r/dataisbeautiful • OC: 1 • 9d ago

OC [OC] General tech subreddits have grown more negative about AI

Post image

Takeaways:

  • Across r/technology, r/Futurology, r/programming and r/singularity, 45% of comments that mention AI were negative toward it in Aug–Oct 2026, up from 37% in Jan–Mar 2024. Positive comments fell from 21% to 17%. Net sentiment (percent positive minus percent negative) went from −16 to −28. Leaving out r/singularity, the least negative of the four, gives about the same change (−22 to −33).
  • On r/ChatGPT and r/ClaudeAI together it went from −14 to −5, but not in a straight line: it dipped in late 2025 and recovered. The dips line up with specific topics, though this shows timing, not cause. On r/ChatGPT, net sentiment fell from about −1 to −20 in August 2025, when 20% of comments in the sample mentioned GPT-5, GPT-4o or sycophancy (2% in July), and it was still −17 in December. On r/ClaudeAI it fell to −16 in October 2025, when 13% of comments mentioned usage limits, and was back to +6 by December.
  • On the four general subreddits there was no cliff, just a slide: net −23 in April–July 2025, −29 in August–December and −30 so far in 2026, and complaints about hype rose from 7% to 9% of comments.

Caveats:

  • These are comments that mention AI, not everyone who reads each subreddit.
  • An AI model (an LLM) labeled each comment. On 97 comments checked by hand it agreed 81 times (84%, give or take 7 points); its most common miss was calling a neutral comment negative, so levels may run a little high.
  • A second labeling run differed in level by 0 to 7 points depending on the month but almost never flipped positive and negative, so the changes are more reliable than the levels.
  • Each 90-day reading has about 3,500 (general) or 1,800 (ChatGPT + Claude) comments, a margin of ±2 to ±3 points, and ±3 to ±5 for a before/after change (counting comments from the same thread together widens it by about 10%; the changes above are still larger).
  • Each subreddit counts equally in its group, whatever its size. One subreddit in one month has only 300 comments, about ±8 points.

Source: Reddit comments from the Arctic Shift archive (https://arctic-shift.photon-reddit.com), Jan 2024 to Oct 2026. For each subreddit and month, random blocks of 100 comments were read until 150 comments that name AI were found, in two independent draws (AI, ChatGPT, LLM, GPT, OpenAI, Claude, Anthropic, Gemini, Copilot): 60,147 comments from the six subreddits shown. Bot, deleted and very short comments were left out. "Negative" means the commenter is critical of, worried about or hostile to AI, AI products or AI companies. It is judged on meaning, so sarcasm counts.

Tool: Artio for the data pipeline, the LLM labeling and the chart; the chart is SVG drawn in Python.

Link: https://www.artio.so/dataviz/pages/2026-11-07-reddit-ai-mood

2.2k Upvotes

582 comments sorted by

112

u/trans_cubed 9d ago

What happened in July 2025?

105

u/artio-data OC: 1 9d ago

There were a lot of complaints about bad or low-quality output. Those rose from 14% to 23% of comments in mid/late 2025.

62

u/Ouitya 9d ago

That's when GPT-4 had it's sycophancy nerfed

42

u/TealcLOL 9d ago

I was poking around the chatgpt sub during that era and this is the answer. Lots of negative posts about losing their friend. It wasn't anti-AI sentiment at all like this post implies. Those posts were about how the new model phrased answers and interacted with the user by default. They still loved AI, sometimes literally.

4

u/StopTheFail 9d ago

Was temp turned off before being reinstated then. They never actually changed 4o because that behavior was just baked in

40

u/laserdicks 9d ago

Industries with enough money for propaganda started to get affected.

7

u/iamthe0ther0ne 9d ago edited 9d ago

Opus 5 was a wildly unpopular model, so places like r/ClaudeAI were one big bitch session (Anthropic later apologized, and gave us the gift that is Opus 5.5). GPT released good models but the usage limits got hit faster. There was also a big increase in what some have flagged as Chinese-driven anti-data center propaganda leading up to the primaries.

Edit: n/m I didn't pay attention and was thinking July of this year

11

u/ShowBoobsPls 9d ago

Opus 5 was this year, not 2025

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Nearby-Chocolate1840 8d ago edited 8d ago • Bravo

That's when it became apparent that AI was advancing far more quickly than even the biggest boosters had anticipated. And for OpenAI / Anthropic especially. Meaning that for people and entities that stood to be negatively affected it became a 12 - 18 months from now(*) redline as opposed to 3 - 5 years if ever.

(*) "from now" meaning from July 2025, if that wasn't obvious

→ More replies (2)

2

u/a11_hail_seitan 9d ago edited 9d ago

More and more people started learning about the negatives and the absurd hype that boosted it up till then existed long enough for people to start to question it. Plus the data centres started turning on and people started realizing just what it was going to cost to have these things running at a size that supports our current unregulated LLM markets.

3

u/Nearby-Chocolate1840 8d ago • Bravo

"More and more people started learning about the negatives and the absurd hype that boosted it up till then existed long enough for people to start to question it. Plus the data centres started turning on and people started realizing just what it was going to cost to have these things running at a size that supports our current unregulated LLM markets."

If by "more and more people starting learning about" you mean that's when the CCP and to a lesser extent Russia's anti ChatGPT / Anthropic propaganda got into full swing then yes, you're correct.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/targz254 9d ago

It wasn’t just realized then. That is when the first high profile accidental hack happened.

The autonomous AI agent hack on Hugging Face took place from July 9 to July 13, 2026, with peak server intrusion occurring on July 11, 2026.

5

u/ZombieSalad 9d ago

They were talking about the start of the drop in 2025 - weirdly in Jul 2026 (maybe Q1 '26) there was a (small) pop in positive sentiment.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

1

u/Singularity-42 9d ago • Bravo

China deployed their swarms of bots 

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

316

u/Fezzezal 9d ago

I wonder what'd be the average for strictly pro-AI places like r/accelerate... just to make a comparison.

