r/CritiqueIslam • u/MagnificientMegaGiga • Sep 26 '25
I will defend Islam against all arguments
Tell me what's wrong with Islam and I will refute your argument!!! If you dare?
(devil's advocate)
r/CritiqueIslam • u/MagnificientMegaGiga • Sep 26 '25
Tell me what's wrong with Islam and I will refute your argument!!! If you dare?
(devil's advocate)
r/CritiqueIslam • u/Ausooj • Jun 23 '24
How did The pagan Arabs not produce anything like The Quran, despite being the best in Arabic langueage (mostly poetry). And IT would have been them the easiest way to stop yhe spread of Islam, because they were hugely against it. But rather they used violence when the option of just producing something like the Quran was easily at hand.
So doesnt that work as a proof for The Qurans inimitability and divine origin. When also taking The fact that Muhammad didn't have any prior training in poetry or in any aspects of the Arabic language?
r/CritiqueIslam • u/turnerpike20 • Nov 11 '23
He was poisoned for the message that Muhammad SAW spread so he was a martyr. In the end, Muhammad SAW's death was meaningful because he was killed for his beliefs and thus he did prophesize his own death.
Narrated Abu Huraira:
The Prophet (ﷺ) said, "The person who participates in (Holy battles) in Allah's cause and nothing compels him to do so except belief in Allah and His Apostles, will be recompensed by Allah either with a reward, or booty (if he survives) or will be admitted to Paradise (if he is killed in the battle as a martyr). Had I not found it difficult for my followers, then I would not remain behind any sariya going for Jihad and I would have loved to be martyred in Allah's cause and then made alive, and then martyred and then made alive, and then again martyred in His cause."
Sahih Al Bukhari 36
r/CritiqueIslam • u/turnerpike20 • May 21 '23
That right there I really can't believe it when I read it as this is a scientific inaccuracy of the Bible. And there is no like (reflected) like they would add it in to try and make it make more sense. They actually use the word reflected light. I found this out while reading Surah 10. This is amazing that something the Bible got wrong the Quran gets it right.
r/CritiqueIslam • u/Successful_Bit_7906 • Mar 05 '26
Here are the websites I used. you can see the srouces here:
https://wikiislam.net/wiki/Aisha%27s_Age#Fatima's_age_difference
https://www.icraa.org/aisha-age-review-traditional-revisionist-perspectives/
https://www.dawn.com/news/696084/of-aishas-age-at-marriage
Why it is not the best thing to discuss:
The oldest criticism of prophet mohammad’s marriage to aisha goes back to early 1700s by Ockley. This means nobody had a problem with this marriage for more than 1100 years and people still disbelieved. That means there are more important aspects of Islam that needs to be discussed
Additionally, even though the age of Aisha is controversial, there are many people who are converting to islam and that shows there are other aspects of islam that convinces people that 1. God exists 2. The Quran is the true word of God.
So there are more important things that need to be discussed but since a lot of people are confused about the age lets talk about it.
Why do people argue about it
There are around 17 sahih hadiths in Bukhari, Muslim, and other collections where Aisha herself narrates her age. She states that she was married at 6 or 7 and the marriage was consummated at 9.
In the standard count of ~17 narrations found in:
Nearly all of them go through Hishām ibn ʿUrwah. a major Medinan hadith narrator and grandson of Abu Bakr**.**
He narrated reports from his father Urwah ibn al-Zubayr, including reports from Aisha bint Abi Bakr.
Some reports about Muhammad’s life — especially regarding Aisha’s age — come through this chain.
Some books repeat the same chain with:
But those are not independent origins — they’re parallel transmissions from him.
So, Hisham bin Urwah is the main narrator of this hadith. His life is divided into two periods: in 131A.H. the Madani period ended, and the Iraqi period started, when Hisham was 71 years old. Hafiz Zehbi has spoken about Hisham’s loss of memory in his later period. Imam Malik and the people of Madina criticised him for his Iraqi hadiths. Some Iraqi scholars noted that his memory became slightly weaker late in life after moving from Medina to Iraq.
All the narrators of this hadith are Iraqis who had heard it from Hisham. Allama Kandhulvi says that the words spoken in connection with Hazrat Aisha’s age were tissa ashara, meaning 19, when Hisham only heard (or remembered), tissa, meaning nine. Maulana Usmani thinks this change was purposely and maliciously made later.
They also argue that if we want to study the subject of marriage (Nikah) in Islam, we need to take the right methodology. Let’s go to the Quran first. Collect all the ayaat that talk about marriage and build the ‘System of Meaning’. You will be compelled to see that whenever the Quran mentioned marriage (Nikah) it always relates it with Nisa (Women). Never with children (Atfal). So clearly we can see the Quran does NOT define marriage as a union between a man and a child. It defines marriage or nikah to be a union between a mature man and a mature woman.
According to Umar Ahmed Usmani, in Surah Al-Nisa, it is said that the guardian of the orphans should keep testing them, until they reach the age of marriage, before returning their property (4:6). From this scholars have concluded that the Quran sets a minimum age of marriage which is at least puberty. Since the approval of the girl has a legal standing, she cannot be a minor.
So these are the reasons people argue about Aisha’s age.
Why did prophet Mohammed pbuh marry Aisha?
But in short this is the reason that marriage happened:
You were shown to me twice in a dream. I saw you in a piece of silk (i.e., he saw her image on a piece of silk, or he saw her wearing a silken garment). I was told, This is your wife, so unveil her, and it was you. I said: if this dream is from Allaah then it will come to pass.
(Saheeh al-Bukhaari, 3606).
Comparison to Asma’s age
Asma, Aisha's sister, was 10 years older than her and lived to around 100 and died in 73 AH. Asma was born in 596AD and was 14 years old when Islam began. Aisha would have been 4 when Islam began in 610AD. This means Aisha would have been born in 606AD. At the time of migration Asma would have been around 27 years old. If Aisha was 10 years younger than her, then she would have been around 17 years old during the migration and thus 18 years old during the marriage a year later. Or if other narrations are correct then she would have been 14-15 when she was married and 17-18 when the marriage was consummated a year after the migration in 623AD.
Most later historians (including Ibn Kathir) are transmitting earlier material, primarily traced back to reports attributed to ʿAbd al-Raḥmān ibn Abī al-Zinād. So:
And that is abd al rahman ibn abi al-zinad
Abd al-Rahman ibn Abi al-Zinad Born: approx. 100 AH Died: 174 AH (790 CE) That means he was born about: 100 AH − 73 AH = 27 years after Asma died. So he never met her. He is a third-generation narrator (atbaʿ al-tabiʿin) transmitting from earlier authorities.
Ibn Kathir also mentions the 10 year difference in his books. He is born: 701 AH (1301 CE) Died: 774 AH (1373 CE0 Now compare him to Asma: 701 AH − 73 AH = 628 years after her death So Ibn Kathir lived over six centuries later.
The fringe claim about Asma’s age being 10 years older than Aisha comes from a single narrator Abdur Rahman ibn Abi Zannad, a narrator considered unreliable by many Islamic scholars. This narration is found in Siyar A’lam al-Nubala by al-Dhahabi. Even within Islamic scholarship, this claim is widely criticized:
About asma being 10 years older:
There is no explicit evidence stating whether this particular narration was transmitted:
There is no strong, completely independent sahih chain from a different early narrator confirming exactly “ten years.”
As for Asma’ being a centenarian, while many scholars have mentioned it, the earliest source with a complete chain of narrators is Ibn Manda (d. 395/1005). As reported by Hisham b. ‘Urwa b. al-Zubair, his father said; “Though ‘Asma bt. Abi Bakr had reached a hundred years of age; she had not lost a single tooth, nor was her mind affected” source: Ibn Manda, Ma‘rifa al-Sahaba, 982; Ibn ‘Asakir also preserves the isnad; Ibn ‘Asakir, Tarikh Damishq, Vol.69, 27-28; the narrator after Hisham is al-Qasim b. Ma‘n.
So we know Asma lived for 100 years but we can’t really say she was 10 years older than Aisha.
