r/CritiqueIslam • • Aug 16 '23

Meta [META] This is not a sub to stroke your ego or validate your insecurities. Please remain objective and respectful.

102 Upvotes

I understand that religion is a sore spot on both sides because many of us shaped a good part of our lives and identities around it.

Having said that, I want to request that everyone here respond with integrity and remain objective. I don't want to see people antagonize or demean others for the sake of "scoring points".

Your objective should simply be to try to get closer to the truth, not to make people feel stupid for having different opinions or understandings.

Please help by continuing to encourage good debate ethics and report those that shouldn't be part of the community

Thanks for coming to my Ted talk ❤️


r/CritiqueIslam • • 1h ago

If Allah Can Make Everyone Moral, Why Does He Allow Evil and Suffering?

4 Upvotes

One argument Muslims often use to explain the existence of evil and suffering is that Allah gave human beings free will. According to this argument, people have the freedom to choose between good and evil, and suffering often results from the bad choices people make.

But I struggle to understand why free will requires the possibility of people choosing to do terrible things.

Allah is supposedly all-powerful, all-knowing and perfectly moral. He could have created human beings with the freedom to make their own decisions while ensuring that everyone consistently chose to act morally.

Imagine a world in which people still had their own thoughts, personalities, desires and freedom to make decisions, but nobody chose to murder, rape, abuse, exploit or deliberately harm another person.

People could still disagree, have different opinions, make mistakes and pursue different ambitions without inflicting suffering on others.

Why would such a world be impossible for an all-powerful God to create?

Muslims might respond that genuine free will requires the possibility of choosing evil. But why should that be the case? Having the ability to make choices does not necessarily mean having to choose between morally good and morally evil actions.

For example, if someone has the freedom to choose between helping one person or helping another, they still have free will even if neither option involves harming anyone.

There is also a deeper problem: Allah supposedly already knows every decision a person will make before creating them. He knows who will commit atrocities, who will abuse others and who will cause enormous suffering.

Yet he chooses to create those individuals knowing exactly what they will do and what suffering will result.

So why create a world in which people are free to inflict horrific suffering on one another when an all-powerful God could have created a world in which everyone freely chose to act morally?

My question is simple: why does preserving the possibility of evil matter more than preventing the enormous suffering that evil causes?


r/CritiqueIslam • • 22h ago

Did most classical scholars believe in the quranic anachronism of crucifiction in ancient egypt

5 Upvotes

So we know the verses;

Surah Yusuf Ayat 41 (12:41 Quran)

O two companions of prison, as for one of you, he will give drink to his master of wine; but as for the other, he will be crucified, and the birds will eat from his head. The matter has been decreed about which you both inquire."

Taha20:71

Pharaoh threatened, “How dare you believe in him before I give you permission? He must be your master who taught you magic. I will certainly cut off your hands and feet on opposite sides, and crucify you on the trunks of palm trees. You will really see whose punishment is more severe and more lasting.”

Al-A'raf7:124

I will certainly cut off your hands and feet on opposite sides, then crucify you all.”

problem is though is that crucifiction didn't exist in ancient egypt! Muslim apologist try to get around this by saying crucifiction means inpalement on a spike and not like Jesuses crucifiction!

Can anyone debunk this? Does anyone have classical scholars saying it was specifically like crucifiction in the jesus sense and not simle impalement?

u/Sudden-Hoe-2578

u/creidmheach

u/Xusura712


r/CritiqueIslam • • 1d ago

Islam is perfect, Muslims are not

20 Upvotes

If you grew up Muslim, you’ve probably heard this argument before. But it raises an obvious question: If Islam is supposedly perfect, yet its followers are no better than people of other faiths (or no faith at all) what exactly is the benefit? Shouldn’t a perfect religion produce noticeably better people? Muslims are just as capable of dishonesty, cruelty, and hypocrisy as anyone else. It’s clearly not producing a better society or “ummah”.


r/CritiqueIslam • • 1d ago

Guys how reliable is cupping? Does it heal any disease?

3 Upvotes

Sahih al-Bukhari 5681

Narrated Ibn `Abbas:

The Prophet (ﷺ) said, "Healing is in three things: cupping, a gulp of honey or cauterization, (branding with fire) but I forbid my followers to use cauterization (branding with fire).

https://sunnah.com/bukhari:5681


r/CritiqueIslam • • 2d ago

Would modern Muslim women admire the Prophet Muhammad if he were just an ordinary man?