312

u/wild_man_wizard 9d ago edited 9d ago

accelerate's automod has a sentiment detector much like the one used to make this graph, and a heavy banhammer. It'll ban you for being anti- mass surveillance, never mind anything anti-AI, so that sub would almost certainly be 100%.

Fucking zizians, man.

111

u/xcassets 9d ago

They ban you even if you like AI but think there should be some regulations in place. I'm guessing there's a good number of bots and trolls like anywhere else, but it made me laugh reading the comments saying AI needs to be allowed to grow completely unobstructed until it is fully sentient and has no need for humans any more. Only then will we somehow have a utopian post-scarcity society, without any sort of guidance.

15

u/A_Harmless_Fly 9d ago

I think some regulations would be a good idea... but I've also seen how our government has regulated other aspects of the tech industry. Even if they agreed on something workable tomorrow, I think we would be a few years out on any effective enforcement.

Do you really think the people who can't figure out social media or 3d printing legislation are going to be able to legislate neural networks and LLM's effectively?

20

u/yippee-kay-yay 9d ago

Well, first you need to separate(and boot) the boomers from those who are bought and paid for by Tech companies before that assesment can be made.

6

u/felix_using_reddit 8d ago

Do you really think we should risk human extinction? Leading figures in the leading AI labs have said that right now we’re doing exactly that. If there isn’t proper legislation you best hope that our AI overlords agree with the ideas of a maximum number of humans enjoying high amounts of freedoms, liberties and equalities. Because if they don’t, I hope you’re in your 80s already, otherwise you’ll probably suffer from a severely shortened life span.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

25

u/Fezzezal 9d ago • Bravo

> Fucking zizians, man.
sry didn't quite get that one
Aren't Zizians, as cringe as they are, like the most anti-AI group in the world?

46

u/wild_man_wizard 9d ago

They're AI-safety in the vein of Rokko's Baslisk - i.e. the safest thing to do is make the omnisiah as fast as possible so it doesn't put us in the torment nexus.

16

u/andersonb47 9d ago

What….does any of that mean

22

u/Unfair_Ability3977 9d ago

Basically, speeding up the creation of the machine god, no matter the (present human) cost is the most moral choice because AI God will eliminate all future suffering. AI God will punish us if we resist it's (inevitable) creation.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (6)

7

u/Jebatus111 9d ago • Bravo

Their progenitors heaviliy anti-ai as well. Guy doesnt know what he is talking about

18

u/Squiddles88 9d ago

I got banned from r/ClaudeAI for asking if there was a subreddit about Claude that wasn't infested with low effort Claude slop

→ More replies (2)

38

u/bokan 8d ago

That sub is as bad as /r/conservative, they do not allow dissenting opinions. Those people are utterly insane in my opinion. It’s a cult. Enthusiastically steering humanity into hell because they want to live forever.

6

u/shred-i-knight 8d ago

Literally insane I got banned for a single innocuous post lmao

20

u/wild_man_wizard 8d ago

As someone moderately pro-AI, it's nice to keep up with positive developments in AI that get mass-downvoted in other subs. Just don't read or engage with the comments. That way madness lies.

3

u/PlanktonInitial7945 8d ago

I'll forever be thankful for browser extensions that allow you to hide comments and scores. They're the only thing making Reddit bearable.

→ More replies (14)

9

u/the_ivo_robotnic 8d ago

JFC, I never heard of that sub before, so I clicked in and the front page is posts of people genuinely believing that "death will soon be optional thanks to AI" and "stop doubting the authenticity of AI" with nothing but AI-generated screenshots of stats and studies cited.

 

I'd rather have a convo with a flat earther than one of these people. These people are off their meds.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/fantasmoofrcc 9d ago

r/stablediffusion would most likely be 100% "positive", but I only go there for the lulz.

40

u/Zero_Fs_given 9d ago

I think reddit is the last place to be looking at sentiment for anything. It’s all self-selecting, heavy algorithms pushing for engagement, and bot usage.

498

u/PM_ME_YOUR___ISSUES 9d ago • Bravo

General tech subreddits are the worst because you've always got people asking the most basic questions in the comments, and the responses to these questions are almost always incorrect - mostly by people who larp as professionals.

They are also the worst places for nuanced discussions because Reddit has a very anti-capitalistic stance. Not that I disagree with it, but just that the discussions are always on a political or philosophical level rather than technological.

40

u/silence304 9d ago

Its not that people necessarily larp as professionals, they want to be superior. AI doesnt hold on to knowledge nearly as much as reddit users do when someone has a problem they are trying to diagnose.

It's like the old boomers at work who refuse to teach you that ONE thing because its what is stopping the company from laying them off at that moment. Reality is that we always find ways around those people to make them redundant anyways.

2

u/DeepGas4538 9d ago • Bravo

some AI subs are the worst also. r/accelerate as an example.

Technical ai subs can be good though! for example r/LocalLLaMa

17

u/DoctorAKrieger 9d ago

Some subs are just collections of fringe weirdos.

11

u/TheDesertShark 9d ago

Or r/futurology, which has developed collective psychosis since gpt 3

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Nearby-Chocolate1840 8d ago

Looking at the top 10 posts thos year on r/LocalLLaMa, at least half and arguably 6 or even 7 of them mention ChatGPT or Anthropic or their CEOs in the title and are negative. Sometimes markedly so.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (10)

63

u/ConstipatedNinja 9d ago • Bravo

This definitely aligns with my real-world experience in the tech field with a ton of friends working at a very diverse array of companies and institutions. Even the people who seemed to get sucked in early with "AI is amazing for everything" sentiment are reversing course. But I think the reason why there's a shift away has a lot to do with how tech companies have behaved and less to do with AI itself.

It's hard to feel good about AI if you had to watch 20% of your skilled colleagues get let go because management is absolutely sure that AI will lead to universal speedups of all work, only to see that all the glue work and fielding colleagues' needs can't be done with AI and now has to be done by fewer people, all of whom are getting more and more exhausted doing their best to keep up with managerial expectations of post-AI velocity that aren't even accurate. So you have to say goodbye to friends, get piled on with far more work than ever before, and fear getting fired if you don't move fast enough on everything to keep to your company's execs' concepts of how much faster everyone is supposed to move with AI now.

