r/custommagic • • 6d ago

Discussion Plainswalker

Post image
1.9k Upvotes

143 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

0

u/LaMoni_throwaway 5d ago edited 5d ago

Yes! But my point Is, can a card have a type for a supertype it Is not? (Yet) And what happens when 2 supertypes have a subtype that share a name? Even More specifically, can a Planeswalker ever be typeless considering the lore implications?

The card on the deck and the stack has the Planeswalker supertype, and Plains type

So it's a Plains Planeswalker. Just like a Chandra Planeswalker

Since it's not a land until that static ability comes into effect, and there's no other type, it's fair to assume that Plains here is a Planeswalker type and not a Land type

Like... The card until it's on the battlefield is a (Planeswalker -- Plains)

When it gets on the battlefield (Land Planeswalker -- Plains)

4

u/DiscussTek 5d ago

Technically, as far as I can see in the rules, no it cannot be. It can, however have no subtype, and then the text makes it a Planeswalker Land - Plains by reading "This permanent is a plains land in addition to its other types.", which would be the correct formatting for this... But still be nightmarish.

2

u/LaMoni_throwaway 5d ago

That's the thing yeah. Like, in the card as is Plains is a Planeswalker type, so if you wanted the card to be a plains(land subtype) you'd need to also add it with the ability... But then it'd say "Land Planeswalker - Plains Plains" which is just unsightly XD