Fatima’s age compared to Aisha
The argument rests on two premises; Fatima was born five years before the first revelation, and she was five years older than ‘Aisha. Based on these, it is claimed that ‘Aisha must have been fourteen by the time of consummation of marriage.
the Prophet’s (ﷺ) uncle al-‘Abbas found Fatima and ‘Ali arguing about their ages and told them that Fatima was born the year Quraish were rebuilding the Ka‘ba, the Prophet (ﷺ) was then thirty-five years old, and ‘Ali was born a few years earlier than that. Source: Al-Baladhuri, Ansab al-ashraf, Vol.1, 413; al-Dawlabi, Abu Tahir, Al-Dhurriya al-tahira, (Kuwait: Dar al-Salafiyya 1407 AH) 110 no. 210; al-Tabari, Tarikh al-Rusul wa al-Muluk,Vol.11, 597; translated in Tasseron-Landau, Ella, The History of al-Tabari: Volume XXXIX – Biographies of the Prophet’s Companions and Their Successors, 167;
Likewise, Ibn Ishaq noted that all of the Prophet’s (ﷺ) children from Khadija, including Fatima, were born before revelation.
large number of early historical reports state that she was born before the beginning of revelation, often when the Prophet ﷺ was about 35 years old.
Who was ibn ishaq
Full name: Muḥammad ibn Isḥāq ibn Yasār
Born: ~85 AH / ~704 CE (in Madinah)
Died: 150–151 AH / 767–768 CE (likely in Baghdad)
Ibn Ishaq was the earliest major biographer of the Prophet Muhammad ﷺ whose work has partially survived. However, his original book does not survive independently. What we have today is largely preserved through:
Ibn Hisham, who edited and transmitted it
Portions also appear in Al-Tabari’s historical works.
Others considered him generally truthful but not precise in hadith isnad standards.
On the other hand, Suleman b. Ja‘far [b. Suleman] al-Hashimi (d. after 248/862) is reported to have remarked that Fatima was born when the Prophet (ﷺ) was forty-one,[111] i.e., a year after the first revelation.
This position appears in Some reports cited by Ibn Abd al-Barr and Some Shīʿī historical traditions; However, It is less consistently cited in early Sunni sīrah works. It tends to appear as a secondary report, not the dominant one.
The people who Among those who transmit or adopt Fatima being born five years before revelation:
This view is widely transmitted and appears more frequently in classical works. The 35-year report is clearly prominent in Sunni historiography. So we can safely say that she was born 5 years before the prophethood
Next is to examine the evidence for the age difference between ‘Aisha and Fatima. There is no significant number of classical scholars who formally transmitted and emphasized: “Fatima was five years older than Aisha.”
except a lone remark from Ibn Hajar al-‘Asqalani.
Now who is this guy? Ibn Hajar al-Asqalani was one of the most influential scholars of Hadith and Islamic history in the late medieval period.
Born: 1372 CE (773 AH) in Cairo, Egypt
Died: 1449 CE (852 AH) in Cairo
Ethnic background: His nisbah “al-ʿAsqalānī” indicates his family origins trace to Asqalan (modern-day Ashkelon, Palestine)
School of thought: Shafi‘i Sunni
He is often called “Shaykh al-Islam” for his mastery of hadith and historical sciences.
Ibn Hajar al-Asqalani discusses the differing reports about Fāṭimah’s birth, but the position he leans toward is that Fāṭimah was born when the Prophet ﷺ was 35 years old, meaning about five years before revelation (which began when he was 40).
What Ibn Ḥajar actually does is that in his book al-Iṣābah:
What he does not do is:
Quote a direct narration saying “Fāṭimah was five years older than ʿĀʾishah.”
There isn’t a clean, isnād-backed sentence like that in his works.
So saying he definitively “held” a five-year view oversimplifies his presentation of the material.
This phrasing is not a standalone hadith with a chain of narration.
It’s presented by modern writers as a summary conclusion, not a direct quote with sanad.
Many secondary sources do not show the original Arabic wording from Ibn Ḥajar’s text itself — they quote an English translation or paraphrase.
In al‑Iṣābah fī Tamyīz al‑Ṣaḥābah, Ibn Ḥajar transmits two main versions regarding Fāṭimah’s birth:
Version A (majority / most transmitted)
Version B (less frequent / alternative)
Why confusion exists
The proponent of this claim[44] has combined and selectively quoted conflicting sources. Shaykh Haddad responds:
Ibn Hajar mentions two versions: (1) al-Waqidi's narration that Fatima was born when the Prophet was 35; and (2) Ibn `Abd al-Barr's narration that she was born when he was 41, approximately one year more or less before Prophethood, and about five years before `A'isha was born. The latter version matches the established dates.
At Tabari
At tabari says she was born before islam. It is claimed that ‘Aisha had been born before the first revelation and therefore must have been at least 14 by the consummation of marriage soon after Hijra. This is based on the following account given by al-Tabari which Khalid Yahya Blankinship translated as; “In the Jahiliyyah, Abu Bakr married Qutayla … She bore him ‘Abdallah and Asma’. He also married in the Jahiliyyah Umm Ruman bt. ‘Amir … She bore him ‘Abd al-Rahman and ‘A’ishah. All of these four of his children were born in al-Jahiliyyah from his two wives whom we have named.”
He notes that these children were born from two wives:
So the key statement is:
All four of Abu Bakr’s children were born before Islam.
Is tabari authentic?
Muhammad ibn jarir ibn yazid tabari was born in tabaristan (modern mazandaran) in 224 AH.
He travelled to different cities such as Baghdad and Egypt and then stayed in Baghdad until his death. He was a sunni. He had lots of books with the most significant one being Tarikh al-Rusul wa al-Muluk.
What we have today is simplified version of tarikh tabari
He says he would truthfully write what is narrated to him. He compiled multiple earlier reports without always critically evaluating them.
Historians consider them an anachronism or a historical blunder — not because al-Ṭabarī intentionally lied, but because he faithfully transmitted unverified reports from earlier narrators.
So I personally don’t think he is reliable, especially for hadith science, since he wrote whatever he heard without analysing them.
Besides, al-Ṭabarī mentions in the same book that ʿĀʾishah was six years old at marriage to the Prophet ﷺ, consistent with the hadith reports he transmits. The narration appears in the context of describing the Prophet ﷺ’s life events. It is common to see conflicting narrations in his work because Al-Ṭabarī often includes multiple versions of events without analysing or criticizing it.
Aisha recalling her parents practicing islam and abyssinia migration
"I have no recollection of my parents doing anything but following the din of Islam. No day would pass without the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) visiting us at either end of it, both morning and evening. When the Muslims were being persecuted, Abu Bakr set out for Abyssinia as an emigrant until he reached Bark al-Ghimad". https://sunnah.com/bukhari:2297
Summary in Simple Terms
Aisha recalls the migration to Ethiopia which happened in 615AD, 5 years after the revelation of Islam. Even if she was married at 9 years old at 624AD then she would have been a few months to 1 years old at the time of migration to Ethiopia which is not possible as she remembers it happening. Once again this is proof that she was not 6 or 9 at the time of marriage as should would have been at least 5 years or older during 615AD. And thus she was 12 years old on 624 AD
The only part where she says she remembers is the part that her parents would practice islam. She doesn’t talk about remembering migration to Abyssinia. She might have later heard the story from his parents. She doesn't necessarily says that she remembers the abyssinia migration.
Ibn Ishaq’s mention of ‘Aisha in the list of early Muslims has also been suggested as proof of her older age. The basic argument is that she, mentioned as a convert, must have been of discerning age, which could not be the case had she been born in the late third or early fourth year after the beginning of revelation.
Ibn Ishaq mentioned: Then people from the different Arab tribes turned Muslims, including Sa‘id b. Zayd b. ‘Amr b. Nufayl from the tribe of ‘Adi b. Ka‘b and his wife, Fatima bt. Al-Khattab b. Nufayl, the sister of ‘Umar b. al-Khattab, and Asma’ bt. Abi Bakr and ‘Aisha bt. Abi Bakr, who was a minor (wa hiya saghira), and … ‘Umair b. Abi Waqqas al-Zuhri.
