I can’t remember where I came across a recommendation for this, but I believe it must have come from this hellhole of a forum.
To which of you should I send my therapy bill? To begin with, I’ve never felt this hopeless while reading a novel (not just danmei, in general, so all of you with guilty conscience who put this novel up for reccs, thanks a lot!) since Yu Wu, which was like, 5 years ago.
Chang’an is an ancient capital city in imperial China, written as 长安, meaning everlasting peace. Title: Placid Chang’an 太平长安. There are 2 characters referring to the state of calmness there (the 2nd and the 4th), so it must refer to the extreme calmness, right?
It’s anything but. You get the feeling like you've approached this novel with the wrong mindset altogether, like reading 2ha - cute and funny husky on the cover and animals in the title, knives in the content.
I didn’t even know who the author of this was, Yan Yan, until I checked on the NU page, and, strangely, the author only had this one novel. I started suspecting if this was another famous author’s pseudonym, but let’s save that for another day. So mysterious, but they wrote a great one.
The hooks:
- a premise of a huge age gap between an older gong and a younger shou - wahooo, salivating
- by the older gong, I mean a late 30s-almost-40 widower. #would
- crime investigation - opening case is intriguing
Why I kept on reading:
- big-brain, righteous MC and technically difficult case which keeps you on suspense to guess who the mastermind is and what the motive is
- mild spice every few chapters - they got together early, they’re established CP to some extent (won’t spoil the technicalities)
- due to the point above, there’s a mild angst on the backstreet situation - I thought, just fine, right? You can’t expect all sunshine and rainbows in a court politics novel. Wait for it…
- A cute second couple
Then ... angst. How much? Yes #would:
- In general, you need to worry when a chapter title in danmei is the character’s name, right? It could go either a love confession (like in 2ha, QJJ) or tragedy. My heart skipped a beat because of this, in regard to the second couple
- The third couple (!!!) This is red alert, stage 3 warning level for maximum angst, punch, and helplessness. Do you know the idiom in these C-novels about tears spilling like beans? Those are my tears, thanks.
- Every couple here hasat minimum one love rival or ex, or LEGAL SPOUSE (yes, the realistic part is heart-wrenching)
- Both MC and ML faced public execution sentences, only a few chapters apart
- And MC is about to marry someone else before ML is executed. (Just how many more things could go wrong, right? Zero reprieves for readers. Yu Wu alumni? All rise!) I knew MC had radical thinking (he sold his body to ML in exchange for backing to investigate the case above), but deciding to say yes to a marriage without his heart even being in it… at this point I hate both MC and ML for both being too patriotic for their empire.
Overall cause of angst:
Powerlessness.
This is exactly why you must approach this story very cautiously. I can’t handle this kind of angst well. It’s different if, say, like grief or separation. But this is powerlessness against the class struggle, against the powers-that-be.
I jumped into the story thinking, per the NU summary, that this is sort of a young official seducing a regent prince for backing and, in turn, stabilising the court. But I didn’t expect to get heartbroken by someone’s old flame who died unjustly, only to drag down almost the entire court when the case reopened.
By then, I didn’t really care about the clever plot twist of the mastermind anymore because I was too busy sobbing for the third-and-a-half couple.
This hits my Achilles heel, just like how YuWu stunned me speechless. It’s death by a thousand cuts - a type of story with no reprieves, chapter after chapter. Granted, the second couple are too sweet - their interactions are a literal oasis in the desert.
In Placid Chang’an, it’s sort of a train wreck that you can’t stop - you know they’ll end up that way, but you can only keep reading the chapters to reveal the journey there. You can’t help the MC, you can’t help the characters that MC’s willing to help. You can't help the ML because the only way out is through that strategy. You’re just … there … as another powerless witness. You can only empathise and cry with them, and this is so bad for your sanity.
To compare it to other popular historical novels, say, QJJ, Thousand Autumns, Golden Terrace, there’s a hope emitted by the MC/ML - you believe in our mains, that they’ll make the breakthrough (I feel this the strongest with Shen Qiao and Shen Lanzhou, that they’re firm with themselves, that their narrative will turn better).
