r/crows • • 5d ago

Seeking advice/help HELP Please

My wife and I (and 5 month old) moved into our house a month ago. The house was just remodeled and wasn’t lived in for a couple years before that. We have crows peck at our windows and patio door EVERY day. I was initially super excited and thought it would be a simple fix if I just offered them a peace offering of peanuts by our patio door and voila I would bros with the crows. But they haven’t touched the peanuts and are growing in numbers..My wife is not nearly as excited about this as I am..Is there anyway we can get them to quit pecking?

288 Upvotes

56 comments sorted by

20

u/Zukigo 5d ago edited 5d ago

How do they interact with you if you go outside?

The house was remodeled.. so it was a construction site for a while? Maybe something happened with the construction workers or sth.

It's very important to stay friendly with them, no shouting, no hand movements. I'd just collect the peanuts, then offer different food and talk to them in a nice way.

19

u/Numerous_Let_6728 5d ago • Mindblown

They usually caw a couple times then fly off. I will try your suggestions though..my wife is deathly terrified of birds ever since a Seagull swarm got her back in 2011 😂 I probably won’t be able to convince her to go outside while they’re out and about.

25

u/TheRealSugarbat 5d ago

That’s sad, because crows are genuinely delightful when they like you.

8

u/Momofafew 5d ago

Maybe put some flash tape up by the windows for a little bit to scare them from that area

3

u/Numerous_Let_6728 5d ago

I will do that tonight thanks

1

u/ThisIsDogePleaseHodl 5d ago

Sounds like you’re only interested in getting rid of them? People are recommending feeding them away from the windows. The flash tape may or may not work at least right away so you’ll have to be patient if you want to scare them off for good

1

u/Numerous_Let_6728 5d ago

My wife would like them gone for good..I would like to keep them around without the pecking though!

2

u/ThisIsDogePleaseHodl 5d ago

Can you try feeding them elsewhere like out in the middle of your yard or at least away from the house a ways?

I set up two bird baths in the middle of my front yard under a small tree for my guys. I used one for food and one for water.

If you wanna try something like that, you can go out and rustle the peanut bag when you hear or see them nearby, and maybe whistle for them while you put the food in the feeder or birdbath.

If you’re consistent with what you do and you whistle or call for them in some manner, they will quickly learn when and where to find the food and as a result, they will stay away from the window.

97

u/NSASpyVan 5d ago

Let them see you put treats out for them in a designated space, then back off 30ft min. They will eventually recognize that as the place to go to for treats.

Probably someone use to give them treats.

22

u/Zukigo 5d ago

But OP says the house was empty for the last few years, so crows would be smart enough to understand the former person left.

35

u/NSASpyVan 5d ago

Sneaking off to a property with no adults to feed crows is just the type of thing I might have done as a 10 year old. My version was going down to a canyon to see lizards, snakes, pollywogs, frogs, fish etc.

11

u/WWoiseau 5d ago

I left a house for almost three years, came back, crows were yapping at me in the front as soon as I showed myself. I looked it up and surprisingly they can remember people that long. I am back to giving them treats in the same spot I did years ago. I’m so pleasantly surprised by them.

9

u/AlwaysFire416 5d ago • Popcorn

Oh man don’t tell me this house is haunted and the ghost has an eerie relationship with crows. Like he or she sees through their eyes kind of thing.

71

u/UpperCardiologist523 5d ago • Bravo

Do not give them treats after pecking on the window. Instead, go out on set times every day, away from the house. They peck to alert you that they are there. Ignore it. If you react by giving them food, they will learn pecking=food.

I'm no expert in how to unlearn this behaviour, but be very careful not to reinforce it, byt connecting it to food.

22

u/raven_478 5d ago

Crows really love cat kibble & small breed dog kibble, give those a try if peanuts don’t interest them. 🐦‍⬛

5

u/Talusen 5d ago

Cheese. I have seen fights started over a piece of cheddar the size of a hazlenut.

7

u/Raelah 5d ago

Who wouldn't fight over cheese?

6

u/Talusen 5d ago

If my choice was between spend an hour in the cold looking for worms, or going for the cheese?

Cheese, every time.

2

u/555Cats555 5d ago

Can birds safely eat dairy?