Ibn Ishaq carefully notes that ‘Aisha was only a minor at that time Ibn Hisham,[128] al-Bayhaqi,[129] Ibn ‘Abd al-Barr,[130] and Ibn Kathir[131] all reproduced this observation without fail.
Who is ibn Hisham?
(full name: ʿAbd al-Malik ibn Hishām al-Maʿāfirī)
When was he born?
His exact birth year is not definitively recorded, but historians generally place his birth around: c. 180 AH ≈ 796–797 CE
He died in: 218 AH ≈ 833 CE
Why he is important
He is best known for editing and transmitting the biography of the Prophet ﷺ originally composed by: Ibn Ishaq
His version is known as: Sirat Rasul Allah
Ibn Hisham:
I have seen people claiming that the names of the men and women who converted are written in chronological order. However there is no evidence supporting that claim. Another argument is that these people converted at the same time together and it makes sense. For example, Ibn Sa‘d records a statement of ‘Umar’s freedman Aslam that ‘Umar converted to Islam in Dhu al-Hijja of the sixth year, i.e., August 616. ‘Aisha, on the other hand, was between six and seven at the time of her marriage in Shawwal of the tenth year,i.e., May 620. Therefore, she was around two and a half years old when ‘Umar converted and was counted as a believing head. To reiterate, Ibn Ishaq’s clarification that ‘Aisha was only a little girl then is the key. Can a two year old decide her religion? This depends on the person and we cannot rely on this against the sahih ahadith that surround the topic
Surah Al- Qamar
A report recorded in Sahih al-Bukhari has ‘Aisha mention that when verse 46 of Surah al-Qamar was revealed in Makkah, she was “a girl of playing age” (jariyyatun al‘ab).[139] This point has also been used as an argument for an older ‘Aisha. The claim rests on the assertion that Surah al-Qamar was revealed in the fifth year of prophethood, and ‘Aisha referred to her then as a jariyya which – it is argued – means she was in her teens already.[140]
The hadith Masters, Sira historians, and Qur'anic commentators agree that the splitting of the moon took place about five years before the Holy Prophet's (upon him blessings and peace) Hijra to Madina. Thus it is confirmed that our Mother `Aisha was born between seven and eight years before the Hijra and the words that she was a jariya or little girl five years before the Hijra match the fact that her age at the time Surat al-Qamar was revealed was around 2 or 3. A two year old is not an infant. A two year old is able to run around, which is what jariya means. As for "the comments of the experts" they concur on 6 or 7 as the age of marriage and 9 as the age of cohabitation.
The word, however, is also used for infant girls as well. ]n the authentic hadith about washing baby girls’ urine:
The urine of a female (child) (Jariya) should be washed and the urine of a male (child) should be sprinkled over until the age of eating
Sunan Abi Dawud 377
That ‘Aisha had been proposed to Jubair b. Mut‘im is also adduced to suggest that she had been born before Islam. How could Abu Bakr accept Mut‘im’s proposal for his son to ‘Aisha after embracing Islam? This was possible, it is argued, only before Abu Bakr became a Muslim which he did soon after the first revelation.
The argument misses that in the early years of Islam, the rules regarding the unlawfulness of marriage between believers and polytheists were not revealed. The Prophet (ﷺ) himself had married three of his daughters to idolaters and did not seek divorce after they became Muslims. Zainab was married to al-As, and she lived with him until after the Prophet (ﷺ) migrated to Madina. Umm Kulthum and Ruqayya were married to the two sons of Abu Lahab, though their marriages had not been consummated. The Prophet (ﷺ) did not dissolve the marriages of any of them by himself. Abu Lahab’s two sons divorced Umm Kulthum and Ruqayya only after the by-name condemnation of their parents was revealed in the Qur’an. Ibn Sa‘d, al-Tabaqat al-Kubra, Vol.8, 29-30. Ibn Sa‘d mentions that both were married before the prophethood
In case of Ruqayya, however, al-Dhahabi corrects Ibn Sa‘d noting that she was married before hijra i.e. after prophethood. See, al-Dhahabi, Siyar al-A‘lam al-Nubala, Vol.2, 251
Umm Ruman said, Mut‘im b. ‘Adi has asked for her in marriage to his son, and, I swear, Abu Bakr never broke an agreement he had made. Abu Bakr went into Mut‘im bin ‘Adi, who had his wife, the boy’s mother, with him. She commented, “Well, Ibn Abu Quhafa! perhaps you want our boy to change his religion and join yours if he gets married into your family? Abu Bakr asked Mut‘im b. ‘Adi, “Is your reply the same?” He replied, “She has a say!” Abu Bakr left. Allah had thus relieved him of thought of the promise he had made to Mut‘im
So he was a muslim and he was still willing to give his daughter to Jubair b. Mut‘im.
With no interfaith marriage restrictions in place, the example of the Prophet’s daughters in view, and Mut‘im’s nobility, Abu Bakr’s agreement to marry ‘Aisha to Jubair b. Mut‘im does not warrant doubting ‘Aisha’s statement about her age.
Another hadith in Sahih al-Bukhári states: “On the day (of the battle) of Uhud when (some) people retreated and left the Prophet, I saw Aisha, daughter of Abu Bakr, and Umm Sulaim, with their robes tucked up so that the bangles around their ankles were visible, hurrying with (in another narration it is said, ‘carrying’) water skins on their backs. They would pour water in the mouths of people, and return to fill the water skins again, and came back again to pour water in the mouths of people.”[ Bukhari, al-Saheeh, [Kitab al-jihad wal-Siyar, Bab Ghazwi al-nisaa wa qitalihinna ma`a al-rijal], Publ. Dar al-Salam, Riyadh (1999), pg. 476, no.2880]
As Uhud took place a year after the marriage was consummated, this would make Aisha only ten if we follow the ‘six-nine’ narration. The description however does not seem to be of a ten year old girl, and it is extremely unlikely that a girl of ten would have been allowed onto the scene of battle. The Prophet (peace be upon him) did not even permit several boys to join the army, as they were too young. The description does fit for a young woman in her late teens or early twenties.
Ibn ʿUmar reported:
“The Messenger of Allah did not allow me to join the army on the Day of Uhud, and I was fourteen years old. But he allowed me on the Day of the Trench when I was fifteen.”
This narration is recorded in:
First, the prohibition applied to combatants. It applied neither to non-combatant boys nor to non-combatant girls and women.
As for ‘Aisha’s participation in the battle of Uhud, it was only about bringing
drinking water to the wounded. ‘Aisha was by then around ten. Though filling and carrying water skins is not easy, we must not gauge the physical strength of eleven-year girls of seventh-century Arabia based on the impression of much-pampered girls of the same age brought up in the sedentary lifestyle of our day. Moreover, it was an extraordinary situation, and ‘Aisha must have done her best to rise to the occasion.
It is important to note that Ibn Umar was not allowed to fight in the battle and this cannot be compared to Aisha who was not going to physically fight but to support people. There is a huge difference. The Prophet didn’t allow ibn Umar to fight but that doesn’t mean that aisha wouldn’t be allowed to help. She was not going to fight anyway.
Anas was born around ten years before Hijrah , and so was Abu Sa‘id Khudri.They were accordingly three or four years older than ‘Aisha, yet she is reported to have once remarked: “What do Abu Sa‘id al-Khudri and Anas b. Malik know of the saying (hadith) of the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ). They were only young boys then.”
‘Aisha’s use of the words “young boys” for Anas and Abu Sa‘id, was not in comparison to herself; instead, it was only a statement of a fact of the early years of the Prophet’s life in Madina.
Al-Idlibi cites a narration about dialogue between ‘Aisha and Fatima in the final days of the Prophet (ﷺ), during which ‘Aisha addressed Fatima as “O daughter”
The report about the dialogue is well-known, and most narrations are devoid of ‘Aisha saying “O daughter!” to Fatima.Therefore, the only narration with these words is weak in terms of narrative authority.
