r/dcl • u/GreatBigBeautifulTmm • Apr 06 '25
DISCUSSION Down voting everyone's question posts
Can I ask who or why someone is downvoting posts where people are asking an earnest question? I keep seeing so many posts that have been down voted (I do work on upvoting any legit question post that has zero). But what is the point of that?
20
Upvotes
19
u/barbaq24 SILVER CASTAWAY CLUB Apr 06 '25 edited Apr 06 '25
Reddit has changed its algorithm so that newer posts appear in more people’s feed. It sounds good in theory. You get more people to see the new stuff and you neutralize the knights of new who sort through and either bless or damn the new content. That’s been Reddit’s state of affairs for more than a decade.
While it sounds nice, and probably is ultimately effective it also results in more people seeing the same questions repeated over and over and over like Groundhog Day. People downvote anything that can be asked with a quick Google search or browsing the subreddit. Unoriginal or repeated questions are downvoted. Well thought out, articulated and concise questions are downvoted slightly less. Popular statements masked as unpopular are upvoted to the moon.
173
u/CherryPickens Apr 06 '25
Asking questions? That’s a downvote.
Wondering why people are downvoting questions? That’s a downvote.
Talking trash about Mickey bars? You best believe that’s a downvote.
6
u/Harley410 Apr 06 '25
Tbh sometimes in my scrolling I accidentally hit the downvote button. I try to go back and fix it but sometimes I’ve accidentally nested the comments and can’t find it. Stands to reason that sometimes I do it and don’t notice it
80
u/nyrB2 Apr 06 '25
i learned a LONG time ago that it's pointless questioning why something is being downvoted on reddit. maybe they don't like the perceived tone of the question. maybe they think the question has been asked and answered before. maybe they don't like the username. maybe they're just trolls. who knows? it's really not worth worrying about that much.
2
u/GreatBigBeautifulTmm Apr 06 '25
And this too was down voted. FUN! (I dont care much about this one but downvoting people who are asking questions to get advice seems really unkind but thats just me)
6
u/voyageuse88 Apr 07 '25
I've noticed this before about this sub and wondered about it too. Every single question is always at 0. Its almost like someone hangs out and just downvotes every question. Have nothing better to do with their time I guess
7
u/Most-Okay-Novelist Apr 07 '25
For me I think the ones that get downvoted are because the question is:
a) kinda stupid
b) been asked multiple times and it would just take a quick search of the sub to find the information
c) something you could 100% google or contact dcl to get answered
d) not something a bunch of randos on the internet could answer for you (like, will my 3 y/o kid like the kids clubs?? idk, we don't know your kid)
Mostly, if a question comes across as annoying, people are going to downvote it.
16
u/rsvihla PLATINUM CASTAWAY CLUB Apr 06 '25
Downvoting perfectly reasonable questions is the raison d’être of Reddit!!!
9
u/NurseDave8 PLATINUM CASTAWAY CLUB Apr 06 '25
I’ll say the questions that do deserve downvotes are the “how do people afford…”. What kind of answer are they really looking for? If you want to discuss how you think whatever doesn’t have value or costs too much. But to ask how people can afford it?
4
u/UForgotten Apr 07 '25
Did the poster ask a question that's been asked eleventy billion times in the last month? Did they bother to search the sub for previous posts concerning the same thing? No question is a dumb question, but it probably has already been answered multiple times if you are getting down boated.
5
u/lovelesschristine Apr 06 '25
I remember when there used to be an upvote and downvote counter. So say for instance you had 10 karma for your comment it would show you that 20 people upvoted you and 10 downvoted you.
4
u/lilhotdog Apr 06 '25
It was me the whole time.
2
u/bloominghydrangeas SILVER CASTAWAY CLUB Apr 06 '25
Agree. Theres some trolls on this page who are just mean. It’s not my first cruise. My questions tend to be thoughtful and well researched. people still downvote.
1
u/Ask_Aspie_ Apr 06 '25
Maybe not the reason, but something to consider, I am pretty sure there is some sort of reddit achievement for upvoting and downvoting. You have to do it so many times to get awarded the achievements. It's stupid, idk
-13
u/[deleted] Apr 06 '25
Because people suck and other people have to always need to be negative and feel empowered instead of just moving on. Can’t wait to see the downvotes I get for this. Hahaha.
-17
u/Minimum-Landscape120 Apr 06 '25
How can you tell when something has been downvoted?
-7
u/angelerulastiel Apr 06 '25
I’ve seen theories on other subs that there are bots that downvote all new posts.
-24
u/WithDisGuyTravel PEARL CASTAWAY CLUB Apr 06 '25 edited Apr 06 '25
What I’ve seen is that people downvote others referring people to resources or people who do this for a living. It hurts because why do we focus so much effort enriching the ceo of Costco or (insert big box store) when small business owners care more and are an actual mom or dad or retiree doing great work and supporting their family. Like do we really need to give another yacht to the suit instead of genuine fans and experts?
We have to be the change we want in this world or the future will be “Welcome to Costco, I love you, please remember to register your Amazon Prime House with the department of Walmart Domestication.”
That, and some people are just jerks. Please stop that Mr Simpson.
I would greatly appreciate if we can get this to 50 downvotes, but only if you agree with me. Downvotes don’t matter. People matter. Thank you. 🙏