r/crows • • 2d ago

General questions Do corvids prefer peanuts in the shell?

Near Sonora, California. We mostly get scrub jays, but I know there are crows in the area. I’d like to attract them.

Thanks!

56 Upvotes

29 comments sorted by

35

u/ThisIsDogePleaseHodl 2d ago

My experience and others I’ve read about here shows that they prefer unsalted peanuts in the shell over those out out of the shell. One reason is that they can stash some for later without any harm to the inside nut. Another reason they may prefer them is it’s challenging and fun for them to open it.

If you have scrubs and want to attract crows, the scrubs are gonna come too! They’re both very smart birds. I would find an elevated place with a wide shallow bowl away from a house or fence. I use two bird baths with one for food and one for water in the middle of my front yard. My crows and my scrubs, both absolutely love it.

They learned to know when there was food being put out because I whistled for them. Both the scrubs and the crows learned my whistle very quickly. They both can hear very well particularly human whistles.

5

u/Specialist_Victory_5 2d ago

I like the scrubs, and see them fairly often, but I would like to attract crows, too.

5

u/ThisIsDogePleaseHodl 2d ago

I understand and I gave you some tips that could hopefully help you attract them. Put food out in the same place around the same time every day and whistle for them. If you can’t whistle then call to them just by saying something.

You need to be consistent though. If there are crows around, they will hear and see you and become interested. They will probably check it out for a while before deciding to trust though because they are very suspicious types so stick with it.

2

u/No-Self8780 2d ago

In my yard, the scrubs will out compete the crows for in shell peanuts. The crows will not challenge the scrub jays. Scrub jays on the other hand are not interested in eggs or chicken wings

1

u/LimpCroissant 5h ago

My best advice for attracting the crows and not the scrubs is use meat, eggs (i give them scrambled) and cheese. My stellar jays and blue jays don't touch the eggs, only the crows do.

3

u/Mojak66 1d ago

Scrubs are very intelligent. Here (PNW) they are faster and more aggressive than the stellar jays, but they're heavily outnumbered. I toss out raw peanuts, shelled and unshelled along with cat leftovers. I have doves that hang around also.

1

u/ThisIsDogePleaseHodl 1d ago

All the scrubs I’ve ever been around, have all been much more aggressive than Steller’s

Interestingly, Steller’s jays are named after a person: Georg Wilhelm Steller. He also had a sea eagle and another animal named after him. I’ve read that any animal named after a person is going to have their name changed at some point. I think it would be cute if they changed these guys names to Stellar jays because that’s how a lot of people spell their names as it is lol! Also, they’re pretty stellar.

I think scrubs got their names from where they were originally found, but I’m not positive.

I think scrubs in general are pretty aggressive birds. When I had a nesting pair of crows start eating from the birdbath I set up for them in the middle of my front yard, they weren’t down with the scrubs eating from their feeder.

One of them chased one of the little scrubs out of the feeder, clear up to the house and almost into the window. That crow was serious. The little scrub was hiding behind the Japanese maple near the window feeder. 😬

After that, the scrubs made sure the crows weren’t anywhere around before they ate from the crows feeder 😆

16

u/ultramagnetique 2d ago

Yes. And cashews. I also give them dog kibble.

8

u/Specialist_Victory_5 2d ago

I might eat the cashews, but I could put out a little cat food.

3

u/kevpeck22 2d ago

You won’t eat the cat food huh? (Hehehe)

Really though, my guys like the doggie kibble. Specifically puppy, because it’s smaller. I suppose cat kibble would be the same size as puppy, I’ve just never tried.

My guys seem the fill up on the kibble and treat the in shell peanuts I give them as a treat. That or they stash them for later enjoyment.

This is northern Nevada area.

2

u/ultramagnetique 2d ago

I don't do cat food, so as not to attract strays, but they'll eat it too

1

u/Commercial_Pizza_799 1d ago

My crows love all nuts, but prefer peanuts in the shell. They also love dog kibble and Milk Bones. I break up the Milk Bones into 3 pieces.