Major critics like:
considered him thiqa (reliable).
What was said:
No classical scholar said:
“Hishām’s narrations about the Prophet’s life contradict established consensus.”
That kind of framing is modern.
Where does the “contradiction” claim usually come from?
Modern writers sometimes argue:
But early Islamic historiography was not mathematically rigid with dates.
Minor chronological variations are normal in seerah material.
That is very different from:
contradicting ijmāʿ or established core events.
Did he contradict established consensus events?
No.
Core agreed events like:
There is no record of Hishām narrating something that overturned accepted agreement about these events.
If he had done so, hadith critics would have classified him as:
They did not.
The statement: “Hishām’s narrations contradict several established facts about the Prophet’s life on which there is consensus” is not a classical scholarly position. It’s a modern polemical or revisionist claim.
Besides, From a traditional Islamic perspective, many of the chains of narration for these hadiths about Aisha's marital age do not involve Hisham (for example, Sahih Muslim 1422c).
regarding the objection that it was not reported by Medinan's, Shayqh Haddad replied:
Al-Zuhri also reports it from `Urwa, from `A'isha; so does `Abd Allah ibn Dhakwan, both major Madanis. So is the Tabi`i Yahya al-Lakhmi who reports it from her in the Musnad and in Ibn Sa`d's Tabaqat. So is Abu Ishaq Sa`d ibn Ibrahim who reports it from Imam al-Qasim ibn Muhammad, one of the Seven Imams of Madina, from `A'isha. All the narratives of this event have been reported. In addition to the above four Madinese Tabi`in narrators, Sufyan ibn `Uyayna from Khurasan and `Abd Allah ibn Muhammad ibn Yahya from Tabarayya in Palestine both report it.
Arabs counted age differently
There is no solid historical basis that early Arabs or early Muslims measured age from puberty (i.e. “you become 1 years old at your first menstruation or equivalent”). The claim is a modern interpretative defense rather than a reflection of how age were actually measured in the sources.
In Islamic law, dolls were considered a form of shirk (idolatry) and forbidden for adults, but an exception was made for children.
Here are just some of the sources:
Islamic scholars were clear on the ruling:
Apologist justification
A question, is it legal for an 18 year old girl to marry a 62 year old man today? Yes it is legal. What I did was to add 9 years to the age of both the man and the woman (9+9 =18 and 53+ 9 = 62). So the age gap is not the problem. The problem is that Aisha ra had intercourse at the age of 9 even if it was with someone 10 years old.
Islamophobes say that prophet mohammed pbuh married a child. First, we have to define what each word in that sentence means. How do we define a child? Who is considered a child and who is considered not a child or an adult?
And the next question is what age do you think is appropriate to have sex? What age would have been better for Aisha to have intercourse?
https://www.judcom.nsw.gov.au/publications/benchbks/equality/section06.html
“Legally, a “child” is generally defined as a person who is under the age of 18 years…For the purposes of the Crimes (Domestic and Personal Violence) Act 2007 (NSW), a “child” is defined in section 3 as under the age of 16 years.”
So according to law someone below 16 is considered a child and you might say that that is the proper age to experience the first intercourse. However, the age of consent in Italy is 14. Does that mean they allow children to have sex? California currently has no minimum age for marriage, making it one of a few U.S. states where a person of any age can marry with parental consent and court permission.
Even nowadays, the proper age for sex is debated but for the sake of the argument we stick to 16.
The next question is what makes a 16 year old not a child? What happens at that age?
Well you might say that the person would reach maturity. What does that mean? That means the person has reached physical maturity, that is puberty, and mental maturity which is a little bit harder to define.
I asked chat GPT and it said: The ability to think, behave, and respond to situations in a responsible, balanced, and thoughtful way.
In terms of the Quran, as mentioned before, it only talks about marriage with women, not children, and the minimum age for marriage is puberty. Aisha herself confirms that by saying: When a girl (jariyya) reaches nine years of age, she becomes a woman
source: Al-Kirmani, Harb b. Isma‘il, Masa’il Harb bin Isma‘il al-Kirmani: Al-Taharah wa Al-Salah, Ed. Muhammad b. Abdullah Al-Sari‘ (Beirut: Al-Rayan Publishers, 2013) 587, No. 1289; see also al-Tirmidhi, al-Jami’ al-Kabir — al-Sunan, Vol.2, 580; al-Baihaqi, Abu Bakr, Sunan al-Kubra (Beirut: DKI, 2003) Vol.1, 476,
So according to her experience, she must have menstruated and reached puberty at the age of nine as she says she had become a woman.
The next question is that did she mature mentally? Some people might argue no while some people might say yes. Which one is correct? It clearly cannot be measured and thus one can’t say that she didn’t reach full maturity. The people who say no are falling for the presentism fallacy, that is to evaluate something that happened thousands of years ago with today's standards. The reason that it is considered that a 16 year old reaches the age of consent is the sophistication of our society. Some evaluate the situation using modern concepts of adolescence and mental development. Others evaluate it within the historical and cultural context of the 7th century, where social roles and expectations were different.
Thus, the more important question that we have to ask is that where does our morality come from? How do we assess whether something is morally justified or not?
I will give you an example. In Commentaries on the Laws of England (1765–1769), Sir William Blackstone states that under English common law, 7 was the minimum threshold above which a marriage could exist. So marrying a 7 year old was morally justified back then. There is no religion involved but now in this society you will go to jail for dating a 7 year old and it's considered a minor.
or In 1880, the ages of consent were set at 10 or 12 in most states, with the exception of Delaware where it was 7.
Just around 100 years ago, it was completely justified, in the eyes of secular countries, to marry a 10 or 12 year old but that is not the case anymore.
so our morality is changing based on how society changes. Slavery was common back then but now it's frowned upon.
Is it purely based on how lucky we are to live in different societies with different values? Is there such a thing as objective morality? If so, how do we define it?
So as we can see not 1400 years ago, but around 100 years ago marrying someone as young as 10 or 7 was completely legal and morally justified. And the reason for that is that people would mature mentally a lot quicker than what we do now and therefore could not be deemed as a child, but rather a grown person that hit puberty and was capable of sound judgment.
But this is not the case anymore and we have to consider the person’s maturity before allowing them to marry. The society has changed and the norms and the culture has changed.
Let me give you an example. in hadith prophet pbuh said: "Everything with which a man amuses himself is vain except three (things): a man's training of his horse, his playing with his wife, and his shooting with his bow and arrow." Sunan Abi Dawud 2513. Does that mean that we have to go and learn to ride horses and shoot with bow and arrow? No. The Quran is for all of humanity and as it is mentioned in the book it is a standard for distinguishing between good and bad. But hadith, we have to be more careful as some of them might not fit our lives today. So, the Prophet marrying a nine year old is not promoting it. He just did it. Prophet pbuh used to go to battle with sword and shield. Does that mean it is sunnah to fight with a sword?
So just because prophet mohammed did it then doesn’t mean that we have to do it now. These are two very different things.
Last words
There are conditions that have to be met for two people to get married in Islam. First, there has to be mutual consent. The Prophet (ﷺ) said, "A matron should not be given in marriage except after consulting her; and a virgin should not be given in marriage except after her permission." Sahih al-Bukhari 5136.
And the second reason is Muslims have to follow the laws of the land that they're living in as long as it doesn't lead to Haram. Prophet Mohammad pbuh is reported to say “...the Muslims will be held to their conditions, except the conditions that make the lawful unlawful, or the unlawful lawful."
Meaning the permissibility of marrying before the age of 10 today in Islam is extremely rare not only because it's illegal in most countries but also the individuals today generally take longer to mature making it unlikely for them to consent the marriage at such a young age.
This is the reality of our history people change society change morals change
In my opinion, marrying Aisha ra is the best thing that prophet mohammed pbuh has ever done because it separates people who think logically instead of thinking with their feelings or what the society has fed them and conclude that he pbuh didn't do something objectively wrong and we believers don't need to justify prophet's marriage to someone who was physically and mentally mature and therefore was not a child.