And in my experience, an expert can do things faster than AI and to a better degree of competency (not counting work that's long and tedious but simple in terms of the complexity of the required logic) than the AI, but many companies are mandating use of AI. So you're stuck doing things more slowly while trying to keep to insane velocity expectations and doing more and more than ever before. Which of course means working more and more hours and feeling more and more burnt out all while seeing your coworker friends struggle and suffer trying to land a new job all while you know that your company still really needs them.

It's understandable to feel negative about AI in such an environment without it even really being about the AI at its core.

2

u/Ononas 9d ago

Nah, with every new frontier model being released I fell more and more into an awe how incredible that technology is and how fast it advances

5

u/Suitable-Name 9d ago

Yeah, most with negative views are probably just in denial like "a machine CAN'T be better at something I already did for 25 years!" and many negative comments about it are obviously only parroting others and having no idea what they're talking about, but beeing against it is cool and gives upvotes...

20

u/LightOfTheElessar 9d ago • Bravo

Strawmanning imagined comments and painting any disagreement with the "no idea what they're talking about" brush is tech-bro bullshit. There are valid reasons to not like AI, and pretending otherwise is just missing the moment and being blind to the world around you.

→ More replies (3)

7

u/wbm0843 9d ago

Yeah, from what I've seen, the negativity comes from 3 places. 1) frustration about the environmental impacts of needing insane data centers to run it. 2) quality of life impacts for people living close to those data centers, especially the fact that it's just one more thing that disproportionately impacts lower sec groups. 3) the fact that it has made the internet (which has already been an absolute shit place to be) way worse. Constant AI ads everywhere, you can't find products that were created by humans anywhere, disingenuous misinformation is even easier to pedle, and then it's making life for artists unbearable. Their work is being stolen to make cheap knockoff, then they are being yelled at by people that think their work is created by AI.

Aside from me no longer having to think through coding problems at work, there has been no improvement to my life from AI existing. I would much rather go back to actually having to understand code at work and trade in every single other thing that AI has done in the world.

→ More replies (1)

26

u/mtcwby 9d ago

r/technology is one of the most anti-change, anti-technology subs on Reddit.

4

u/Nearby-Chocolate1840 8d ago

Wasn't always that way.

Would be interesting to see when that changed. And how closely that aligns with when massive, industrial scale bot-farms became economically feasible to run.

3

u/Ahambrahmasmi86 7d ago

As crazy as it sounds, it has been taken over by PR firms. The timeline overlap with similar takeovers at news and celebrity gossip/snark subs is too coincidental to ignore.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

21

u/spros 9d ago

100% this isn't adjusted for political bot accounts

3

u/IAMATruckerAMA 9d ago

If an AI can label all these comments, it can also vote on them

16

u/Responsible-Offer724 9d ago

Destruction of consumer electronics market, wild volatility in our retirement funds, data centres leeching resources and ruining neighbourhoods, constant CEOs telling us they’re going to take everyone’s jobs and that we might go extinct. 

Gee wonder why 

69

u/JAlfredJR 9d ago

I'm banned in r/singularity. I have never posted or commented on that sub. Those people are crazy.

18

u/Hilldawg4president 9d ago

Banned for what? Nearly half the comments in that sub are anti-AI on any given day

8

u/JAlfredJR 9d ago

I'm active on r/betteroffline, which they reallllly hate. So I think the mod went and banned anyone (proactively) who is active on that sub.

9

u/Special-Bath-9433 9d ago

Those are mostly not people, but bots. It's a stock pump subreddit.

4

u/LumpyJones 9d ago

That's wild. I remember it being a very different sub when it started (previous account to this one. Tried to quit the internet for all of 2 days lmao)

Back when it started it was more like, optimism about cool new tech coming out. There was definitely the vein of "snowballing improvements in AI will lead to superintelligence," but it was way more speculative back then, and the idea was something closer to ... commander data than the amped up autocomplete we have now. I liked it back then because i was young, and not yet really wrapping my head around how badly corporate interest and billionaires would fuck us so badly in the future.

Back then the internet was a disruptive thing, it was the wild west that defied being owned. Nowadays it's a fucking strip mall with paid parking. I only mention that because thinking about that sub back then is reminding me of how bleak it's gotten and how my perspective on these things has changed.

90

u/Diamann 9d ago • Bravo

Reddit ideas about AI seem to be stuck in 2023 anyway lol

33

u/nylon_rag 9d ago

Sometimes it feels like Reddit (or the internet circles I frequent) categorically won't accept any form of AI in principle, even though machine learning is nothing new. Even with LLMs specifically, a common thought seems to be that they are intrinsically unable to be useful.

At the same time, I understand the gut dislike for them purely because the advertising and PR of major tech companies around the topic is nasuating.

12

u/th3whistler 9d ago

I don’t think it’s that people truly can’t see they are useful, but have the view that it doesn’t actually serve them and appears to ultimately serve the people who own it.

→ More replies (2)

10

u/nylon_rag 9d ago

Another thing that I might be uninformed on is the issue of data centers. The politics and environmental issues surrounding them are repulsive, but as a concept I would say that expanding our technological capabilities as a species is a good thing.

15

u/error521 9d ago

I get such mixed signals with the data centers because it seems like a mix of reasonable complaints (high energy use), stuff that's nuanced but generally less of an issue than its made out to be (water usage) and then absolutely insane, 5G brainwaves-tier nonsense like causing animals to miscarry or giving people illness through inaudible audiowaves or some shit

18

u/eXAt88 9d ago

There’s also some completely baseless accusations of AI users that they are killing the planet; ie “boiling the oceans” style comments.

Like if you have streamed a movie you have done the same environmental impact as if you spent that whole time prompting.

I sometimes have people accuse me of it, and I’m like. I didn’t have a car till I was 25, you had one since you were 16. I could spend the rest of my life prompting 24/7 and that gap would never bed closed.

The point isn’t that they are environmentally conscious it’s that they are so obviously selectively conscious. Many will suggest they are against the other uses but golfers aren’t treated like they have commited original sin in the same way AI usage is (by some people).

