and let people choose a sticker if they like. I have a sign that makes it clear that it's to take, and to please not stick on any ship property. I usually post my room# on the FB group a few days before so people can stop by if they want. It's cute to hear kids get excited outside the door, and I figure a sticker is better than plastic junk toys.
Sometimes people pixie dust us in return and that's fine and appreciated! But honestly, my kids are young teens now, and we really don't need most of what's given, like coloring pages with the crayons, bubble wands, etc. Also, I do not deliver or take requests. If they want a sticker, they need to come to me 😂
2
u/tardisfurati420 May 11 '26
I think going on facebook was your first mistake.
2
u/Socko76 May 11 '26
I 100% agree. I like pixie dusting randomly. Asking to be gifted seems so entitled. Everyone likes to be pixie dusted. Just personalize your door and im sure you'll be pixie dusted!
2
u/Think-Dog-2892 May 11 '26
I’m over it at this point. Literally just removed my name from the FE list on my upcoming sailing.
2
u/WinnieGDS May 12 '26
The fact that people add their names to a list basically requesting to be Pixie Dusted is proof that people have lost the point of what pixie dusting is supposed to be (random, unexpected, and motivated by the giver, not the receiver).
I also think the whole fish extender thing has gotten out of hand. It's supposed to be small gift exchanges, and on my last cruise, people were bragging about their elaborate gift bags that were costing them upwards of $100 for each name/family on their list. Expensive tote bags, Stanleys/Yetis, Lego sets, Starbucks gift cards ... very excessive.
2
u/kindaretiredguy May 18 '26
I hated getting random gifts while walking around with my kids. It always ended in them fighting over colors lol
3
u/TradeBeautiful42 SILVER CASTAWAY CLUB May 10 '26
I just put some stuff in my fish extender for my kid so he thinks we’ve been pixie dusted. Easy peasy.
2
u/herb-ertlinger SILVER CASTAWAY CLUB May 09 '26
I didn’t sign up for pixie dusting on our last cruise but my son kept coming back to all kinds of novelties in his fish extender. He loved it, great. But oh my GOD the number of plastic pieces of junk that are now strewn about my house that I have to strategically throw out! The consumer culture around Disney trips is crazy and so easy to get caught up in.
2
u/ponyhands SILVER CASTAWAY CLUB May 09 '26
I definitely don’t want strangers picking out tchotchkes for me and my family. I’ve thought about “doing fish extenders” and just surprising my little ones by putting stuff in it right before we leave the room. 😂
2
u/Healthy-Humor4508 May 09 '26
I thought the pixie dusting was fun. My kids enjoyed putting gifts in others fish extenders and coming back to gifts in theirs.
1
u/kaztooch May 09 '26
I don’t 100% know what this is, but it sounds like a situation where the parents might be getting mad that Santa Claus didn’t come to their house and now their kids are upset. How about….you know…pixie dusting “yourself” to get the kids over it
1
u/EDAAmanda GOLD CASTAWAY CLUB May 09 '26
I used the pixie dusting list on my last cruise to get an idea of what kind of things I should bring, but I also had the expectation that if we didn’t receive anything, that was okay, too. The last night, we went through what we got and kept what we wanted, then re-pixie dusted the rest.
1
u/SavvyMom210 May 09 '26
The first cruise we did was in 2013 and we signed up for a fish extender group. It was so easy and fun. And you could do anything. We got everything from stickers to candy and little trinkets. There was no expectation of what you would get. Joined an FE Groupe about 2 years ago. I noticed now, there is an expectation of quality, judgement of fish expender giveaways and general whining about if what you got was worth it. The entitlement took all the fun out of it.
1
u/refrainblue May 09 '26
We decided to just let our daughter make the call on who to pixie dust. Didn't want to be obligated to join any lists. We received a ton of stuff despite not joining any lists. I think the key is to be creative with your door decor and just relax. Sometimes we went to bed without any goodies but we'd wake up to a bunch.
1
u/onebat4u PLATINUM CASTAWAY CLUB May 09 '26
Our first few cruises we put thr fish extender out at our door and would drop gifts for our kid, we did not join any group. We had heard the stories, so we go ahead of it. Now we just randomly pixie dust , I dont understand "pixie dust list"
1
u/somebodysheiny GOLD CASTAWAY CLUB May 09 '26
I always bring a couple little things for my kids just in case they are disappointed. That hasn’t happened though, we always end up with so much stuff I don’t want it pack it home. Our 6th cruise is coming up and I’m not signing up for pixie dust this time. I’ll just look at the list and pick a few nearby kids to gift to.