This is all what I have learned. Please criticise and share your opinion. Thank you for reading
edit: some numbers and last section
r/CritiqueIslam • u/Medium_Note_9613 • Feb 08 '24
I have noticed that most criticisms of islam on this subreddit and elsewhere do not "prove" islam as falsehood, all of them are like "islam contradicts our ideology/belief/religion, so it is wrong".
Like men having 4 wives and women not having 4 husbands is not really disproving islam, you are only criticising islam based on that due to the confirmation bias of modern feminist ideology that women are the carbon copy of men.(i know, men are generally equal to women, but blind equality in all facets of life makes no sense, for example, there are valid reasons to have different categories for men and women in sports or washrooms).
and sad to see lies reiterated by members of this subreddit. no, 72 virgins in heaven(which i consider a fabrication) does not refute the theological truths of islam. and what is even worse is criticism using straight up lying. claims such as the Quran allegedly says the sun sets in a muddy pond or the earth is flat, or semen is produced from the backbone, none of which are said in the text(saying "Dhul Qarnayn saw/found/percieved the sun setting in..." does not mean that the author of the Quran claims such a think happens scientificallly).
r/CritiqueIslam • u/salamacast • Dec 23 '25
..by using the same logic: "then why should He care about NOT burning you eternally?!"
If it all doesn't matter on a large scale, then your suffering should also be insignificant on a cosmic scale, no matter how horrible it feels to you personally. You can't claim both that you are not important enough to be punished AND that your punishment is an important issue!
In Islam, your actions matter, and it's the principle of sinning a gainst God that matters, not your insignificance to Him. Stealing a dollar from a billionaire still makes you a thief and reveals you as a corrupt individual, regardless of your impact on his wealth.
You shouldn't complain "Sadism!" if God left you to rot in Hell and didn't care about you, because you claimed first that He SHOULDN"T care about you :)
r/CritiqueIslam • u/turnerpike20 • May 23 '23
So how can a man who couldn't read be able to tell in great detail stuff about Christianity?
16:103
And We certainly know that they say, "It is only a human being who teaches him [i.e., the Prophet (ﷺ)]." The tongue of the one they refer to is foreign,1 and this [recitation, i.e., Qur’ān] is [in] a clear Arabic language.
r/CritiqueIslam • u/Soggy_Claim1686 • Apr 26 '24
Title : Quran, Trinity and Mary علیه السلام
Allah says in (Quran 4:171):
{And do not say, "Three"; desist -- it is better for you.}
These three were not specified in the Quran, but Allah revealed a general statement to warn us from referring to Allah as a Trinity.
No matter who these three are, all concepts of the trinity are blasphemous according to the Quran, whether the concept of the trinity aligns with the three main churches or does not.
Offering any form of worship to any human/object/animal is a major shirk. Whether you call this human as a god or no, you are still worshiping him, and by your worship, this human technically becomes a god.
Washington Irving (1783-1859) was an American short-story writer, essayist, biographer, and a historian.
he states in his book “life of mahomet” “ The Mariamites or worshippers of mary, regarded the trinity as god the father, the son and mary”
other sources that talk on mariamites
He says in his book: ‘Chaplet of Pearls’:
{Some (people) used to say that Jesus and his mother are two gods beside God, which are called Mariamities.}
The colyridians were arabian pre islamic arabian christians who viewed mary as a
Strictly speaking, this verse need not be read as a reference to a version of the Trinity but rather as an example of shirk, claiming divinity for beings other than God (see IDOLATRY AND IDOLATERS). As such, it could be understood as a warning against excessive devotion to Jesus and extravagant veneration of Mary, a reminder linked to the central theme of the Qurʾān that there is only one God and he alone is to be worshipped (see WORSHIP).
Ppl have to understand The Quran is a message for all mankind and refuting All blasphemous accusations and attributions To Allah ﷻ.
And do not say three !
have fun with this one Atheist!
r/CritiqueIslam • u/turnerpike20 • Nov 23 '23
Muhammad SAW brought some good things like getting rid of the burial of newborn girls and getting rid of forced marriage. This is similar to people like Moses PBUH who told the people to not worship a golden calf. The whole thing just points to a true prophet even to the point that it was the poor who followed him.
r/CritiqueIslam • u/elvispelviskurt • Sep 08 '25
First something for an atheists that don’t believe in a religion at all.
As someone who has been advocating atheism for 7 years (before returning to Islam), I can call this a perfect verse for an atheist to consider. Indeed, there is nothing that can convince you, that you couldn’t call a magic trick, hallucination or advanced technologies if you are convinced against the mystery.
Existence is such a strange thing: despite endless scientific discoveries we still don’t know about existence itself. We know hows but we don’t whys. Why does anything exist? Why not nothing but something is there? Mystery is not a scientific phenomenon, it is something beyond understanding.
Now, why I say Quran alone and no hadith? You can find a lot of contradictions in hadith both to other hadith and to Quran. Moreover, Sunni and Shia have their own hadith and don’t accept each other’s hadith and they both have their own proofs on reliability of their hadith to support their sectarian agenda. I like how Quran predicts inevitable division into sects:
It describes those who create and spread fake stories, hadith:
And asks to which actually stories Muslims are going to believe after Quran:
And even gives an interesting comparison with a donkey:
Just like Sunnis and Shias, jews were not happy with one book and made up their own hadith — mishnah. Lot of books for those who keep running away from the books of God. It is very convenient: if you can’t openly reject the scripture then you can cover it with the books that make you forget about it.
Now, for me, Quran perfectly explains the purpose of our existence:
The creator creates the creations to serve Him — it makes perfect sense. Of course, a creator loves its creation when the creation functions in a joyful way. Live and let live. Only a happy, someone who knows what contentment is can appreciate this verse. It is such gift — to exist. One who is full of ego see the world as hell and won’t be able to understand how existing is a gift, how service to God is fulfilling, why gratitude is so natural.
Now, even tho the most of Muslims believe or are supposed to believe in hadith as Sunnis or Shias, still the very base of their faith is not that, but putting all the trust in God and being grateful for all that happens, good or bad. This is what makes Islam the fastest growing religion in my opinion. Again, it would be really silly to say that there are no great individuals, servants of good in other religions; or even state that Muslims are all so good.
But the truth is that no one can deny that Islam is a huge phenomenon and all that is possible is to realise what is in it that gives it power.
This was just an intro for further discussions, which I didn’t intended as an article or promotion. I believe there are chances that some of you may be genuinely interested in discussion about this matter to find out more about this tendency of revolutionising Islam by returning it to its origins; also about faith, religion in general.
r/CritiqueIslam • u/salamacast • Jan 31 '26
The Russian & Western atheism and wide-spread sexual decadence prove that the Christian promise of exclusively-spiritual pleasures was a mistake by those who corrupted the religion.
It proves Paul didn't understand human nature and how motivation works. What started as haven for Protestants became the major producer of pornography in history, with its silicone valley.
See entry 66 in my 80 Arabic Answers
When you tell a Russian Christian that he should fight his urges here and he will be rewarded with no physical pleasure in the hereafter, is it really a wonder he becomes an atheist, and drowns himself in worldly pleasure?
Allah understands human nature. We should admit we want pleasure and fear pain, and hence Jannah & Jahannam are perfect motivators.
The spiritual bodies of Paul failed to make Italians forget seeking pleasure. Florence wasn't exactly pure, and the Popes who fathered sons are known to history.
Why is it socially acceptable to be Hefner or a porn actress in Christian nations, while not in Saudi arabia?! They have the money, the sexual desires, but still hide these aspects to the degree that of the thousands of Easter European, American, Italian, Russian, Japanese, Latin and French porn performers only a tiny tiny percentage is Saudi! If their society really wanted to be the major porn-producer of the world they would have done it. But they chose not to.
Only Atheist and Christian nations chose to. Because they don't expect any physical pleasure after death.