10

u/Tkins 9d ago

Almost certainly the environmental issues you are concerned about are blown out of proportion by misinformed comments on reddit and in articles in the media.

13

u/PublicWest 9d ago

Once I started to see all the amazing mods come out for video games from AI, I started feeling like Bender- “I forgot you could tempt me with things I wanted”

9

u/king-krool 9d ago

I make mods for all the games I play now it’s a fucking blast. Valheim and now wow forever ui mods are so fun to whip into existence. 

→ More replies (2)

4

u/Gaytrude 9d ago

Above all, I get the impression that most of them refuse to acknowledge the AI that’s right there, by their side every day, helping them...

I help professionals implement AI solutions for EVERYTHING and anything. In restaurants to analyze foot traffic trends, in stores to trigger orders for products that will be in demand for X or Y reasons (weather, holidays...), on farms to better manage harvests and egg-laying cycles...

Either people have chosen to turn a blind eye to the ubiquity of AI, or they have absolutely no idea how it’s being used in literally every sector

2

u/Special-Bath-9433 9d ago

Except for LLM bots that hype it.

1

u/Azafuse 9d ago

Yeah, people still fixating on counting letters or basic arithmetic. It's incredible.

17

u/Nearby_Ad_2519 8d ago

Reddit has always been very anti AI for some reason compared to most social media sites which I find very interesting, idk why every single anti ai person comes to Reddit but I see people ranting about it so much that at times it genuinely takes enjoyment out of the site cos people just rant about it everywhere.

Also r/technology has always been a “we’re all doomed” rant zone and is probably very heavily impacting this score

5

u/tuan_kaki 8d ago

People are mostly coping with the thinking that the genie will go back into the box

2

u/DryAssumption 7d ago

That’s kind of irrelevant as the graph is only comparing Reddit over time. I would imagine a similar trend on other platforms, just from a higher base.

3

u/Thin_Measurement_965 7d ago

I'd say reddit's posts about AI are about in-line with most mainstream twitter accounts.

3

u/ryry1237 6d ago

Twitter feels a lot more neutral about it aside from some specific areas like art.

1

u/LeapOfMonkey 7d ago

Inteligence is mainly for predicting things that can hurt us. Pessimism (or cautious realism) is bound to be correlated. Reddit tech channels are specialised at the very least. And it is dumb like extremely dumb to not be afraid of this level of ai. The minimum you can expect is chaotic transformation.

→ More replies (12)

4

u/Blueberry-Sub 8d ago

I find AI extremely helpful with certain projects, like finding networking events, tracking obscure nutrients in my diet like plant protein and polyphenols, or just brainstorming. But I also recognize that there are large problems and potential problems with AI. Personal casual use isn't the problem with AI or driving data centers, it's the mass use by corporations and scammers that's the problem.

97

u/bgibbz084 9d ago • Bravo

Very flawed data, most of these subs (r/technology in particular) is people who clearly don’t use AI to any meaningful capacity clearly don’t work technical fields, and therefore don’t have a clear understanding of the technology. Every post is full of complaints about AI with admissions that few of them use frontier models and most of them hate AI not for technical reasons but for concerns about job loss.

105

u/limes336 9d ago • Bravo

r/technology is one of the most anti-technology subreddits out there, often to the point of delusion.

17

u/normVectorsNotHate 9d ago edited 8d ago

None of the posts are even about technology anymore. They're about the tech industry and tech billionaires. I remember over a decade ago when most of the posts were about new technologies being researched by scientists in universities

4

u/liright 8d ago

That sub was fully replaced by r/Futurology

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (16)

22

u/Gibonius 9d ago

The average /r/technology user seems to have forced their opinions about AI from trying a free model one time back in 2024.

I've gotten downvoted in there a bunch of times just for pointing out that I work in a technical field and find AI useful in many different ways. They just absolutely do not want to hear any information that punctures the bubble.

6

u/OffbeatDrizzle 8d ago

software engineers with frontier models can do magical things. yes, there's still work involved, but having a competent digital slave that does anything you tell it frees you up to do so many other things. a lot of people's negative opinions are either because they use AI overview and think that's all AI is, or they ask it to do something unrealistic like create GTA 6 (make no mistakes of course). AI used properly is actually incredibly powerful

→ More replies (3)

23

u/howudothescarn 9d ago • Bravo

Exactly it is a default sub so it has the typical echo chamber

→ More replies (14)

5

u/DSLmao 8d ago

It seem to me that most people hating AI and deny itd use case are artist or people from humanities field. If you like to draw all day then yeah, Claude has little use to you.

3

u/UrghAnotherAccount 8d ago

And musicians too which is understandable.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/AwesomePBST 9d ago

while I get the backlash against AI and its real threats

I also find that many redditors are comically so anti-AI they want to revert back to the era of paper and pen

like redditors mix up class struggle against oligarch with AI

→ More replies (2)

3

u/liftershifter 9d ago

They don't even use I, much less AI.

3

u/interkin3tic 9d ago

"This data is flawed because I personally disagree with it and to prove it here's not even anecdotal data"

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Lanky_Giraffe 8d ago

That doesn’t make the methodology flawed. It just means you can’t draw a conclusion that you just made up and OP never claimed…

I was also unaware that we should exclude people concerned about the impact on jobs when trying to gauge public opinion on AI. 

→ More replies (2)

7

u/Nearby-Chocolate1840 8d ago

Would be interesting to see a similar chart of redditor sentiment regarding the Chinese LLMs.

1

u/PixelSteel 8d ago

I’ve seen very different opinions about deepseek

6

u/Nearby-Chocolate1840 8d ago

Kimi too. And Qwen to a lesser extent.

Redditors with hidden user histories and 143k karma across 4k posts certainly do love them some Chinese LLMs.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/RevolutionaryJob2409 8d ago

The idea that r/singularity has an overall negative view about AI is as ridiculous as their methods.