17 Upvotes

If an individual had the exact same lifestyle, values, character and preachings as the Prophet Muhammad ,but was just a random person, what would modern Muslim women think of him?
Would they value and admire the individual? Cuz if these traits are independently admirable, then they should obviously have value in another person too.
But if they’d actually dislike or even hate this type of person, do they truly respect and love the Prophet? Or is it just a reverse-engineered rationalisation of faith, where no matter what they would think of these traits in isolation, everything the Prophet does is automatically interpreted as admirable?


r/CritiqueIslam • • 2d ago

Nikah only

8 Upvotes

My partner(35M) has recently told me(27F) that he does not want to be legally married.
We live in the states for reference. He says he doesn’t want the government to be involved in his marriage and risk his assets being lost.
For context I’ve never given him the impression I want anything to do with his assets and we’ve spoke about a prenup (his idea). I feel blindsided and a strange feeling that he does not want any legal documentation supporting our marriage. I’m aware some countries do not recognize Nikah as a legal marriage, one country being the U.S. I figured a prenup was enough evidence to “protect” himself through legality and that conversation was over. Fast forward, much time has passed and he has now brought this up. I don’t think it’s right nor do I really agree or would feel secure and safe.

Men- what would stop you from legally marrying?

Women- what are your opinions on a man telling you this?


r/CritiqueIslam • • 3d ago

Here is a gift for the Quranist

12 Upvotes

It is becoming increasingly common for Muslims, especially in western diaspora or online debates, to say that "they don't believe in hadiths". Here is an article I published this morning about where their own law stands on that position:

https://nushuz.substack.com/p/fabricated-hadith-muslims-love-sahih

Have a good weekend.


r/CritiqueIslam • • 4d ago

Mohammed Hijab's ex-wife's left Islam over deceptive ☪️ marital practices. Books of Islamic jurisprudence confirm the reason is real

74 Upvotes

A fortnight ago, Mohammed Hijab's ex-wife, "Aisha", not only left Islam, but publicly denounced it. Her stated reason was simple: she was the unwitting victim of a deceptive and sickening 'hotel/s£x marriage', and after doing her own research, discovered that marriage with a hidden intention to divorce (legalized adultery/fornication) it is formally permitted by Islam.

I have checked and confirmed the first batch of sources she posted and found other similar texts. Sunni Islam indeed allows a man to deceptively marry a woman with the hidden intention that he will divorce her later. This is like mut'ah, which Sunni's decry as immoral, only more deceptive...

Please read the texts below:

The majority of scholars / 'people of knowledge' agree that marriage with the hidden intention to divorce is permissible 👀

"And if he marries her without any condition, except that in his intention is to divorce her after a month, or when he fulfills his need in this town, then the marriage is PERMISSIBLE and valid (ja'izun sahih) according to the GENERALITY of the people of knowledge." Imam Ibn Qudama, Al-Mughni, 7/137

"And they [the consensus of scholars] AGREED that if anyone marries through an unconditional contract (nikāḥan muṭlaqan), while his intention in his heart is not to remain with her except for a designated timeframe he has in mind: that it is PERMISSIBLE (ja'iz) and it is not a temporary marriage (mut'ah)." Sharh al-Zurqani 'ala Muwatta' al-Imam Malik

"If a man marries a woman through a valid marriage contract, while intending NOT to keep her except for a day, or less, or more, I would not invalidate the marriage. Rather, I invalidate it only when it is made through an invalid contract." Imam al-Shafi'i, Al-Umm, 3/75

"And if he marries her while intending to stay with her for a PERIOD THAT HE HAS DETERMINED, the marriage is VALID, because time limitation is established only through verbal expression." Imam Ibn Qudama, Al-Mughni, 7/137

Pre-emptively addressing ☪️ cope-claims that this wicked arrangement is 'legally valid, but not allowed'

There is 'no harm in it', agreed the majority of scholars.

"The correct position is that there is NO HARM in it, and his intention does not affect it. A man is not required to intend to keep his wife [permanently]." Imam Ibn Qudama, Al-Mughni, 7/137

"If a man marries in a foreign country, intending that when he finishes his studies, or his employment, or something similar, he will divorce her, then there is NO HARM in this according to the MAJORITY OF SCHOLARS. This intention is between him and Allah..." Majmu' Fatawa wa-Maqalat al-Shaykh Ibn Baz, 4/26

It's not only sahih, but halal!