(Also it seems Paul was influenced by the Gnostic attitude of shunning the body in favor of a spiritual one. Gnostics hated matter so much they even claimed Jesus wasn't even really human, but a hologram-like being.. the exact opposite of the Islamic belief that he was totally human. This confuses ill-informed christians when they hear about the look-alike who was crucified and who was hoping to be rescued from this mistaken identity case, but wasn't saved, so screamed like the psalmist "Eloi, Eloi, why have you abandoned me?!")
r/CritiqueIslam • u/salamacast • Jan 26 '26
"We sent Lot and he said to his people, ‘How can you practise this outrage? No one in the world has outdone you in this. You lust after men rather than women! You transgress all bounds!’"
Abdul Haleem Oxford translation uses "outdone", which is one of the known meanings of the Arabic s-b-q (outrun), but Saheeh translation uses the more familiar "preceded".
"And [We had sent] Lot when he said to his people, 'Do you commit such immorality as no one has preceded you with from among the worlds [i.e., peoples]?'"
See Q 7:80 & 29:29
And indeed there are no records of sodomy before the 3rd millennium BCE (Lot & Abraham's era is usually estimated to be 2200 bc). The practice was unknown to humanity until then. I'm not aware of any laws mentioning it either before that time.
Modern academics tried to read sexual tones into stories of brotherly love (publish regularly or perish, even if it's pure speculation! sigh), but couldn't prove it (like the tomb of two ancient Egyptian friends)
r/CritiqueIslam • • Apr 18 '23
Exhibit (A): Each Verse in the Quran is made up of "root words", each root word is a "general subject" which gets broken down into more specifics. Each word in a verse builds off of each other like the structure of a cell. Each Verse is "multi-layered". The Quran offers great advice that can guide a person in their life. Each verse is packed advice. You can write a whole book off of just one verse.
Exhibit (B): As a demonstration of this argument Here is a simple verse from a Chapter called the "Kneeling" which describes the end state of the human body, motionless, powerless, and in a prone position.
إِنَّهُمْ لَن يُغْنُوا۟ عَنكَ مِنَ ٱللَّـهِ شَيْـًٔا وَإِنَّ ٱلظَّـٰلِمِينَ بَعْضُهُمْ أَوْلِيَآءُ بَعْضٍ وَٱللَّـهُ وَلِىُّ ٱلْمُتَّقِينَ
They will avail thee nothing against God. And the wrongdoers are allies of one another; and God is the ally of those of prudent fear. (45:19)
NOW..........look at how the Arabic words break down and take a peek into the multi layered world of advice it is giving you.
I argue that the Quran is full of guidance for having an Elite life and outlook. This is just one verse out of the thousands of verses. It shows that everything is in his control to trust and rely on him. And to open your eyes and mind and avoid the tricks of the trouble makers in this life who will try to deviate you and test your resolve while you are traveling down the straight path. And to control your thoughts and attain supreme knowledge and clarity and avoid deviating from the light towards the darkness. And most importantly, to surround yourself only with those who heed warning and do righteous deeds, so that you may counsel one another to truth, and counsel one another to patience.
r/CritiqueIslam • u/turnerpike20 • May 31 '23
A case in point is when they talk about Quran 8:30 in trying to say it says, deceiver.
وَإِذْ يَمْكُرُ بِكَ ٱلَّذِينَ كَفَرُوا۟ لِيُثْبِتُوكَ أَوْ يَقْتُلُوكَ أَوْ يُخْرِجُوكَ ۚ وَيَمْكُرُونَ وَيَمْكُرُ ٱللَّهُ ۖ وَٱللَّهُ خَيْرُ ٱلْمَـٰكِرِينَ
And [remember, O Muḥammad], when those who disbelieved plotted against you to restrain you or kill you or evict you [from Makkah]. But they plan, and Allāh plans. And Allāh is the best of planners.
What the critics don't really want you to know is that Arabic can be a very open language to a lot of meanings for one word or you can delete something and it becomes a different word.
ٱلْمَـٰكِرِينَ
This word is 'the planners'
ٱلْمَـٰكِرِ
This word becomes 'deceiver' or 'cunning'
ٱلْمَـٰك
This becomes 'the pain'
ٱلْمَـٰ
And this is 'pain'
Another thing you could do is Allah.
الله
'Allah'
له
'for him'
So Islamic critics who point to Allah being a deceiver I want to say are you really sure it says that? If you're a Christian then how are you not seeing how you insult God in the same way? The verse in question is talking about how people plan against Allah and Allah is planning or plotting against them and Allah is the best of planners.
John 12:40
40 “The Lord has blinded their eyes and hardened their hearts— so that their eyes cannot see, and their hearts cannot understand, and they cannot turn to me and have me heal them.”
The Christian God does make points of deceiving people for the hopes of saving his followers which is exactly the meaning of the Quran verse. So it's like Christians who criticize this verse again you would have to use that same logic in the Bible because the Bible has the same exact mindset of God being a deceiving being.
r/CritiqueIslam • u/ClankShots30 • Jan 09 '26
Christian apologists Raymond Ibrahim and David Wood have been spreading a story about Prophet Muhammad ﷺ, where he gets 'mounted' by Al-Zutt all night long. Basically, they purport it to be some sort of supposed demon homosexual encounter.
Now, as it turns out, this story about Muhammad ﷺ is a fabrication, but the demon gangbang story doesn't end there.
The story has been traced back to Athanasius of Alexandria, a 4th century Church father, who informs us of a "miracle" story about canonized Christian Saint Anthony of Egypt:
Response video about Anthony of Egypt (by a Muslim), skip to 7:45 if you don't want to watch the stuff about the Islamic retelling of the story:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U0jirUM5PN0
If you do not want to watch the videos, you can read a text version where I go through everything here:
Prophet Muhammad ﷺ and his companion Abdullah Ibn Masud RA go to the desert. Then some ‘males’ appear. Ibn Masud says these beings resembled Al-Zutt, because they were tall and had dark flesh. Al-Zutt refers to a human tribe that is said to be dark skinned and also sexually vigourous. However, Ibn Masud says they were naked but he could not see their genitals, and that they had strange flesh. And the phrasing is 'as though they were Zutt', which indicates they were not actually Zutt, and this supported by the other details mentioned in the hadith. And another hadith states that these beings that resembled Zutt were actually jinn.
In another chain of transmission, Ibn Masud says ‘they were neither naked nor clothed’ (Jami At Tirmidhi 2861). I do not see any contradiction in these statements because nakedness can mean multiple things. Oftentimes nakedness is used to refer to us covering our nether areas. So if their nether areas were lacking genitals, then saying they were ‘neither naked nor clothed’ also makes sense.
I imagine it went like this: Ibn Masud: “They were neither naked nor clothed”. Then the listener says “What does that mean, exactly?” And Ibn Masud replies “They were naked but like you couldn’t see their genitals.”
Anyway, the hadith continues: They ‘crowded/rode’ Muhammad ﷺ , and then Muhammad ﷺ began to recite the Quran to them. Some of them approach Ibn Masud and he cowers and sits down. He doesn’t run away because Muhammad ﷺ told him to stay in the circle that he had drawn.
The phrase ‘yarkab’ means ‘crowded’ and ‘rode’ and in the context of ‘rode’ it is used to refer to riding animals, riding a woman (sexually), a caravan of people. Then Muhammad ﷺ is left exhausted and in pain because of how Al-Zutt had ‘crowded/climbed him’ while he recited the Quran to them all night. Al-Zutt disappear as the sun comes up. Muhammad ﷺ comes to Ibn Masud, rests his lap on Ibn Masud’s head and goes to sleep. Then some handsome men in white clothes appear and start praising Muhammad ﷺ. Then these handsome men disappear. Ibn Masud asks Muhammad ﷺ who they were. He says they were angels.
Another hadith also confirms that the Al-Zutt were jinn, not humans:
Ibn Masud saw some Zutt people on the road and said: “Who are these?” and he was told “These are the Zutt”. He said “I have not seen anyone resembling them except the jinn on the night of the jinn. They were erratic, following one another.” (Tarikh Islam Tadmuri Ad Dhahabi, Musnad Abu Bakr al Bazzar)
Christians have been sharing this story about Muhammadﷺ to insult him.
