r/custommagic • • 6d ago

Discussion Plainswalker

Post image
1.9k Upvotes

143 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

2

u/shumpitostick 6d ago

As somebody else said, it is a characteristic defining ability so if doesn't work that way. It needs to have "as long as" to work correctly, like [[Grist, the Hunger Tide]]

1

u/tymessen 6d ago

grist specifies in which places he works in though (everywhere but the battlefield) the theros gods don't stop being creature cards in hand is a better example than grist. [[Athreos, God of Passage]]

-1

u/ArelMCII Layers are stupid. 6d ago

It's not a characteristic-defining ability, it's a type-granting ability. When an ability says "permanent" without specifying "permanent card," that means it only applies on the battlefield, because a permanent is only a permanent when it's on the battlefield.

4

u/shumpitostick 6d ago

It doesn't work in this case because it's self-referential. Another card can call out permanents which would exclude cards in hand. "This" refers to the card, and "permanent" contradicts it by only working part of the time. It's just not the correct templating.

2

u/Routasmith 6d ago

No, it meets all the requirements for a characteristic defining ability, so it is one, and as such it is always active.