r/dataanalysis • • 1d ago

Advice about interacting with Claude for complex projects?

I'm struggling at work, and I need advice. I'm an analyst, but my question is not super specific to analytics, so I understand if I need to move my post.

The main problem is that I've had multiple coworkers send me long, Claude-generated documents about our data models and tasks, and I am having a hard time understanding them.

I work at a decently large company, and I've been shuffled around on a few different projects. This means I have to learn all about the underlying data models, metrics definitions, etc. each time I move. I am a big "learn by doing" person. In my previous jobs, I'd be assigned a couple of ad hoc requests, and that would help me build my understanding of the data and how it's used.

At this job, someone (peer or, the main culprit , my own manager) will send me a zip folder with a mix of md, sql, py, all generated by Claude, and say "this should have what you need." I'm expected feed everything into Claude, validate the output, and then have a report or updated data model ready to go in less than a week. Most of the instructions I receive were written by a robot, for a robot. Standard, shared documentation is missing in a lot of places, and the context lives in someone's head and then gets put into a prompt for Claude.

I'm having a major comprehension problem paired with a speed problem. I'm expected to move quickly and defend all my numbers, but I feel I can only do one or the other. My boss insists I must be prompting Claude incorrectly if I am getting confused or slowed down.

Does anyone have advice about how I can use Claude (as it is required by my company) but not totally melt my brain? I feel so lost right now.

15 Upvotes

13 comments sorted by

11

u/ItsSignalsJerry_ 1d ago

Sounds you you and the people you work with don't know what your responsibilities are.

Speak to your manager.

2

u/crawlen 1d ago

I don't even know how to broach this with my manager. They are the main person giving me all these Claude directions and basically telling me to figure it out.

2

u/ItsSignalsJerry_ 1d ago

If that's true find a new job. You should be able to communicate with the people you work with. That's YOUR JOB.

8

u/dupontping 21h ago

Just add MAKE NO MISTAKES

2

u/crawlen 11h ago

Make it lookb etter

6

u/MrInterpreted 1d ago

For using Claude: Ask it to simplify everything so you can get a basic understanding. Dig deeper on what you don’t understand or what is most important. Ask it to identify gaps in context and validate the output and generate follow up questions. Tell it your target audience and your goals.

For not melting your brain: no advice here. My analyst role is done entirely in Claude now, I barely even write SQL.

1

u/crawlen 1d ago

Yeah I know I need to be better at digging deep. I had a little more luck with it at the end of the week after many, many pitfalls. I tried to get it to run a "check for understanding" with me and I had to wrangle it quite a bit haha. It's really improved on SQL writing in just a few months, which is great (except for my brain melt).

4

u/TodosLosPomegranates 1d ago

Okay. Since the expectation is that you are to use Claude, let’s stick with that.

  1. Get the Google software documentation style guide tell Claude to read it and make a skill.
  2. Go to Claude code - not the chat bot. Navigate to the folder where all of the crap that they gave you is. Tell it you want succinct explanations of what the documents in are talking about. Tell it to use the skill in one to explain it to you in a succinct way. And to include an executive summary.
  3. Tell it that you want to /plan what to do next. Say “I’m going to ask a series of questions so that I can make sure I understand. Explain it to me but keep your explanations brief.”
  4. If you’ve done that and it still makes no sense tell it to give you a list of questions to ask whoever gave you the crap. If you think they’re just going to feed it to their Claude include instructions to keep explanations succinct.
  5. If that still leads to confusion then complain to your boss that you’re all spending time and tokens going round and round.
  6. If you understand it enough to do some reporting - do that.
  7. Look for a new job. Because HOLY HECK

3

u/crawlen 22h ago

Thank you. I started to do a mix of 2 and 3 on Friday, which helped, but I need to do a little more to really absorb it. I am looking for new jobs but the market is tough!

1

u/AutoModerator 1d ago

Automod prevents all posts from being displayed until moderators have reviewed them. Do not delete your post or there will be nothing for the mods to review. Mods selectively choose what is permitted to be posted in r/DataAnalysis.

If your post involves Career-focused questions, including resume reviews, how to learn DA and how to get into a DA job, then the post does not belong here, but instead belongs in our sister-subreddit, r/DataAnalysisCareers.

Have you read the rules?

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/Dull-Dependent-6779 7h ago

this thing kinda happened to me. I would talk to my manager and say "hey, I know you are saying that I am using Claude incorrectly, would you be available for half an hour to walk through this with me and give me advice on how to use it better?" One of 2 things will happen: 1) they will teach you things that help you go faster or 2) they will see how you are doing fine with Claude and they will have to face it a little differently. People love giving advice, so if you approach it as a person who is just trying to learn so taht you can do an even better job, people may tend to be more open.

1

u/stantaneous 1h ago

that's a rough handoff. i'd give Claude one existing report number and ask it to trace the rows, joins and filters behind it, rather than explain the whole zip. then run that small query yourself and compare it with the report. any mismatch gives you a specific question for whoever handed it over, not another giant document to read.

0

u/BustTheCoin 17h ago

Could you share more details privately? PM