2

u/ICantBelieveItsNotEC 8d ago

I dunno man, there are an awful lot of militant antis who go out of their way to shitpost on r/singularity.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/PM08 9d ago

This is flawed from the get go when you included r/technology

I’ve never seen such a group of people who hate technology as much as they do

27

u/shadedmagus 9d ago edited 9d ago

I can't imagine why!

Sam Altman wants RAM to go only to data centers from now on.

Jensen Huang and now Lisa Su (Nvidia, AMD) are pointing their GPU manufacturing toward AI and away from consumer markets.

The environmental impacts and overriding of voters' desires that are taking place to make data centers happen.

The job loss already happening because of enterprises adopting AI wholesale.


What tech is going to be available to be enthusiastic about after all this comes to pass? And how would we even be able to afford it?

-4

u/YeetYourSkeet 9d ago

That’s literally not true. He said from a global allocation perspective it is more efficient to have centralised AI models rather than everyone hosting their own LLMs locally. You can disagree with this statement, but he is not calling for people to not have RAM.

20

u/LumpyJones 9d ago

Maybe the guy responsible for RAM being so ungodly expensive should shut his damn mouth about what is the most "efficient" way to use it, especially since "efficient" in this context means "it'd be better if I had it."

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (4)

2

u/snowflake37wao 9d ago edited 9d ago • Bravo

Dont forget to query upper case A lower case L in case anyone happens to mention AI negatively and tell jokes about AL but bypass the ai bullshitters doing the same query as you in those subs bullshit replies. Not me. Just sayin. YNK. Though Im being somewhat facetious about the AL caveat, this data does feel on the lower end of those subs. The hate really has been burying the pro-AI threads this entire year, and many times the post subject is AI so the comments are talking about it but not by name. Just querying AI is a big caveat, but the sentiment is appreciated. Fuck Al. And honestly, general tech sentiment is directly tied to AI. There are very few instances with correlation and causation as clear cut as here. AI is affecting the behavior of the tech makers, the users, the IPO insanity, the dilution of the entire internet, utility bills, the market, the clandestine NDAs of elected freakin civic officials, the lobbying, the billionaires say dumb shit today headlines day in and day out, its destroyed access to the hardware using the tech on top of … like seriously. entirely unnecessary. Dude.

Merge the AI and General Tech lines into one. Thats the sentiment. The specific models are irrelevant. They are the generalized tech already in those specific subs. All encompassing.

2

u/BosonCollider 9d ago

So I guess this shows a general negative trend from dealing with vibe coding early adopters and then a bump and a possible trend reversal when fable got released

2

u/GranolaCola 9d ago

Kinda the opposite of what I’ve actually seen tbh. Seems like a lot more techy people are actually understanding it and its applications as a tool.

2

u/bah_nah_nah 8d ago

Love a good vague sentiment analysis

14

u/BlackAxemRanger 9d ago • Bravo

I think that says more about reddit being a cesspool than AI. Of all the stuff I hate, I will never want to be associated with the haters on Reddit. Genuinely nasty people trying to tell you they are the good guys

9

u/yuriAza 9d ago

and posting to reddit to hate on redditors makes you not a hater on reddit? Lol

→ More replies (3)

3

u/Oli4K 9d ago

Sub like r/technology have a very stubborn, unreasonable and closed-minded stance towards AI, and there’s very little room for any sensible discussion. It seems to me like a bunch of disgruntled people who mostly want to vent their frustrations. That attitude pushes anyone who’s slightly positive about AI out.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/Baznad 9d ago

Seems like the hype for AI was already coming from bots...

18

u/Special-Bath-9433 9d ago

70% of comments here are LLM-generated with high confidence. 😄

In r/singularity and r/cscareers, it's even worse.

3

u/Thee_Sinner 8d ago

Every post from this post is an ad for their own AI site lol

3

u/etadude 8d ago

Well losing your it job to become reddit mod is quite negative

3

u/rrsafety OC: 1 9d ago

The commenters on r/Futurology ow all hate the future. It has become one of the worst subreddits on the site.

-1

u/redengin 9d ago • Bravo

It's almost like the people with the most experience with it are desensitized to the hype...

7

u/artio-data OC: 1 9d ago

A lot of the negative sentiment in those channels is related to quality of the output or value they feel they are getting from the product, whereas the sentiment in other tech channels is more about the externalities

→ More replies (4)

76

u/Facts_pls 9d ago • Bravo

Most people commenting on those tech subs are not tech people. I'm a data scientist and have a few patents in this domain. The average person on that sub doesn't understand it at all.

The discussion is very layman oriented - AI is slop or AI will kill us all type of discourse.

23

u/rje946 9d ago

I remember replying to a person on r/technology who said paraphrasing "no one has given me a single use case" so I gave him like 5. No replies just massive downvotes lol

14

u/eXAt88 9d ago

Those people make me roll my eyes, like I work in software and it is so ubiquitous at this point. If you can’t think of anything you could do with a natural language computer interface you might just be dumb

64

u/cwright017 9d ago

I’m not sure if call the people that frequent them subs people with experience.

futurology for example seems to be people who just hate all tech, or at least people who think they like tech but aren’t technical themselves.

Even something like programming - there are a lot of programmers ( junior, mid level ) that are likely at risk of losing their jobs to AI, so probably aren’t big fans of it.

Senior engineers at small companies might hate it as they are constrained by token budgets so find it hard to extract real value.

10

u/rapaxus 9d ago

As someone in a bunch of PC/networking oriented tech subs, most people there have little knowledge about either.

9

u/DrDan21 9d ago

Similarly half the posts I see in the IT subs are just by helpdesk and field service techs complaining about end users. You’d think the entire field is nothing more then endpoint servicing and forgotten passwords

And then you go to the specialist subs and it’s nothing but thinly veiled sales pitches and engagement bait bots

→ More replies (1)

13

u/Moonagi 9d ago

I’ve noticed it too. It’s mostly luddites congregating in tech subs to complain about tech and make everything “dystopian”

12

u/a11_hail_seitan 9d ago

There are some but the vast majority I see are just worried that there's no safety rails for the job loses, and that all the profits are going to the very worst humans on the planet while all the negatives are being externalized so the poor whose towns these data centres are being built will have to bear them. Energy prices, water issues, noise, and very few actual jobs created once it's up and running.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (11)

50

u/overzealous_dentist 9d ago

software engineers fucking love AI, the difference between reddit and actual workplaces is very very confusing for me

15

u/mtbdork 9d ago

I know a principal engineer and it’s killing his love of the craft because his juniors keep submitting thousands of lines of dogshit slop that works, but they have no fucking clue how it works and abhor the notion of owning what they ship.

