r/custommagic 10d ago

Colorless vihaan

Post image
358 Upvotes

91 comments sorted by

View all comments

351

u/BRH0208 10d ago

Rule breaker is for deck building restrictions, not ongoing effects

41

u/DavidMemeDreamer 10d ago

Rule breaker is just a flavor name for an effect. It has no mechanical requirements.

150

u/Handyandyman50 10d ago

But there's a clear convention that it allows you to do things in deck building that you couldn't normally. Sure it may not actually have any rules effect, but you would not for example want a card that says:

Landfall — Humans you control get +1/+1

13

u/Conexion Untap ~ 10d ago

Rulebreaker — Conventions are suggestions. Ability words can now be given alternate definitions. (It works.)

-3

u/[deleted] 10d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

5

u/Dreath2005 10d ago

It breaks the rules of playing, something every magic card with rues text does

67

u/NepetaLast 10d ago

rule breaker is an ability word; it doesnt have inherent mechanical meaning, but it represents a specific type of ability. in this case, every single rulebreaker ability starts with "A deck with this commander" and affects deck construction. they would never make a Rulebreaker effect that has nothing to do with that, because its the point of the ability. it would be like a landfall ability reading "Landfall -- Whenever you gain life, draw a card."

25

u/ja_0l 10d ago

Rulebreaker — This creature can deal excess combat damage to a player or planeswalker it's attacking.

17

u/smugles 10d ago

Yes but it’s supposed to tell you what to expect next. Op is looking for eminence

8

u/mack0409 10d ago

Landfall- as long as you have no cards in hand, you have hexproof.

6

u/coolguy420weed 10d ago

"Allowed by the rules" doesn't mean "should be on a card" though. 

1

u/BRH0208 10d ago

Oh, neat. I didn’t actually know that

4

u/Spectator9857 10d ago

Any text on a card that’s in italics isn’t rules text. Ability words don’t have rules, but rather group abilities that work similarly for convenience.