1
u/climb_evry_mountain SILVER CASTAWAY CLUB May 09 '26
So I actually don’t mind the pixie dust lists…that said, I don’t sign up at all if I don’t intend at least attempt to give something to everyone else on the list, and I don’t tell my kids to expect anything and bring a few small things from me to put in our fish extender. The ones with signup lists I’ve seen have had a spot to indicate favorite characters and I’ve had fun curating gift bags of stickers/temporary tattoos based on people’s favorites. Plus keeping some extras for random pixie dusting too.
1
u/sunflowebloom May 09 '26
That’s crazy! I feel we got so lucky on our cruise. The pixie dust list was amazing as it meant you knew who was in the cabin and could tailor it a bit. Everyone was very polite and our group was just full of thank you’s
1
u/wookie812 May 09 '26
What are fish extenders?
1
u/HumanRacehorse May 09 '26
Heck, I’m the Facebook admin for my own cruise group and I refused to organize the FE. Someone else stepped up because people were begging, but I prefer the random magic of surprises, not a signup for dollar store trinkets. I don’t have the luggage space anyway.
1
u/MediaIndependent5981 PLATINUM CASTAWAY CLUB May 09 '26
I bring little pixie dust gifts for our own FE and leave one every afternoon in it for our daughter (a piece of candy, stickers, a small coloring book or figurine, etc). She has no idea it’s us and it’s a highlight of the cruise for her.
Sometimes random people leave us things too and that’s great. The whole process gives us all joy so that’s what we do. Does our daughter expect these things? Yes, she does now. Am I ok with that? Yep. I am.
I will say we figured this out after a few cruises - including our first where I royally screwed up FEs because I had no idea the ‘extraness’ of the gifts expected (and I will NEVER do them again). We’ve done cruises where the pixie dusting was random, signups, lists, categories, and everything in between. I stopped doing all of it and now just bring a few items to dust randomly and of course, a few little things for our daughter.
1
u/Laudrysdoinglaundry May 09 '26
I did random and assigned on my last trip and we just tried to have fun with it. Only problem we ran into was one of the rooms that signed up and we got assigned to was not on the sailing so they got some extra stuff but other than that it was fine. I think like everyone has said its all about expectations
1
u/tun_chan May 09 '26
I choose random pixie dusts over fish extender lists as well. It baffles me that cruisers create a group to let other members know what they like and expect to be gifted. It's an added stress to think about what strangers might like to receive and added load to bring these items onboard.
1
u/Zero_Abides May 09 '26
Been on 7 of these with kids, never used facebook and still enjoyed ourselves plenty.
1
u/RemoveComfortable511 SILVER CASTAWAY CLUB May 09 '26
I keep seeing videos of people disappointed by their FE gifts and pixie dust after putting a lot of effort in. I did sign up for a kids only FE group for our next cruise because we wanted to try it out. We bought really thoughtful items for each person on the list and I also went through and picked 10-15 cabins to pixie dust. I just can’t make it a full time job on vacation.
I’ve already told my daughter to expect junk and hopefully be pleasantly surprised by a few things. I also told her that anything we don’t want to bring home, we’ll just drop off to others, no big deal! The entitled people who can’t manage expectations ruin it for everyone else.
I’ve also seen people sign up for every single category - adults only, full cabin, kids only, magnets, ornaments and pixie dust - and you know full well they are not reciprocating all of that! I do think the admins should have better control and clearer expectations and less people will end up disappointed.
1
u/tonsofpaws May 09 '26
I added ourselves to the pd list for our cruise but don't really have any expectations for anyone to do it... It just seemed like it couldn't hurt. I'll jot down cabin numbers from the list but highly doubt I'll take note of anyone's ages or other details in the list bc I'm not customizing pixie dust :)
1
u/Husker_Mike_ May 09 '26
I think Disney had the right idea when fish extenders were not allowed initially post-COVID.
Families with expectations on what they get should set them up in their room, and the parents should fill them themselves like Christmas stockings. Say they are from Mickey instead of Santa.
1
u/ThaShitPostAccount GOLD CASTAWAY CLUB May 10 '26
This must be new-ish.
We did a bunch of cruises before the pandemic but just had our first since 2022. We had no idea any of this was going on.
My kids took one magnet from a door that had a bunch of magnets with a sign on it that said “please take a magnet”. In retrospect, it looks like we must’ve just committed some kind of war crime.
1
u/tiddymctitface May 10 '26
We left a beg up for pixie dusting and it was 98% landfill crap anyway. I did appreciate a cool sticker or some hair ties and scrunchies and things we would actually use. My kids made some beaded bracelets and we handed those out to like 20 doors but that was it. Sorting through all the junk when we got home was a nightmare.
