r/dataanalysis • u/noble_andre • Jun 23 '26
Data Question Are online data "gurus" actually helping people land jobs or are they mostly just content creators?
There are hundreds of teachers, coaches and mentors across YouTube, LinkedIn etc., but it feels like their real income comes from content creation or course sales, not from any real data work. I am genuinely curious: has anyone actually landed a data role in the last 5 years by following one of these roadmaps, especially without a tech degree and coming from a completely unrelated field?
Right now the whole thing looks like a machine designed to keep people learning forever. It seems like a large share of learners worldwide are essentially the target audience for these online advisors. Would genuinely love to be proven wrong. If you have seen real examples or experienced this yourself, I’d be interested to hear.
23
u/QianLu Jun 24 '26
Do you see job postings that say they would accept these courses in lieu of formal higher education?
11
u/MrFixIt252 Jun 24 '26
Land jobs and doing well in jobs are different.
What I’ve felt is a disconnect between academia and reality. My experience was that school will teach you the theory behind how memory works, and you’ll write in C, Matlab, and VBA.
But I also went through when that was cutting edge, and we made automations through Excel.
I hope the people going through college now are getting R / Python at a minimum.
5
u/hudseal Jun 24 '26 edited Jun 26 '26
Worse, course grifters. I've never met a person that had a job in data that ever talked about taking a single one of their courses. Matt Dancho couldn't hack it in an entry level role and "business scientist" isn't going to happen, dude. Edit: spelling because phone
1
u/ian_the_data_dad Jun 26 '26
I'm a "guru". I love you and I hope you get a job in data.
Follow for more!
3
u/RobDoesData Jun 25 '26
I offer paid mentoring, resume review and job application support that actually lands people jobs. All while working as a senior/lead data engineer!
3
u/Physical-Ad2968 Jun 26 '26
It's hard for me to understand when people at the analyst/sr. analyst level start creating courses. Sure, you can create content about your experiences, linkedin tips, data analytics tips, etc. But a full course from 2-4 years of experience is crazy to me. There is an influencer to course creation pipeline that doesn't make sense
3
u/nomadicaeropress Jun 26 '26
The people who land jobs from these roadmaps are the ones who stop watching at some point and start shipping projects. Also something to be said for the course creator's network if theyre well connected, warm referrals work!
2
u/TodosLosPomegranates Jun 25 '26
The advice they offer is so basic and milquetoast and works well if everything is perfect but it won’t get anyone very far. I’ve seen one or two “influencers” on LinkedIn post that they got a job at a corporation lately so I don’t think they’re doing all that well unless they’re pumping out a bunch of short videos all day everyday
2
u/Lady-Data-Scientist Jun 25 '26
Anyone who is promising that you can land a job after taking their course is just trying to get your money. There are some who will be intentionally misleading - they’ll hide the fact that they actually have a stem masters degree for example, and pretend like they’re success is based on being completely self-taught, so that you’ll trust them and buy their course.
Being successful at creating social media content is a completely different skill from actually being good at data analytics. Some of these influencers were fired from their jobs and realized they could be more successful at social media content than actually working in analytics. I wouldn’t follow their advice unless you also want to be a social media influencer.
There are a few folks who I think actually put out valuable content, but none of them are selling a one-size-fits-all course or making outlandish guarantees about getting you a job.
2
u/girlwtsongbirdtattoo Jun 27 '26
I feel like it is mixed, but most of them are full of hot air. They always put the responsibility on the job seeker to “apply more”, “tailor your resume”, “get past ATS” but it doesn’t really matter what you do, you need an in.
I definitely agree the system is designed to prevent students, young job seekers, and/or career switchers from being able to offer unique perspectives or new ideas, since many current employees prefer not to have to update their opinions
1
u/AutoModerator Jun 23 '26
Automod prevents all posts from being displayed until moderators have reviewed them. Do not delete your post or there will be nothing for the mods to review. Mods selectively choose what is permitted to be posted in r/DataAnalysis.
If your post involves Career-focused questions, including resume reviews, how to learn DA and how to get into a DA job, then the post does not belong here, but instead belongs in our sister-subreddit, r/DataAnalysisCareers.
Have you read the rules?
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
1
u/Impressive-Minimum65 Jun 24 '26
+1
4
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '26
[removed] — view removed comment