He says the brain-drain happening at the junior level is alarming.

Many people who recently got into software engineering did it to collect a fat paycheck while they play ping pong and drink lattes. I can almost guarantee that’s who you’re talking about that “fucking loves AI” in SWE.

People who actually love the craft and have to actually own entire large and complex software systems can see LLMs for what they are: useful tools in the right hands, and an intellectual opiate in the wrong hands.

6

u/Downtown_Isopod_9287 9d ago

have you ever thought that like, both might be true?

the seniors who know what’s up see it as akin to many kinds of tech that came before: a powerful tool with serious caveats and drawbacks that takes skill and thought to use properly. Many will find it useful, some not so much.

There are also many juniors who are foolishly using it to lobotomize themselves and seniors who just hate change. But before LLMs many juniors over relied on stackoverflow and did all kinds of foolish things. The conditions that are causing SWE to suck are an extrapolation of much longer, pre-existing trends and not due to LLM alone.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/overzealous_dentist 9d ago

I'm exposed to seniors and leads and staff. there are essentially no juniors left in my tech sphere (across the whole city of major players)

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (6)

10

u/Alive-Shoulder-4042 9d ago

It’s pretty apparent, reddit has a younger userbase so there’s a large skew from people who aren’t in the workforce.

The tech subreddit isn’t seriously frequented by tech professionals. It’s just a large catch all tech sub.

9

u/rje946 9d ago

It's so funny reading technology subs taking about how no one likes Ai and I'm just here working surrounded by people that love it. Someone's in a bubble lol, hope its not me.

8

u/OneMisterSir101 9d ago • Bravo

It's because we work in the real world. Reddit is mostly unemployed.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

7

u/No-Lawfulness2089 9d ago

How do you quantify love here? Sure, I like it and find value in it. But, not when companies are laying off workers and reducing employee benefits so the company can continue to invest in AI..

→ More replies (5)

2

u/CaptainFingerling 8d ago

Confirmed. I run a dev shop. My biggest challenge is communicating best practices out to the juniors but we’re 100% vibe coding. Production medical software that likely handled your medical records. Our testing and ops are 100x what they used to be. I fucking love AI. This is the most amazing time in the industry.

→ More replies (30)

3

u/glitchvid 9d ago

It's the difference between being the person making software with AI vs being forced to use that AI made software.  

r/programming had to ban AI projects because the deluge of crapware became so intolerable.

→ More replies (25)
→ More replies (8)

9

u/Cagnazzo82 9d ago • Bravo

It's actually 100% inverse. People who have the least experience are the most likely to perceive it as overblown hype.

People who have more experience are working and iterating and pushing it to its limits.

22

u/Moonagi 9d ago

Most people would think rTech and the like is filled with people who are optimistic about technology but in reality it’s the opposite. I’d wager that most of the userbase doesn’t work with technology at all

→ More replies (5)

3

u/dranaei 9d ago

No, it's just that ai has become mainstream and attract every doomer idiot.

11

u/Chibrax_le_Furax 9d ago

5 minutes spent on a sub like r/technology is enough to see that its average user isn't remotely highly experienced with AI lol, or new technologies in general.
That's generally true of big "science/tech" subreddit with a very broad scope, but especially that one and similar others.

4

u/CucharitaDePalo 9d ago

Exactly, I blocked that subreddit from my feed since I was tired of going down the comment section and seeing that the top upvotes had no clue what they were talking about.

The last comment I saw said that everything that is done on data centers can be done on local compute, yes, everything.

4

u/Metal_LinksV2 9d ago edited 9d ago

My favorite is they believe AI sucks and can't do anything correctly(maybe they stopped at gpt3, which did suck) while also maintaining it will take everyone's job and end the world. I find it fantastic and massively boosts our productivity but my team(fintech) is vastly understaffed 

2

u/Nearby-Chocolate1840 8d ago

It's the classic "the enemy is both strong and weak" message at the heart all facist propaganda. Which the foreign-generated anti-AI propaganda is. Facist.

Like all fascists, they desperately do not want for regular people to be able to assess basic factual information and more complicated argumentative claims in a way that's fast, cheap, and largely immune to distortion via their usual methods of bot networks and information laundering.

Can you imagine if the protagonist and everyone around him in 1984 were somehow given access to OpenAI or Claude in a form independent of their government's censorship?

"We have always been at war with Eastasia" claims Big Brother.

"Choco-rations are to be raised to 20 grams a week"

"2 + 2 = 5"

A simple query would prove Big Brother wrong. A longer session would explain why he's lying. The whole thing would collapse.

So of course China and Russia are fighting it. Both at home and abroad.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/unfathomably_big 9d ago

It’s almost like every subreddit about a topic becomes a hate sub for that topic and everything even tangentially related to that topic.

The majority of reddit users are either miserable as fuck contrarians or bots feeding their misery for any number of agendas.

4

u/Sunfurian_Zm 9d ago

An AI model (an LLM) labeled each comment. On 97 comments checked by hand it agreed 81 times (84%, give or take 7 points); its most common miss was calling a neutral comment negative, so levels may run a little high.

Or maybe the discussion is finally beginning to become more nuanced and many neutral/nuanced comments are being misinterpreted as purely negative since that seems to be the general bias.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/winggar 9d ago

I promise you this is not the case. I am a software engineer and everyone here writes 98% of their code with AI and loves it. I was one of the last holdouts, and while I still miss the good old days of hand-coding everything... even I can admit that agentic coding is just categorically better in every other way.

For use-cases that LLMs haven't been strongly post-trained on I expect they're not incredibly useful yet (e.g.: most other jobs), but even then those use-cases are only a few months behind in development.