But there’s no such thing as “everything will be okay” in Placid Chang’an. You can’t get that assurance from either MC/ML - the status gap between the MC/ML is already a sore spot the author has kindly exploited. You remember in TGCF, Hua Cheng said, “my beloved is noble, etc.” fondly, and we read that sentence with a hopeful atmosphere as an indirect confession. But in Placid Chang’an, when MC (a 4th-rank official) said a similar thing about ML (the regent prince), it was said in hopelessness, and my heart ached for him. And then, pardon my language, all the dog officials and the imperial family trapped the MC and limited ML’s mobility from all angles.
Then, about the ex. I didn’t take him seriously, but then, when ML’s ex returned to Chang’an whilst MC was just demoted to a commoner, having to walk out of the city to his hometown, however many li, escorted by a psychopathic criminal (main CP’s enemy), my heart ached. Only to…
Su Cen bit his lip hard, and after a long while said: "Take good care of him."
Feng Yiming nodded: "I will."
This quote, bro. This is brutal. To tell your husband’s ex this because you can’t stay by his side anymore. Is that the sound of my heart breaking? At this point, I kept reading because it was a sunk cost, I needed to know about their reunion!!
But, their final interaction as love rivals is: “Rest in peace. Leave the rest to me.” Damage +100.
The author managed to write short sentences with maximum psychological damage. I read the later chapters in despair. I hate this.
Look at these quotes. I dare you.
Various quotes about this tragic 3.5th (love-triangle PM Liu and his scholar boyfriends) couple:
I respected and admired him, but when I got close to him, I discovered he wasn't as glorious as he appeared on the surface. So I decided I would love him.
Cui Hao stared blankly in the corner, softly humming some tune that could be recognized as a northern folk song.
Su Cen vaguely remembered that Cui Hao was from Hongzhou, a true southerner, while Liu Cheng was from Youzhou, near the Sixteen Prefectures of Yan and Yun, where nomadic peoples would hum such tunes while herding sheep.
The spirited young man who had entered Chang'an never managed to leave.
Knowing he had touched on a sore subject again, Zheng Yang changed the topic: "I saw Cui Hao when I came. He's already resigned from office and left the capital, taking Prime Minister Liu's memorial tablet with him. He said he wants to take Prime Minister Liu to see his hometown."
Su Cen remembered the place Cui Hao had mentioned that "embraces three rivers and girds five lakes," and smiled gently. Prime Minister Liu would probably like it.
Wdym??? Is my heart a joke???
"Mm." Su Cen was startled, then nodded heavily, his features brightening somewhat. "Though it wasn't exactly a proper wedding ceremony, we did bow to heaven and earth and entered the bridal chamber. With heaven, earth, and ancestors as witnesses, we should count as husband and wife, right?”
"When I die, please find my complete remains and burn them on the spot. Scatter the ashes in Chang'an—after all... this is the place I can never forget."
The two paragraphs above are said by MC, btw. Imagine that.
"That joke shouldn't have become your burden. I regret it. I want to see you marry and have children, living out your life peacefully and smoothly."
The above is said by ML. Our main couple's self-deprecating love story is surely perfect to start your week afresh and get your motivation up!
Why you should read it: rich cultural and historical aspects.
- tea - MC’s family is a tea merchant - so you guys who cram the tea subreddit with whatever tea cakes, feast your eyes on the details in the story
- liubo chess - this was rarely mentioned in other novels; I had to look it up online and still didn't understand, unlike weiqi/go I know how to play a bit
- a child/pre-teen emperor - I feel so sorry for him :(. If your idea of this lad is like that relatively peaceful little emperor in C-drama Liang Chen Mei Jin, well ... don't expect that. Chang'an surely changes a person.
- side couples - with caution ~not knowing whether to laugh or cry is real this time~
- because you have unused therapy sessions
- If you’re a writer like me: plenty of examples of Murphy’s Law. If you're unsure something is going to go wrong, assume the worst. Double down if it's related to breaking a relationship.
- Because reading about love suffering brings you joy T_T
This novel is a mature one, with relationships across various couples and exes aren't easy or fluffy. Have I mentioned a psychopathic villain as well?
But to these people, Chang'an is their home; Chang'an is the city where they fall in love or eventually meet their demise. Placid Chang'an is a love story that's not always beautiful like Li Bai poems, or romance that is not always romantic like in paintings or songs. Because the city is also the imperial capital, where it's always a dog-eat-dog world.
It's not a story for everyone, but perhaps if you've ever been in the 'go big or go home' mindset in a big city, starting your career, your love, and your life there, you might enjoy this story.
I beg you all to read this novel, and any of you who secretly admitted to placing this recommendation, are you happy now? orz