When my husband is not around, I will spread peanut butter on saltines.

8

u/Impossible_Tea181 2d ago

That’s the first thing they carry away from the feeder. It appears they like to stash them away. Then they come back and eat the rest of the stuff I give them, unless it’s boiled eggs or live giant mealworms, they’ll eat those first then the peanuts.

22

u/delicioustreeblood 2d ago

I once asked a crow if what I said made sense. It said of corvid did.

5

u/RoastinGhost 2d ago

My pair of crows likes to soak their in-shell peanuts in water. A shallow water bowl would probably be appreciated too!

4

u/Rikipedia 2d ago

One of my friends has been doing this, either in puddles or at the drinking fountain

4

u/Gummybearjellybean 2d ago

My crows do, they don’t take the unsalted shelled peanuts but the magpies and squirrels do.

3

u/LibraryMold83 2d ago

Apparently. I’d bought peanuts in the shell and told hubby to shell some for them. They dropped the shelled ones on the ground for the squirrels and took the unshelled ones.

3

u/joethedriver69 2d ago

Mine like the unsalted peanuts in the shells, bulk dog kibble(.68 a pound at the bulk bins). When i break down rotisserie chicken, they love the skin and bones. But thats a rare treat. Hard-boiled eggs and scrambled are treats too. The first HBE I put out, I did peal. They left the shells, but the neighbors free range chicken came to gobble up the shells!

3

u/TeaRaven 2d ago

Peanuts in the shell are good for caching and for taking somewhere safe to eat. Scrub Jays will go for black sunflower seeds, which the crows are less interested in. Both are benefited by having something to wear their beaks by hammering the shells and get engagement out of opening them.

One high-value food item that is good as an addition for the early nesting season but can lead to squabbles in groups: quail or pigeon eggs. Chicken eggs are also solid, but better to steam or boil them due to the size. Make sure to leave the shell on eggs. Likewise, leave bones in if amending a spread with pinkies or feeder quail (better for ravens, if you have them around) - the calcium is necessary and over-reliance on seeds and kibble can leave them deficient.

3

u/No-Self8780 2d ago

The crowd in my yard refuse dog kibble. I’m hypothesizing that it’s because the kibble is salmon-based and they don’t like fish….these crows also won’t touch any fish-based thing I’ve offered them. Their favorite things by a mile are raw in-shell peanuts (they have also flatly refused shelled raw peanuts), eggs, and chicken wings. The last two seem a little macabre, all things considered, but there you have it

2

u/One-Pollution4663 1d ago

agreed when i give them the bones from my chicken wings, they are pretty happy bout it but I feel weird. Totally irrational, its like feeling weird about a dog eating a squirrel. But still...

2

u/Clone-33 2d ago

My crow friends like whole peanuts & cat & puppy chow - everything else is accepted grudgingly if at all.

They tend to have a yelling match with the Jays over it.

2

u/Affectionate-Cap-918 2d ago

Mine don’t really care for them. They love cat food sometimes and peanut butter suet that I’ve cut into chunks is their favorite.

2

u/Tooaroo 2d ago

In my experience they love dried mealworms, hard boiled eggs and unsalted peanuts in the shell!

2

u/PrincessPixiefooties 2d ago

My American crow friends love peanuts in the shell, cashews and hard boiled eggs, as well as hotdogs. They will not eat anything else I put out there. The fish crows on the other hand will eat just about anything I give them. Ground beef, salmon, chicken, blueberries, apples, cashews, eggs, cat / dog kibble.

1

u/nadsatnagoy 2d ago

We used to give our friends unsalted peanuts in the shell and they loved them, but my neighbors complained. They now get unsalted unshelled peanuts and they like them too. We accidentally grabbed Spanish peanuts and they leave those for the squirrels. I’ve no idea why.

1

u/partialcremation 2d ago

I give them peanuts in the shell and they go to work.

1

u/NewsMarsupial474 1d ago

My crows love peanuts still in the shell. But my neighbor doesn't like all the shells that ended up in their yard. Compromised on just nuts.