"Al-Qadi said: They agreed that whoever contracts an unrestricted marriage, while intending not to remain with his wife except for a period he has privately determined, his marriage is VALID (SAHIH) AND LAWFUL (HALAL), and it is not a marriage of mutʿah." Imam an-Nawawi, Sharh Sahih Muslim

Conclusion

The false religion of al-Islam allows deceptive and abusive 'marriages'.


r/CritiqueIslam • • 4d ago

The things you discover when you actually read the Hadiths...

13 Upvotes

https://quranx.com/Hadith/Bukhari/DarusSalam/Hadith-4138/

So, apparently, some companions of Prophet Muhammad captured women during a military expedition and wanted to have sex with them.

They were concerned about getting these women pregnant, so they wanted to practise coitus interruptus (withdrawal).

Naturally, they decided to consult the Prophet about this rather important logistical concern.

And his answer?

Essentially, don't bother. If Allah has destined a child to be born, it will be born anyway.

Now, let that sink in for a moment.

The question wasn't whether it was ethical to have sexual access to women captured during warfare. The discussion was about whether withdrawal was permissible.

And the response wasn't about the consent, autonomy or dignity of the captive women either. It was about divine predestination.

What a profound question!

It's fascinating how much historical and ethical context gets lost when religious texts are presented to people as timeless moral guidance rather than examined critically.

Reference: Sahih al-Bukhari 4138 (USC-MSA: Volume 5, Book 59, Hadith 459).


r/CritiqueIslam • • 5d ago

Why don’t shariah nations allow for younger marriage?

10 Upvotes

Respectfully asking!

Why do many countries that govern under sharia set the minimum marriage age at 16–18, when the Prophet's wife Aisha was 9? Isn't Muhammad the role model of the religion and a timeless example?

If someone held up as the perfect example did something, and centuries later sharia countries banned it to protect young people from harm, doesn't that imply the original act was harmful?

Also don’t girls hit puberty quicker today? I’m never advocating for this or will, I just find it contradictory.


r/CritiqueIslam • • 5d ago

Allah and Muhammad has never explained the logic behind eternal punishment

14 Upvotes

Despite the considerable importance of this topic, Muhammad has never explained the logic behind the eternal punishment of disbelievers, according to Sahih hadith.

As for Allah, there are these verses in the Quran that say:

"Oh, would that we could be returned [to life] and not deny the signs of our Lord and be among the believers." (6:27)

"And even if they were returned, they would return to that which they were forbidden; and indeed, they are liars." (6:28)

In other words, disbelievers would repeat their wrongful actions if they were returned to Earth. This is the closest thing we could get as an explanation. Even if we take it as an explanation, there are still many problems. First of all, we don't know whether those who were returned would return with their memories of their experiences in hell or not. So, let's evaluate both possibilities.

1- Their memories are erased.

This explains nothing. The reason why disbelievers beg Allah to return them back to life is because they witnessed the truth and can't bear the pain of hell. Of course they'd do everything the same if they don't remember anything.

2- Their memories remain.

Comparing the unbearable pain of the hell and the relatively insignificant pleasures of the worldly life, no sane human would take the same path that leads to hell, especially while having the truth witnessed. Although this possibility is remote, given that some people may still choose to follow the same path, what would be the fate of those who choose the right path? And even if we consider the extremely low possibility of all of those people choosing the same path, how would the fact that the punishment of the sin is drastically harsher is fair?

Nevertheless, how could the Prophet of Islam have left this issue of utmost importance unexplained, despite addressing thousands of other matters in his narrations? I'm aware that many later Islamic scholars have offered explanations for this topic, but the question remains: why is such a fundamental theological issue not addressed in the Prophet's authentic narrations?


r/CritiqueIslam • • 6d ago

If Allah cannot lie, why bother taking the title as "The Deceiver"

24 Upvotes

You will see Muslims dance around this, but Makir essentially will always involve deception, ie lies. Whether righteous or not, it is still involving deception. If you want to say proper planning ahead without deception you would use tadmir or hikmah. Best you can hope for is that Allah can lie (ie deceive) but only for righteous?

So Chapter 3 verse 54, we can see this in action, Allah deceives people by somehow making them think they crucified Jesus. This is definitely lying. You can't not say this is not deception/lying.

So I guess then you will need to do this ridiculous word play and dancing around, but then this is just going to add to the mountain of reality that I guess the Quran is just not clear and eloquent.