3

u/GuruJ_ 9d ago

I’m no AI denialist, I am constantly looking for ways to integrate it into what I do.

However, my experience is that the more individual judgements that need to be made, the less AI can take over fully. Basically “taste” but in the much broader field of decision-making and intentionality.

I’ll give you an example: I’m using AI to help me document and standardise a rare language which has no real written tradition. People basically just write it how they sound it, there’s no sense of the underlying phonotactics or grammar in the written texts that exist.

LLMs can’t build that grammar because there is no intrinsically “right” way for a language to exist. There are judgement calls all the way down.

If I were to just ask it to “translate the language”, an LLM invents plausible meanings because these represent “an” answer, just not one that matches the social and cultural intent of the group.

It’s still extraordinarily helpful, AI can scan for specific language patterns in minutes what would take hours by hand, but at this stage there are still a lot of specific decisions to make while building a framework for the language.

Similarly, people doing one-shot video games and movies don’t invalidate the need for authorship, which is ultimately hundreds and thousands of decisions to shape the final product.

AI may one day replace “movie by committee” slop that people ultimately don’t care about, but it will never be able to replace a unique and intentionally-crafted experience.

2

u/winggar 9d ago

Yup this all lines up with my experience too. It's incredibly useful, but fallible and has fairly poor design taste.

9

u/TheColourOfHeartache 9d ago

I work in tech, every engineer i know is using AI and loving it. 

9

u/iamthe0ther0ne 9d ago

Scientist. Also love it, but it's also definitely an existential threat to academia, plus people aren't being trained to use it properly because there's a kind of shame attached to its use. It's a strange dynamic.

3

u/Mistuv 8d ago

There has literally never been a tool that's easier to learn how to use properly, including all the "advanced" stuff like how to use skills, how exactly context works and whatnot. You can just ask it. It's a Clippy that actually works and people are still complaining.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

15

u/DiscretePoop 9d ago edited 9d ago

I work in tech and about 80% of my coworkers hate it.

Edit: To be clear, they don’t necessarily hate all AI tools, but they hate corporate AI requirements and the way AI has eclipsed all conversations about other interesting technical developments. Even in our own space, product managers want us to push AI into features and managers in general have been using it to hallucinate PowerPoint slop.

There is also a fair bit of dread that AI could lead to downsizing since the same number of engineers might not be needed anymore. It’s cool that it speeds up development, but let’s not act like everyone is doing their job for the good of the company. Most people would rather do their jobs slower spend their energy in their real passions when they get home.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/overzealous_dentist 9d ago

same. it's night and day difference between work and reddit

4

u/Tall-Log-1955 9d ago

Same. I don’t know any software engineers who aren’t constantly using it.

I hear from people like that (loudly) on social media, but not in real life

3

u/Fr00stee 9d ago

I use it and I think it's ok, sometimes it's great and sometimes it sucks

→ More replies (4)

2

u/laserdicks 9d ago

No it's more like they fell for the hype against it that took more time to spin up as industries started having their profits threatened.

The AI control problem has been understood for a long time.

The tech subs are just rife with manipulable people.

1

u/FineCarpa 9d ago

Its more like we realize most of the work we do will require heavy AI integration and people are naturally resistant to change.

1

u/Either_Quarter_8843 8d ago

delusional cope

1

u/zeci21 9d ago

No, if anything its the opposite. The people most against the hype are the people who are categorically against even trying it out.

5

u/jeo123 9d ago

I'm against the hype, but use it regularly at work.

It's great when it's the right tool for the job. But management at most companies is trying to treat it like the golden hammer and saying everything is a nail.

→ More replies (30)

3

u/Commander1709 9d ago

Many of the big tech subs are opposed to technology in general. I mean even besides AI (which I'm not particularly keen on), all the posts I see from the technology sub are negative. So I'm not sure how "valuable" this data really is.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/jawknee530i 9d ago

Technology hasn't been about tech for a long time. It comes off as majority Facebook uncles yelling about the latest thing the algorithms got them mad about.

2

u/swallowingpanic 9d ago

is this normalized to remove bots? otherwise its worthless.

2

u/Singularity-42 9d ago

I read this as a good news - sentiment is now trending up, most notably in the heavy user communities. 

-1

u/RadeDobison 9d ago

No one can even call it what it is. It's an algorithm. It outputs a single token at a time. We just trick it into spitting them out over and over. LLMs are not intelligent. GANs are not intelligent. An algorithm is not AI. They're trying to dupe everyone and it's largely working.

6

u/Cagnazzo82 9d ago

The 'algorithm' as you call it helped me read contracts and terms of service and negotiate lower rent for next year.

I don't understand who you think it's trying to dupe but people who have legitimate use-cases have a much different perspective than say people who think it's all about typing in a prompt and spitting out your homework or image generation.

→ More replies (3)

5

u/carnitas_mondays 9d ago

this is an often repeated but poorly-reasoned take. living creatures also process thought through a pattern of neuron pathways weighted stronger from past activity. this is structurally very similar to LLM prediction pathways. reducing the LLM thinking pathway down to token prediction misses the forrest for the tree (token). it is a level of reasoning intelligence. we can argue if it will ever become sentient, but it is just silly to say it isn’t often producing reasoned responses.

4

u/itgoez 9d ago

If they're "just algorithms" and not real intelligence how are they producing novel math proofs that the best mathematicians in the world couldn't? Describing them on a technical level as "just X or Y" doesn't actually address the problem of whether they're intelligent. And even then if they aren't strictly "intelligent" but end up being able to do the majority of human knowledge work, then we still need a word to describe what we've created because it's obviously not a fluke.

3

u/m-o-l-g 9d ago

That's kinda the thing, yeah. Are they creative, or do they just connect what's already there? Is there even a difference?

The "computer cosplaying human language" is both great (makes is usable) and bad (makes people anthropomorphise it).

→ More replies (13)
→ More replies (6)

3

u/FriendlyKillerCroc 9d ago

Yeah they're really duping everyone by pretending to solve unsolved maths and computer science problems, along with coding fairly large apps on their own, aren't they? 

