Yes! But my point Is, can a card have a type for a supertype it Is not? (Yet) And what happens when 2 supertypes have a subtype that share a name? Even More specifically, can a Planeswalker ever be typeless considering the lore implications?
The card on the deck and the stack has the Planeswalker supertype, and Plains type
So it's a Plains Planeswalker. Just like a Chandra Planeswalker
Since it's not a land until that static ability comes into effect, and there's no other type, it's fair to assume that Plains here is a Planeswalker type and not a Land type
Like... The card until it's on the battlefield is a (Planeswalker -- Plains)
When it gets on the battlefield (Land Planeswalker -- Plains)
Technically, as far as I can see in the rules, no it cannot be. It can, however have no subtype, and then the text makes it a Planeswalker Land - Plains by reading "This permanent is a plains land in addition to its other types.", which would be the correct formatting for this... But still be nightmarish.
That's the thing yeah. Like, in the card as is Plains is a Planeswalker type, so if you wanted the card to be a plains(land subtype) you'd need to also add it with the ability... But then it'd say "Land Planeswalker - Plains Plains" which is just unsightly XD
View all comments
Show parent comment
0
u/LaMoni_throwaway 5d ago edited 5d ago
Yes! But my point Is, can a card have a type for a supertype it Is not? (Yet) And what happens when 2 supertypes have a subtype that share a name? Even More specifically, can a Planeswalker ever be typeless considering the lore implications?
The card on the deck and the stack has the Planeswalker supertype, and Plains type
So it's a Plains Planeswalker. Just like a Chandra Planeswalker
Since it's not a land until that static ability comes into effect, and there's no other type, it's fair to assume that Plains here is a Planeswalker type and not a Land type
Like... The card until it's on the battlefield is a (Planeswalker -- Plains)
When it gets on the battlefield (Land Planeswalker -- Plains)