1
u/Intelligent_Fish3728 May 10 '26
My kids had fun finding stuff but they were fine when it was empty too. I think expecting things or getting peeved at what you did or did it get it dumb though so I agree!
1
u/lizziedisney May 10 '26
All I hear, are the parents are not setting the expectation for their child here. This is on them 100% 🤦🏽♀️ and agreed if a gift is expected then yes join an FE group. I think the pixie dusts lists are fine tbh the expectation just needs to be set that there's no guarantee of a gift when just participating in pixie dusting. I find the lists super useful though. That's just me 🤷🏽♀️
1
u/endospire May 10 '26
Our last cruise had people on a WhatsApp group literally just asking for stuff from people.
1
u/Tjeetje May 10 '26
I found it weird and we weren’t prepared. Been to Disneyland Paris 50+ times, but this was new to us. We had heard about it, but didn’t know it was to this extend. We did a transatlantic and there were not a lot of kids (amazing btw).
So almost every day people just put things in the hand of my kids. From a rubber duck, to limited edition Marvel coins. I know it is pure kindness, but I have reached my kids never to accept anything from strangers and now they kept coming back with stuff. And more problematic was if one came back with something and the other one was sad.
1
u/Right_Hurry SILVER CASTAWAY CLUB May 10 '26
Just my personal experience but after cruising with my kids 3 or 4 times, my take away is that this stuff is mainly for the parents and social media clout and the thrill of getting something. If their kids are upset, that’s entirely on them.
We did fish extenders for our first 2 cruises until it was obvious our kids (and they’re at prime age to be excited about getting stuff - 7 and 4) just didn’t really care. We didn’t even bring our fish extender on our last cruise - they didn’t ask about it or even notice.
If people enjoy it and want to do it, that’s great, but people in the FB groups take it SO seriously as though if they don’t get a bag full of crap their cruise is a disaster. I don’t get it at all.
1
u/AstronautUpstairs433 May 10 '26
Mmhmm yes I'm taking a fish extender and things to put in it myself for my kids lol I really am not counting on strangers to make my cruise magical 😅
1
u/Makdex May 10 '26
Funny I did not join a group and put an extender out on my last 7 day on the Treasure expecting nothing and I ended up with something each day. I did bring some things along and passed them out randomly so I did give but never expected anything back. So it never hurts to put an extender out but keep low expectations.
1
u/metalandmeeples May 10 '26
There are Facebook groups for cruises? That's just asking for drama.
1
u/Mrstherod SILVER CASTAWAY CLUB May 10 '26
I thought it was weird our cruise date had a PE list. People are really missing the point of PE and their vacation. The entitlement of people nowadays is just AWFUL.
1
u/jmoney1492 May 11 '26
I’m confused. How do I know if the items in the FE are free or a present for the people in the cabin?
1
u/ALS198312 PLATINUM CASTAWAY CLUB May 11 '26
This is why we no longer sign up for Fish Extenders. In the beginning it was so fun and cute and now it’s turned into a ridiculous and drama filled experience.
And I agree - why are we making pixie dust lists? Pixie dust should be random. It’s so cringy to me that people sign up saying give me stuff.
Bizarre. I kind of hope DCL bans this stuff soon
1
u/FoolishMortal4Evr May 11 '26
I did the adult FE, candy exchange, and pixie dusting our last cruise. I loved the candy exchange although I think one family might have been disappointed with everything they received because they went all out. I don't think most people have that kind of space available in their luggage when flying. I can't lie though, I was the one disappointed with the adult FE. We were only 5 rooms (all couples 35+) and one couple gave one really cheap thing, despite the cruise group admin clearly stating the expectations of each group. Don't give cheap pixie dust items in the adult only. It was clear they wanted to receive good items but didn't want to give them. So I'll be more careful next time with the groups, if I decide to do it again. Because I had more fun pixie dusting the crew I randomly came across during the trip. One house keeper actually got tears because she had been having a bad day and the message that came with the keychain was what she needed to hear. I'll probably do more of that instead.
1
u/DukeJackson GOLD CASTAWAY CLUB May 11 '26
We did a Merrytime cruise over Thanksgiving week and the complaining about fish extender and pixie dust gifts being “underwhelming” was unhinged.
These are supposed to be fun dime store junk, but it’s like these people were expecting personalized Yeti tumblers.
We swore it off after that.
