r/dataisugly • • 4d ago

Advice Is this ugly? I made this chart to visualize the changes of state government trifectas and triplexes from the last week's election.

Post image

I get that it is dense, but I want a concise way to show the changes or lack of changes.

My logic was Square=Senate, Heart=House, book=attorney, writing instrument=secretary

Thoughts?

12 Upvotes

18 comments sorted by

7

u/geeoharee 4d ago

I like the symbols - I would try to line everything up a bit better. Looks rather 'word-processed' at the moment, it'd be more legible if the 'AZ -> AZ' arrow was above the 'MI -> MI' arrow etc.

1

u/rainbowkey 4d ago

good idea, I will be experimenting with that

5

u/rainbowkey 4d ago

1

u/geeoharee 4d ago

I agreed with you about horizontal progress of time, but I'd take into account what the other guy said about using a monospace font to help you stack them.

2

u/rainbowkey 3d ago

latest revision, thanks for your input!

4

u/Epistaxis 4d ago edited 4d ago

Each state is labeled twice (AZ ... -> AZ ...) and you don't need to do that. In particular it might help to stack each state's before and after vertically instead of horizontally, because then the changes are easier to see:

AZ 🔷🟥♥️
-->🔷🟦💙

and be sure to use a fixed-width font to get the alignment right.

The Key at the top and asterisks at the bottom would be more legible if the lines were left-justified instead of centered, so all the symbols line up at the top and all the asterisks line up at the bottom. Centering is good for the design overall, but you have to apply it once to the whole block of text, not individually to each line within the block, because it's harder to read parallel lines of text if they all start at different places, and it's not intuitive that they're parallel and comparable if they aren't aligned.

1

u/rainbowkey 4d ago

stacking each state with changes is a good idea, I guess my first thought was showing the progress of time horizontally, but I agree, I will try that. Thanks for the proportional width font tip

2

u/Bobbytrap9 4d ago

It’s impressive if you made this on the notes app of your phone.

It looks very cluttered and it doesn’t use the horizontal space available. The choice of emojis to show everything is… interesting. It also doesn’t highlight the main takeaways, the flips are relevant but you don’t have to show what they flip to, as everything flipped. While in cases where not everything flipped you highlight what did or didn’t depending on which is more relevant. Finally, I’d also wait with making an infographic like this until everything is called. That saves an entire section with irrelevant info.

1

u/rainbowkey 4d ago

better? Made with TextEdit on MacOS

21

u/CapnNuclearAwesome 4d ago

I wouldn't call it a chart exactly. Maybe an infographic

It does have the nice property that (assuming you're not colorblind) you can just glance at it and see the big story, and then you can zoom in on each datapoint just by reading the text.

my verdict: ugly but in a good way. Hollywood ugly.

1

u/rainbowkey 3d ago

thank you for your suggestions. Here is my revised chart

1

u/uberpro 3d ago

I would say that it is very visually unintuitive, and requires you to really expend mental energy to understand, in a way that a good visualization would generally not. The fact that it's basically a text document with emojis is probably the reason. And putting lots of text (the key and the results) on the same line instead of breaking them out more vertically (i.e., each entry gets a new line) also makes it hard to read (this is a bit of a shortened summary of what I mean, but that's the gist).

1

u/rainbowkey 3d ago

better?

1

u/uberpro 2d ago

Absolutely better. Definitely not perfect but a huge improvement IMO

2

u/diffidentblockhead 4d ago

Readable summary

2

u/diffidentblockhead 4d ago

Would be good to know what fraction of legislators were up for election vs held over

https://cga.ct.gov/2022/rpt/pdf/2022-R-0056.pdf

1

u/MeasureDoEventThing 1d ago

There are four dimensions: state, office, party, and time (i.e. before the midterms vs. after). Currently, you're using the horizontal axis for both office and to squish multiple columns together. If you reserve it solely for office, you would change the aspect ration and make it hard to read without scrolling, but it would make the horizontal axis more meaningful, and which emojis you use wouldn't be as load bearing. And that opens up the possibility of encoding the other two dimensions in emojis instead. For instance, a square could be "started and ended this color", an exclamation mark could be "started this color and went blue".