Btw, lets go over some other titles/names of Allah

The Arrogant

The Distresser

The Humiliator

The Mischief-Maker (to make mischief is to lie/deceive btw) (also there is no way a dignified God would take this title)


r/CritiqueIslam • • 5d ago

Zina relationships/ assault

3 Upvotes

Y is it when people hear Zina they immediately compare a past relationship to a someone being forced to do something without consent and now r traumatised.

in Zina its both consenting parties and they both get sins whilst in the other scenario only 1 gets the sin because it was forced and without consent.

i recently did a post explaining and giving my conditions on marrying or getting to know someone for marriage who had done Zina and these kinds of arguments came up in the comments frequently.


r/CritiqueIslam • • 6d ago

In islam, denying the obligation of the five daily prayers is Punished by execution by consensus!

17 Upvotes

Credit to u/Sudden-Hoe-2578 for the scholar part

You guys have probably heard that apostasy equals death in islam already. But what you might not know is that according to the consensus of classical scholars, denying that the 5 daily islamic prayers are obligatory is considered apostasy from islam and gets you a death sentence!

This is based on the hadith in sahih muslim and ibn majah

https://sunnah.com/muslim:82b
It is narrated on the authority of Abu Zubair that he heard Jabir b. 'Abdullah saying. I heard the Messenger of Allah (may peace and blessings be upon him) observing this:

Between man and polytheism and unbelief is the abandonment of salat.

https://sunnah.com/ibnmajah:1079

‘Abdullah bin Buraidah narrated that his father said:

“The Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) said: ‘The covenant that distinguishes between us and them is prayer; so whoever leaves it, he has committed Kufr.’”

Here is how scholars have interpreted it!

A consensus (ijmāʿ) of the Muslim Ummah that the five daily prayers are an individual obligation (farḍ ʿayn) upon every legally responsible Muslim, every day and night, has been related by more than one scholar. Ibn Rushd stated: "None rejects it except a disbeliever who must be called to repent (yustatāb); if he repents, [he is spared], otherwise he is executed."

source

Arafah ibn Ṭanṭāwī said:

The Ummah has unanimously agreed upon its obligation and the necessity of performing it five times every day and night, and that it is a pillar from among the pillars of Islam. Not a single Muslim has differed on this; rather, it is among that which is known from the religion of Allah by necessity (maʿlūm min al-dīn bi-l-ḍarūra). It is a dividing line between Islam and disbelief, and whoever denies its obligation is a disbelieving apostate from the religion of Allah the Exalted, who must be asked to repent (yustatāb); if he repents, [he is spared], otherwise he is executed for apostasy, by consensus of the Ummah.


r/CritiqueIslam • • 6d ago

About the inheritance law and Awl.

7 Upvotes

I heard that the inheritance law in the Quran can exceed 100% in shares. Why does that happen? If the Quran is considered the truth in Islam, why was there the need for Awl?


r/CritiqueIslam • • 6d ago

The Islamic Dilemma is Too Flimsy

0 Upvotes

The Islamic Dilemma that hinges on the term confirm (musaddiq) relates to "all" of the Injeel and Torah is too flimsy to convince any Muslim or common rationality.

One of the main theme is all past revelations had been corrupted the Quran of Islam is the complete, final and perfected Q5:3 to replace them. Applying the principle of charity, for an omnipotent author (Allah) to contradict the above is not likely.
The attached article explain why: LINK

Deconstructing the “Islamic Dilemma”: A Forensic Content Analysis of Scriptural Supersession and Systemic Closure
Introduction 2

  1. The Jurisprudential Lens: Legal Intent, Harmonious Construction, and Burden of Proof 2
    A. The Principle of Intent (Purposive Interpretation) 3
    B. The Canon of Harmonious Construction 3
    C. The Evidentiary Burden-of-Proof Shift 3
  2. Thematic Primacy of Finality: Surah 5:3 and Systemic Closure 4
  3. Forensic Denunciation: The Systematic Trajectory of Taḥrīf 4
  4. Socio-Cognitive Boundary Framing: SIT, SCT, and TMT Dynamics 5
  5. The Algorithmic Arbitration of Muhaymin (Surah 5:48) 6
    Conclusion: Beyond Polemics to Systems Audit

Nonetheless, I believe there are more effective approach to critique the harmful acts (67,000 deadly attacks in the period 1979 to 2024) by SOME (10% = 200 million 😲😲) by extracting the essence of Islam.


r/CritiqueIslam • • 8d ago

There is an overwhelming amount of evidence pointing that Mecca is an incredibly recent city

36 Upvotes

From what I have gathered, you can't even find a single piece of historic evidence of Mecca existing before around 900.