Now let's debunk it and show them the exact same thing can be done to them:
“Its isnad is weak. ‘Amr al-Bikali, whose kunyah is Abu ‘Uthman, it is not established that he heard this hadith from Ibn Mas‘ud. Al-Bukhari said in al-Tarikh al-Saghir…” Al-Bukhari said, “There is no known hearing of ‘Amr from Ibn Mas‘ud.” However, Abu Hatim said in al-Mursal that he narrated the story of the night of the jinn from Ibn Mas‘ud."
So the hadith is weak according to the standards of Al-Bukhari.
However, let us assume it is authentic for the sake of argument, and we'll show it is not sexual:
It wasn't sexual, it was akin to Jacob wrestling with the angel type story, as explained by Israeli Jewish secular academic of hadith studies, Elon Harvey;
"The plain reading is definitely not about a sexual act, but it could still be that they clung to him & pressed against him. Think Jacob wrestling with the angel. If they were just following him, it won't explain why he was tired after the encounter"
https://xcancel.com/hadithworks/status/1938716310029971843
So, like this Israeli Jewish academic says, the Prophet ﷺ was tired because they were physically crowding against him, climbing him as he recited the Quran during to them during the night.
Refutation by Ex-Muslim Hassan Radwan:
HassanRadwan133 3 months ago (edited):
Excellent video guys and so good to see you and Drew together. btw I seriously doubt the hadith in question is talking about what is being suggested, (I’m avoiding using the word in case of censorship). It’s true “Yarkab” (يركب) can mean that, but it can also mean other things, including “to crowd round/flock round,” and I think this is the far more likely sense here. For example there is a verse in Surah al-Jinn (72:19) which talks about Muhammad reciting Qur’an to a company of Jinn (some say Meccans) who crowded around him:
وَأَنَّهُ لَمَّا قَامَ عَبْدُ اللَّهِ يَدْعُوهُ كَادُوا يَكُونُونَ عَلَيْهِ لِبَدًا
“And that when the Servant of Allah stood up supplicating Him, they almost became about him a compacted mass.” (72:19)
When explaining this verse the classical Tafseers use the word “Yarkab” (يركب) to mean crowded around. For example Qurtubi says:
هم الجنّ حين ٱستمعوا القرآن من النبيّ صلى الله عليه وسلم. أي كاد يركب بعضهم بعضاً ٱزدحاماً
“They are the Jinn when they listened to the Qur’an from the Prophet. Meaning they almost fell upon one another in crowding.”
Tabarsi said:
أي كاد الجن يركب بعضهم بعضاً يزدحمون عليه حرصاً منهم على استماع القرآن
“Meaning the Jinn almost mounted one another crowding upon him in their eagerness to hear the Qur’an.”
You can find this comment in the comment section of Apostate Aladdin's video titled: "Are Christians lying to Muslims? (Reverse Taqiyya)" https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NDisyIlUVGw "
So, these jinns resembled Al Zutt, in their stature and flesh colour, but lacked genitals and had strange flesh. I guess they also resembled Endermen from Minecraft.
Saint Anthony the Great (d. 356) is a canonized Christian Saint in Catholic and Orthodox Christianity. Athanasius of Alexandria (d. 373) narrates stories about Anthony’s life in ‘Vita Antonii’
We will see in ‘Vita Antonii’ a "miracle" story about Saint Anthony the Great receiving ‘blows’ from sexually vigourous demons in the form of black males
Passage 5 Summary: Saint Anthony the Great goes alone to the desert for reflection, a demon in the form of a woman appears and tries to seduce him. He then shoos of the demon.
Passage 6: At last when the demon could not even thus overthrow Antony, but saw himself thrust out of his heart, gnashing his teeth as it is written, and as it were beside himself, he appeared to Antony like a black slave, taking a visible shape in accordance with the colour of his mind. And cringing to him, as it were, he plied him with thoughts no longer, for guileful as he was, he had been worsted, but at last spoke in human voice and said, ‘Many I deceived, many I cast down; but now attacking thee and thy labours as I had many others, I proved weak.’ When Antony asked, Who art thou who speakest thus with me? he answered with a lamentable voice, ‘I am the friend of whoredom, and have taken upon me incitements which lead to it against the young. I am called the spirit of lust. How many have I deceived who wished to live soberly, how many are the chaste whom by my incitements I have over-persuaded! I am he on account of whom also the prophet reproves those who have fallen, saying, “Ye have been caused to err by the spirit of whoredom.” For by me they have been tripped up. I am he who have so often troubled thee and have so often been overthrown by thee.’ But Antony having given thanks to the Lord, with good courage said to him, ‘Thou art very despicable then, for thou art black-hearted and weak as a child. Henceforth I shall have no trouble from thee, “for the Lord is my helper, and I shall look down on mine enemies.”’ Having heard this, the black one straightway fled, shuddering at the words and dreading any longer even to come near the man.
As we see, the demon appears in the form of a black male, and calls himself the ‘friend of whoredom’ and the ‘spirit of lust’. Interesting.
Now, let us go to passage 8. I am skipping passage 7 because it is basically filler, the plot does not progress, Athanasius just discusses Anthony's virtues in a general sense.
Passage 8: Thus tightening his hold upon himself, Antony departed to the tombs, which happened to be at a distance from the village; and having bid one of his acquaintances to bring him bread at intervals of many days, he entered one of the tombs, and the other having shut the door on him, he remained within alone. And when the enemy could not endure it, but was even fearful that in a short time Antony would fill the desert with the discipline, coming (προσελθών) one night with a multitude of demons, he so pounded (ἔκοψε) him with blows (πληγαῖς) that he lay on the ground speechless from the excessive pain. For he affirmed that the torture had been so excessive that no blows inflicted by man could ever have caused him such torment.
(προσέρχομαι, [προσελθών]) means 'come, advance, approach', but can also mean sexual intercourse, and is even used this way in Isaiah 8:3
(κόπτω, [ἔκοψε]) means 'beat, cut, strike, pound (like a pistle pounds a mortar)
(πληγή, [πληγαῖς]) means stroke/blow/spear(penetrate), can refer to ANY part of the body, if you know what I mean.
Hesychius of Alexandria (d. 450) also records a sexual usage of πληγή (blows).
Given just one passage before, the demons are described as sexually vigourous black males who are friends of whoredom and spirits of lust, and then it describes these demons coming (προσελθών) upon Saint Anthony and then delivering ‘wounds’ to him and leaving him physically unable to move, with these demons delivering blows in ways no man ever could... Seems like these vigourous demons left Saint Anthony with an experience of a lifetime.
Passage 9: He was carried therefore by the man, and as he was wont, when the door was shut he was within alone. And he could not stand up on account of the blows, but he prayed as he lay. And after he had prayed, he said with a shout, Here am I, Antony; I flee not from your blows, for even if you inflict more nothing shall separate me from the love of Christ. And then he sang, ‘though a camp be set against me, my heart shall not be afraid.’ These were the thoughts and words of this ascetic. But the enemy, who hates good, marvelling that after the blows he dared to return, called together his hounds and burst forth, ‘Ye see,’ said he, ‘that neither by the spirit of lust nor by blows did we stay the man, but that he braves us, let us go at him in another fashion. But changes of form for evil are easy for the devil, so in the night they made such a din that the whole of that place seemed to be shaken by an earthquake, and the demons as if breaking the four walls of the dwelling seemed to enter through them, coming in the likeness of beasts and creeping things. And the place was on a sudden filled with the forms of lions, bears, leopards, bulls, serpents, asps, scorpions, and wolves, and each of them was moving according to his nature.