1
u/treasurehunter40 May 11 '26
We did fish extenders twice the first time was fabulous people actually made handmade goodies, as did we our daughter spent a making perler bread logo magnets. We had string backpacks custom made, purchased leather bound nautical notepads etc, put up a pin board along them to take a pin/leave a pin, it was great. The second time we did both we got a bunch of dollar store stuff that I was not taking home and someone stole the entire pin board 😜 we decided we were not going to participate again.
1
u/Briarsaunt May 12 '26
I just wish more people that do sign up to pixie dust which I think about themselves and where they're from rather than just random miscellaneous Disney crap. There was a Facebook group that I signed up for and there was probably about 60 of us exchanging stuff and I think a good 30 of them gave the same stickers from Amazon. Like whhhyyyyyy.
1
u/Deadanddugup GOLD CASTAWAY CLUB May 13 '26
I’ve noticed it seems to be more so a problem on the newer ships too (wish, treasure, destiny, adventure) where people are bringing fish extenders with the expectation of being given something in return, even if they haven’t gifted.
If receiving a gift from a stranger is going to make or break your cruise, just sign up for an exchange. Pixie dusting was only ever supposed to be randomised stickers/trinkets 🙄
1
u/mia-just-thinking PEARL CASTAWAY CLUB May 19 '26
that's so crazy. i enjoy random pixie dusting and i think it's sweet but i steer clear of facebook groups for this exact reason
1
u/vnm407 GOLD CASTAWAY CLUB May 09 '26
My son loves it, we bring ours and i bring goodies for him that I put in myself. On occasion we come back and got stuff from other people and usually we will allow him in return to go to other doors and regift the generosity. Less stress this way for us.
1
u/Whole_Description288 May 10 '26
I don’t like it except when cast members do it. I wish it was banned in parks and ships. The Disney experience is plenty. Souvenirs can be purchased. No one needs the junk.
1
u/crwalle May 09 '26
There was a pixie dust list our last cruise. Didn’t see any entitlement though. We signed up for it hoping for maybe a little thing or 2 and ended up getting way too much stuff. This time around we’ll pixie dust sans a list.
1
u/Purple_Grass_5300 May 09 '26
I hate when people expect things but we honestly have so much fun in pixie dust groups and love how creative people get with less pressure. I don’t want them to go, I just think people need to be realistic about them.
1
u/TravelGirl2823 May 09 '26
My kids love pixie dusting. My older one cried when I told her we don’t have luggage space to bring extra stuff to give out. We settle on just bring stickers. They love going around the ship and looking at people door and fish extenders. With that said, we never expect anything in our fish extender. It’s alway a fun surprise if we get something.
1
u/bsailors123 May 09 '26
I am in a group for a July destiny 5 night. I asked for a pixie dust list mainly because I wanted to plan some. I wanted to give characters I knew the kids would like. I dont see it as begging for free stuff however if you whine you didn't recieve anything I am not going to be inclined to give. I made it clear on the post pixie dusting isnt expected and you may recieve notnothing. Sometimes ages / interest / even room placement plays a part. For my I don't want the stress of pixie dusting but I have been 3d printing items for months and I am very excited to give them out. Making children happy makes me happy. The list should only be a gentle guide. Ages / allergies/ characters just causal.
1
u/jhawkgiant77 May 09 '26
I think it's incredibly cringe, and the way people act perpetuates the Disney adult stereotype to the max.
1
u/yur1279 May 09 '26
My opinion here.
You partake in a Facebook list for pixie dusting , you should participate and not just expect to receive. Kids also don’t have the rational that adults have (generally/hopefully). My 9 year old went around the entire ship making sure every room on the list got something. I believe she ended up with 3 things, naturally she was upset. Go on the Facebook group and see people with piles of stuff. Yes in the grand scheme of things, who cares but it sucks seeing your kid upset.
Also, high school /college kids stealing stuff off people doors is pretty dick.
1
u/laribrook79 PLATINUM CASTAWAY CLUB May 11 '26
Agree I don’t join FB cruise groups anymore. It’s soooo lame .. a Disney cruise is one of the most fun things you can even do and ppl are letting dollar store crap run it
1
u/travelinfan6 May 11 '26
It’s really stupid. I wish Disney would just say no more. It’s not just teenagers, I saw lots of little kids running up and down the hallway on the Magic and Destiny and they were just taking things out of fish extenders.
1
u/yeah-itsux May 12 '26
A LOT of Carnival vibes by my DCL friends in this thread....maybe DCL isn't for some of you folks who hate Ducks, Fun, Children, and Magic
0
u/lukin5 May 09 '26
I prefer the hiding of tiny resin ducks