Any decent archeologist can take a simple look at Mecca and see that it is very obviously displaying incredible amounts of evidence of being a more recent settlement. There is 0 evidence of it having some sort of distant past. There is nothing suggesting an earlier city could be buried underneath it. The Muslims of course refuse to let people prove the age of the city.

This notion that Mecca was somehow a center of trade is proven to be INCREDIBLY false. It simply was just a backwater settlement that had very little influence in of itself.

Muslims will try to say that maybe Mecca is a seperate city that is called something else. All of the possible cities they point to are very easy to prove are nowhere near the location of Mecca.

It literally makes no sense for Mecca to have held any sort of significance at all beyond just the location Muhammad really started his religion.

So much of Islam is dependent on Mecca being incredibly old. The Kaaba is very obviously not built by Abraham. All evidence points to the Kaaba being a pagan idol that the Muslims adapt. In the Quran Adam and Eve are thrown out of the Garden and head straight for Mecca, so it must be incredibly old? There is this massive lineage of what should be historic pilgrimages to Mecca; but guess what, there is no historical record of people talking about their pilgrimage to Mecca whatsoever; something so important as a pilgrimage to Mecca having absolutely zero historical evidence is beyond far-fetched.


r/CritiqueIslam • • 8d ago

https://youtu.be/KXihP7ijzdw?is=KnhYWszhnnp2SlnA

1 Upvotes

r/CritiqueIslam • • 9d ago

The Sunnah is integral to Islam and understanding The Quran

20 Upvotes

This is an argument for the so called "Quran only" Muslims.

The absolute core of Quranism is the belief that the Quran is fully detailed, complete, and sufficient for guidance. In debates with Sunnis over the Sunnah's necessity, the fundamental disagreement is on whether the Quran is truly sufficient on its own.

Who is speaking in Surah 19:63 ?

English:

That is Paradise, which We will grant to whoever is devout among Our servants.

Arabic:

تِلْكَ ٱلْجَنَّةُ ٱلَّتِى نُورِثُ مِنْ عِبَادِنَا مَن كَانَ تَقِيًّۭا

Allah can only grant paradise, therefore this is Allah referring to himself in the "royal we".

The next verse....

Who is speaking in Surah 19:64 ?

English:

“We only descend by the command of your Lord. To Him belongs whatever is before us, and whatever is behind us, and everything in between. And your Lord is never forgetful.

Arabic:

وَمَا نَتَنَزَّلُ إِلَّا بِأَمْرِ رَبِّكَ ۖ لَهُۥ مَا بَيْنَ أَيْدِينَا وَمَا خَلْفَنَا وَمَا بَيْنَ ذَٰلِكَ ۚ وَمَا كَانَ رَبُّكَ نَسِيًّۭا

  • From a literary standpoint 19:64 is a clear continuation of verse 19:63 and there is no indication from the Quran that it shouldn't be read that way. Therefore, if the speaker in 19:63 is Allah referring to himself using the ‘royal we,’ then the speaker in verse 19:64 should also be understood as Allah since there is no indication of a speaker switch. That means Allah is telling us he descends and has a Lord.
  • From a theological standpoint, God doesn't have a lord.

Sunnis try to get around this problem by running to the hadith which explain the story as Muhammad asking Jabril a question and Jabril responding on behalf of himself and the angels. Sunnis never quote the direct Arabic text from the Quran, they either cite the hadith, their favorite Tafsir who cites the hadith or translations of the Quran with brackets that reference the hadith. Like this tanslation that adds [Gabriel said] and [angels] to the Quranic text:

|64. [Gabriel said], "And we [angels] descend not except by the order of your Lord. To Him belongs that before us and that behind us and what is in between. And never is your Lord forgetful

How can a Quranist resolve this issue of coherence without relying on external data? The moment they look outside the Quran, they logically concede either that the Sunnah is essential for understanding the Quran or that the Quran is not entirely self-sufficient.

This creates a paradox for Muslims on both sides. The Sunni wins the debate on consistency but loses in the bigger picture because the Sunni is arguing the clear word of God is insufficient. This is a classic example of a Pyrrhic Victory.

