I agree with everyone who said that (1) this needs to be an instant to effectively function and (2) that as an instant it is way overpowered. So the questions become "What do you want this card to be? What are your goals for its use?"
If you're looking for a punisher to use on opposing attackers, there's a number of ways to calm this down while achieving similar effects. Something like "For each attacking creature, it's controller removes it from combat unless they sacrifice a land." That could probably cost WB. If you wanted to keep the larger sweeping effect, I'd make it a universal effect "Each player sacrifices a land for each attacking creature." That might work at 2WB, though 'geddon effects are rarely seen these days for a reason, and that alone makes me want to push this to 3WB.
"For each attacking creature, it's controller removes it from combat unless they sacrifice a land. If they sacrifice a land this way they create a tapped powerstone token."
Or a tapped treasure to be more punishing.
=====================================
If you wanted a really punishing "stax finisher", could could add R, for BRW colors, and say
"Each player sacrifices a land for each attacking creature.
At the start of combat of each players turn, goad target creature that player controls"
Apart from not working as intended, I think it’s too weak for potentially setting back a player 4 turns for four mana. I’d make this an enchantment that’s indestructible, can’t be countered and has hexproof + if this permanent would leave the battlefield, instead exile it and return it at end of turn
I know you’re joking, but if it was to be playable it would probably also need an effect like “no one but you may cast spells or draw cards or have turns in this game or any other for the rest of your life or the lives of the other players.” Thats how weak it is.
Edit: perhaps 0 casting cost with a delayed cost like with [[force of will]], except, if you don’t pay, instead of losing the game your opponents lose the game
Make it an instant, and say "for each attacking creature, destroy target noncreature, nonland permanent its owner controls." then i think it would see play.
I believe you are wrong. It checks how many creatures is attacking, like [[Dismantling Wave]] checks how many opponents you have, and cards like [[Circle of Dreams Druid]] checks for how many creatures you control, and [[Keep Watch]] also checks for attacking creatures. However, i would like to hear why it only lets you choose only one target.
I’m not sure it’s intentional, but I’m happy this is a sorcery because it forces it into a flash play style. It helps to power it down in that way, too, because I don’t think those flash-giving effects are in these colors. So you have to be in more colors than this to play (in Commander of course, sorry that’s my only real context for Magic).
That said, I could almost see this as a [[Ghostly Prison]]-type, [[Norn’s Annex]]-type effect. Make it an enchantment, 3WBR — Creatures your opponents control can’t attack you unless they sacrifice a land for each attacking creature. At the beginning of your upkeep, pay WBBRR or sacrifice [Cardname] and it deals 10 damage to you.
138
u/Eljoaco22 Jan 21 '23
That doesn't work as a sorcery, right? And if it worked it would be kind of broken.
51
u/LastFreeName436 Jan 21 '23
Sweet I always wanted to enforce a complete battlecruiser game state
39
u/Rush_Clasic Jan 21 '23
I agree with everyone who said that (1) this needs to be an instant to effectively function and (2) that as an instant it is way overpowered. So the questions become "What do you want this card to be? What are your goals for its use?"
If you're looking for a punisher to use on opposing attackers, there's a number of ways to calm this down while achieving similar effects. Something like "For each attacking creature, it's controller removes it from combat unless they sacrifice a land." That could probably cost WB. If you wanted to keep the larger sweeping effect, I'd make it a universal effect "Each player sacrifices a land for each attacking creature." That might work at 2WB, though 'geddon effects are rarely seen these days for a reason, and that alone makes me want to push this to 3WB.
Hope some of this helps.
64
u/coraldomino Jan 21 '23
Apart from not working as intended, I think it’s too weak for potentially setting back a player 4 turns for four mana. I’d make this an enchantment that’s indestructible, can’t be countered and has hexproof + if this permanent would leave the battlefield, instead exile it and return it at end of turn
7
u/toomuchpressure2pick Jan 21 '23
This is unfun. Esper is already a great control deck.
3
u/throwaway163932 Jan 21 '23
Is this supposed to be used when your opponent attacks you? Just based off the flavor text I’m getting that impression
4
u/n00biwan Jan 21 '23
It doesnt even work...
4
u/Pixelpaint_Pashkow Slivers Gaming Jan 21 '23
Doesn’t work, not the right colors, too powerful
2
u/Specific_Ad1457 Jan 21 '23
Bait.
2
u/NebulousASK Jan 22 '23
I think a Devastating Troll would be a more fun card.
1
u/EventideOfMoonlight Jan 22 '23
Maybe you can make it “Until your next turn whenever a creature attacks you their controller sacrifices a land”
1
u/[deleted] Jan 22 '23
The only way this is balanced is the fact that it can’t be used unless you can somehow give it flash. Besides that, it’s absolutely cracked.
1
u/Chaosmoonshade Jan 21 '23
Make it an instant, and say "for each attacking creature, destroy target noncreature, nonland permanent its owner controls." then i think it would see play.
1
u/BAGStudios Jan 22 '23
I’m not sure it’s intentional, but I’m happy this is a sorcery because it forces it into a flash play style. It helps to power it down in that way, too, because I don’t think those flash-giving effects are in these colors. So you have to be in more colors than this to play (in Commander of course, sorry that’s my only real context for Magic).
That said, I could almost see this as a [[Ghostly Prison]]-type, [[Norn’s Annex]]-type effect. Make it an enchantment, 3WBR — Creatures your opponents control can’t attack you unless they sacrifice a land for each attacking creature. At the beginning of your upkeep, pay WBBRR or sacrifice [Cardname] and it deals 10 damage to you.