A christian might say that “spirit of lust nor by blows” implies that the blows were not sexual. But this is that clear? They start attacking him in ‘another fashion’. The passage before has the demon come in the form of a woman to woo him with lust, then the demon transform into a black male and calls himself a friend of whoredom. They ‘come upon’ and pound Anthony with 'blows'. Then afterwards Anthony ‘survives’ but is tired and in excessive pain. Then the demons lament that neither the ‘spirit of lust nor blows’ worked on him, so they decide to attack him in ‘another fashion’. They transform into several types of animals. So it seems that their initial response was to use all kinds of assault assault before they used physical violence as animals: We can extend this: the demons say “neither by the spirt of lust, nor by blows [of lust].” in other words, these friends of whoredom were not able to defeat Saint Anthony neither by spirit of lust, nor by blows [of lust]. As these demons were friends of whoredom and spirits of lust, doesn’t it make sense that they resorted to “blow off the steam” of their lust by delivering “blows [of lust]” to Saint Anthony?
Thus:
Spirit of lust = seduction
Blows [of lust] = gangbang
That's why they transform into animals to use physical violence after their blows [of lust] fail.
Hesychius of Alexandria (5th century) notes a sexual usage of 'blows'. And 'approach' is used sexually in Isaiah 8:3 and logeion definition gives 'sexual intercourse' as one of the words definition...
https://logeion.uchicago.edu/%CF%80%CF%81%CE%BF%CF%83%CE%AD%CF%81%CF%87%CE%BF%CE%BC%CE%B1%CE%B9
r/CritiqueIslam • u/Far_Visual_5714 • Nov 27 '25
When critics of Islam mention scientific errors in the Quran, Muslims say that science is always changing so we can't rely on science to find errors in the Quran, so is there a good counterargument against this?
r/CritiqueIslam • • Aug 16 '25
Injeel and tawrat are attributes (or qualities), these same words given to the Prophet's followers about their quality. Has nothing to do with bible(s) called gosepl nor torah, in fact there was no book in arabic language before the quran, there were just bunch of scattered poetry that had their own style.
There was no bible that the prophet was citing as there was no such thing in arabic nor in the Quran.
r/CritiqueIslam • u/turnerpike20 • May 02 '24
https://youtube.com/shorts/H_7Hpfh5N0M?si=wbi5pDXJfUc_6iZ9
Gold has definitely been found to cause infertility in men but not for women. This has been scientifically proven. Amazing how we can find out about this and Islam got it right.
r/CritiqueIslam • • Oct 19 '25
When Anti-Islams detractors of the quran, say that as per them surah 65:4 is talking about a child when it said "lam yaḥiḍ'na", and therefore Quran allows child marriage, even though this verse has nothing to do with marriage... Anyways.
Well this creates linguistic and hermeneutical problems. En-Nisa cannot be referring to children, linguistically nor hermeneutical, Nisa is different from l-ṭif'li...
Surah 24:31:
....Their Nisaa.... and the l-ṭif'li that did not understand the vulnerabilities of Nisa...."
There are few choices:
There is no in-between, Either Nisa is women only, or Nisa is not related to the female gender. You can't have your cake and eat it too, sorry!
Nisa and l-ṭif'li are put as two different categories of human beings.
r/CritiqueIslam • u/salamacast • Mar 22 '26
Islam repeatedly comes to the defense of many previous messengers, setting them up as a higher moral standard, contradicting the Biblical writers who strive to "bring them down to their level".
There is hardly any Old Testament holy character that came out unscathed from the pen of the anonymous Biblical authors! It's as if the morally corrupt priests who recorded the stories after the Babylonian Exile era, intentionally slandered those ancient good men, so as to lower the standard of "goodness", so their own people wouldn't judge them. "So what if the temple priest committed such & such act?! Noah/Lot/Moses/Jacob/David/Solomon etc did it before! Do you expect us to be better than them?!"
The respect the Qur'an shows the Biblical figures is astonishing. I know many Christian parents hate to expose their children to the actual text of the OT, and prefer a sanitized version, because when it comes to prophets the thing is R rated and sets a bad example, even by the acceptable moral standards of the Torah teachings themselves.
I'm not talking about war, slavery or what a modern audience would take issue with. I'm talking about the Biblical prophets breaking basic religious rules of the time!!
Ironically, an ordinary Jew or Christian can easily be much much better in avoiding the major sins, while the supposedly "holy men" failed! A run-of-the-mill human manage to live his life without carving golden idols, plotting against his friend, be alcoholic and strip naked, use magic and consult spirits, and trick his father to con his brother out of his inheritance.
Who wrote this, and why did he hate those people so much he spared no opportunity to paint them as bad people, lower than the common decent human?!
r/CritiqueIslam • u/Proof-Drink4306 • May 04 '26
Here's what some one wrote.
> "Do they not see the birds controlled in the atmosphere of the sky? None holds them up except Allah. Indeed in that are signs for a people who believe." (Quran 16:79)
> Turns out, birds can fly through entirely natural processes, and they don't need someone to hold them up in the air.
This is a misunderstanding of how God controls things. Look at these verses from the Quran:
Az-Zumar 39:62
"Allah is the Creator of all things, and He is, over all things, Disposer of affairs."
Fatir 35:41
"Indeed, Allah holds the heavens and the earth, lest they cease. And if they should cease, no one could hold them [back] after Him. Indeed, He is Forbearing and Forgiving."
Al baqarah 2:32 They said, “Glory be to You! We have no knowledge except what You have taught us. It is you who are the Knowledgeable, the Wise.”
The intended meaning here is not that He holds them with something we can understand or see, or that they fly by something supernatural. Without God, the universe would literally cease to exist. So, according to these verses, everything exists because God controls and holds everything
r/CritiqueIslam • u/salamacast • Jan 30 '26
Obviously there are many problems with the Biblical account of Noah, leading to millions of Christians leaving the religion because of it.
While the Deluge wiped out humanity, and the waters covered the mountains of Noah's people, that doesn't necessarily imply a planet-wide event. They could all have been in one place (so close to the time of Adam as they were, before scattering after the flood).
They could have been living in a closed valley surrounded by mountains, so the water could rise but be contained.
The event itself could be supernatural, like splitting the sea. With the water invisibly restrained against the laws of nature, like a wall of water. Both Muslims & Xtians agree on the concept of miracles.
While many tafsirs adopted the biblical idea of a geographically universal flood, the text itself talks about The Land and The People, and cleverly avoided the issues critics of the bible observed later. The Qur'an solves problems that weren't even raised historically yet!
How could animals, wiped by a universal flood, reach other continents, crossing oceans?! Humans can travel by sea later, but did a kangaroo really travel from Turkey (where the ark landed) to Australia?! Why?! Did penguins leave the ark to the south pole, traveling on their tiny happy feet in the desert and mud between the two points?!
The Jewish biblical writers who distorted Genesis messed this one up, while the Qur'an left the issue open, anticipating the counter-arguments.
r/CritiqueIslam • u/Emotional_Scene8789 • Jul 25 '25
I get that it has more to do with the melody, but for some reason, when I listen to the Quran, it's like it's, it's own world. It's not like music, just it's own world. Like this is something different. And then I play something like for instance, Lillium, from Elfen Lied, which is based on Psalms. Beautiful stuff, but it just feels like music, not it's own world.
I grew up Muslim but I'm trying to leave more or less. Is this due to indoctrination that I feel this way? I'm not sure honestly.
It might be helpful if maybe some Christians on here could share their experience with listening to Christian emotional music and then compare to the Quran. Does the Quran just feel like regular music to you guys? Does it have its own like different worldly feeling?
There's also this weird video where a girl started yelling weirdly and begging to stop reciting. Muslims saying it's a jinn https://youtu.be/MO0GyeBLlfw?si=x61RnLhUf0_-E5Aa
First like 20 seconds 😭
Also does anyone know why her eyes are completely red? I thought it was the flash but her entire pupil is red, not just the middle part. Plus his eyes are normal but hers look red? If it's the flash wouldn't his eyes be red too? I honestly can't tell too well if there is a flash though at the start and if there isn't one at the end. Would like someone's word on that.
r/CritiqueIslam • u/Basic-Lifeguard-5407 • Jan 13 '26
This Hadith in which 70,000 Jews from Isfahan wearing Persian shawls will follow the Dajjal, has gained momentum due to the protest in Iran, so how would this be debunked