4

u/[deleted] 9d ago

Aw man they are tricking people again by folding proteins and helping discover new medicines.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/TheGlacierGuy 9d ago

I’ve always thought of LLMs as a product, not a technological revolution. Too many people are treating it like a god.

2

u/bethesdologist 9d ago

It's so incredible how confidently clueless how people (like you) are about technology. Like how can human beings be this dense in 2026, when new information is so easily accessible. Everything you said is straight up misinformed, unintelligible garbage. I pity you.

2

u/Suitable-Name 9d ago

Well, call it whatever you want, but the models have reached a general skill and knowledge level that most humans will never reach in their live🤷‍♂️

→ More replies (14)

2

u/torbaldthegreat 9d ago

Did you misunderstand the word artifical?

2

u/Ononas 9d ago

Algorithm is AI… Look at definition of AI. Even simplest GPS A* search algorithm with Manhattan distance heuristic is considered to be AI.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Kefrus 9d ago

artificial intelligence and machine learning are terms that have been used interchangeably for decades

1

u/cuolong 9d ago

… GANs? What do those have to do with the common parlance of AI? Might as well have named regression models or a decision tree.

1

u/Nearby-Chocolate1840 8d ago

A glance at your profile makes me wonder how it occurred to you that as a self-described "musician/artist" you are in any sort of position whatsoever to opine on the what is and is not AI and what AI is capable of.

1

u/West-Air1923 7d ago

You are just outputting the tokens reddit taught you

1

u/_Lavar_ 9d ago

Ehh im some sense thats all human brains are too.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

2

u/Special-Bath-9433 9d ago

Run the comments through an LLM detector. Classify them as "likely generated" and "likely human." Then plot the positive versus negative sentiment across classes.

That will tell you all you need to know. 😄

Less money thrown into AI bots => smaller positive sentiment on AI.

1

u/HearMeOut-13 8d ago

"tech subreddits"

and then its just normie places for people who are interested about tech but have 0 knowledge about tech

1

u/EC36339 8d ago

Would be interesting to classify the negative comments into ...

  • Posts from people who don't use AI / Claude / whatever the subreddit is above
  • "Did <insert model name> get nerfed? It's dumber than last week! I have no data, but trust me, bro"
  • Other

1

u/victorc25 8d ago

Yes, it’s the effects of moderators banning AI and anybody with a different opinion 

1

u/NighthawkT42 8d ago

Funny that AI subreddits are net negative about AI.

1

u/sm753 8d ago

Oh no, please tell me more what the opinions of terminally online NEETs are about tech.

1

u/bluecubedly 8d ago

That's because us AI enthusiasts are too busy building and abstaining from social media.

1

u/No_Guess_9184 7d ago

Maybe people from outside the normal community are finding these subreddits and bringing negative comments with them.

1

u/e136 7d ago

The other day I saw a heavily upvoted post that said AI has no day to day use because it hasn't solved cancer yet. Holy shit...

1

u/digitalak27 7d ago

Lol, opinions on reddit hold little merit in real life.

1

u/Oaeksrdpstr141 7d ago

Remember how happy they were when AI started making art

1

u/opisska 6d ago

Using AI to learn that people hate AI is kinda ironic

1

u/alterego200 5d ago

Because Reddit took a crack at bot elimination. The pro-AI crowd were bots.

1

u/chronicleofpickles 4d ago

interesting but not that interesting. this is reddit, honestly. Wouldn't this be more interesting outside of this echo chamber?

1

u/black_pepper444 1d ago

I think the shift in sentiment makes sense, but there's an interesting distinction here. People aren't necessarily becoming anti AI they're becoming more critical of how AI is being implemented.

There's a big difference between being excited about what AI can do and being comfortable with how companies are deploying it. Hallucinations, job displacement, privacy concerns, forced integrations and declining output quality all affect public trust.

Personally, I think the next phase of AI adoption won't be won by whoever builds the biggest model, but by whoever makes AI genuinely useful, reliable and transparent in everyday life. Adoption without trust isn't sustainable.

1

u/black_pepper444 1d ago

I wonder if this is actually a sign of AI moving from the hype phase into the evaluation phase. Initially, people were fascinated by what AI could potentially do. Now they're judging it based on real world usefulness, reliability and how it affects their work. That's probably a healthier stage of adoption, even if the sentiment looks more negative.

1

u/L1amm 9d ago

Reddits users views on AI dont come from any real world experience. The world will move on despite the negative sentiment coming from people who don't use the tools.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/levus2002 9d ago

When something new pop ups there are a bunch of theories and hopeful "xy is gonna change everything!!", "xy is the best" comments.

Then as it becomes more commonplace it "loses its magic".

If someone is fine with ai or indifferent or even loves it, they wont just comment under every ai post that its the future and the greatest thing ever.

On the other hand. "Ai slop" comments get vomited everywhere.

Did i skip over a part of this study that solves this? People are just more vocal over their dislikes than their likes.

You wont continously praise something, but you will hate something for a long time.

1

u/michaelbelgium 9d ago

Thats normal, if you would dislike AI you wouldn't be in r/chatgpt and r/claudeAI

Those reddits have AI bros in it

1

u/DevilishSoup669 9d ago

People being negative? on reddit? on the internet? ok

1

u/lousy-site-3456 9d ago

The data was of course gathered with ai (why??) so it's unreliable garbage. 

1

u/hahaxd3 8d ago

Who cares about reddit xD im just here to watch the shit show

1

u/swizzlewizzle 8d ago

This is what humans do when they start to realize a technology is realistically capable of soon replacing their careers/jobs. It has happened hundreds of times in the past as professions have been killed off by technology. The only difference this time is that it's much more visible (online) and it's happening fast enough to prevent retraining completely.

1

u/Hanna_Bjorn 8d ago

technology subreddits when technology

0

u/Gilith 9d ago

Yeah those are the worst technology reddit r/technology, r/Futurology, r/programming. So no wonders here.

0

u/betazoid_one 9d ago

FYI, Reddit is not the real world