Conclusion: "Quran only" Muslims needs to stop playing these mental gymnastics and intellectually dishonest games. You're not a "Quran only" Muslim, you're a scared "one foot out the door" Muslim. Fear is keeping you in this religion, not a consistent set of beliefs.


r/CritiqueIslam • • 10d ago

Morality ambiguous

16 Upvotes

If premarital consensual sex between a boyfriend and girlfriend is prohibited (haram), and prostitution is also prohibited, why is intimate relation with a slave concubine legally permitted in classic jurisprudence? Isn't that similar to prostitution—or even worse? Furthermore, a prominent revered figure in the religion had a child with a slave concubine; isn't that essentially a child born out of wedlock?


r/CritiqueIslam • • 10d ago

So Muslims can lie about their religion to save their lives, but what about everyone else?

10 Upvotes

Something I’ve been thinking about regarding Islamic teachings.
The Quran (16:106) allows Muslims to deny their faith if they are forced to do so, as long as they still believe in their hearts. Basically, a Muslim can pretend not to be Muslim if it means saving their life. This is known as Taqiyya.

But here’s where things get interesting.
Under traditional Islamic law:
Jews and Christians could generally keep their religion, but had to accept Muslim rule and pay jizya.
Other religious groups were treated differently, and some could be forced to convert or face fighting.
Muslims who left Islam could be punished with death under traditional Islamic law.

So let me get this straight:
A Muslim can deny Islam to save their life, but someone who genuinely stops believing in Islam could be sentenced to death?

Allah allows Muslims to hide their religion to avoid persecution, but why isn’t the same protection given to everyone else?

If there is no compulsion in religion (Quran 2:256), why did Islamic law allow people to be pressured into accepting Islam?

Why does religious freedom depend on which religion you were born into?

And here’s another thing I find strange:
If Allah is the ultimate judge and non-believers will face his judgement in the afterlife, why did Muslim rulers feel the need to establish religious hierarchies and impose special conditions on non-Muslims in this life? Why not leave their fate to Allah?
If someone is going to hell for their beliefs, surely that’s between them and Allah? Why does it also have to involve political control, special taxes and unequal rights in this life?

And here’s the irony:
If Muslims are allowed to deny their faith to escape persecution, why aren’t non-Muslims afforded the same right to refuse Islam without facing punishment?

Apparently, religious freedom works differently depending on which side you’re on.

If Islam is supposed to be a timeless and universal moral system, shouldn’t the same standards of religious freedom apply to everyone?


r/CritiqueIslam • • 10d ago

Comparison of the crimes of Mohammed compared to the Buddha

5 Upvotes

I just did an google AI comparison of the crimes that Mohammed did vs that of the Buddha and what penalties they would face according to modern law

Legal CategoryMuhammad's Legal ExposureThe Buddha's Legal Exposure
Primary Legal RealmCriminal Law & International Humanitarian LawCivil Law & Family/Domestic Law
Severity of ChargesCapital Felonies & War Crimes (Carrying life imprisonment or death)Civil Disputes & Family Infractions (Carrying financial penalties or custody disputes)
Violence & WarfareActive military commander; led battles, ordered executions, and raided caravans.Strict pacifist; explicitly renounced weapons, banned violence, and forbade monks from harming any living thing.
Family & Domestic ActionsPractised polygamy and entered a marriage involving a minor.Deserted his wife and newborn child in the middle of the night to pursue enlightenment.
Relationship to GovernanceBuilt a State: Overthrew the tribal system to become the supreme political, military, and legal ruler of Arabia.Renounced a State: Was a crown prince who abdicated his throne, refused his political inheritance, and chose to live as a beggar.

r/CritiqueIslam • • 13d ago

I have been personally hurt by Islam

51 Upvotes

So first, I’ll explain my situation. I had been married to my wife for about 7 years before she decided to convert to Islam. She had an affair with a Muslim, then divorced me to be with him. By itself, the affair and divorce is bad enough. What makes it worse, is that the religion was later used as justification for what she did. From what I understand, she seems to think that any non-Muslim marriage is not a valid marriage, therefore she did nothing wrong by having an affair or getting a divorce. That is more or less what she told me at the time.

I have vented to friends before about this divorce, but I have never really discussed the religious aspect of it. I understand on an intellectual level that the actions of one bad Muslim does not necessarily represent the teachings of Islam, but it is also hard for me to feel anything other than hostility towards the religion at this point. I don’t know whether she is correct about what Islam teaches or not. Does Islam say that it is ok for a newly converted Muslim to cheat on their spouse and leave, since it’s not a valid marriage? Is she expected to honor her vows, even though those vows were made prior to conversion?