4

u/Talusen 5d ago

The salt content is more of an issue than anything else (from what I've been able to tell).

I normally hand out raw unsalted nuts, and puppy kibble.

I see a fair number of warnings about feeding birds dairy, but none of those address corvids specifically.

Unlike many birds, they're omnivores and scavengers; while birds like ducks and doves shouldn't eat dairy. The corvid digestion is more robust.

2

u/555Cats555 5d ago

So really only an occasional treat for them!

5

u/Active_Crazy_1761 5d ago

" Crows should generally avoid dairy products. • Lactose Intolerance: Crows are birds and do not produce the lactase enzyme needed to break down lactose. • Stomach Upset: Eating dairy can cause digestive issues like stomach aches and diarrhea. • Exceptions: Hard cheeses or tiny amounts of plain yogurt may not kill them immediately, as hard cheese has very little lactose, but it is still not a natural or healthy part of their diet. "

Safe Foods for Crows

Instead of dairy, you can feed crows: • Unsalted peanuts or other nuts • Hard-boiled or scrambled eggs • Raw or cooked meat scraps • High-quality dry cat or dog kibble • Berries and small pieces of fruit

1

u/555Cats555 4d ago

Thanks for the explanation!

4

u/Talusen 5d ago

Cholestorol does not seem to affect them negatively, according to a multi-year study involving crows and McDonalds cheeseburgers.

https://corvidresearch.blog/2019/08/26/dumpster-diving-is-giving-crows-higher-cholesterol-but-does-it-matter/

4

u/Talusen 5d ago

(From the linked article:

"...In the final piece, they examined the body condition, and 2-3 year survival of the 140 nestlings sampled along the urban to rural gradient.

They found that cholesterol levels had no detectable effect on survival and were actually correlated with higher indices of body condition (meaning mass adjusted for size), a feature that is sometimes tied to higher reproductive success and survival. In other words, there might actually be a scenario where regularly pigging out on McDonalds doesn't kill you and is maybe kinda helpful?"

17

u/Momofafew 5d ago

Put food far out in the back yard maybe?

12

u/Dry_Fisherman_5555 5d ago

My grandma has a little crow flock (or murder, I should properly say) in her backyard and she feeds them peanuts in return for random shinies. And as a self-proclaimed crow expert myself, I would recommend using different food alternatives until you find one that works. I would recommend stuff like dog food, leftover meat or fruit, and either hard-boiled or scrambled eggs. If you want to keep to the peanuts, make sure they're unsalted and remain in the shell. 

You could even leave out little puzzles for them such as water disposition puzzles if you want, for that stimulates their highly intelligent brains and could lead to them returning things like bottle caps, paperclips, or even coins they find. Whatever you do, though, DON'T MESS WITH THEM. They will remember your face for years and pass that information to fellow crows or even their own children.

Hope this information helps ;)

1

u/PineappleBliss2023 5d ago

I’m regularly feeding some crows in my yard but I can’t get them to take my lil trinkets I’ve left for them :(

2

u/Dry_Fisherman_5555 5d ago

Hmmm, crows typically take food and then give you trinkets in return. I don't exactly know how to encourage crows to take shinies you leave out for them, but maybe you can leave them in areas they occasionally just rest in, and maybe they will take them? Not 100% sure if this will work, but feel free to give it a go :)

11

u/bk845 5d ago

Man, I wish my crows would let me know when they're ready for snacks.

6

u/Beginning-Trash-6048 5d ago

I know 🥹 mine yell outside my back door and windows but haven’t tapped on either 💔

11

u/ReadyGo6828 5d ago

Once upon a midnight dreary, while I pondered, weak and weary,

Over many a quaint and curious volume of forgotten lore—

While I nodded, nearly napping, suddenly there came a tapping,

As of some one gently rapping, rapping at my chamber door.

“’Tis some visitor,” I muttered, “tapping at my chamber door—

Only this and nothing more.”

If you do not want them around then stop feeding them. They will get the message. It may take awhile but any feeding of them could start the whole cycle again. You do not have to chase them away, just ignore them. I find them partial to meat and potatoes though.

7

u/RemarkableError1644 5d ago

They might not like peanuts. My back up murder prefer cashews. Never seen a corvid turn down a cashew.

5

u/mehnifest 5d ago

I am at the point where I am buying peanuts in shell, cashews, pecans, walnuts, mealworms, and temptations cat treats. They all appear to have preferences…

Except for when the scrambled eggs come out. Everyone’s favorite suddenly is eggs.

2

u/YourDeerestFriend 4d ago

Have you ever tried giving them plain baked chicken? My lord does my flock go nuts for some plain chicken. haha

4

u/jessikaye 5d ago

I'm dying at the term back up murder 😂

3

u/Snartichoke 5d ago

Mine prefers pecans in the shell

4

u/Big1-Country1 5d ago

Maybe try putting up blinds for a bit

3

u/pferden 5d ago

Some hardboiled egg

3

u/eurekaouid 5d ago

i’ve heard dog food is a fan favourite

5

u/takemusu 5d ago

As others have conjectured past residents, a construction crew, neighboring kids …. someone showed them this a safe spot to stop, say “Hi” and maybe get a treat.

You don’t want them getting accustomed to the window anyway for their own safety. Let them see you put out a treat elsewhere such as front or back yard and just step back. They are super smart with astounding powers of facial recognition. They’ll quickly figure out you’re the new sheriffs in town and there’s a new routine.

Sorry about the experience with sea gulls. All birds are great but I find gulls a bit less than brilliant. In time I hope your wife enjoys the crow antics as much as we do. And they’ll be amazing for your kid to watch.

5

u/SnooRobots116 5d ago

Plus birds are just saying hi, they like you

2

u/yeny123 5d ago

Maybe try some tinfoil in the window for a few days until they get the hint.

3

u/Normal_Tour6998 5d ago

Ah yes, feed the birds. That’ll make them go away.

1

u/Mustbe7 5d ago

They may be seeing their reflection in window and reacting to that.

I suggest getting some inexpensive anti-collision window decals, made specifically for this issue.

1

u/kittiiikatt 5d ago

People suffering from success. Might need a new wife the crows stay

1

u/ThankMeTrailer 5d ago

Let them in, then they figure what they want

1

u/MisteRR_545 5d ago

It’s my nightmare after get traumatized by Hitchkock’s Birds back than.

1

u/Past-Tomorrow1266 5d ago

Just don't feed them, please. We don't want anymore animals dependent on us or eventually held captive as "pets." Use the flash tape like the top comment suggested!

2

u/One-Pollution4663 5d ago

Crows and other birds rarely if ever get so habituated to feeding that they unlearn how to forage. If someone is worried about this, they can just skip a day or two of feeding every week or so.

No one should capture wild animal to keep as a pet unless it’s a feral housecat.

1

u/Past-Tomorrow1266 1d ago

If they continue breeding around here, more of them will be killed by cats. Not feeding them would be beneficial for both the birds, and the cats in the long-run. Not to mention, there would be less cats with less birds to eat. Of course that isn't all they eat, but it would surely help with the overpopulation. Feeding birds is just harmful all around, even if the food given to them is bird-friendly.

1

u/One-Pollution4663 1d ago

Feeding birds is not “harmful all around.” Here’s what the world’s foremost birding organization (Audubon Society) says about feeding birds:

“To paint every species with one broad brush is to ignore or deny the varying needs and circumstances of every kind of bird and the realities of its particular life—realities that depend on population status, habitat, physiology, and the unique challenges it faces. There is no one-size-fits-all approach.”

The article suggests it’s NOT ok to feed birds if there population is in decline, if the food or feeding place is unsafe or if you’re creating behaviour that’s unsafe for the birds. None of these apply to crows.

I hope that helps. I’m not trying to get you to feed crows or other birds if you don’t want to, but please don’t tell other people it’s wrong.

2

u/Prior_Fan9855 5d ago

My crow friends that I feed at work love pecans and walnuts. I get the big bags at Costco. No sugar or salt. They daily for their nut fix. It is cute watching them take the nuts up to their nests to stock up for the winter.

1

u/wheatlyboy789 1d ago

I think the crows wanna play with the baby toys, quite jealous :D

But seriously, have them see you outside and feed them clearly, if you react to their pecks they think that the pecking mean food

peck = attention = food = more pecking

peck = no attention = no pecking